Mels: Just to get underway, what is your current position?
TA: I am a teaching assistant from CUPE 3903 and a PhD candidate
Mels: What do you study?
TA: Social & Political Thought is the program and I am in the Black Studies stream
Mels: What position do you hold in CUPE 3903?
TA: I am a rank-and-file member, I’m a very active rank-and-file member. I organize a lot of rank-and-file specific events. I like to think of the union as very unique because it emphasizes and insists on the fact that it is rank-and-file driven. But I think that the ethos of the union is starting to disappear a bit, so we are trying to bring the executives in line with the rank-and-file membership. I’m part of the effort to try and revitalize that understanding of the union and I organize around this.
Mels: So, tell me about the recent strike
TA: Yes, we lost hard! The strike was very interesting and I’ve been thinking about it a lot lately. A lot of the organizing I’ve been doing is around creating room for militant members of the rank-and-file to assess what went wrong because the strike was very interesting. There was a very top-down effort to ensure that we failed including what felt like the bargaining team and our executives. We think there are lots of reasons for that. Coming off of a strike where equity was weaponized against a desire to increase wages was interesting but also a very disturbing thing to encounter. We were dealing with an executive and a bargaining team that understood equity as a separate set of issues from wages, we were dealing with an overwhelming police militarization of our picket lines and an arrest of one of our picket captains that was widely unaddressed by the media as well as the labour movement broadly. We had executive members that tried to repress that story because they felt like it risked compromising the optics of our strike. We are in a interesting moment with 3903. There is a desire to remove the militancy from the space and bring it into the common liberal union structure. This is of course a dialectical inevitability, so we are working intensely to go against this move.
Mels: You mentioned that there are issues with the higher up members of the union, can you tell me some specific problems around them?
TA: Yes, of course. Focusing on the strike as it is a clear example, many of the executive members didn’t believe in the integrity of the picket lines because they didn’t think they produced any leverage and would instead create animosity from the wider community. Many of the executives, as well as many rank-and-file members, don’t understand what solidarity is. They think that solidarity is about undermining the integrity of the striking position. We see the language of equity and diversity weaponized to actually advance the interests of the employer all the time. For example, there was a rank-and-file member who expressed dissatisfaction with something called the racialized harassment fund which is essentially a $30,000 fund in order to protect employees who faced harassment. The bargaining team unilaterally decided this was a red line without any consultation of the broad membership including members of colour. This rank-and-file member was accused of being a racist and was subsequently thrown around as a reason why militant communist components of the union are impossible to work with. There is a sort of “Tumblr-ification” of politics happening at the executive level. Luckily, there has been an identification of the issues within the higher-ups, particularly that many don’t even understand what a union or a strike actually is. There has been turnover but we are still cautious. Within the CUPE structure, the higher up you go the more conservative things get.
Mels: Are you familiar with industrial unionism by any chance?
TA: No
Mels: Essentially, it states that all workers with one industry should be under a single large union rather than divided among various unions or local structures. Do you think this is something that would benefit your situation?
TA: Yes, I think in general scaling up always better, especially in our current environment where unionism is so focused on legal strike action which is deeply limiting in the leverage it can develop. With our strike, there was a huge effort to co-ordinate with 3902, which is the equivalent union at UofT, to strike at the same time. I didn’t work out ultimately because 3902 got a deal that they were comfortable with. I think that in general, the hyper-fixation with the individualism of union strategy is a losing strategy.
Mels: Certainly if there was better co-ordination between the two, the strike would have been more successful.
TA: Yes, exactly. One of the other issues with the strike was that other workers were crossing our picket line to continue business as usual. Of course, they are coerced into doing so by management, and wildcat striking is highly criminalized currently as well. I also have been wondering how to work more across sectors within our workplace to make sure that doesn’t happen, and how to strike to actually shut down York rather than having just a section of the workers withholding their labour until they’re forced back.
Mels: As a communist yourself, do you try to agitate your co-workers? If so, what problems and successes have you seen?
TA: I’m always trying to agitate my co-workers. The Social & Political Thought program is interesting because it attracts a primarily communist group of people. Of course, what particularly that means is subject to debate amongst ourselves but there is a shared ethos. Social & Political Thought is also a space that has been increasingly attracting reactionary philosopher types, for example Hegel without Marx people. A lot of the work others and I have been trying to do is to maintain the radical edge of the program, which has been a theatre for CUPE 3903 in general. A lot of my time at York has been about defending that spirit of agitation against intellectualism that is focused on pragmatism or explicit reactionary beliefs. More broadly, my academic work focuses on political violence, I am fascinated by watching academics seek to resolve problems through fantasy and idealism. Sometimes it is very difficult to break through these thoughts for people, and people often get upset with my work.
Mels: I would think that means you are on the right path.
TA: Thank you, I would agree. But we need to have these people break past the emotions and really take in the ideas I’m trying to spread.
Mels: Certainly. Do you think that these academics are so stuck in their ways because there is no genuine Communist Party in Canada?
TA: Yea, we can be honest in saying that the “Communist Party of Canada” is a joke. It is entirely incoherent.
Mels: And that is to ignore all the controversies they are in as well.
TA: Yes. Obviously we are still living in the aftermath of Red Scare propaganda, but I think it is very important that we insist on the communist label. I think that the gut reaction to be like “I’m a socialist” is underpinned by a kind of liberalism. Sorry I’ve gotten a bit off track, could you repeat your question?
Mels: Of course. Is the lack of action among academics due to the lack of a real Communist Party of Canada?
TA: Yea absolutely. In academia there is a fetishism on the idea of radicalism, and particularly with a “pure” radicalism that doesn’t understand the impurity of political violence. I find it distressing because it can be very difficult to puncture this trend.
Mels: You’ve given your opinion on the so-called “Communist Party of Canada,” what do you have to say about the other “communist” organizations in Canada such as Fightback (currently “Communist Revolution”)?
TA: Its hard for me to even take these organizations seriously, and I’m sure there are well meaning people working in these organizations so I don’t mean to blanket critique everyone involved.
Mels: And the problem with the genuine people is that they are looking for something where it doesn’t exist so they get brought into the fold of their revisionism.
TA: Yes, it feels like a sort of strange cult.
Mels: You are certainly not the first person to use that word.
TA: Oftentimes when I am at social gatherings when I meet people and they hear about my political opinions they are quite taken aback by the fact that I do not organize in those spaces. Firstly, I’m always looking to organize where I am at first and scale up from there. Secondly, I’m always thinking that these just aren’t serious sites of organizing. I would be more than happy to contribute to a program that I think is serious.
Mels: Scaling back a bit, what are some of the main issues that you face in your field of work?
TA: The impossibility of talking about violence is definitely first and foremost. I mean that both in my academic work and my union work. During the strike, there was an obsession with maintaining the legal integrity of the strike, anything that could possibly risk an injunction was heavily, heavily pushed back against by the executive along with the deputized rank-and-file members.
Mels: We saw the same issue in relation to the UofT encampment, they wanted to maintain legality at all costs. Even their speeches touted the fact that they never engaged in any political violence or engaged the police.
TA: Yes, yes. I’m very disturbed by this move that is happening. I don’t want to boil it down to something as simple as progress or regress but it really is a regression to me of the kind of conversations that are happening. It’s a trap because we know what the purpose of the law is, to maintain the racist capitalist order. We know that a strike will only be legal in as much as it doesn’t actually do anything to harm the boss. To play into this is to consistently invest in our own humiliating loss and I am not interested in playing out a sort of humiliation kink through politics.
Mels: How did you become interested in communist politics?
TA: That’s a great question, I think I had an unorthodox path. In my youth, I thought I was a Libertarian. I had a critique of the state because I come from a very poor rural community, I saw the abandonment and state violence in a very clear way. A lot of people like to romanticize rural white communities but they are not pretty. Horrible things have happened there, and they are also deeply anti-communist places. Anyways, I ended up in UOttawa and studied what I had seen very seriously and came up against contradictions in my own thoughts. I also started talking to other socialist and communist people and realized that I was wrong. I had a hard and fast turn from Libertarian to anarchist and ultimately to communism.
Mels: Growing up in a rural community, what needs to happen economically to improve their situation?
TA: The first thing is that there needs to be safe housing, the core of small towns are often dilapidated houses. Also, access to healthcare. I used to have to drive 45 minutes to see a doctor which obviously promotes skepticism around doctors. A major problem that needs to be solved in order to begin to fix the situation is effective political education for people in rural areas, which can obviously be very difficult to co-ordinate at scale. These areas are also a hotbed for Fascism and that needs to be interrupted.
Mels: Have you worked any other jobs in the past?
TA: I started in retail, and that was horrific. The way retail workers are treated by management is horrible. To give you an example, they would set sales goals that were deliberately impossible to meet so that they could fire anyone at any point with justification. It was an open secret that no one ever met the sales goals. If they decided that they didn’t like you, you were gone.
Mels: Did they use this as justification to fire someone trying to form a union?
TA: No one ever tried to form a union at my retail job, it was also sort of culty. They try to make you feel like you’re special for working there in a way that’s very toxic and anti-social. They did it to try and flatten the hierarchy that was present between the staff and the management. Anyways, after that I worked for a student union and it was awful. Probably the worst working experience I have ever had. It was shut down due to embezzlement. The union was completely impotent but because I had no idea how a union should actually work I just assumed everything was normal.
Mels: This seems to be a pervasive problem, most unions aren’t interested in on-boarding and educating members. That’s why many union members are complacent.
TA: Definitely.
Mels: What are some immediate issues that you would like to see a popular communist organization address?
TA: Frankly, I can’t point to one thing. All of it needs to go. We need to push forward the path toward communism, and this can be a hard thing to articulate to the average person.
Mels: On that note, what actions do you think need to take place to politicize the masses in Canada toward socialist revolution?
TA: Yea, I mean I’m biased because I am an educator but I often think about a political education. I think there’s a lot of people who are our enemies who will not move and we shouldn’t try with them, but there are a lot of people who are movable. Finding ways to practice political education outside of universities is what I think is most important. Having effective intellectual propaganda that actually identifies problems and has a clear position that is easily accessible is vital. I’m still in touch with a lot of people from my small town, and I try to be very strategic with how I talk to them. When I talk to them they always agree with maybe minor disagreements, and this way you’re able to slowly move people. Now the question becomes, how do you do that education work at a large scale? You cannot be afraid of how specifically politicized it must be. I will continue to stress again that we do have concrete enemies, because I’m tired of academic space where there is a “we’re all humans” mentality. It obviously glosses over so much violence that happens.
Mels: Do you think that our paper will be beneficial in this task?
TA: Yea, the kinds of critiques that I’ve read so far are actually committed to good faith engagement to radical communist organizing, which is really exciting to see. I don’t want to get caught up in names but even the name “The People’s Hammer” for me articulates a kind of ethic that’s so clear. As long as the ethic of that name is adhered to, that serves an important purpose for me. I think it’s great that members of your paper are going out to events and reaching out, I will say that I hadn’t heard of the paper until you reached out to me. The articles that I have read get me excited that this space of critique exists, and specifically that you are open to criticism for the work the paper is doing. I think its very important because this is why I think that the Trot papers are so awful. There’s so many problems but at heart they aren’t open to critique, they think it’s a closed thing.
Mels: They want to convince people that only they are right and they don’t have a willingness to understand that the people themselves good ideas that should be implemented and put into practice.
TA: Yes exactly
Mels: This is the end of the interview, thank you for participation. Do you have any final words that you would like our readers to hear?
TA: Abolition Now, Communism Now, Free Palestine!