The Saskatchewan Chamber of Commerce recently published its provincial election platform.1 The chamber, like the bourgeois state, represents the general interests of the class. However, their principal functions differ. The chamber unites the bourgeoisie in their economic struggle against the proletariat, while the state unites the bourgeoisie in a political struggle to crush the proletariat.
While the chamber is not directly running candidates, their election platform serves to inform the different bourgeois parties what the bourgeoisie generally aim to achieve in the next legislature.
Among the proposals put forward in the election platform is the reduction of the minimum working-age from 14 to 13.2 Currently, 14 and 15-year olds are subject to a number of restrictions on the industries and positions that they can work. Additionally, they must complete the Young Worker Readiness Certificate Course before entering the workforce.3 Under the chamber’s platform, 13-year olds would have to take this course as well before working.4
The reason behind the proposal given by the chamber is to resolve labour-shortages in the province.5 The Saskatchewan Federation of Labour has criticised the proposal saying that the problem of a labour-shortage could be resolved instead by raising the minimum wage which would entice more workers to join the workforce.6 Both of these positions fail to understand the reason behind a shortage of labour in the province.
In reality, there exists a mass of workers sitting unemployed. These workers form a surplus above the existing demand for labour, thereby acting as a lever that keeps wages and conditions low. In times of high unemployment, the bourgeoisie can easily fire a worker who attempts to form a union and bring in an unemployed worker. When unemployment is low the worker is less easily replaced and is in a better position to demand higher wages and conditions. This situation has been worsened by the bourgeoisie’s effort to cool inflation by hiking interest rates which has pushed more workers into unemployment than usual.7
Saskatchewan currently has an unemployment rate of 5.6%.8 When looking at these numbers, however, the workers must remember that employment statistics always undercut the actual situation of the workers. This is because there exists another large group of workers that are underemployed in part-time jobs that are utilised in the same way by the bourgeoisie. The SFL’s proposal to raise the minimum wage will undoubtedly benefit the workers, but it will not increase the workforce as the vast majority of the unemployed are so not by their own choice.
The solution to the problem is not raising the minimum wage or expanding the workforce. The workers are already there and are looking for work.
If a workforce-shortage is not the reason behind the chamber’s call to lower the working-age, what is? The bourgeoisie look for any opportunity to accumulate capital by increasing the rate of exploitation. This is done by the bourgeoisie internationally by super-exploiting (exploitation above the normal rate) workers overseas. Domestically, this is often done by cutting wages for certain kinds of work, for workers of certain age groups, and for immigrant workers. While, the last example is generally done illegally by the bourgeoisie, the first two have been codified into law in provinces across the country. In Alberta for example, workers below 18-years old who are in school can legally be paid $ 2-an hour less than an adult.9
The value of the labour-power sold by the worker does not only reflect the labour-time necessary to produce the worker but also those dependent on the worker such as children. By bringing the worker’s children into the workforce, the value of the worker’s labour-power is reduced.10 While workers may not want to send their children to work, proletarian families often cannot turn down the extra income. By lowering the minimum working-age, the bourgeoisie are looking to 1) lower wages and working conditions by increasing the workforce and 2) introduce a new source of future super-profit through reactionary laws such as those in place in Alberta.
Under capitalism, child labour is employed by the bourgeoisie to crush the proletariat and increase their accumulation of capital. However, under socialism children’s labour will be maintained in a different form. Socialist education will combine productive labour with intellectual education. This will benefit the child by developing them both intellectually and manually rather than the one-sided education they receive today.
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/13-years-age-of-work-sask-1.7238317
- https://www.cjwwradio.com/2024/06/20/saskatchewan-chamber-advocates-for-lowering-legal-age-for-workers-from-14-to-13/
- https://www.cjwwradio.com/2024/06/20/saskatchewan-chamber-advocates-for-lowering-legal-age-for-workers-from-14-to-13/
- https://www.cjwwradio.com/2024/06/20/saskatchewan-chamber-advocates-for-lowering-legal-age-for-workers-from-14-to-13/
- https://globalnews.ca/news/10576301/sask-chamber-of-commerce-calls-for-lowering-working-age-to-13-years/
- https://globalnews.ca/news/10576301/sask-chamber-of-commerce-calls-for-lowering-working-age-to-13-years/
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/05/01/the-proletariat-will-not-pay-for-the-imperialist-crisis/
- https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/240607/mc-a001-eng.htm
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/31/submission-young-workers-of-alberta-unite-and-fight-for-equal-pay/
- https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch15.htm#S3a
Responses to “Saskatchewan Chamber of Commerce Push to Lower Minimum Working-Age – by Daniel H.”
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/saskatchewan-chamber-of-commerce-push-to-lower-minimu… […]
LikeLike
[…] 3. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/saskatchewan-chamber-of-commerce-push-to-lower-minimu… […]
LikeLike
[…] 3. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/saskatchewan-chamber-of-commerce-push-to-lower-minimu… […]
LikeLike