The People's Hammer

Criticising Two Lines in Actions for Palestinian Liberation – by Ivan D.

,


In recent student actions for Palestine in Calgary I have attended, two issues present themselves that are worth criticising. In this article, these trends will be exposed and show how they run counter to the movement for national liberation for Palestine.

A Concrete Strategy and Tactics, not Encampments and Student Strikes

One observation I have made is that many of the protesters who stood strong against police brutality on May 9th should be commended for their bravery and resolve. Those participants should also be commended on their recognition of the interests that University of Calgary have in continuing the oppression of Palestinians for the sake of their investments, and the resistance by these students. However, bravery and resolve alone will not lead to the liberation of Palestine from Israeli imperialism. There are numerous issues that were present from both individuals and groups, mainly the call for greater encampments and the call by some for “student strikes”.

Regarding the encampments, it is not only UofC students, but students from universities across Canada and the US who have tried to employ them to get their respective universities to divest from Israel1. One must inquire what these encampments would actually do to force the hand of the university beyond being bad PR and making a lot of noise throughout daily operations? At UofC, the encampment was on the grass of an interchange, and at universities like the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, they are located on a soccer field hidden away. While students in recent days have moved to occupying things like administration buildings, this strategy just is a little more in the face of university administration without sharp teeth. How do the ones at UofC and UBC force the administration to divest from Israel? It should be noted that some of the encampments such as those in the USA have occupied buildings and disrupted the administration, but this has not been the case in the Western Canadian encampments. Further, it is disgusting that UofC students were mistreated by the Calgary Police Service, but strategically positions like static encampments can be easily overwhelmed. Thus this strategy of encampments suffers by not forcing the hand of the administration and leaving the students vulnerable to attack.

A similar criticism must be made to those calling for student strikes. The University of Calgary has likely already received tuition from these students for the semester. On its own, skipping class would do little more than lead to students performing worse on exams and possibly even have to repeat classes, meaning more money for the university. A student strike would be little more than just students skipping class and possibly adding to the university’s coffers.

Now, all of this is not to condemn the encampments as a whole, the bravery and willingness to struggle against Canadian imperialism is a great show of internationalist spirit from these students. But they cannot be the be all, end all. What a positive progression could be is that there are those who seem to want to eventually link up with workers on the university such as cleaning and food service workers, but that is not seen as a priority right now. What this does address though is the need for students to unite with and be led by the working-class. The reason for this is workers are in the position to attack what is most important to all the bourgeoisie: production, distribution, and administration. A university can run relatively smoothly if students strike, however, if workers in cleaning, logistics, and the offices stop working, it crumbles. If the professors and other intellectuals employed by the university walk-out with the workers, and the students, then the masses will be able to force the hand of the administration.

An example of the above is given in the fight against South African apartheid where many longshoreman unionised under the International Longshoremen and Warehouse workers Union refused to unload any goods shipped from South Africa, putting extreme pressure on the country to end Apartheid2. A similar struggle waged here would put real pressure on Israel. There is also a material economic interest for all Canadian workers to resist Israel. Over the past decade, Canada has exponentially increased their support for the Israeli government in the form of over $21 million in military goods that have come from Canadian tax dollars in 2022 alone3. Money that could have been spent solving the many issues Canadian workers face today.

Neither Islam Nor Any Other Religion As A Guide for Liberation

Another tendency I observed was a significant minority of attendees who were firm in their belief of Islam as a guide for the national liberation of Palestine. People were distributing Qurans and there was even a speech given that held that the Quran and Islam should be a guide to unity and national liberation in Palestine.

It is necessary to push back against this idea that Islam, or any religion can a nation to liberation. Nasreen Jazayeri4, although a revisionist, provides a useful summary of the reactionary role that Islam plays in both class and national liberation struggles;

The leaders and core cadres of these Islamic movements generally come from: the clergy who aspire to be restored to their old place in the ruling structure or seek greater accommodation with the system, disgruntled urban middle class intellectuals, and sections of the feudal-comprador classes pushed out of the ruling structures (i.e. splits within the exploiting, propertied classes of these societies). But their foot soldiers come from amongst the desperate displaced urban masses who from afar are being seduced by the “oppositional” posturing of these reactionaries. What makes these Islamic movements reactionary is not mainly the class origins of their leaders and core cadre, but rather their promotion of an archaic ideology – a religious ideology – that is not based on reality, and therefore is absolutely unable to transform the present day realities of the world. And they are reactionary because they want to preserve the same class-structured oppressive societies, simply making them “more Islamic” (by applying the sharia, which is the Islamic law based on the Koran and tradition, written after the death of Mohammed and subsequently updated many times by each Islamic sect). This can only mean, and has meant, strengthening the feudal-patriarchal elements of society. These movements in different parts of the Muslim world uphold one of the various brands of Islam – Shiite or Sunni, for example. But almost all of them adhere to the basic tenets of Islamic ideology – with unimportant nuances – and derive the future promised Islamic society from the old models established by the original Islamic prophets. Specifically, the society established by Muhammad is cited as the most favourable model by almost all of these trends. All misfortunes of the Muslim countries are explained away as a “deviation” from this early model, which according to them was corrupted after the first four caliphs (successors to Mohammed).

