History
The British Columbia telecommunications union emerged at the turn of the 20th century as a local of the electricians union, then formed into its own local, and got replaced by a company union in the late 20’s, during World War Two emerged as an independent Canadian union, and finally the 60’s saw a resurgence of militancy with the first strike in 50 years by the union. We will look at the history from the 1977 lockout and proceeding 1981 occupation and strike.
“For the first 20 years since 1949, and for most of the past 20 years, there were few major labour disputes between the Union and BC TEL. However, for about a dozen years in between, from 1969 through 1981, labour relations with BC TEL were rocky, to put it mildly. Major issues such as wages and working conditions during a time of high inflation, contracting out, jurisdiction, layoffs, pensions, and more recently pay equity, have caused tensions between the company and union which resulted in a number of work stoppages.”i
Leading up to the 1977 lockout the health and state of the union was the following. The union was formally one, but operated as three different ones. The dues were paid to each division, division appendices to the contract were diverse, there were 3 chiefs and 3 general secretaries, they all shared an office and each paid office staff through the administrative fund. The three divisions were traffic, plant, and clerical. At one point the divisions even required different majorities in strike vote.ii No general conventions were held, but each division held yearly council meetings. At this time the internal communication of the union was “abysmal.”iii
“While this was ongoing the structure underwent a major change. For nearly the first 30 years after 1949, the FTW was known affectionately as the “three-headed monster”, as it represented the three divisions (Clerical, Plant and Operator Service) separately, with separate executives and divided memberships. By the 1970’s, it was becoming apparent that such division and relatively small membership was not in the best interests of the members. This resulted in a number of proposals being put forward. One suggestion was a merger with the U.S. based CWA, another proposal was a merger with the Bell Canada Union, then known as the CWC. In fact, the FTW and CWC did form a loose alliance in 1972 with joint membership in the CFCW, but this was a voluntary association, and no further steps toward a merger resulted.”iv
The militancy of the 1969 strike brought people together from across the divisions for the first time. “In the early sixties growing militancy and increased dissatisfaction with the response of the FTW leadership to changes in the telephone industry led to a strong movement for structural change.”v
This demand coincided with the growth of the plant division and the decline of the traffic division. “Shortly after Donnelly’s election as president, the federation council struck a committee to make recommendations on constitutional changes.”viAfter the proposals were ratified the divisions lost their autonomy.
In the spring of 1977 Federation of Telephone Workers of BC became Telephone Workers Union. This signified a change from basic telephone services to wider telecommunication. This change aimed to consolidate and unite union in order to better respond to issues from management and industry.
1977 lockout
This period of the late 1970’s was felt as an economic recession across Canada and the USA. Canada specifically experienced the Anti-Inflation Act which was introduced in 1975. “Prices were supposed to be controlled and rise only in relation to costs, but land prices, interest rates, basic food prices and energy costs were exempted from the controls program.”vii The labour movement called this act the “Wage and Wage Controls” Act.viii Essentially wages were on freeze but not the cost of living. Prices continued to rise but wages were restrained.
This Act restricted bargaining power, BC Tel didn’t offer much and put a squeeze on the union. BC Tel took advantage of the financial squeeze on the union in order to try and undermine the strong protections the union had on contracting out, demoting managers in order to reduce union labour, and temporary worker provisions not working alone without supervision of a journeyman.
During this round of bargaining the Labour Relations Board mediator wrote in his statement that there was a “fundamental lack of mutual trust between the parties.”ix The identified core issue was technological change.
Even as the union was put on the defensive, with little room to demand any monetary increases during a recession to its membership, the union organized many walkouts and had 18 reported incidents in arbitration.
