Rachel Notley, leader of the Alberta NDP since October 2014 and former premier announced in January 2024 her intention to step down as party leader.1 Her decision to resign came after 2 failed electoral campaigns under her leadership following her initial victory in 2015.2
Six candidates initially put themselves forward to replace Notley. MLA Kathleen Ganley, MLA Sarah Hoffman, MLA Jodi Calahoo Stonehouse, 20-year Alberta Federation of Labour president Gil McGowan, former Calgary mayor Naheed Nenshi, and MLA Rakhi Pancholi.3 Both Pancholi and McGowan have since withdrawn. Pancholi withdrew to support Nenshi’s campaign,4 while McGowan was forced to resign after failing to raise the $60 000 entry fee (a fee that exists to prevent workers from being able to take part in the leadership of the “workers’ party”).5
Since Notley announced her resignation, the party has grown five times in size to more than 85 000 members.6
The election of a new NDP leader is playing out in the midst of a two-line struggle in the NDP that has been particularly intense in the Alberta branch of the party. This two-line struggle is part of the general liquidation of social-democracy. The split that occurred in the international communist movement in the first world war produced those who maintained the principles of Marxism reunited under the Communist International and the broad group of social-democrats united in the Labour and Socialist International. Among the social-democrats a left-wing and a right-wing existed. The left generally supported socialism and was willing to build a united front of workers, but opposed the strategy and tactics of the international communist movement and the dictatorship of the proletariat. The right-wing often rejected socialism completely and fought for a united front with the bourgeoisie against the rank-and-file, unemployed, and unorganised workers and their allies. In Canada, the right-wing of social-democracy gradually defeated the left-wing entirely. Today, these left-wing social-democrats are not found in the leadership of the NDP and other social-democratic parties. Despite this, social-democracy as a whole has had its basis in the labour aristocracy and the union bureaucracy.
In the past few decades the NDP, a right-wing social-democratic party, has liquidated further under the leadership of Mulcair and Singh. Socialism has been written out of the party constitution entirely.7 The party has also turned its back on the part of the labour movement that it represented: the union bureaucracy and labour aristocracy by abandoning its demands for better conditions and wages in favour of the demands of the urban petite-bourgeoisie.8 This liquidation has been greater in the Alberta branch than in the other sections particularly under Notley’s leadership. This stage of liquidation has not yet been completed and is coming to head in the Alberta NDP’s leadership contest.
The right-wing of the NDP has been represented in this election by Stonehouse, Nenshi, Hoffman and Pancholi. The left has been represented by Ganley and McGowan. This can be seen in the programmes each has put forward for their campaigns.
Stonehouse has declared the focus of her campaign is access to water.9 Access to clean drinking water is an issue that the masses of rural Canada especially on the reserves face, however, this is a demand that can be found in the platform of nearly every party in the country.
Nenshi is both the front runner and the foremost representative of the right in the NDP. Nenshi has never been associated with the NDP and only joined in order to enter the race.10 He has been the most explicit about the need of the NDP to abandon its role as the political arm of the union bureaucracy and labour aristocracy in Canada in order to become a “big-tent” party.11 Nenshi has put forward no programme or political line.12 When asked by The Alberta Worker about Nenshi’s labour programme, Nenshi’s campaign responded:
“given that Naheed is running to be leader of the official opposition, he is wary of releasing ‘policy’ that can appear as promises he can’t keep. Plus, he does not what to subvert the party membership by dictating policy without proper membership deliberation.”13
However, we can see where he stands by looking at his actions as mayor of Calgary. Under Nenshi’s administration, Calgary evicted the residents of Midfield Mobile Home in 2017.14 In 2019, Nenshi appealed to the provincial government to violate the city workers’ contracts and deny their wage increase.15 Nenshi’s campaign is being directed by a longtime Alberta Party leader Chima Nkemdrim and managed by a former aide to Justin Trudeau.16
Hoffman, like Stonehouse, has no programme only a focus on health, climate, and housing.17
Ganley and McGowan can generally be seen on the left of the NDP (though still part of right-wing social-democracy overall). This is because they are all still committed to the NDP as the political wing of the TLC and are opposed to the abandonment of the labour aristocracy and union bureaucracy at the sake of petite-bourgeois votes. Ganley has received the support of former Alberta NDP leader Brian Mason.18 In the labour movement, Ganley’s programme calls for the abolition of the youth wage, raising the minimum wage to $16, then $17, and finally pegging it to inflation every following year. She also opposes leaving the Canadian Pension Plan. She is campaigning for the return of card-based unionisation, the overturning of Bill 32,19 and prohibiting double-breasting where a company operates two affiliated companies, one union, one not in order to bid on non-union work.20
Nenshi along with Ganley, and Pancholi have all voiced support to some degree in the separation of the Alberta and federal NDP. This reflects the high-level of opportunism among the Alberta branch.21 Pancholi expressed the opportunism of this split most overtly saying it was an attempt to separate the provincial NDP from federal NDP policies that are unpopular with UCP voters.22 One big example of this that occurred under Notley’s administration was her support for Trudeau’s purchase of the TMX while the federal NDP opposed it.23 The NDP is concerned only with its electoral performance and not with winning the demands of the proletariat.
