In September 2026, a full two years after she first contacted the Vancouver Tenants Union over her landlord’s attempt at a bad-faith eviction, Abby Leung hits a piñata in Kensington Park with the word “EVICTIONS” written on it. On June 19th, she had finally received the news that the RTB, after multiple appeals and a judicial review later, had ruled in her favour. How did we get here, and what can we learn from that process?
Campaign Overview
Abby has lived in her home for twenty years. She has a close personal friendship with her landlord, took care of her landlord’s garden and dog when she went away, and had been afforded cheaper rent and a great deal of leeway in the living arrangement. As such, Abby was surprised when her landlord served her a “Notice to End Tenancy for Landlord’s Use of Property” in September 2024. The landlord claimed that she intended for family members to move into the upstairs unit, and that she herself would move downstairs. However, given the fact that the landlord had, the previous year, attempted to raise the rent by 42%, but settled on 24% after negotiations with Abby, anyone could tell that this eviction was in bad faith. The motive of the landlord was clear: she knew she could make more money if she kicked Abby out and re-rented the unit for a greater profit. Below is a timeline of what ensued once Abby reached out to us:
| July 2007 | Abby moves into her home |
| November 2023 | The landlord informs Abby her rent will increase by 42%. Abby informs the landlord this would be an illegal and unjust increase |
| January 2024 | Feeling pressured by the landlord, Abby agrees to a 24% rent increase. The landlord is angry with Abby |
| September 7, 2024, | The landlord serves Abby with an RTB-32L “Four Month Notice to End Tenancy For Landlord’s Use of Property” (eviction date Jan 31) |
| October 4, 2024 | Abby disputes the notice & delivers a letter to her landlord, asking her to drop the eviction |
| November 8, 2024 | First RTB Hearing |
| December 2024 | RTB rules in favour of the landlord, granting the landlord an order of possession. Doorknocking and community outreach begins for Community Dinner. |
| January 2025 | Abby holds a community dinner in the Kensington Community Centre |
| January 30 2025 | Abby wins a stay of eviction until March 31st |
| January 2025 to October 2025 | The Abby Campaign continues postering and doorknocking. It also begins putting lawn signs in her neighbourhood with the support of the East Side chapter. Abby also does traditional media and a social media campaign. She holds rallies at her home |
| March 24th | Abby wins another stay of eviction, this time an indefinite one until she gets a Judicial Review date |
| Summer 2025 | Abby delivers a demand letter to the landlord to drop the eviction. Canvassing and community events in Abby’s neighbourhood all summer |
| October 5 2025 | Rally against landlord |
| October 24 2025 | Abby’s Judicial Review date |
| November 27 2025 | Abby finds out that she won the JR |
| Early May 2026 | Abby got notice that the RTB is scheduling the rehearing |
| May 23 2026 | Community BBQ with a DJ and pinata to make Abby feeling supported before hearing |
| May 25 2026 | Abby attends a 7 hour re-hearing at the RTB office. The landlord calls in. |
| June 19 2026 | Abby receives the decision that she has won! |
| September 19 2026 | Victory BBQ with cake, DJ, pinata, and supporters from the neighbourhood |
Tactics
Because Abby lives in a single-family dwelling, we could not organize in the way we usually do: door-knocking in a building to try to get tenants out to a meeting where they can collectivize their struggle and strategize on how to move forward. Instead, once we had decided to organize against Abby’s eviction, an organizing team consisting primarily of members of the East Side chapter met with Abby to determine the direction she wanted to go. Our tactics started out small and grew with Abby as she got more and more comfortable being in the public eye, and with the necessities of building momentum over a drawn-out campaign. We can break them down roughly into three categories (though most tactics accomplished all three purposes to some degree: (1) Those focused on pressuring the landlord, (2) Those focused on building community support, and (3) More immediate support during Abby’s eviction process. These included:
- Landlord Pressure Tactics:
- Letters to the landlord, delivered with witnesses & support from VTU organizers (“delegations”)
- Rallies outside Abby’s/the landlord’s home
- Social pressure on the landlord (events in the park where she dances, canvassing outside the community centre she frequents)
- Postering around the neighbourhood
- Lawn signs
- Media interviews
- Community Building:
- Community events (park picnics, community dinner, tango, etc.)
- Doorknocking, canvassing local events, petition
- At one point, we were regularly going out in the neighbourhood every other Sunday
- Speaking in community spaces (e.g. churches in Cedar Cottage/South Van)
- Partnering with other community orgs (e.g. we ran a Know Your Rights workshop at the South Van Neighbourhood House)
- Eviction Defense:
- Court support (inside and out)
- VTU members acting as Abby’s advocate, and also just going into courtroom with her
- coordinating with Abby’s lawyer
- Preparing for eviction defense
- Court support (inside and out)
Key Learnings
1. A Face for the Movement
As anyone who saw Abby’s face on a poster in their neighbourhood over the last two years would guess, this campaign drove home the critical value, in organizing, of a tenant who is willing not only to stick out a long-haul fight, but to be the public face of a campaign. A question we sometimes got when canvassing was, “why doesn’t Abby just move? Surely all of this angst and trouble is not worth it—can’t we all just work on finding Abby another home?” Many people would, very justifiably, have decided exactly that. But Abby, sitting at a booth in Duffins during one of our early meetings, declared that for her, “”Moving is not an option.” Abby meant this literally, as displacement would mean separation from her community, her health services, and a physical effort that could seriously harm her.
The first lesson was how imperative it was to have a tenant who was publicly committed to taking the leap and doing something that might seem scary to someone with no previous experience being in the public eye. People around the city came to recognize Abby’s face, and her willingness to share her story over and over again brought visibility to the union and the struggle as a whole. Abby’s struggle, for some time during the campaign, came to symbolize what it meant to be faced with injustice at the hands of greedy landlords, and the dignity gained in fighting back. People knew Abby’s face and they knew her name.
As a result, the campaign brought people into contact with the union who might otherwise not have been. The ins and outs of Abby’s situation (the shocking rent hike, the landlord’s shifting legal tactics) meant we had lots of opportunities for mass education (for example, Abby telling her story at Know Your Rights workshops). A lot of people we talked to perceived this tension between what some decided would be “best for Abby” (being displaced and attempting to find another home) and the decision, made by Abby and supported by her comrades, to instead fight the battle to the end. Abby’s campaign gave us the opportunity to demonstrate that the fight is worth it. We don’t have to give ground to landlords; we don’t have to take displacement lying down.
Reflecting on the campaign in an interview with one VTU organizer, Abby spoke about learning how many people had encountered similar problems, and of the consciousness-building that the fight required: learning to think of her home as something she has a right and claim to, even when our legal system and politicians are not working to protect it, and our enforced system of private property ensures that its ultimate ownership remains alienated from her.
2. Organizing vs. “The Legal Route”
A question we were asked when we were organizing court support rallies was, “Isn’t the court decision going to go the same either way? Why does it matter that we’re here, doing this?”
One positive learning from Abby’s campaign is that community organizing and community support are key to making it possible for tenants to stick out the long court process. When applying for the various appeals and stays of eviction, Abby knew that she would have a community to support her if things deteriorated into the worst-case scenario. Realizing that there was a lot of people willing to stand with her was a determining factor for Abby, who has noted many times since that she would not have continued on otherwise. It meant, as well, that that court process was now about something bigger than just her—it became about the right of all her comrades and fellow neighbours to live in their homes, free from the threat of for-profit evictions. This is undoubtedly an important function of the tenants’ union: because we are not alone, it becomes both possible and necessary to stand up for our homes.
That we did not keep Abby’s campaign a private affair but turned it into a popular movement meant that we were able to train up new organizers and raise the profile of the VTU through the campaign. Abby herself is now an active member of the union, and even an elected member of our Steering Committee. It is worthwhile knowing that this was not happen-stance. Considerable work was put in to emphasise, from the beginning and throughout, that the work of the union was not one way. For the union to take on the fight, Abby would need to become an active part of it.
Moreover, we learned that social pressure on a landlord really does work—the fact that we were always ready with a rally, a letter delivery, a pamphletting campaign, impacted the landlord’s morale and decision-making. We saw this, for example, when, leading up to Abby’s first eviction date and appeal, the landlord attempted (and failed) to have Abby evicted early over the “disturbance” caused by the rallies. Or when the landlord attempted to negotiate with Abby, offering her a chance to stay (but at a higher rent) if she agreed to stop organizing – an offer she ultimately rejected.