September 20th, the union announced the “work-to-rule” campaign, which meant that the workers were going to do their work as close to the contract as possible. Often, there were tasks that were done outside of the contract that became standard tasks, or rules were not followed as closely in order to do the work quicker. Following the rules exactly meant that work was slowed down and even limited in some capacity.x
The next day on September 21st the union held a truck parade of workers in 400 company cars who drove downtown Vancouver and circled the BC Tel building on Seymour street with signs on the trucks and the horns and lights going off for 30 minutes.xi
At the end of September, operators held a brief protest at the Seymour street office by “downing cords” for 15 minutes.xii The following day the clerical computer staff walked out for 24 hours. Pickets were held in several cities over October. Workers on the Kingsway location in Burnaby staged a rotating strike with 1400 of them walking off the job.xiii These are a few examples to show the caliber of action of workers while the union was in a defensive position.
After all this, the company retaliated with a lockout. The company had media and public support and the union was on the defensive, workers felt militant but hesitant because of the vulnerable position of not being able to make the monetary demands they needed. By December it was still lagging. The workers continued to harass managers in January, attempting to prevent them from doing the workers’ jobs. A tentative agreement was reached in February of 1978. Union officials noted that there was a “huge amount of resentment against the company.”xiv
1981 Occupation
Disorganization and need for centralism was debate at the union convention. Workers complained about poor communications from their union in terms of updates during the last round of bargaining and lockout. Review and analysis continued during the summer convention at which the following were discussed: report from the bargaining committee, established bargaining priorities, adopted new structure that abolished the divisions, strike coordination structure, job action strategies in possibility of another company forced confrontation.xv
When bargaining started, the company immediately forced challenges by low balling the union. Again, the union began its “work to rule” campaign in order to follow all the steps and create a work slowdown. The campaign was called “super service” which involved 530 workers reporting to work and refusing all assignments except emergency repair work.xvi These workers were working in the most profitable area of the company. The workers reported to work and then “sat in” the coffee rooms, garage, spare rooms, and played boardgames or sports. The union paid them 70 cents on the gross wage, which was drawn from regular workers’ contributions of $13/week to the strike fund at this point. When the company sent out supervisors to do this work, the union followed them down the streets to job sites with flying picket squads.
Two linemen entered the BC Tel office in Prince George and barricaded themselves inside two rooms containing the electronic telephone switching equipment.xvii This action showed the distrust and desperation that workers had in order to force their employer in bargaining. It also showed that workers were ready to take further action against their employer in order to get a stronger contract through since last time it ended up in lockout and mediation.
At the same time as bargaining, BC Tel was also going through Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) hearings where the company was trying to argue about the need to raise subscriber fees to services. The union participated and “argued that the company’s massive automation campaign was not designed to improve service but rather to create an outlet for purchasing GTE equipment, with telephone subscribers in BC footing the bill through higher rates.”xviii In essence, the workers were told to work faster at the expense of quality of service while the company also made record profits. The “crown corporation now” campaign to nationalize the industry was suppressed by BC Tel at this time.xix
At the start of 1981 BC Tel started escalating action by suspending a few hundred workers. On February 3rd, 21 maintenance workers in Nanaimo and 8 in Duncan were suspended for “going slow.” The workers gathered in the lunch room of the company headquarters and occupied the building after a consultation call with the union office in Burnaby.xx
“Shop stewards wrote up shift schedules so that workers would control the switchboards 24/7; the evening shift arrived with sleeping bags and provisions. A banner was raised proclaiming BC Tel was “UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT”. Suspended switchman Alf McGuire told the media, “When ordinary people get desperate enough to take over a building, things are getting pretty desperate.””