Th final candidate is Gil McGowan. While he has dropped out, it is important to still look at his campaign as it relates to the two-line struggle in the provincial NDP. As stated before, while McGowan is found among the left of the Alberta NDP in that he continues to represent the interests of the labour aristocracy and the union bureaucracy as opposed to the right of the NDP which is based on the petite-bourgeoisie, he is a right-wing social-democrat overall.
McGowan is the president of the AFL, having been in that position for 20 years.24 McGowan’s campaign had a highly labour-focused programme.25 He has been vocal that the NDP must remain a workers party (in reality it has only ever been a party representing the upper crust of the class), saying:
“The party has been drifting away from workers in the labour movement for a very long time. Now I’m afraid that drift is going to turn into a gallop and that will hurt their prospects in the next election no matter who leads it.”26
The right-wing social-democratic nature of McGowan was revealed when he cited former progressive conservative premier Peter Lougheed and Joe Biden as models for his future government’s industrial policy.27 He also sought to divide Canadian and permanent resident workers from illegal and temporary immigrant workers in Alberta. From The Alberta Worker:
“McGowan claims that Alberta’s market ‘has been flooded labour market by a large and increasing number of non-permanent residents’, which employers like because these workers are less likely to push back against exploitation and less likely to leave their job for a better job. He wants to refocus immigration growth in the labour force to what he called ‘real immigration’.
“He wants to increase investigation and enforcement toward employers using undocumented workers. Employers who bring in large numbers of undocumented and temporary workers do so because it’s cheaper. Not only because they are less likely to ask for more money but because a larger labour force means there are more workers competing for jobs, so workers are more willing to accept lower pay. A tight labour market increases wages overall.”28
The reason why the bourgeoisie may choose to hire workers in Canada illegally or temporarily is due to the low wages and conditions that they can be given compared to Canadian and permanent resident workers. The proletarian response to this question is not to pit the two against each other in order to tighten the labour market, but to organise workers regardless of nationality. The temporary and illegal immigrant workers will see their wages and conditions increase and the Canadian workers will see less competition with these workers. As a result, the bourgeoisie’s ability to push down wages and conditions is diminished.
For the mass of workers, whether Nenshi or McGowan’s faction takes leadership of the NDP does not matter. The NDP, in Alberta especially, is a right-wing social-democratic party more inclined to unity with the bourgeoisie than a united working-class. It has proven its inability to deliver even superficial demands to the workers everywhere it has held government. The workers must abandon the illusion of transforming the NDP into a workers’ party and fight for the reconstitution of the Communist Party of Canada.
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-ndp-leadership-big-tent-party-versus-left-wing-values-1.7193773
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-ndp-leadership-big-tent-party-versus-left-wing-values-1.7193773
- https://edmonton.ctvnews.ca/alberta-ndp-leadership-race-final-tally-shows-historic-membership-mcgowan-drops-out-1.6884695
- https://edmonton.ctvnews.ca/alberta-ndp-leadership-race-final-tally-shows-historic-membership-mcgowan-drops-out-1.6884695
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-votes-to-take-socialism-out-of-party-constitution-1.1385171
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/17/crush-fightback-and-destroy-trotskyism/
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-ndp-leadership-big-tent-party-versus-left-wing-values-1.7193773
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-ndp-leadership-big-tent-party-versus-left-wing-values-1.7193773
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/city-to-close-midfield-mobile-home-park-in-2017-1.2655659
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-ndp-naheed-nenshi-letter-anti-union-1.7198518
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/naheed-nenshi-ndp-leadership-campaign-orbit-1.7146018
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-ndp-leadership-big-tent-party-versus-left-wing-values-1.7193773
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/02/28/resist-albertas-anti-worker-laws/
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-ndp-federal-party-ties-1.7159926
- https://rabble.ca/politics/canadian-politics/gil-mcgowan-bows-out-of-alberta-ndp-leadership-race/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-ndp-federal-party-ties-1.7159926
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
- https://thetyee.ca/Opinion/2024/05/15/Alberta-NDP-Leadership-Race-Heats-Up/
- https://albertapolitics.ca/2024/03/rakhi-pancholi-quits-ndp-leadership-race-endorses-naheed-nenshi/
- https://albertaworker.ca/news/ndp-leadership-candidates-on-worker-issues/
Responses to “NDP Alberta Leadership Election – by Daniel H.”
[…] 8https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 8. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 11 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 3 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike