In many Indigenous organizations and struggle, there is a reactionary form of leadership present. That form of leadership is an idea that leadership for Indigenous masses should be “traditional forms” or leadership, based on the view that Indigenous people should turn towards an “authentic” system of leadership based on the conditions of Indigenous people prior to the colonisation of Canada by British and French colonists. It is a view that preaches a return to “tradition”, pigeon-holing Indigenous nations as only being able to exist in the past. This form of leadership is seen in a need for leadership based on heredity, “matriarchy”, clan leadership, defaulting of the lines put forth by “Elders”, among others. What this form of leadership is based upon is an attempt to mechanically pull forms of leadership that existed in the past, and try and place them in present conditions, with disregard for how different conditions require different methods, and thus is guided by idealism.
Examples of this trend are common, and errors that result amongst it are rife. The struggle of the Tsleil-Waututh Nation against the TMX pipeline going through their territory stands out as one. The de facto leader of this struggle is Reuben George and his mother Ta’ah George, both of whom largely gained prominence in the struggle because of their positions as descendants of Chief Dan George and their prominent cultural positions within the Tsleil-Waututh nations, and in the case of Ta’ah, as the oldest member of the Tsleil-Waututh nation. What their leadership has brought the working class of the Tsleil-Waututh is nothing. After years of the supposed fight, their actions have mainly consisted of garnering publicity and grants for their own family and the organizations chaired by Reuben George. They have also taken a line against anyone pursuing any action seen as “violent”, including towards working-class Tsleil-Waututh and Canadians who have expressed a need to go further than the press events and lobbying led by the Georges. The pipeline continues to be built, and will likely finish, and working-class Tsleil-Waututh who have opposed the pipeline are left unorganized and unable to fight it. There have been those in the nation who have internally criticised the Georges’ actions and leadership style, only to receive their own criticism for going against the nation’s leadership tradition.
Another aspect about the idea of “traditional” leadership is its lack of class understanding in favour of cultural position. It subordinates political leadership based on those who have demonstrated themselves to be correct and consistent in defending the working class, and instead traffics in an ability for opportunists to impose their ideas upon the Indigenous working class based on lineage, age, or some other “traditional” factor. Workers cannot be fooled by such thinking. In the case of the Georges they are bureaucrat-capitalists opportunistically positioning themselves against the pipeline to gain funding for themselves, to the detriment of their nation’s working class. They were able to gain these positions of prominence and leadership largely from their “traditional” cultural positions. This cannot stand.
What the Indigenous working class needs is not leadership who nominally acquires the position based on past tradition, but a leadership based on those who best serve the Indigenous working-class struggle. Those who uphold the ideology of the working class globally, and who ground their ideas in the struggle of the working class. The method for generating this leadership is democratic centralism. Simply, this view seeks to see the complete and uncurtailed criticism and opinions of all the Indigenous masses on issues of the day, to allow an understanding to be reached through struggle. To create a unified action based on a shared unity of ideas, a unity generated by the ideas of the Indigenous working class, rather than unity based on following the dictates of a “traditional leader”. It is the Indigenous working-class that has nothing to lose and everything to gain in the struggle against national oppression and capitalist exploitation. It is time the Indigenous class have a leadership that works in their interests, through the methods that represent them best. Down with the undemocratic “traditional” leadership. It is time for democratic centralism.