The workers set themselves out a set of rules:
“Door Committee:
-only 1 open entrance
-make sure fire exits are accessible
-all other entrances manned
-all windows on ground floor locked
General Rules:
-definitely no equipment damage
-encourage operators to give “best” service
-no alcohol on premises or intoxicated people to come in (put them on another shift)
-set up shift schedules to cover 24 hours a day
-shifts to be 12 hours
-maintain all services, billing tapes, etc.”xxi
On Thursday, Lila Wing was told to go home for her pro union shirt. She called the union office which authorized her to occupy the Burnaby office. At the same time, the union called workers at 14 other major exchanges in the province to do the same. The union held a press conference that same day to defend their position. The union told the public not to pay their bills to BC Tel.xxii
The union welcomed press tours and allowed workers to speak their perspective.xxiii Part of the press tours was to show the workers were capable of administering their own workplace and that the equipment was not being damaged. The police stayed off the occupation because of concern with damaging equipment. “The workers were occupying the province’s central communication network. In addition to BC’s intraprovincial telecommunication links, the occupiers handled telecommunications to Asia, Canada’s west coast defence communication network, as well as national television and radio connections. [emphasis mine]”xxiv
The occupation was ended because the union was convicted of criminal contempt in court for the occupation. The union was at an impasse, not sure of what to do since their goal was to reach a collective agreement, not to demand nationalization of the industry, or to form workers’ councils. Defying the court order would have meant the destruction of the union. So, ultimately they disbanded the occupations.
768 Seymour, in downtown Vancouver, was the “central nerve” and the last to evacuate. When they evacuated at noon it took 20 minutes for all of the workers to leave in a militant march, which was met with a solidarity rally crowding the street of mainly construction workers who left their jobs just before noon to rally outside of the BC Tel building. The solidarity rally went out on the street with the telecommunications workers and bagpipes. A giant sign was hung displaying “Beastly Tel is alive and leeching.”xxv
1981 Strike
The flying picket squads resumed after the occupation ended which went after the company. Another mediation round occurred after the occupation which was a fail. BC Tel was asking for more subscriber rate hikes and demands from the CRTC which the mediator said was highly unusual to demand for during bargaining. BC Tel fired 24 people for their strike activity, and the union demanded to hire them back.
At the end of February, BC Federation of Labour announced a general strike program in support of the TWU. One day general strikes occurred in different regions of the province. BC Fed threatened to expand one day strikes to an all out general strike. On March 6th, Nanaimo was shut down entirely: “Ferries, buses, the Harmac Pulp and Paper Mill, Crown Zellerbach, MacMillan Bloedel, Assembly Wharves, SuperValu, Safeway, Overwaitea, federal government offices, post offices”xxvi were all closed for an entire day midnight to midnight. The pulp and paper mill was not even part of BC Fed but still shut down in solidarity with the telecommunication workers.
The province got alarmed from these general strikes and brought in a special arbitrator, March 23rd the workers returned to work with a contract and the workers hired back.
Technological advancement, the crown corporation demand
One issue that remained a constant thread was the issue of BC Tel being a US owned company and remained that way even as it went through several hands in ownership since founding in 1926. At the time of writing of The Long Distance Feeling in 1982, BC Tel was the only western Canadian company that wasn’t publicly owned, and is the most major of them.xxvii The “Crown Corporation Now” campaign existed within the union but was not generalized, which would have made the demand more possible. Instead, there was a regulatory body that existed, the CRTC, and BC Tel had to appeal to those hearings first to change any rates to subscriber services.
Earlier issues of being disjoined even among same company were resolved once the TWU merger completed and the divisions were eliminated. Learned lesson from fracturing and union went about fully integrating three divisions of union into one leadership structure after 1977. The division structure was an odd separation even as the union existed across the different sectors of work in the company. Today, the United Steel Workers Union is the successor to the TWU and this union is even more fragmented where the jurisdiction of the union is much smaller. Maybe because BC Tel was foreign owned, or because it was the biggest regional competitor, the union was isolated from others in the telecommunications sector. I am not sure why the union did not amalgamate with, or organize, the workers in the smaller companies that existed.
