The People's Hammer

A Festival of Exploitation, Condemn Cowboys Music Festival – by Ivan D.



Introduction

“My description of working there would be the hardest work I have ever done, for the least pay I have ever received… I have also never felt so degraded on a jobsite before.”

This statement was given in an interview with a labourer who worked for the Cowboys Music Festival (CMF) in Calgary, AB. The statement they gave was one of many similar statements given from a handful of workers interviewed about their time working to set up and tear down the festival, and speaks to an overall crisis for workers in Alberta. In the face of a lack of strong worker organisation in the province in tandem with a worsening imperialist crisis in the country as a whole1 the working people of CMF and Alberta in general will continue to deteriorate. Here, this article will expose what the workers who put on CMF were put through, the exploitation they suffered, and the impacts it has had on their lives. Beyond condemning the labour conditions at CMF, this article will also serve to show that regrettably, CMF is not an exceptional case for the province, but a microcosm of greater deterioration of the lives for working people in the province as a whole. Ultimately, the working people of Alberta must recognize the conditions they suffer are not immutable, and can be changed through the necessity to organise together, and fight for better conditions.

Cowboys Music Festival and its Working Conditions

The CMF is one of about a dozen annual 10-day music festivals that takes place during the Calgary Stampede, a city wide, annual event that started as a display and portrayal of the “wild west”.2 Stampede is also the largest event the city puts on each year with dedicated city grounds to the event. Much of the province’s finance and industrial capital also scrambles to the city to advertise themselves, make deals, and generally try and boost their yearly profits through various booths and promotionals. The CMF itself is connected to the Cowboys Casino, one of the cities largest Casino’s and nightclubs. The festival itself is one of the largest at Stampede. While they do not publish data on attendance and their economics, estimates can be made. Reports from concert goers noted that this year was the highest attendance they had ever seen, with some raising concerns online about just how packed the festival was, noting the thousands of attendees being packed like sardines.3 There were also rumors that VIP concert tickets were being sold for as high as $30,000 per ticket. With this, it can be estimated that the concert is bringing in millions in profit each year, particularly 2024. Taking all of this into account, it makes what workers for CMF all the more disgusting.

Many workers for CMF were interviewed by Calgary United Workers4 (CUW), an organisation in the city dedicated to advancing workers struggle, about their experiences. CUW was limited in its reach focusing mainly on a handful of labourers being unable to talk to tradespeople or those who worked during the festival itself. Even with this limited reach, CUW still uncovered a litany of abuses these workers suffered detailed below.

On day one, many described it as one of the most intensive days of work they have experienced, being made to empty trucks of wooden structures and scaffolding used during the festival. Safety conditions were poor with some being made to haphazardly climb unstable piles of wood and walls to off load them. Smaller pieces were often flying over peoples heads. Several people on their first day experienced minor cuts and stab wounds as many of the structures were riddled with screws. A semi-truck even backed into a trailer while several of the workers were still inside of it almost knocking them over. No intervention was made by any of the supervisors on site. Workers were also made to assemble temporary fencing that was spiked while standing on unstable fencing below. When another worker got cut by moving heavy wooden flooring, they were told to put a band-aid on only to discover some of the first aid boxes on site were entirely empty. This lack of safety from day one appeared to be an omen for the rest of the time there. The site lacked safety at almost every point possible. There was no Construction Safety Officer on site, no mandate to wear hi-viz clothing or lids (with the exception of those who were putting up scaffolding for tents which was only the first couple days), people standing near ledges without proper barriers in place, people using heavy machinery without certification and training to do so, handling septic tanks that leaked raw sewage all over the ground and being made to clean it up without any additional PPE. For the last week of work it involved workers transporting all the festival supplies throughout the Cowboys warehouse which remained heated in the midst of a heat wave in Calgary. Similarly, a significant amount of time was spent to pressure washing dozens of garbage cans that had been sitting in the hot warehouse since last year without being cleaned from last years concert. Many were full of mold and chemicals that smelled putrid and were splashing back on the workers when they were being pressure washed. One worker was said to have vomited after being covered in black mold sitting at the bottom of one of the garbage cans. Additionally people who had little experience in the construction industry were asked to do unsafe things such as move under large trailers while suspended only by forklifts while at the same being being told to not go under “for safety” or use ladders which they were inexperienced with and were standing at significant height in unsafe ways as they had never been taught to use a ladder. On one day where temperatures were in excess of 30°C, the site had run out of water. After expressing outrage at this situation, workers were told to continue to work until water arrived, roughly 4.5 hours later. Not to mention there were multiple days where workers reported more than one supervisor who at some point “reeked of alcohol” and were still continuing to drive labourers between sites and operate heavy machinery around them. Another supervisor showed up so drunk on site one day he was unable to walk steadily by himself. These were the people who were supposed to be directing and looking out for the many workers on site.

