As with the NDP in BC’s recent expansion of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police’s (RCMP) Critical Response Unit (previously the Community-Industry Response Group [C-IRG]),1 the NDP in Manitoba have pledged to greatly expand the police in the province. In the new provincial budget for 2024-2025, Wab Kinew, the NDP premier, has proposed raising the police budget by $ 28.6 million which will see the police budget rise to just under $ 300 million.2
The increased funding to the police in Manitoba is in line with the provincial NDP’s “Tough on Crime, Tough on the Causes of Crime” platform. The name of this platform is a quote from UK Labour leader Tony Blair who in 1993 declared “Labour is the party of law and order in Britain today. Tough on crime and tough on the causes of crime.”3 Wab Kinew’s decision to pull this slogan from Blair is revealing of the shared reactionary nature hiding behind both parties’ “labour” facade.
Blair was a key leader in the international imperialist united front led by the US from the early 1990s into the 2010s. This united front was aimed at preserving imperialism and holding back the world proletarian revolution through a general counter-revolutionary offensive. Two of Blair’s most important contributions to this offensive against the workers and people of the world were the invasion of Iraq and his championing of right-wing social-democracy. While social-democracy has been loyal to the bourgeoisie and has acted as a “left-” form of fascism for more than a century, Blair’s brand of social-democracy rejected even the superficial reforms such as the nationalisation of key industries commonly used to lull the workers into supporting social-democratic parties at election time. Kinew’s use of Blair’s quote for his anti-crime platform shows how far the NDP has moved away from the workers’ movement. Its only remaining connection being its parasitical funding from our union dues.
In announcing their “tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime” platform, the NDP went so far as to criticise the previous conservative government for having cut policing.4 In fact, Kinew’s increase of the policing budget is the first since 2017!5 Regardless of this fact, come the next elections the workers will no doubt be told by opportunists of all stripes that they need to elect the NDP as the lesser evil.
The policing budget of the NDP government includes expansion of funding to both the RCMP and urban policing in areas like Winnipeg.6 Another major commitment is the opening of a new jail in Dauphin.7 The government has also dedicated itself to expanding Indigenous police forces.8 These budget allocations not only expand the regular policing units in Manitoba, but contribute to the development of the bureaucrat capitalism among the oppressed nations in the province. The development of Indigenous police forces means deepening the oppression of these nations. As is seen in the budget, these police forces are being funded and directed by Canadian imperialism through the provincial government. The fact that these police officers will have badges from an Indigenous police force rather than the RCMP makes no real difference. Just as the use of the Haitian army and police in Haiti instead of the RCMP in no way means that the country is not oppressed by imperialism. In either case, it is the interests of Canadian imperialism being defended not the interests of these oppressed nations or their proletariat. The shift to funding Indigenous police forces rather than use of the RCMP is rooted in the bourgeois policy of reconciliation. Much like social-democracy, reconciliation is a means of offering minor superficial reforms to the oppressed in order to maintain imperialism in a now more legitamised form.
It is notable that the budget includes cuts to the budgets of bodies meant to monitor the action of the police such as the Law Enforcement Review Agency and the Independent Investigative Unit.9 Whether these bodies are funded or not makes little difference. For the workers, they do nothing when the police crush them on the day-to-day. They are only active when the police violate bourgeois legality. Even when they do investigate the police, they rarely hand down any real punishments. Why the reduced funding to these agencies should be of note to the proletariat is that they reflect the reactionisation of Canadian imperialism and the decay of liberal democracy. However, this is the natural tendency of capitalism. While it may be slowed, it cannot be reversed. The proletariat’s interests do not lie in defending liberal democracy and its institutions which only serve the bourgeoisie. The necessary task of the proletariat in this period of imperialism’s decline is to fight for its overthrow and the construction of socialism.
The 2024-2025 budget is only the most recent action of the Manitoba NDP to expand the armed force of the state against the workers. Early this year, Kinew’s government also proposed a series of bail reforms. One prominent one of these was the dedication to fund police intelligence services provincially and federally.10
The NDP are expanding the low-intensity warfare against the workers that became generalised in the 1990s under the banners of the war on drugs, the war on crime, and the war on terror. While claiming to be tough on the causes of crime and not just crime itself, the NDP are attempting to put a progressive spin on what is by now a decades-old policy of the bourgeoisie. However, the causes of crime can never be resolved under class society. As Engels explained:
“We eliminate the contradiction between the individual man and all others, we counterpose social peace to social war, we put the axe to the root of crime — and thereby render the greatest, by far the greatest, part of the present activity of the administrative and judicial bodies superfluous. Even now crimes of passion are becoming fewer and fewer in comparison with calculated crimes, crimes of interest — crimes against persons are declining, crimes against property are on the increase. Advancing civilisation moderates violent outbreaks of passion even in our present-day society, which is on a war footing; how much more will this be the case in communist, peaceful society! Crimes against property cease of their own accord where everyone receives what he needs to satisfy his natural and his spiritual urges, where social gradations and distinctions cease to exist. justice concerned with criminal cases ceases of itself, that dealing with civil cases, which are almost all rooted in the property relations or at least in such relations as arise from the situation of social war, likewise disappears; conflicts can then be only rare exceptions, whereas they are now the natural result of general hostility, and will be easily settled by arbitrators.”11
Crime is a social phenomenon. While crimes of passion are sensational they are the exception with property crimes being the rule. If the NDP wanted to be tough on the causes of crime, they would fight for the abolition of capitalism not for its reinforcement. They would not pour police terror into the neighbourhoods of the workers and oppressed nations. They would not ease the formation of a constant pool of unemployed workers to keep wages low. The bourgeois solutions offered are only relative and weak solutions. It is the workers alone, united under the leadership of the reconstituted communist party that will eliminate crime. The proletarian solution to the roots of crime is to abolish imperialism and establish communism. The fundamental principle of communist economics, from each according to their ability to each according to their need, will resolve the issue of property crimes absolutely. By introducing full employment and ensuring every member of the communist society has enough to survive, the necessity to resort to property crimes will disappear.
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/03/rcmp-attempt-to-rebrand-c-irg-by-daniel-h/
- https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/manitoba-ndp-increase-provincial-policing-spending-by-almost-30-million
- https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/acref/9780191866692.001.0001/q-oro-ed6-00001715
- https://web.archive.org/web/20240110210631/https://www.mbndp.ca/kinew_lays_out_manitoba_ndp_s_5_point_strategy_to_be_tough_on_crime_and_tough_on_the_causes_of_crime
- https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/manitoba-ndp-increase-provincial-policing-spending-by-almost-30-million
- https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/manitoba-ndp-increase-provincial-policing-spending-by-almost-30-million
- https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/manitoba-ndp-increase-provincial-policing-spending-by-almost-30-million
- https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/manitoba-ndp-increase-provincial-policing-spending-by-almost-30-million
- https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/manitoba-ndp-increase-provincial-policing-spending-by-almost-30-million
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/manitoba-bail-reform-announcement-february-28-2024-1.7129476
- https://marxists.architexturez.net/archive/marx/works/1845/02/15.htm
Response to “NDP Strengthen the Police in Manitoba – by Daniel H.”
[…] 19. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/03/ndp-strengthen-the-police-in-manitoba-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike