The People's Hammer

Report and Summation of the UBC Vancouver Encampment – by Kale



On April 29, an encampment was set up on UBC Vancouver with a list of five demands1:

  1. Divest – Divest from all companies complicit in the Israeli apartheid regime and in the oppression and genocide of the Palestinians.
  2. Boycott – Participate in the global academic boycott of Israeli universities and institutions:
    1. Terminate all AMNE archaeological excavations on stolen Palestinian land.
    2. Cut all ties with these three Israeli universities that are complicit in the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians: Tel Aviv University, Technion-Israel-Institute of Technology, and Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
  3. Condemn – Publicly condemn and demand an end to the genocide in Gaza, and condemn the scholasticide in Gaza.
  4. Campus Safety – Keep cops off our campus. The RCMP engages in suppression and violence against BIPOC and other marginalized communities.
  5. Reaffirm – Reaffirm Palestinians’ right to resist and their Right of Return.

The encampment organizers highlighted that UBC’s 2023 financial disclosures revealed investments exceeding $111 million in banks and companies implicated in the settler-colonial occupation and ongoing genocide in Gaza.2

UBC’s response to the encampment differed notably from many other universities’ approaches, as they refrained from direct political repression and open violence to quickly shut things down. Instead they utilized RCMP presence for surveillance and intimidation through measures like traffic stops, random ID checks, and profiling of students.3,4 On one occasion, UBC’s President Bacon sent out a response, obfuscating the facts about UBC’s investments in companies complicit in the genocide of Palestinians, claiming that just 0.28% of UBC’s Endowment Fund is invested in companies that are complicit in the illegal occupation of Palestine when from the publicly published 2023 investments disclosure report, this number is actually around 5.2%.5,3 As the organizers pointed out “even IF UBC only invested 0.28%, that is still millions of dollars as the Endowment Fund is $2.2 billion.”3 The only other political response was that of the occasional Zionist counter-protesters who would leave if it so much as started to rain.

Recognizing the limited impact of their encampment efforts, the organizers decided to escalate things by occupying a campus bookstore. They renamed it “Sidra’s Bookstore” in memory of Sidra Hassouna, a 7 year old girl who was murdered by the Israel Occupation Forces (IOF) along with her family during a series of airstrikes in Rafah on 12 February 2024. The bookstore and adjacent Starbucks were closed for the day due to the disruption. Attending the action, I noticed that many individuals were timid of the police and did not block the doors from cops entering the bookstore. Cops quickly filtered in, and protesters inside displayed printouts of the Charter taped on their shirts and on the walls. The strategy inside became to pack up slowly so as not to defy the police but to “buy more time” for the protest. The escalation ended as quickly as it began. At the same time, the summer semester hadn’t even begun meaning that this act of escalation was not agitational to any external viewers as there were none, and did not stop UBC’s business for long.

The protesters displaying the Charter call into question the foundation of the opposition to the Canadian state that these protesters have. If the protesters believe that the Charter exists to protect them and that the legal foundation of Canada is legitimate, then their issue with the current struggle in Palestine can only be reduced to grievances with the current government. Unfortunately, Trudeau and his administration are not the root issue of imperialism. It is the whole foundation of Canada and the laws that were built to serve and defend the bourgeoisie. These are the foundations that students must attack if they are to mount any challenge to the genocide in Gaza or the imperialism wrecking destruction globally.

As time went on and UBC continued to ignore the demands of the encampment, both the momentum and intensity of support for the encampment started to dwindle. There are few likely reasons for this.

One is that there was not a substantial effort made to link up the encampment with the broader workers’ movement and the chant “the students united shall never be defeated” occasionally heard in the encampment is emblematic of that. Discussions within the encampment often centered around colonialism and even capitalism. While discussions did go as far as integrating the student movement into the workers’ movement,6 this did not become a significant focus of the encampment which was being worked towards. One issue of this is that ideas remained perpetually in the realm of discussion which severely limited the scope of activism. There were many evening meetings at the camp that circled around discussion and yielded little result.

Another contributor, Ivan, mentioned in a previous article that many of the students participating in the encampments have already paid their tuition.7 Many students’ futures are also tied to the completion of their education as it will project their careers and future livelihoods. This is not to put blame on individual students but rather a reflection of the petite-bourgeois class interests of students. The university was not economically affected by the student protesters since the money for tuition and graduation was already processed. Students, as it turns out, have a lot to lose by protesting their universities. This reflected in the general atmosphere of the encampment: there was a small group who did their best to bottom-line the tasks necessary to keep the camp going. However, the majority of those present were there to hang out, eat lunch, chat with friends, and go back to their lives afterwards. Much of the activity of the camp centered around holding “events” which can be reduced to entertainment in order to encourage attendance at the camp. We have to ask, what strategically do these events amount to?

There was a great sentiment from the broader circle of people supportive of the camp that the purpose of non-students is simply to support the students in their venture. This brings up the question of lack of command and lack of strategy. Outside of campus, although there have been rallies in Vancouver for 10 months now, the “coalition” leading the rallies has little glue to bind them together. We know that there is no agreement between the different groups of the coalition on politics, and a lacking of a strategy. Yet, the rallies continue at the same time rallying around the Vancouver Art Gallery. Fundamentally, strategy is missing from this coalition and from the camp. Simply expending manpower to hold a student camp base does not put any pressure on UBC. Even worse is the lack of responsibility that those in the vicinity of the camp felt towards the initiative, which can only be understood through the lack of any strategy being communicated.

Last were the State agitators that were present in the form of anarchists. There was a notable presence of anarchists initially that attended camp to do posturing and chase clout. From the people who were at the camp, and from my own experience, these individuals did not help in the life of the camp, and did not bring any productive tactics to aid the small group of students who were maintaining the camp. Instead, they attacked the organizers and the students, spread incredibly damaging rumors, published a statement calling the camp organizers pig sympathizers and for the broader student base to turn against the camp. This is outright doing the work of the State for them by weakening any initiative and destroying the morale of friends.

The reality of the situation is that it is workers who work daily to build up and maintain society hold economic power, while the students do not. Workers can leverage this by withholding their labor-power until their demands are met. And in order to effectively impose the will of the masses on bourgeois institutions and political processes, the students must link up their movement with the workers’ movement. After all, if campus workers had gone on strike, disrupting the institution’s operations, would UBC have remained as detached?

On July 7, the encampment was officially dismantled with the organizers stating “This encampment was one strategy. We will continue to employ a variety of tactics and strategies until UBC divests, and until Palestine is free”.8Despite its shortcomings, we can nevertheless see the encampment as a positive step, one we can learn from in order to act more effectively in the future and our critiques are made in this light. We must call for the student organizers to regroup and let’s come up with a strategy that will strike the bourgeoisie where it hurts.

1. https://www.instagram.com/p/C6WMcv_rwXb/?igsh=OHd2Z2dncTV0aXln

2.https://www.instagram.com/p/C6ZREoDP9P_/?igsh=dHB3ZjBsbHhjbjZ2

3. https://www.instagram.com/p/C6xa8sKrzYt/?igsh=MWgxYnN3aHppcmU5Yg==

4. https://www.instagram.com/p/C6zJKBkv0p7/?igsh=NWx1ZGRnOHp5YXU0

5. https://www.instagram.com/p/C7UcozaJ0nd/?igsh=dml2YWk0M3hhN3Ns

6. https://www.instagram.com/p/C9RIkb1RJ7Q/?igsh=MWlsaHz1bmEzbjRtNA==

7. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/14/criticising-two-lines-in-actions-for-palestinian-liberation-ivan-d/

8. https://www.instagram.com/p/C9RIkb1RJ7Q/?igsh=MWlsaHz1bmEzbjRtNA==


Response to “Report and Summation of the UBC Vancouver Encampment – by Kale”