The Islamic fundamentalist forces have been opposing the imperialist powers and the ruling cliques of these countries with hot rhetoric and, at times, violent actions. But they are easily co-opted, becoming the new and at times more ruthless guardians of the same old system. This dynamic took place in a major way during the Cold War, when the US launched its Green Belt strategy to make use of the Islamic countries (Islam is symbolised by the colour green) strung along the southern border of the USSR, to contain and later help dismember its Soviet social-imperialist rival. The US imperialists aided the rapid development of the Islamic fundamentalist forces in Afghanistan in the 1980s, and it was the US imperialists and their European allies that opened the way for Khomeini and his cohorts in Iran to hijack a great revolution there. Under a false revolutionary mantle, they established themselves as the new ruling clique, quashing the real revolution and massacring the revolutionary and communist forces. It must be brought to light that the 1979 defeat of the revolution in Iran, through the establishment of the theocratic regime, was a product of the collaboration between the Western imperialist powers and the Islamic fundamentalist forces in Iran. US General Huizer was right when he said, “We unplugged the Shah and plugged in Khomeini.” (See the review of his book on the Iranian revolution in AWTW 1986/6.) In the last 25 years, the biggest Islamic jihad was financed by the US imperialists – the war of the Islamic fundamentalists of Afghanistan (the generic name for them was mujahedeen, which is Arabic for fighters) against the Soviet Union. The experience of the last two decades has ripped apart the mask of the Islamic forces and shows that they are neither revolutionary nor anti-imperialist. Islam is and can only be an ideology and tool of the exploiters.5

What can be understood from this is that while many Islamist groups have played some role in combating US imperalism, they often end up supporting it such as in the case of the Mujahideen in Afghanistan. This is due primarily to the ideology of Islamism as a reactionary ideology seeking to refound a past era of feudalism, and secondarily with the main leadership of Islamism being those who would benefit most; not the working class, but clergy and feudal compradors looking for a position of leadership. Or, in Canada the imperialists.

Taking this to Palestine, there is further evidence of the counter-revolutionary role Islam has played. As pointed out by Jazayeri, Islam cannot play a uniting role for Palestinians. Hamas, an openly Islamist group claiming to fight for Palestine. While at its current standpoint, it plays a relatively progressive role in leading the national liberation struggle in Palestine in their military operations against the Israeli Defense Force, and have been willing to work with other progressive classes in the region, they are ultimately a bureaucrat capitalist party with a heavily political Islamic line. With a successful military struggle against the Israeli state, they would at best be able to bring Palestine from the status of a semi-colony and become the administrators of imperialism for another imperialist country. Bringing a colony to the status of a semi-colony is not national liberation. Such a national struggle can only be accomplished by a communist party and the class leadership of the working class in Palestine. This will involve a push against Islamic institutions that prop up organisations like Hamas, and a combat of political Islam in the ideological sphere as it can only reinforce a bureaucrat capitalist government in Palestine. Islam is not a friend of Palestinian liberation.

Even at the protest on the UofC campus on the 12th Islamism was playing a wrecking role. The original plan for the event from organisations like the Watermelon Foundation and Justice For Palestinians was to march in a nearby park. This was sidelined and had to be conducted on the university grounds. This was due to the arrival of Omar Suleiman, a Palestinian Imam who wanted to scrap any mass action in favour of preaching to only the university’s Muslim Student Association and similar groups and individuals.

From all of this it is clear that Islam plays a fundamentally reactionary role in detracting from the masses who seek liberation by causing disunity and either mobilise a section of the masses to sporadic actions, or are out right co-opting in their role and serve to entirely demobilise the masses in favour of turning to religion, rather than concrete action.

To restate the point, it is neither Islam, nor any religion that should be seen as a means for liberation. To underscore that point, there have been numerous instances in recent history in Canada where religions like Catholicism have played a similar reactionary role to link up with ruling powers and quell mass action in the case of the national liberation of Indigenous Canadians, such as the visit of Pope Francis in 2022.6 What the working class of Canada, Palestine, and all nations of the world need is not a religion to turn to, but a scientific ideology that will unite the whole working class against all ruling classes. This ideology is not religious, but scientific. This ideology is Marxism-Leninsim-Maoism-Gonzalo Thought, the guiding thought of the Canadian revolution.

1. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/palestine-encampment-western-university-london-ontario-1.7202544

2. https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/ilwu-unions-ceasefire-israel-gaza/

3. https://www.cjpme.org/pr_2023_06_12_arms_exports

4. It should be noted that Jazayeri was a revisionist herself, and a member of the revisionist and Avakian “Communist Party of Iran (Marxist-Leninist-Maoist), and should not generally be viewed as a true, strong revolutionary

5. https://www.bannedthought.net/International/RIM/AWTW/2002-28/28_Islam.htm

6. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2022/08/01/denounce-pope-francis-visit-revolution-not-reconciliation/


Response to “Criticising Two Lines in Actions for Palestinian Liberation – by Ivan D.”

  1. Report and Summation of the UBC Vancouver Encampment – by Kale – The People's Hammer