The Liberal government has introduced its 2024-2025 budget proposal to parliament. At the moment, it is unclear whether it will pass as the Conservatives, the Greens, and the BQ have all declared their intentions to vote against it.1 The NDP, who the Liberals rely on to pass legislation in the current House of Commons, has stated they have not decided to support the budget or not yet.2 The budget does include the paltry pharmacare deal and a school lunch programme the NDP has called for.3 With this, alongside their past record of caving to the Liberals, it is likely they will end up supporting the budget.4
Assuming the NDP falls in line and this budget passes, the workers need to understand how it will relate to their current conditions. Will it make them more tolerable or less.
Much of the budget is dedicated to housing and the bourgeoisie’s attempt to solve the shortage that they have created. This section of the budget opens by stating that the housing question is a market issue. There are too few houses creating a shortage of supply and an excessive demand. Their solution to this framing of the housing question is to rapidly increase the supply of housing. The first way to increase this supply is by making use of publicly-held lands for housing. This includes transforming Canada Post, military, and underused federal office real estate into new housing units.5 Additionally, the federal government has proposed to tax vacant land in order to incentivise construction.6 The third major proposal is more money put into the Apartment Construction Loan Program.7
The overall premise of the budget relies on the false assumption that there exists too many people and too few homes. This is demonstrably false. The Organisation of Economic Co-operation and Development, not an organisation allied to the workers, has reported that around 1.3 million of Canada’s housing stock is vacant based off of the Canadian census.8 There is more than enough room to house the current population of Canada especially when the oversized housing of the bourgeoisie is taken into account. Who benefits then from directing the workers attention towards more construction and away from this 8% of the housing stock sitting empty? The bourgeoisie in general benefit as the workers are not demanding to be let into these homes left vacant. In particular, the bourgeoisie in the construction industry stand to benefit. Construction remains a labour-intensive, and by extension a lucrative, industry. Further, the budget specifies nothing regarding the wages and conditions of workers employed by companies receiving the loans such as that they be paid union rates. This allows the construction bourgeoisie to increase profits by bringing wages down. The money being dedicated to ease the costs of apartment construction as well as the vacant land tax both demonstrate how the bourgeoisie are aiming to use the construction industry in order to resolve the current economic crisis. It particularly stands to benefit the bourgeoisie in the construction industry.
The budget introduces a measure where paying rent on time contributes to one’s credit score.9 This is intended to make it easier for people to buy a home. While this may contribute to raising one’s credit score, the worker still needs to earn enough for a down payment and the subsequent mortgage payments. This alone has long been out of reach for the majority of workers in Canada.
In the end, Liberals are correct that the housing question is a market question. However, the immediate need is not to increase the supply to bring down costs. For the workers, the resolution lies in the abolition of the market. The nationalisation under workers’ control of all capital held as real estate by the big and middle bourgeoisie to be converted into housing for the masses of workers on the streets and over-stuffed houses is the first step to the workers’ solution to the housing question. As the population grows, new buildings will be needed. However, this is not the case here and now. The bourgeois plan for construction laid out by the liberals aims to stimulate production for profit and not for use as it will be under socialism.
The federal government is also proposing an extension of the ban on foreign purchase of real estate in Canada. The stated purpose of this is to remove speculation from the housing market.10 Foreign investment is not the cause of speculation on housing, the existence of a housing market in the first place does this. The banning of foreign investment only serves to strengthen the Canadian and Quebecois bourgeoisie in this sector of the economy relative to foreign imperialists.
In other areas, the budget proposes the scrapping of fees levied to customers of telecommunications services when they want to switch providers. However, in the monopoly stage of capitalism, this choice is purely an illusion. The vast majority of telecommunications companies offer very similar to the exact same plans as each other.11 As with the housing question, to bring down the cost of living in part caused by the cost of telecommunications plans, the workers must fight for nationalisation under workers’ control as a first step.
The budget is proposing a right to disconnect. This means that outside of work hours, a worker would legally not have to answer calls, texts, and emails from the boss.12 This law is a positive reform for the workers, but it would only apply to federally regulated industries and therefore the majority of workers in Canada would not stand to benefit. While Ontario has a similar law provincially, the NDP government in BC has openly stated they are not interested similar rights for workers in the province (showing where this “worker’s party” stand relative to Progressive Conservative government of Doug Ford).13
A large portion of the budget is being allocated to the expansion of Canada’s military capacity. It is aiming to invest $73 billion over 20 years to the the Department of National Defence, the Communications Security Establishment, and Global Affairs Canada.14 Other arms of the state such as the Canadian Security Intelligence Service will receive $114.7 million.15 Canadian imperialism is also using the budget to further subjugate Ukraine to imperialism with $2.4 billion in loans16 as well as $216.7 million to the reconstruction of Ukraine.17 The workers’ demand is for an exit from imperialist military alliances such as NATO and the replacement of the military and police with a workers’ militia. The military budget of the Liberals only serves to strengthen theses military pacts and the armed wing of the state.
The final major effect of the budget on the workers is the changes to the capital gains tax. The budget proposes to raise capital gains tax from 50% to 66% on everything over $250 000 per year.17 However, this is being hedged with a number of tax cuts and benefits for the bourgeoisie. The main form of this is raising the lifetime tax-free capital gains limit and pegging this limit with inflation.18 Additionally, to benefit “entrepreneurs”, the capital-gains tax will be cut to 33.33% for the first $2 million lifetime earnings.19 The workers today are being crushed by taxes. The worker goes to work and is robbed by the capitalist, then every paycheque they are robbed again to finance the capitalists’ state that is used to crush them daily. Outside the workplace, when the workers buy their basic necessities they are again robbed by the bourgeois state. The Liberals’ budget raises taxes on the bourgeoisie, but also introduces new tax cuts that benefit them. However, there is no consideration of the needs of the proletariat. The workers must fight to obtain an abolition of indirect taxes and all taxes on those who are forced to sell their labour-power.
Some of these reforms alleviate conditions for the workers. All of these reforms strengthen the bourgeoisie and their state. The workers cannot be pacified by the Liberals’ false solutions to their problems. It is necessary to organise as a class and mobilise as a class to rip genuine concessions from the bourgeoisie. In this fight, we cannot rest content with these concessions. Even nationalisation under workers’ control of major industries is not enough to resolve the contradictions of capitalism, only communism can do this.
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/singh-ndp-budget-2024-1.7181367
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/singh-ndp-budget-2024-1.7181367
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/singh-ndp-budget-2024-1.7181367
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/03/yukon-ndp-abandon-free-transit-for-whitehorse-by-daniel-h/
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/report-rapport/chap1-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/report-rapport/chap1-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/report-rapport/chap1-en.html
- https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/tens-of-thousands-of-homes-are-sitting-vacant-across-canada-report-1.4621000
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/report-rapport/chap1-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/report-rapport/chap1-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/budget-2024-new-laws-1.7175815
- https://bc.ctvnews.ca/b-c-has-no-plans-to-give-you-the-right-to-refuse-email-calls-after-work-1.5937139
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html
- https://budget.canada.ca/2024/home-accueil-en.html