Barely a month after taking control of the Yukon Employees’ Union (YEU), the Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSAC) has placed another of its component unions under trusteeship. On September 4, PSAC’s National Board of Directors placed the Canada Employment and Immigration Union (CEIU), representing more than 32,000 workers, under trusteeship. The decision suspended CEIU’s bylaws, removed its national and regional elected officers and transferred their authority to a trustee and administrator appointed by PSAC.1
PSAC National President Sharon DeSousa told members that concerns had been raised about CEIU’s “governance and fiduciary operations.” PSAC has so far provided little public detail about the specific problems underlying these concerns. Particularly significant is the timing. CEIU’s triennial convention was scheduled for September 13–18 in Vancouver, only nine days after the trusteeship began. PSAC postponed the convention as part of the takeover. Under CEIU’s bylaws, delegates to this convention elect the union’s National President and National Executive Vice-President.2 Instead of allowing the component’s own delegates to elect its leadership and address its internal problems through the union’s highest democratic body, PSAC suspended that process altogether.
CEIU is now the third PSAC component placed under trusteeship in less than a year. The 27,000-member Union of National Employees (UNE) was placed under trusteeship in October 2025, with PSAC citing concerns over representation and support for members.3 On August 6 of this year, PSAC placed the YEU under trusteeship after five months of administration, suspending its bylaws and removing its elected president, vice-president and directors. PSAC representatives later explicitly stated that the YEU intervention did not involve financial misappropriation, instead pointing to problems with governance, dysfunctional locals and representation.4 Less than one month later came CEIU.
There may be genuine and serious problems within each of these unions. Trusteeship cannot simply be dismissed as unnecessary in every possible circumstance, particularly where members are being denied representation or union finances are endangered. But three component takeovers in eleven months demonstrate a broader problem with how PSAC resolves such crises. The recurring solution has been to suspend the component’s constitution or bylaws, remove elected officers and concentrate their authority in officials appointed from above.
The Workers United Front programme proposes a fundamentally different direction for rebuilding dysfunctional unions. It calls for the “formation of workplace committees as the basic units of the industrial unions,” with elected and recallable bodies rooted directly among workers.5 Where union structures have become dysfunctional or bureaucratised, control should be pushed downward toward the membership so workers can investigate problems, recall ineffective leaders and reconstruct their organisations themselves.
This does not mean opposing strong central organisation. The WUF also calls for a single centralised all-Canada industrial union centre, but one constituted through a congress based upon the organised bodies of workers themselves.6 The distinction is between centralising the collective strength of workers and centralising administrative control over them. A labour movement capable of confronting highly organised employers needs the former; repeated suspension of union democracy produces the latter.
The response from CEIU members already suggests that this contradiction is being felt. A member petition calling for a live meeting with PSAC officials, a detailed explanation of the trusteeship and meaningful membership involvement has collected nearly 500 verified signatures.7 Whatever problems exist within CEIU, its 32,000 members should be the decisive force in correcting them. With PSAC now imposing trusteeships across multiple components, the question extends well beyond any one union: when a component fails, are workers going to be organised to take greater control of their union, or will their control be suspended from above?
1https://psacunion.ca/notice-ceiu-trusteeship
2 https://ceiu-seic.ca/call-for-observers/
3https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-employees-union-placed-under-trusteeship-by-parent-union-9.7302148
4https://ottawacitizen.com/public-service/psac-ceiu-trusteeship
5Workers United Front of Canada Programme point 2: The WUF calls for workplace committees to function as the basic units of industrial unions and argues for elected, recallable organisation rooted directly among workers.
6Workers United Front of Canada Programme: The programme calls for a single centralised all-Canada industrial union centre constituted through an all-Canada congress of the workers’ movement.
7https://www.change.org/p/ceiu-members-deserve-a-live-membership-meeting-on-trusteeship