Last July the ILWU Canada union went on strike. One of their strike objectives was “To protect current and future generations from the devastating impacts of Port Automation.”1 One ILWU spokesperson said that automation of “work may be ‘existential’ for the long-term viability of these workers’ jobs.”2
Concurrently, the Canadian Animation Guild launched a campaign to monitor AI use in the workplace,3 and IATSE, the parent union, launched a commission on AI use in the industry.4
ILWU and IATSE view automation and AI as a threat. Yet, it is not automation or AI itself that is causing the problem. In fact, two container terminals in Vancouver are already semi-automated and are among more than 50 terminals across the world with some automation already implemented.5
The problem itself lies in capitalist production. New technology can turn craft work into proletarian work such as with AI and the digital artist, or the introduction of the spinning jenny into the textile industry. When the ownership of the means of production is private, the introduction of new machinery and technology into the workplace is meant to increase productivity by substituting machines for workers. In doing this, what results is a commodity that costs less to produce.
This provides communists and workers with both an opportunity and a challenge. The newly proletarianized worker broadens the base of the socialist revolution (the working class itself). Currently, in the animation industry, AI will only affect petit-bourgeois jobs that exist around generating concepts and ideas. For the animation workers, AI will not replace or reduce their work load as currently AI is not sufficient in producing realistic and fluid animations. On the other hand, where work takes less people to get done than it used to, workers will be cut from an industry and be forced to look for work elsewhere. A historic example is with the “deindustrialization” of the automotive and steel industries: whereas before more labour-power was required to produce a product, with the introduction of automation less people are required to produce the same amount of product. A more contemporary example can be seen with the introduction of self-checkout machines at stores. The accumulation of capital moves the need from skilled to unskilled, older to younger people.6
The challenge lies in the fact that as capitalists increase the amount of exploitation on less workers the relative amount of people needed to get work done decreases.7 This relative decrease forces more people to either find other work or remain unemployed. The result of the large “reserve army” is that this allows the capitalist to discipline the workers. Navigating these conditions, communists must be able to organize workers to defend their jobs and fight for wages while also working tactfully with the fact that the trend under capitalism is to dislodge skilled workers with unskilled and in doing so threaten the bargaining power of skilled workers due to them becoming replaceable with the introduction of new technology. Specifically, communists must lead the fight to obtain a reduction in working-hours with no loss in pay as the workplace is increasingly automated.
The problem is with capitalism because under socialism machinery and technological advancements will be used to help workers. Under socialism there will be a planned economy dedicated to building communism making it such that new technology will reduce work hours necessary for society to reproduce itself instead of working to increase production to maximise profits.
Notes:
1. https://www.ilwu.ca/ilwu-canada-issues-72hr-strike-notice/
2. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/b-c-port-workers-contract-strike-1.6917224
3. https://www.cag938.ca/ai-reporting/
4. https://iatse.net/iatse-launches-commission-on-artificial-intelligence/
5. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/bc-port-strike-automation-1.6900521
6. Capital volume 1 p. 788 penguin edition
7. Capital volume 1 p. 791. penguin edition.
Responses to “The Union Crisis Over Automation – by Bessy”
[…] 6 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/the-union-crisis-over-automation-by-bessy/ […]
LikeLike
[…] xxixhttps://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/the-union-crisis-over-automation-by-bessy/ […]
LikeLike