Pride in a job as a profession, craft mentality, were disappearing because of tech development. There was a huge wave of de-skilling of former craft jobs from the 70’s-80’s. Common appeal by the union to the general public in the 1981 occupation was the declining quality of service and the egregious subscriber price hikes that BC Tel appealed to the the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) for. Incidentally, as the plant division was growing the union was pushed to become more centralized and militant in the 70’s. It is a hint to the fact that the growth in the productive sector of the union pushed a more industrial union line rather than craft union line of the past.
One of the biggest struggles of the TWU union was technological advance. Since the union’s start in the 1920’s to its end, telecommunications developed at an incredible rate. The introduction to The Long Distance Feeling notes that, “The choice of appropriate technology, and the organization of work, are claimed as prerogatives of management. Yet the selection and design of technology has a profound effect on all of us.”xxviii As a result of the union’s work, the TWU had one of the strongest contracting out clauses among telephone companies in North America. The result was that even as technology advanced and developed, and there was loss of jobs because of that, that the union was able to maintain an industrial union that had a stronger say over working conditions.
It is impossible, and quite futile, to try and halt technological development today especially as it already dominates across most industries. The question, as addressed in an older articlexxix is the problem of capitalist production and the process of flooding an industry with capital and then the commodities become cheaper to produce and are overproduced, and as a result capital pulls itself out to be dropped elsewhere and the industry shrinks because you don’t need as many people to do the work anymore. This is also the cause for why the telecommunications industry moved from a craft to an industrial union, as indicated in the plant division’s growth.
Lessons, soviets, state intervention
Ultimately, the union was not prepared to handle the workers who were ready to go further than the demand of collective bargaining. While the workers’ emotions were not distilled into precise demands that go beyond the strike, clearly the mix of desperation and militancy is a potent combination for action. When workers were pushed against the wall they saw no way out except to fight. The method they took surpassed the union’s capacity to handle this in the typical union-bureaucrat fashion through the LRB and bargaining. BC Tel was definitely also not prepared for the action that was taken on, as they were probably hoping to surely crush the union in 1981 after the successful lockout and weak contract that the union had to agree to in order to proceed with the legal and bureaucratic collective agreement bourgeois standards.
Workers’ capacity to run their own workplaces is no surprise to any communist who’s looked at China or other socialist efforts. However, it is inspiring to see the evidence of workers in Canada seizing such a huge sector of industry given that the BC Tel telecommunication system not only served residential and commercial clients but also Canada’s west coast defence communication network.
It is exactly in this position of instability that the presence of communists in the dispute would be able to shift and further the workers’ struggle beyond trade union conciousness and make a break towards their clear eyed understanding of class struggle. If the linesmen barricading themselves in the office had a political goal and clarity beyond the emotional distress and need to act, then there would have been a greater development.
On the question of the police intervention it is surprising that the state didn’t come crashing down it’s fist on the workers’ occupation. With the tendency of the state evolving today, and the right to strike being limited by the Carney government, one can assume that the state really didn’t have another way of saving the valuable capital from potential workers’ destruction in the offices.
ihttps://www.twu-canada.ca/about_the_twu/history/history.html
iiBernard, Elaine. The Long Distance Feeling: A History of the Telecommunications Workers Union. New Star Books, 1982, p. 174.
iiiIbid.
ivhttps://www.twu-canada.ca/about_the_twu/history/history.html
vBernard, Elaine. The Long Distance Feeling: A History of the Telecommunications Workers Union. New Star Books, 1982, p. 174. (Note: digital version available here: https://archive.org/details/longdistancefeel0000bern )
viP. 176
viiP. 177
viiip. 177
ixp. 180
xp. 183
xiIbid.
xiiIbid.
xiiiIbid.
xivp. 189
xvp. 193
xvip. 199
xviip. 200
xviiip. 201
xixp. 205
xxp. 207
xxip. 210
xxiip. 209
xxiiip. 214
xxivp. 215
xxvp. 218
xxvip. 220
xxviip. 3
xxviiip. 3
xxixhttps://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/the-union-crisis-over-automation-by-bessy/