The following is an interview conducted with a barista who was fired for trying to unionize her work place in Vancouver. While the barista at first didn’t mention the union names she later asked to include them. The interview was edited minimally for clarity in some parts.
Bessy: What industry do you work in?
Annie: So I work in the food and beverage service industry. I am a barista and a cashier.
Bessy: Cool. How long have you been doing that for?
Annie: I’ve been working in that industry for two years I would say cumulatively but my current job, or former, most recent job, about a year and three months.
Bessy: What are the typical conditions at your work? Can you describe your workplace?
A: Yeah, so, the work is very fast paced which means that there’s no time for breaks. At my specific workplace we were always short staffed and being in a role like barista did not necessarily mean that would be your role. You would often be called to help out in the kitchen and use equipment that you were not trained on. There were several workplace safety hazards. Some mislabeling of our cleaning solutions which posed chemical hazards, this happened quite often. There was not really any sort of I guess discussion or even care on behalf of our employer of workplace safety. It was just something that the onus was placed on the workers to figure that out and to train each other and to prepare each other. So it was pretty disorganized, it was pretty chaotic. A lot of fast paced changes and new menu items would come quickly from owners and it would be up to the workers to implement it and this would happen over night. If I could summarize all of this I guess I would say: overworked, unpredictable, and unsafe.
B: Totally. Was this a chain or a small shop?
A: This was a small shop expanding slowly towards a chain. The cafe had two locations both of which had different menu items, again, this was another issue where customers would come in and be upset that one cafe would have one thing and the other one would not despite having the same name store. And that was something we had to figure out on our own. Ttwo locations and despite owners saying that they were struggling financially there were plans to open a third one later this year.
B: Yeah, that’s ridiculous. How were the wages do you know? How does it compare to other coffee shops?
A: Minimum wage which is lower than at other coffee shops. Even the Starbucks near by my workplace, they were unorganized [editors note: un-unionized] workers, but still made more than us at minimum wage.
B: Could people expect a raise after a year? Like is there a standard expectation?
A: No expectation of a raise but people would get raises based on how much the owners personally liked them or knew them.
B: How did that impact retention do you think?
A: Pretty dramatically I would say. The people that the owners liked and often knew personally would stay for a very long time because they would keep getting pay incentives and would get special treatment and kind of prime tip earning shifts at work. Retention for those who did not get wage increases was usually quite fast. The turnover was quite high just because no one would get raises and just due to the general work environment you would know pretty quickly you were not welcome. So people left quite frequently.
B: You mentioned that you had worked in the past. Can you tell me why you’re not working there anymore?
A: At this current job I am not working any more because I was unofficially fired from my position after I tried to unionize my workplace. I was not explicitly fired, and I did hear this about another colleague who had a similar experience from the owners themselves… they explicitly said that when they want to get rid of people they will not schedule you for shifts because they want to avoid paying workers severance. And that is what happened to me. After trying to organize my workplace I did not get called for shifts probably for around 4 months. I got called back to do a few shifts which really involved me training other workers and then never got called again. It was only recently when they despite not scheduling me they did not approve a holiday request for a busy time and that’s when unfortunately I had to quit on my own accord. Otherwise I would have just stayed and been as stubborn as possible until they had to let me go and pay me severance.
B: Could you talk a little bit more about your union effort?
A: Yeah, so I reached out to several unions. The response was lackluster to be honest. I signed a membership card to one union [USW] who completely ignored me after I signed the card. And it was frustrating because this was at a point where I was finally getting several, and probably enough, coworkers on board for unionizing efforts and to completely lose that contact was really devastating for our workplace organizing. The overall morale and thoughts on unions really really soured after that. As did my own reputation. I think that I was considered unreliable, people did also tell me that how can, asked very rightful questions, like how can we expect a union who is not even answering your questions to support us in organizing efforts.
Another union [UFCW] I reached out to I facilitated a meeting with but I ended up getting the person’s front desk telling me that the local representative was not available to chat with me and would reschedule despite calling them several times after I never got a rescheduled meeting. So the efforts have been frustrating but not so much because of the workers or talking with my colleagues. Its been a real struggle dealing with union bureaucracy.
B: Can you talk a bit more about how your coworkers received your kind of discussion of a union initially? Or throughout the process?
A: Yeah. A few coworkers have family or partners who are in unions and speak highly of unions so they were relatively easy to kind of bring on board. …We have a lot of workers on work visa who were particularly mistreated and definitely wanted to unionize but were very scared because our employer was their visa sponsor and they were worried about retaliation, and rightfully so. It took a lot to win them over which did eventually happen but then for the union [USW] to not respond totally, totally like killed that response. The consensus was why would we risk our own position in this country and risk our own employment no matter how precarious it might be on a chance that these people may or may not respond to you. Everyone was really worried and afraid of retaliation. A small minority of my colleagues were also very close friends with the owners and close personal friends so they would get rides to work, they would spend time together outside of work… I had the sense to not talk to them about it because I knew there would definitely be snitching. But yeah they were pretty anti-union just generally in the way that they spoke.
B: Do you know how the boss found out that you were organizing a union?
A: I have no idea.
B: They just found out one day and then you were cut from the schedule?
A: Yeah. They never explicitly told me that that was why but the timing was pretty much, like, there was no other explanation given the timing. I think it was two days after I had the conversation kind of, well there were many conversations, but kind of like the final conversation of OK great, lets get some cards signed, really putting plans into motion. It was two days after I was completely cut off from the schedule.
B: Let me just get the story right. So you had your card signed and you were getting others cards signed and that’s when you were cut from the schedule, and the union stopped responding to you?
A: Yes.
B: Wow. That’s terrible timing.
A: A little bit.
B: Do you know what happened after you were fired? Did the boss take any measures to retaliate against the workers like you keep mentioning?
A: Not so much retaliation but a very ridiculous way of trying to mitigate a lot of the complaints that were going around. Actually no, maybe there was retaliation. We can start with that. We got a bunch of very angry messages in our work chat… which I at the time had access to, about [paraphrasing] “we know that you are talking about us. And if you have any comments or concerns it is not OK to discuss those with workers. We as owners love and care about you as family.” That sort of thing and “Would love to hear any concerns you have about wages or employment directly to us and not among your fellow workers.” Because most of the people interested in unionizing were in the kitchen, which was separate physically from the bar, there was a lot of communication between us and they were also saying “the bar staff and the kitchen staff need to limit communication” which in my mind is directly referencing the communication that we all had about unionizing.
They also, this is just so funny I mean sorry I can’t help but laugh, they tried to mitigate directly a lot of the concerns that workers were bringing up such as wages by implementing standardized tests and not mandatory…they would make you do knowledge tests and skill based tests and that would determine if you would get a raise. The general idea if you work hard enough and if you were knowledgeable or whatever then you are entitled to more compensation and this really divided the workers… The tests were done in work hours and you could only do them if you were not scheduled so… Conveniently, certain people, and these were also the favorites I mentioned, were never scheduled during test times and therefore could go take the test and be eligible for wage increases.
B: How does this differ from, maybe, paid training? Because you know some workplaces if they are a coffee shop for example that wants to start serving liquor, they might pay for your Serving It Right certification which legitimately you know helps you because you have more training on your resume for future jobs. How does this compare to what they were doing at your work?
A: If I can actually talk about Serving it Right for a second. We were required to get Serving It Right because we do sell liquor. However, our employer did not pay for that.
B: They told you to go get it but then didn’t compensate?
A: Yeah and they also never checked to see if we got it anyways so the whole thing was pretty useless. I also have it on good authority that they don’t check who has their Serving It Right and we ended up having several minors who weren’t certified serving liquor. There is no kind of check on that so if that’s what they’ll do for a provincial standard imagine what they will do for their own arbitrary standard.
The knowledge and skill tests they were implementing were arbitrary, completely based on their own standards which had nothing to do with any sort of standard, any sort of Food Safe, anything practical at all. It was essentially memorizing ingredients of menu items which again is useless because the menu items are right there with their descriptions. Measuring weights of the espresso shot that you pull, seeing if you’re in the weight target which again is useless because there was the tools on the job such as a scale for you to verify that. There was really no need to do something like that. It seems pretty clearly that it was put in place just to give some false sense of we hear your concerns and we want to give the quote unquote worthy people raises. So when I kind of pushed back over that with my coworkers it added to even among some who had supported the union previously were sort of saying like “Oh are you just mad about this because you know you won’t get a good grade in the knowledge test?” so again seeming a very individualist way of dividing us and like no worker solidarity when we’re all competing against each other for top grades. Very bizarre, yeah.
B: I don’t have any more questions on my end. Did you have anything else you wanted to be included in the interview?
A: Yeah, again if I could speak against my employer for a couple of seconds. Bringing up another ridiculous example of wage increases. While I was talking to coworkers and building that union support, I did find out from people who have worked at our workplace longer than me that previously at a Christmas party several years ago this was the only time people got wage increases and that was only because they turned it into a game and made workers essentially play games while owners watched. Like, arbitrary party games and the winners would maybe get a raise but only if the rest of the workers voted on who was most deserving. Even the non-union people I spoke to were really outraged by that. There was consensus that it was absolutely ridiculous.
Responses to “Fired Barista Speaks about Unionizing and Union Busting By Boss – By Bessy”
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/02/fired-barista-speaks-about-unionizing-and-union-busti… […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/02/fired-barista-speaks-about-unionizing-and-union-busti… […]
LikeLike