The People's Hammer

Justice for Dale Culver – by Kale



The recent staying of manslaughter charges against two RCMP officers, Cst. Paul Ste-Marie and Cst. Jean Francois Monette, in the death of 35-year-old Gitxsan and Wet’suwet’en man Dale Culver has once again brought to light the systemic failures of the so-called “justice system” in British Columbia. This case is a stark reminder of the impunity enjoyed by law enforcement and the lack of accountability when it comes to police brutality, particularly against Indigenous people.1

The circumstances surrounding Culver’s death are deeply troubling. He died in police custody in 2017 after being pepper sprayed by his arresting officer who initiated an emergency call. He was then punched in the head and kicked or kneed in the head or upper body by the two officers who arrived on the scene first, Cst. Ste-Marie and Cst. Monette.2 The initial forensic report indicated that Culver died due to blunt force trauma to the head, which was inflicted by the officers during his arrest. However, a subsequent review by Ontario chief forensic pathologist Michael Pollanen attributed Culver’s death to cardiac arrest brought on by sustained methamphetamine use and the struggle with police. As a result, the Crown decided to stay the proceedings against the officers, claiming that there was no basis to hold them legally culpable for Culver’s death. However, as rightly pointed out by Culver’s daughter, Lily Speed-Namox, it was the actions of the RCMP officers that triggered the heart attack, and they should be held accountable for his death.1

This outcome is a blatant injustice and a reflection of the systemic racism and classism inherent in Canada. It is worth noting that a Globe and Mail investigation revealed that charges against police officers in B.C. are extremely rare, with the Independent Investigations Office (IIO) recommending charges in only 14 out of 220 death investigations over the past decade. Of this, only one case going to trial and the officer being found not guilty of manslaughter.3 Furthermore, the BCCLA (British Columbia Civil Liberties Association) stated that they had documented 379 police-related deaths in B.C. since Culver was killed, with only a small number of charged being laid.1 These alarming statistics underscores the deep-rooted bias in favor of law enforcement and the systemic failure to hold them accountable for their actions.

Meanwhile, Chris Voller, one of the directors of the National Police Federation took to social media to discuss the impact the charges had on the accused officers. “There have been 2,453 sleepless nights these members have had to endure.

“These members still have a shadow cast over their career and personal life indefinitely,” he wrote. “The journey to reclaiming their name and rebuilding shattered trust is a herculean task … Exoneration comes too late in the biased and relentless court of public opinion.”1

The reaction from the National Police Federation, the union representing front-line Mounties, further highlights the problematic nature of this case. Their statement focused on the impact of the charges on the accused officers, ignoring the devastating loss experienced by Culver’s family and the broader Indigenous community. This selective empathy is indicative of the privileged position of law enforcement within the capitalist state apparatus.

The outrage and frustration expressed by Culver’s family and civil rights advocates are entirely justified. The length of time it took for this case to reach this point, nearly seven years, is unacceptable and has caused unnecessary suffering for all involved. The fact that three other RCMP officers have pleaded not guilty to obstruction of justice in relation to the deletion of witness video footage further underscores the lack of transparency and accountability in this case.

The staying of charges against Ste-Marie and Monette is a stark reminder of the urgent need for systemic change and the dismantling of the oppressive structures that perpetuate racialized violence and impunity for law enforcement. Indeed the persistence of these oppressive structures is intrinsically linked to the functioning of capitalism and imperialism, which have historically relied on the exploitation and marginalization of Indigenous communities to consolidate power and wealth. Through policies and practices rooted in exploitation and extraction, capitalism has perpetuated racialized violence, dispossession of land, and the erosion of cultural and social structures. The ongoing struggle for Indigenous rights and self-determination is intrinsically linked to the need for a fundamental transformation of capitalist and imperialist structures that perpetuate discrimination, inequality, and violence against Indigenous peoples in Canada and beyond.

The death of Dale Culver must not be in vain. It should serve as a rallying cry for revolution and the creation of a truly just and equitable society that values the lives and well-being of all its citizens, regardless of race, nation, or any other identity. The only path to true justice and liberation lies in the overthrow of capitalism and the construction of a socialist society. In such a society, Indigenous Nations would have the right to self determination and institutions would exist to serve the working class who now dictate how society should function. In such a world, tragedies like this would be a thing of the past.

Rest in power, Dale Culver. Your death will not be in vain, and your memory will fuel our struggle for a better world

Citations:

  1. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/dale-culver-court-case-rcmp-mansalughter-1.7165319
  2. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/law-crime-and-justice/criminal-justice/prosecution-service/media-statements/2024/24-10-bcps-stay-of-proceedings-relating-to-charges-arising-out-of-the-death-of-dale-culver.pdf
  3. https://thetyee.ca/News/2023/02/03/Six-Years-Deadly-RCMP-Incident/