In a vote taken from June 6 to June 19, the members of Assiniboine, Caisse, and Westoba credit unions voted to merge.1 The merger was initiated by the boards of directors of the individual credit unions earlier this year.2 The new credit union set for creation on January 1 2025 will have 50 branches, 216,000 members, and $ 9.6 billion in assets.3
The merger of the three credit unions is in reality the swallowing up of the other two by Assiniboine. With $ 6,067,731,381 in assets, Assiniboine holds nearly double the combined assets of Caisse ($ 2,042,708,094) and Westoba ($ 1,553,337,072).4 This will also be reflected in the composition of the board of directors. Of the 12-person board, 6 members will be from Assiniboine while Caisse and Westoba will each hold three seats.5 Through this merger, Assiniboine will become the second largest in Manitoba and among the top ten in the country.6 Assiniboine will in effect control this new credit union. Generally, the bourgeoisie only need a sizable minority of the shares and board seats to control a company. Lenin explains this as follows:
“As a matter of fact, experience shows that it is sufficient to own 40 per cent of the shares of a company in order to direct its affairs, since in practice a certain number of small, scattered shareholders find it impossible to attend general meetings, etc.”7
Credit unions, as a form of cooperative, are often raised by social-democrats as an alternative to the financial institutions of the big bourgeoisie. For example, in the height of the RCMP attack on the Wet’suwet’en, anarchists in Vancouver advocated switching banks from RBC, BMO, Scotiabank, TD, or CIBC to credit unions like Vancity. Today, this same idea is raised with respect to the movement to boycott, divest from, and sanction Israel. However, cooperatives, whether they are financial, productive, or distributive, are bound by the laws of capitalism.
Cooperatives bring about collective ownership over some private property, but crucially they do not abolish the commodity-form or the market and are forced to operate as regular capitalist entreprises. These cooperatives compete with the bourgeoisie at their own game for domination of the market. Inter-capitalist competition leads to the ever-increasing centralisation of capital in fewer hands. The smaller firms fail to compete, liquidate, and are taken over by the larger firms. This law applies equally to cooperatives and ordinary capitalist entreprises. This condition makes cooperatives susceptible to the anarchy of production that characterises capitalism.
This nature of cooperatives under capitalism makes them easily incorporated into imperialism as can be seen with the example of Desjardins in Quebec.8 Where cooperatives do not succeed, they are crushed by competition, often de-mutualised, and bought up by their competitors. This can be seen with the once-cooperative wheat pools whose remnants are now centralised under Viterra. Many regular capitalist entreprises such as Starbucks have even adopted a quasi-cooperative model by providing stock annually to workers in an effort to bust union drives. All three of these examples show that cooperatives do not break with capitalism and in some cases can be adopted by the big bourgeoisie towards their own ends.
Cooperatives are fundamentally unable to resolve class contradictions or the antagonism between manual and mental labour. If workers purchase a business from their boss, a new bourgeoisie develops in these entreprises from the bureaucrats elected to run the cooperative. Those who are put into administrative roles quickly stop their participation in production and live off of the backs of their former co-workers. This process occurs more quickly and dramatically in the case of credit unions who produce nothing and accumulate capital through finance.
The centralisation of capital by Assiniboine shows how cooperatives under capitalism can only act according to the laws of capitalism. To resolve the contradictions of capitalism, the workers must establish their dictatorship over the bourgeoisie and nationalise their private property. This proletarian state-sector of the economy must be the basis for any effort to abolish capitalism in Canada. This does not mean that the workers can throw away cooperatives entirely. There are those in Canada who are oppressed by imperialism yet still hold their own property such as the farmers and urban professionals – the petite-bourgeoisie. This class generally opposes imperialism which crushes them through heavy debts, however, they also oppose the immediate nationalisation of their property. As an intermediate step, the proletariat must lead the petite-bourgeoisie to organise cooperatives. Unlike the social-democrats who call for cooperatives as an end in itself, communists recognise cooperatives as a transitional form applicable to the allies of the proletariat who hold some property. Through the socialist revolution both state-property and the collective property of the petite-bourgeoisie will become the common property of the people as a whole.
- https://winnipeg.ctvnews.ca/three-manitoba-credit-unions-approve-merger-1.6934065
- https://winnipeg.ctvnews.ca/three-manitoba-credit-unions-approve-merger-1.6934065
- https://winnipeg.ctvnews.ca/three-manitoba-credit-unions-approve-merger-1.6934065
- https://wowa.ca/manitoba-credit-unions
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/credit-union-manitoba-merge-1.7179651
- https://winnipegsun.com/news/provincial/manitoba-credit-unions-merger-gains-approval
- https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ch03.htm
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/02/06/quebec-is-an-imperialist-power/
Response to “Centralisation of Credit Unions in Manitoba and Dead-End of Cooperatives – by Daniel H.”
[…] 1 A longer criticism of cooperatives can be found in the article Centralisation of Credit Unions in Manitoba and Dead-End of Cooperatives […]
LikeLike