The People's Hammer

Yukon NDP Abandon Free Transit for Whitehorse – by Daniel H

, , ,


The New Democratic Party (NDP) has shown again and again that it has no intention of fighting for the interests of the working-class. They are another capitalist party aiming to crush the workers of Canada. We can see this directly in the move of two former BC NDP leaders, John Horgan and Diane Nicholls to take up positions on the boards of large enterprises exploiting the workers of BC.1 Recently, the NDP in Yukon showed their true colours again when they abandoned their demand for free transit in Whitehorse in order to maintain their close relations with the territorial government.

Like the NDP federally, the Yukon NDP has a confidence and supply agreement (CASA) with the governing Liberal Party. In both cases, the liberal parties do not have the necessary seats to form a government on their own and have made deals with the NDP in which they adopt certain tenants of the NDP platform in exchange for the NDP’s continued support of the Liberal government. In another parallel to the federal situation, the Yukon NDP has been more concerned with maintaining this alliance than in fighting for the interests of the workers it claims to represent. The resolution of the most recent NDP federal convention that a universal pharmacare bill be agreed upon by the end of 2023 or the NDP withdraw their support was ignored by the NDP leadership.2 Instead, the NDP continued to support the Liberal government after the deadline passed saying that if the Liberals required more time then the NDP would make sure more would be included in the bill. In return the workers got a bill confined to insulin and contraceptives.3 The NDP is effectively incapable of putting pressure on the Liberal government. Its sole weapon is to pull support and they have demonstrated that they will not do this. This liberal-labour coalition that opportunists have dreamed of since the 1920s has at least served to illustrate to the workers the total bankruptcy of the NDP. The reason they refuse to pull their parliamentary support is because the NDP lacks popular support. Opinion polls currently show that a conservative government is likely the result of the next federal election with the NDP projected to win less seats than the Bloc Quebecois who only run in a single province!4 If this proves true, then the NDP will be just a regular opposition party and not one with a CASA relationship to the government.

In the Yukon, the CASA with the Liberals includes a commitment to free public transit in Whitehorse.5 The Liberals dedicated $ 1.5 million towards this goal. However, this number is $ 200 000 short of the $ 1.7 million that would be needed to actually fund the system.6 For a brief period, the NDP made a public display of demanding the remaining sum, even claiming that the Liberals were “weasling out” of the agreement by not providing it.7 Now, as every worker who has been burnt by the NDP should expect, the NDP are also “weasling out”.8 As in the federal case, the NDP has declined to use its one actual weapon against the Liberals – revoking support.

The city of Whitehorse has routinely said that it is unwilling to accept the funding for free transit. It has done so due to the aforementioned difference in funding offered and the actual cost of operation and more importantly the fact that free transit is linked to the NDP-Liberal CASA set to expire in 2025. After that deadline, the funding would disappear and the city’s transit system would not be operational.9 This is a rare instance where the bourgeoisie has admitted to the flimsy nature of reforms under capitalism. Even if the NDP were legitimate in claiming to be the workers’ party, come the next election this reform could be snatched away. Any gain the working-class wins can only be secured with socialism and the dictatorship of the proletariat to defend it. In fighting for free public transit not linked to some government’s time in office, the workers of Whitehorse must keep this in mind.

The city government of Whitehorse has also been citing the results of a survey in defence of their refusal to support free public transit. It is important to note that the population of Whitehorse is 28 201 and there were only 900 total respondents to the survey. Clearly, this is not a legitimate survey, however, the results claim that the main concern is for better quality and more regular public transit.10 Considering Whitehorse only has 15 regular buses and 2 handy buses to serve the entire city, it is clear how this poses a problem for the workers.11 However, the fight for higher quality transit and the elimination of fares are not mutually exclusive as the Whitehorse city government would have the workers believe.

The NDP are now looking to win back support from the workers after this betrayal. With the support of the Whitehorse city government, the NDP is pushing for the $ 1.5 million dedicated by the Liberal government to go towards the purchase and distribution of bus passes for the poorest residents.11 While this will temporarily relieve the burden on some workers, it is also linked to the CASA and these passes will likely disappear under the next government. It is a far cry from the demand of free public transit.

The workers of the Yukon and the whole of Canada need a real proletarian party. The NDP was founded as a party of the labour aristocracy and the union bureaucracy, but the NDP has been increasingly casting aside even these strata for the petite-bourgeoisie. For example, in BC when the Federation of Labour resolved to lobby the provincial NDP government for 15 paid sick days a year, the minister of labour responded that the problem was the workers need to build a commitment to their boss.13 Clearly, the NDP cannot lead the workers in the fight for even basic reforms, much less the abolition of capitalism and the seizure of power. The task before the workers today is to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada in opposition to all bourgeois parties including the NDP.

  1. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/06/21/submission-the-hypocrisy-of-the-bc-ndp/
  2. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/02/09/ndp-overrules-membership-on-pharmacare-deal/
  3. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ottawa-unveils-pharmacare-program-1.7129439
  4. https://338canada.com/federal.htm
  5. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-ndp-whitehorse-free-transit-passes-1.7143162
  6. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-ndp-whitehorse-free-transit-passes-1.7143162
  7. https://www.whitehorsestar.com/News/liberals-accused-of-weaseling-out-of-pledge-on-transit-fares
  8. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-ndp-whitehorse-free-transit-passes-1.7143162
  9. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/whitehorse-yukon-government-free-transit-1.6830352
  10. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-ndp-whitehorse-free-transit-passes-1.7143162
  11. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/clock-ticking-whitehorse-bus-fleet-1.7156456
  12. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-ndp-whitehorse-free-transit-passes-1.7143162
  13. https://thetyee.ca/News/2022/12/02/Labour-Paid-Sick-Leave-15-Days-Province-Hesitant/

Response to “Yukon NDP Abandon Free Transit for Whitehorse – by Daniel H”

  1. Oppose the Ban on Samidoun – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer