The People's Hammer

Bill 51: The imperialists want to “modernize”, the workers must prepare to fight! – by Michael B.



The imperialists of Quebec, led by the CAQ(Coalition Avenir Québec) government, are attempting to “modernize”1 the construction industry. What does this mean, exactly? Well, from all accounts this simply means they want to 1. attack the livelihoods of the workers and; 2. increase the rate of profit for the capitalists. As we know from studying Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, points 1 and 2 are inherently linked, and are never independent of each other. This raises the question of how a reactionary class of exploiters who uphold a moribund mode of production believe they can be the agents of progress, and this would be an excellent question. This investigation will inevitably arrive at the answer that, simply put, they are lying to us.

To quote directly from the bill:

“Cette loi a pour objet de moderniser l’industrie de la construction. Pour ce faire, elle prévoit des modifications à la Loi sur les relations du travail, la formation professionnelle et la gestion de la main-d’œuvre dans l’industrie de la construction afin de modifier les règles relatives au fonctionnement du régime de négociation collective dans l’industrie de la construction. La loi devance l’échéance de diverses étapes du processus menant au renouvellement des conventions collectives. Elle crée également une obligation pour les associations de salariés représentatives, l’association sectorielle d’employeurs et l’association d’employeurs de transmettre, par écrit aux autres parties, dès le début du processus de négociation collective, leurs demandes, leurs offres ainsi que des propositions sur l’ensemble des matières pouvant faire l’objet des négociations…

“La loi modifie également le Règlement sur la formation professionnelle de la main-d’œuvre de l’industrie de la construction dans le but d’accroître la polyvalence dans l’organisation du travail des travailleurs de certains métiers de la construction. Ainsi, elle introduit dans ce règlement les conditions permettant la mise en œuvre de ce principe de polyvalence, tout en y précisant nommément les travaux et les métiers qui ne peuvent donner ouverture à une telle polyvalence.”2

In particular, the bourgeoisie is concerned about a “productivity gap” with neighbouring Ontario3, clearly pointing to the demand of Quebecois capitalists to better compete against Canadian capitalists in the extraction of surplus value from construction workers. Bringing in less profit than their counterparts in Ontario has created a resentment in them towards the relatively better average conditions for the workers in the province of Quebec. They know that the total unionization of the Quebec construction workers is in large part responsible for these better conditions, but that this is not subject to change without great risk of revolt, so they have opted to try and lessen or remove certification requirements for several trades, opening the door for reductions in wages.

This lessening of certification requirements is being done in the name of “increasing versatility of workers”4, and bourgeois “think tanks” like the MEI are saying the measures proposed in bill 51 “do not go far enough”, and propose to “…aim for the removal of as many compulsory certifications as possible. A first step would be to abolish compulsory certification for all trades for which certification is compulsory only in Quebec…”. The bourgeoisie has always wanted workers to be as minimally educated as possible, so as never to question their preferred methods of doing the job, the exploitation of the worker’s labour at the hands of the bourgeois, or why the old state always acts against the interests of the workers long-term. In construction, the lack of certification requirements means an increase of inter-worker division by taking work away from the higher-paid trades, and make the jobsite less safe by having less qualified workers doing the labour without the required tests of competency.

Knowing the proper techniques and possible dangers that are involved in using heavy tools and machines, working around dangerous materials, and working around high voltage electricity is a must in order to avoid workplace accidents, which are especially dangerous in these conditions. Construction workers know all too well that the speed of production and the cutting of corners demanded by the bourgeoisie in this industry puts any worker, even the most skilled at great risk, and more training and testing, paid for by the capitalists instead of by the workers, is what should be demanded.

Unions such as the FTQ-Construction have held protests against this proposed change to the law in Quebec City outside of the National Assembly.5 Their stated reasons for opposing the reform were primarily because of reduced amount of training required for different trades.6They see less-trained workers being more common as having the potential to increase workplace accidents. They also oppose the elimination of caps on workers traveling to different regions to work, saying it would reduce the ability of workers to work close to home.7

This bill is also being introduced ahead of next year’s contract negotiations, attacking the working conditions of the workers even before the current contract has been expired. The contract has already been skirted in every possible way by the construction bourgeoisie where it can be, more so in the small jobsites where union delegates are not present and workers are less-informed of their rights.

The union bureaucracy at the 5 construction unions in Quebec seem to be alright with allowing these violations to occur to the workers who don’t proactively submit their services to the promotion of the union, despite automatically paying dues from their paycheque every week8. The rank and file must fight for control of their unions so that they become real fighting organisations of the working class, and prepare to strike in the upcoming contract negotiations by building the workers’ united front9 which can overcome the weaknesses of the public sector Common Front from late last year.

Notes:

1. https://ftqconstruction.org/general/modernisation-de-la-loi-r-20/

2. https://www.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/fileadmin/gazette/pdf_encrypte/lois_reglements/2024F/83590.pdf

3. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/quebec-construction-trades-need-to-decompartmentalize-and-increase-inter-regional-worker-mobility-study-1.6547815

4. https://www.iedm.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/lepoint042024_en.pdf

5. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/quebec-construction-company-demonstrates-at-the-start-of-consultations-on-reform-1.6800160

6. Notes from a People’s Hammer reader who attended their union meeting.

7. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/quebec-construction-reform-will-kill-the-regions-and-pose-safety-problems-says-union-1.6585834

8. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/quebec-construction-company-demonstrates-at-the-start-of-consultations-on-reform-1.6800160

9. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/11/04/transform-the-common-front-into-the-workers-united-front/




















































p { margin-bottom: 0.1in; line-height: 115%; background: transparent }