The People's Hammer

Report from the Abolitionist Pride Rally – by Mels G. & Cliff Z.

,


On June 30th the No Pride in Policing Coalition (NPPC) held its annual Abolitionist Pride event at Grange park in downtown Toronto. Similarly to in years before, the event consisted of a march in front of the 52 Division Toronto Police service building while chanting various slogans and holding various speeches. The purpose of the event is to promote the idea of police abolition, a belief that instead of reforming the police, they should be abolished while under the liberal state structure.

The Problem With Abolitionist Ideology

Before we address the abolitionist ideology, we must first understand what the purpose of the police is and how they came into being. The police are one of the manifestations of the State, the armed wing of the ruling class. Every oppressive class in history (today, the capitalists) has had its particular organization of armed force. The slave states, such as the Roman Republic, utilized a police force in the form of slaves tasked with the violent oppression of their unruly peers. In the feudal states, such as pre-revolutionary France, landlords hired mercenaries to keep the peasants in line. Today, in capitalist society, the police exist as the protectors of the capital of the bourgeoisie. In all of these cases, we see that the organization of violence does not exist independent of the economic oppression of the masses, but instead it is done so directly to facilitate this violence.

Abolitionist ideology believes that we can eliminate the violent wing of the ruling class without doing away with the ruling class itself. Even if the formal police as we understand them are abolished, some new form of organization would take its place to fulfill the same purpose. We see this increasingly with the hiring of private security forces by large companies or other institutions like universities. The only real solution to the issue of state violence is to smash the state as it exists, and build a state for the working people through People’s War. If the supporters of this mode of thinking are committed to this ideology, there is very little that separates them qualitatively from a common liberal. Instead, they merely seek to change the quantitative amount of violence perpetrated by the State.

Issues With The No Pride In Policing Coalition

As a result of following an ideology which does not understand the functioning of the State, it follows that the practice of the organization and its followers is flawed. This manifests itself in a number of ways during the various yearly rallies they hold:

1.) Lack of militant organization;

2.) Lack of political program;

3.) Lack of organizational foresight;

4.) Lack of commitment to their own principles.

Let us tackle each of these issues through their manifestation in the organization’s practice.

Lack Of Militant Organization

The structure of the rally is incredibly loose. There are a few core members who are directly affiliated with the Coalition, many members of the supporter organizations, and a large number of people who have no formal affiliation to the Coalition who have showed up to the rally on their own whims. The organizational structure of the rally is focused on decentralism, resulting in many moments where it is unclear who should be speaking, where the rally is moving, and how to arrange their pieces of propaganda. All of the various organizations involved have their own leadership and membership structures, resulting in incongruity at the coalition level. If instead it was a centralized body, issues of leadership and organization could be handled internally rather than manifesting as public disorganization during the rally. In a frankly embarrassing example of their disorganization, their About Us page states “NPPC continues to hold its yearly Abolition Pride. 2023 which was titled ‘No More Shit! Anti-Abolitionists (italics ours) and Anti-Fascist Pride’ had approximately 10,000 people march with us on the streets.”1 How one could miss such a fundamental mistake is beyond reason.

The Coalition also suffers from a false understanding of what militarism is. Militarism requires a deep level of organization, which as discussed above the Coalition does not have. Beyond this, militarism is not when you stage a protest or shout crude slogans at the police. Militarism entails a willingness and capacity to fight in order to achieve your goals. No where is it made clear that the rally was held with the intention of pushing their goals forward through force, instead they intend to make their goal manifest through chants, speeches, poems, and a mildly inconvenient blocking of downtown streets. Aside from the final point, what will these actions do to force the hand of the bourgeois politicians, the bourgeois organizers of Toronto Pride, or the police? The answer, of course, is very little. One poster from a protester could read “Pride is a riot” however there was certainly no rioting or any other such violent activity present.

Contrast this to the organization and militancy of the Toronto Police Service. Every single officer in attendance had a defined role with equipment and strategy designed to handle crowds. Each officer was organized into specific units and separated by duty, for example riot control and medic. This allows them to immediately respond to situations as they arise. If the police were to have engaged the rally, the attendants would have been unable to operate at the same level of efficiency of the police in order to combat them. While strength in numbers is a tactical advantage, a relatively smaller force can overpower a relatively larger force through the use of more sophisticated strategy, tactics, and logistics. If a confrontation had broken out, it is likely that this would have resulted in a defeat for the Coalition on the basis of inferior strategy, tactics, and logistics.

Lack Of Political Program

On the Coalition’s website, they have stated the aims for their 2024 rally which read as follows

“– We are demanding the liberation of Palestine

– We will celebrate the fierce resistance and labour of queers and trans, medical personnel, women, educators and others in Gaza, Rafah and elsewhere in Palestine who have been defending Palestinians against Israeli bombardments

– We will celebrate the determination and resilience of the many queers and trans Palestinians, Arabs, Jewish, Indigenous and two-spirit, Black and racialized people who have been on the front lines protesting the Israeli genocide of Palestinians

– We will name all the violators and genociders and demand they be held accountable for their crimes

– We will make clear the intensification of brutal policing attacks against protesters and demand the abolition of police, prisons and all forms of carcerality

– We will hold each other close as we march together, as we sing, as we dance, as we refuse and resist any attempts to stop us from marching for our lives.”2

None of this amounts to a political line in which march goers may arrive and understand what they must do, why they must do it and how they should go about it. The only goal here that could possibly apply pressure to the local politicians is the intention to name and hold accountable those who have contributed to the Palestinian genocide, and this is a generous stretch. Nothing within these goals threatens the existence of police, prisons, or “carcerality” as they deem it. They have provided no basis for those who are interested to organize and move beyond this one march and its list of goals.

