
All across Canada, university students are demanding that the institutions they find themselves in begin to cut ties with Israel and its ongoing imperialist war in Palestine. This demand is being backed up by students setting up encampments on university grounds. Currently, the student encampment at the University of Toronto (called the People’s Circle for Palestine) is on its 43rd day of protest. Upon entering the main grounds of the campus, the central lawn space has been fenced in by the protesters. The barricades used by the students have been draped in tarp, with an organizer later informing us that they were put up to protect the identities of the students from surveillance. The tarp is adorned with various slogans, paintings, posters, leaflets, etc.
A spokesperson stated “The demands of the protest are simple, for the University of Toronto to divest from Israel and its occupation of Palestine.” Another stated, “We would like to put more pressure on the university, we want this to end just as much as they do and we will do so within the bounds of the law.” They also stated “I don’t think it matters if you’re on the left, the right, if you haven’t turned on a TV in the past month, the University of Toronto shouldn’t be involved with Israel.” In their fight, the People’s Circle has worked with organizations such as the Ontario Federation of Labour(OFL), Canadian Union of Public Employees(CUPE), and the Palestinian Youth Movement(PYM). A retired CUPE worker was present at the encampment and had the following to say about the students. “They seem to be well organized ad they have the support of the union. I hope that they’re prepared for the long haul, this battle won’t be over anytime soon.”
A problem that the organizers have been facing during the duration of the protest has been counter-protesters. An old Zionist was seen harassing the organizers and attempting to call the police. Many of the counter-protesters are unorganized and simply lash out against the People’s Circle, however it was stated that the Jewish Defense League, a terrorist organization, attempted to disrupt the activities of the circle. Zionist actors have also frequently been seen sticking their phones above the barricades to attempt to record and uncover the identities of protesters. Further, the police have set up flood lights and new security cameras facing into the encampment for the same reason.
The presence of opportunists at the encampment
At the entrance of the People’s Circle for Palestine there was a member of the Trotskyist organization “Communist Revolution” (Formerly Fightback) attempting to hand passerby their materials. Unsurprisingly, the people were uninterested in engaging with them. After about 30 minuted of sitting idly by, they quietly packed up their things and left. Speaking with one of the organizers responsible for letting people into the circle, they stated that “We previously let someone from Fightback into the encampment but they caused a disturbance and we had to remove them. They tried to portray us as “Anti-Communists” as they were being escorted out, but many of the people here are communist themselves or communist sympathetic.” Another organizer stated they had previously worked with Fightback but were put off by the overly centralized and “cultish” behaviour of the organization. They also stated that it was the policy of the organization to never plan their own events, but rather to attend events planned by actual popular groups uninvited in an attempt to bring more people into the fold of their revisionism.
Of course, Communist Revolution was not the only opportunist organization present. Posters and signs from every Trotskyist organization could be found, such as Bolshevik Tendency, The Sparticist League, & Socialist Action. In addition, signs from the Communist Party of Canada(Marxist-Leninist) & other non-Trotskyist revisionists could be found. What could not be found, however, was what these organizations were doing to aid in the struggle of the students. This comes as little surprise, the opportunists aren’t concerned with the interests of the popular masses, either here in Canada or in Palestine.
Shortcomings
While the students should be supported in their efforts, there are some issues surrounding the movement that should also be taken into consideration. Firstly, while there are efforts being made to cooperate with unions and other progressive organizations, there needs to be greater emphasis put on incorporating university workers such as janitors into the protest to increase pressure on the school. In addition, many construction workers were at the site of the protest with large industrial machinery, however it seemed as though no effort had been made to win these workers over to the cause. These workers and their tools could be an asset to force the hand of the university. A few of the signs on the barricade read “The students united will never be defeated”. This is a concerning attitude, as without the economic power of the workers there is little damage the students can do to the university aside from bad publicity. Another concerning slogan seen at the encampment read “From McGill to UofT, Palestine is almost free”. The liberation of Palestine is still going to require a monumental effort, and our task of smashing Canadian imperialism will also take a great deal of struggle to achieve. Secondly, the position of the students is vulnerable to repression by the state. The site of the encampment can be surrounded and all paths out of the encampment area can be blocked by a coordinated action from the police. With no plans of resisting the authorities, the protesters may face repression similar to that of Calgary.1 The organizers have also stated that the decision to occupy university buildings has been rejected, instead focusing on peaceful negotiations with the administration which have self admittedly been described as being in “stalemate”. In rejecting this tactic, they lose a valuable tool in forcing the administration into meeting their demands.
Conclusion
We stand in solidarity with the students in their fight against Canadian & Israeli imperialism. Any criticism is made in the effort of aiding their struggle, and we hope that our commentary can be of value to the students. We hope that their demands are met and that the students will continue to struggle in support of the liberation of Palestine, the destruction of Canadian imperialism, and the reconstitution of the Communist Party of Canada as a means to achieve these aims. We also welcome any criticism that the students may have of us, and would like to extend an open invitation for dialogue to any reader involved in the protest.
Responses to “Report from the University of Toronto Student Encampment – by Mels G. & Cynthia M.”
[…] 4: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/28/report-from-the-university-of-toronto-student-encampm… […]
LikeLike
[…] 4: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/28/report-from-the-university-of-toronto-student-encampm… […]
LikeLike
[…] 1: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/report-and-summation-of-the-ubc-vancouver-encampment-by-kale/ and https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/28/report-from-the-university-of-toronto-student-encampm… […]
LikeLike