The legal and organizing routes did also come into conflict at times, however. Especially in the later stages of the campaign, tensions arose between what organizers might have wanted to do to escalate pressure (continue with the rallies and community picnics, etc.), and what legal advisers recommended. In the lead up to the judicial review, for example, Abby’s lawyer recommended that Abby not take any antagonistic action. It makes sense that a lawyer, who seeks to mitigate risk for their client, would recommend this. But this was also the moment when, as organizers, we would have wanted to lean into all of the support and momentum we had built. It proved very hard to regain momentum once we lost it, and the campaign suffered from twin issues: (1) too many starts and stops, with long gaps in between, and (2) a consolidation program to bring in new volunteers, which we put a great deal of effort into, but to some extent lacked coherence and consistency.
3. How We Choose Our Battles
The flip side of a campaign built around a single committed tenant, attached to an individual landlord with no other tenants, however, is that it was incredibly difficult to build collective power.
When door-knocking in Abby’s neighbourhood, it was generally easy to generate support. Lots of people signed our petition and got on the mailing list, and some even signed up to receive lawn signs or came out to the picnics and other community events. However, neighbours didn’t necessarily see themselves as having a personal stake in Abby’s eviction and generally did not get involved. Notably, in a neighborhood composed of mostly single-family homes, the majority of them were homeowners. Despite so many people in the neighborhood approaching Abby to wish her luck or say they knew of her fight and recognized her face, the campaign never was able to transform itself into a struggle by or of the local neighbourhood, no matter how consistently we went out and knocked on doors or how well Abby was known by the end of it. ✨️
Our target, as well, was a single small landlord renting out her basement suite, not a corporate one. Abby’s landlord was a member of the petty bourgeoisie and was not, in the orthodox Marxist sense, a capitalist with significant claim over a portion of the real estate economy. This meant that she had less power, but also less tenants meant that we, in-turn, had fewer opportunities to grow. This did provide the opportunity to employ tactics, like certain forms of social pressure, that appeared to work more effectively on the landlord, which a larger entity might have cared less about. There was, however, less direct or immediate material significance, as Abby’s karisma and voice inspire tenants across the city who themselves may be willing to take on the fight. Here, organizers were forced to make a decision: was the campaign too far from the ideal to be worth it? Or should we take it on because of Abby’s exceptional ability to communicate, and because of her need? The union decided, obviously, to do the latter.
In this context, the lines between tenant organizing and advocacy get blurry. Was Abby’s campaign a basis for community organizing, or were we ultimately doing RTB advocacy on behalf of an individual tenant? Another lesson from these past two years is that, in some circumstances, one is not necessarily separate from the other. In the course of organizing, we will ultimately end up doing both: when we build a strong organization of tenants helping tenants, sometimes what those tenants will be doing is showing up for each other’s RTB hearings. But we should also be thinking about how it makes sense to prioritize our energy as organizers. Questions organizers should ask themselves to determine when considering taking on a campaign could include:
- How willing is the tenant to treat this as primarily an organizing campaign?;
- What social base is there to build from and what formation would we be organizing them into?; and
- How would this campaign build not only itself, but the union at large?
- Is the relationship being established with the tenant(s) transactional or mutual?
Abby did not have a transactional relationship with the union. While organizing her own campaign, she has served as treasurer for two years in a row, has been an active Eastside chapter member, and spoke at many union rallies. She has become a movement leader and, in her own words, grown stronger because of it. In situations where the line between advocacy and organizing is unclear, if the tenant themselves does not view them as a crucial part of the VTU, it becomes advocacy.
However, when it comes to strategically picking the battles that we want to focus on as a union, our experience attempting to “scale up” Abby’s campaign does suggest that single-family-dwelling campaigns, where the landlord does not own multiple homes nearby or on the same block, and which are located in neighborhoods primarily comprised of more of the same, are not going to be building collective power the way that building campaigns are.
Perhaps there are things organizers could do differently in the future to help this be a more neighbourhood-level struggle, but there does seem to be an inherent limitation in organizing around single-family dwellings. Especially in South-East Vancouver—specifically, the Kensington-Cedar Cottage Neighborhood, nearby both Clark Street and the 41st Avenue corridor—where the Eastside chapter did not have a prior presence. Perhaps because of the nature of this socio-geographic terrain, or perhaps because of the emergent and changing nature of our plans to consolidate the neighbors into, we were not able to organize the renter base that exists in Kensington-Cedar Cottage. If and when this kind of fight does come our way again, and we decide to take it on, we should never assume that we can build collective power without shared material concerns. We should expect that these kinds of fights will consume a lot of collective energy and we should assess how we hope the campaign might build up collective energy and “scale up” in other ways.
Based on our experience, some additional questions that we believe organizers across the Union would be wise to ask themselves, both when presenting with a possible campaign & more generally: Do we already have a relationship with or a base in the neighborhood we intend to organize in? Are there apartment buildings in that neighborhood? Should we be developing a protocol or the skills necessary to run physical eviction defense? How do we do popular education around this or that particular issue? Does a landlord have a lot of other properties we could use the campaign to organize and mobilize?
4. The Day-to-Day: Keeping a Campaign Going for Two Years
Beyond these big-picture considerations, the two years of Abby’s campaign resulted in a lot of practical learnings around keeping the struggle up for the long haul. There were long stretches between Abby’s court dates, and, to keep momentum and pressure on the landlord, we settled on consistent smaller events that we could pull off every couple weeks—picnics, canvassing in the park, community dinners. We built up a system of rolling phone-banking and door-knocking scripts so that different people could take on organizing regular, lower-stakes outreach. We also tried out a new-to-us software, Facilmap, for mapping out neighbourhoods during door-knocking, which seems to have lots of potential!
Since so many people were making contact and getting involved with the union through Abby’s campaign and, as discussed above, were not in a building together where they might be having building meetings, the campaign drove home the importance of having a lot of intentionality and effort around raising up newer people effectively into positions of more leadership (e.g. through identifying keen new organizers in our organizing meetings). We never really figured out a consistent system for this, which is definitely something to continue working on in the future—especially if we’re doing neighbourhood-level organizing, and even more so when that organizing is happening in a neighborhood in which we do not have an active Chapter.
Through the Abby Campaign, we also made contact with a lot of people who wanted to stay in touch but didn’t necessarily join the union, primarily via a petition built in Google Forms. Those people were entered into Nationbuilder with a special “Abby” tag, but not as members, which means that now that we aren’t sending out regular Abby emails those contacts have become dormant. From a data perspective, in the future we might want to think about best practices for building email lists with non-members, as the various iterations of the petition eventually created a bit of a tagging headache in Nationbuilder.
Another growth area is our ability to do multilingual organizing. For this campaign, to the extent possible, we tried to make key documents (e.g. the petition and informational pamphlets) and some signage bilingual, in English and Chinese. Our ability to apply social pressure in the landlord’s circles could have been made more effective by more ability to have organizing conversations in multiple languages.
Looking Towards the Future
From September 2024 to May 2026, Abby was living under the threat of eviction. That’s over two and half years, in which Abby felt daily uncertainty and anxiety about whether she would stay housed. Abby was living surrounded by boxes—she packed up her stuff in December 2024 after she lost at the RTB. She never felt comfortable enough to unpack them, which she finally did in spring 2026.
Abby demonstrated strength, courage, and conviction in keeping up the fight over two years. She took the power into her own hands and organized her neighbourhood, ran direct actions against her landlord, and was transformed through the process. The support of the entire Eastside Chapter, who listened to her worries and promised to fight for Abby to stay, and her legal team at the Community Legal Assistance Society, were both invaluable to this win. This is also not the case for all tenants facing evictions. Most do not have the robust support system that the union provides. Abby often says that, without the VTU, she would have given up. This system, which places the onus on the tenant to prove a bad-faith eviction, rather than on the landlord to prove an eviction is in good faith, is just one manifestation of the incompatibility of the capitalist rent system with a livable world.
Abby’s campaign culminated in a heartening and long-earned win, both for Abby and for the VTU at large. However, it is our duty as organizers to analyse this work that lead up to this victory, and to take away lessons that can better our organizing going forward. By doing so, and honing our ability to grow our organization, we make it more and more possible to tell landlords across the city: Moving Is Not an Option!