Nowhere on their website can you find a definitive political program, which is indicative of their eclectic ideology. What can be found are lists of demands in previous years rally statements, such as their 2023 Statement3. Without a definite political program and without proper militancy as discussed above, how do they plan on winning their demands? They state the following, “We will continue to build a mass movement of all those harmed by Toronto police, and of all people who believe in freedom from police surveillance and control. We remember and honour those killed by police, and those who have survived criminalization and violence. With love and determination, we will build the political will that is lacking in Toronto’s political class.”4. The NPPC does not believe in combating the state with power and force, instead swaying them with “love and determination.” Instead of using the power of the masses, the NPPC instead wants to use their mass base as a way to sway the bourgeois politicians of City Council into enacting their demands. In rejecting the strength of the people, they affirm the strength of the police, and the state apparatus as a whole, which they so vehemently hate!

Lack Of Organizational Foresight

During the rally, few if any future plans were announced or planned. If it is clear to the state that your group is only going to organize a rally on an annual basis, what motive do they have to listen to you? They can simply put up with one day per year of minor disturbance and continue enacting the same policies for the other 364 days. What needs to be done is constant, unwavering movement that pushes for your aims, not a yearly boil over where everyone simply goes home the next day. Of course, the various organizations involved have their own events and actions, but if these are not being promoted at the rally, why does the rally and the Coalition exist in the first place? All of this is of course due to the lack of a definite political program.

Lack Of Commitment To Their Own Principles

The entire thesis behind the organization and the rally is that the police are a violent institution that should be done away with. The NPPC shuns Toronto Pride for allowing police officers at the event, so naturally it should follow that the NPPC would refuse involvement with the police in any capacity. Unfortunately, this is not the case. During the beginning of the rally, one of their vehicles was unable to move. The organizers were unable to get it started again, and the event was running behind schedule. In a desperate attempt to continue as normal, organizers of the event called over an officer to inspect the issue and get the truck going.


After the officer resolved the issue and returned to the police line, the organizers began rousing the crowd with chants of “Fuck the police.” Officers could be seen laughing during this fiasco.

This behaviour from the NPPC should be scorned by their supporters, and we encourage any supporter reading to make their dissatisfaction with Coalition leadership known.

The Alternative Pride Protest

With all these calls for justice in Palestine within their writings and speeches, one must wonder how these messages can break out beyond the NPPC’s echo chamber. Fortunately, a proper disruption of the police that not only called for attention to Palestine generally, but properly demanded the attention of all Pride Toronto attendants happened on the same day as the NPPC event. This group did not organize their own separate pride, tucked away from the Pride Toronto event, they hijacked it. The Coalition Against Pinkwashing organized and executed a disruption of the corporate pride event and succeeded in forcing roughly 67 of the floats to stop marching5. The Coalition Against Pinkwashing aimed to directly call out Pride Toronto’s corporate and police interest and force it to halt its operations. This strategy was so much more successful than the NPPC’s because they forced themselves into the bourgeois Pride Toronto and painted clearly the contradictions between corporate interest and the interest of the masses. This disruption came about because this group had met with Pride Toronto, stated their demands, and been refused. When an attempt at democratic negotiations was shoved to the side, they planned militantly to ensure their voices were heard and their opposition’s drowned out. Their attempt was effective enough to cut the parade short, to halt the lies that the private corporations and the Canadian government support LGBT+ people, that refuses to listen to the interests of these groups and make lasting change to their conditions. It forced the whole city to witness the uncomfortable truth of the Palestinian genocide. Contrast this with the NPPC, asking the police they so vehemently despise for help starting their truck.

Conclusion

The No Pride In Policing Coalition and its Abolitionist Pride event are deeply flawed, both in their theory and practice. Of course, the basic idea that the police are an institution that exist to harm the people and protect the ruling class is true. However, the solution to this is not to beg to the ruling class themselves to get rid of this institution. All abolitionists must take up the task of studying Marxism-Leninism-Maoism-Gonzalo Thought, as well as study the conditions of Canada to fully understand the revolutionary path forward. We greatly encourage all supporters of the NPPC to join us in the struggle for reconstituting the Communist Party of Canada, as without it we cannot effectively beat back the police and the oppressive class they defend.

Citations

1.) https://www.noprideinpolicing.ca/about-us/

2.) https://www.noprideinpolicing.ca/statements/nppc-pride-2024/

3.) https://www.noprideinpolicing.ca/home/

4.) https://www.noprideinpolicing.ca/media/apologies/

5.) https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/pro-palestinian-protesters-say-toronto-pride-parade-stopped-over-refusal-to-meet-demands-1.6948119


Responses to “Report from the Abolitionist Pride Rally – by Mels G. & Cliff Z.”

  1. On Movementism – by Mels G. – The People's Hammer
  2. Translation: Hareketçilik Üzerine – Mels G. Tarafından – The People's Hammer
  3. Ontario Throws $77M at The OPP Price Hike – By Cliff Z. – The People's Hammer
  4. Report from Toronto May Day – By Mels G. – The People's Hammer