Other portions of working at CMF were not much better. Management was constantly giving contradicting information to workers and it was common for workers who received different instructions to be yelled at by supervisors for doing something another supervisor told them to do. Another day saw several workers sent home early for sitting as there was no genuine tasks for labourers to do. They were berated for being lazy and not doing what they were hired to do even though there was nothing for them to be accomplishing and that they should “at least just stand there with a broom or something”. The supervisor that sent these workers home later admitted to other workers that he did that because his boss was upset labourers weren’t doing anything, and in an effort to save his own face, took it out on them. What this led to was an eventual crack down on “laziness” on site. When there were no tasks, workers were expected to know to pick up a broom and mindlessly sweep the site in an effort to pretend to be doing something. Some supervisors admitted that this was a deliberate thing and that we should just do our best to “look busy”. This led to countless days where workers were made to sweep the site pointlessly, sometimes for as long as 6 hours. It led many to start signing out early as the monotony of the job became too frustrating to handle. The workers wanted to do something productive, but they were given no input and any actions outside of the “look busy” mindset tended to get workers berated as well. This accelerated further as workers would often sweep together to converse and pass time whilst they worked on the meaningless and tedious tasks they were given. This too was eventually seen by some of the supervisors as an act of insubordination and lack of work ethic, so they made workers sweep isolated and in the sun as a way to ensure what looked like productivity. Many workers also reported having supervisors knock on the doors of porta-potties when relieving themselves as supervisors were convinced they were wasting time. Additionally, especially during set-up, certain supervisors engaged in deliberate public reprimand and punishment of those deemed unproductive. These workers were often given harder work like moving particularly heavy equipment by hand, or performing work handling garbage as a way to be made an example of. The disposability and contempt many of these workers faced was increased in interpersonal interaction as many supervisors refused to even learn the names of workers and instead referred to them as “you” or sometimes derogatory nick-names they would come up with.

Time theft was also frequent with workers often being asked to work up to 15 minutes before their breaks or start times officially began with no additional compensation. Additionally, workers were consistently given changing and contradictory information about when their shifts started, days they were working, etc, particularly during the tear-down of the festival. Particularly pernicious behaviour was that initially workers were promised a 45 day contract over the period of two months. This was cut short by a week with a hastened tear down schedule, and additionally included a 10 day gap while stampede occurred. This meant many workers had to find different jobs and quit the contract mid way through as they could not manage so many days without work.

And what was the compensation for what all of this that these workers were put through? The pay structure for the job was initially $15 which is the provincial minimum wage, with a bonus structure of varying amounts to be paid at the end of the contract. The bonus ranged dependent on skill level from $2 to some people making $5 for every hour worked, the stipulation being if you miss a day unannounced, you forfeit the whole bonus. This stipulation was what many workers were forced to do given the structure of the schedule of the job, meaning they were put through the despicable treatment they received from CMF for essentially minimum wage. On top of this, CMF had issues with their pay systems and so there were days where pay was 1-2 days late, adding further insult to the workers. CMF further increased their attempts at bolstering exploitation in the teardown phase by hiring a significant amount of non-contract temporary labourers who were paid just minimum wage. They also attempted to make the contract workers oversee and snitch on any temporary labourers who they felt were not being productive.

Now, what help were so-called protections and law for these workers. There was a call to Alberta Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) not from the labourers CUW spoke to, but from someone working during the festival itself who complained that they were being forced to work 12 hour shifts without water. By the time OHS had actually showed up to the site, the festival was several days complete meaning the worker who complained would have never been attended to by OHS. Additionally the only actions OHS had taken were mandating that water be present on site and that people were not allowed to work 12 hour shifts. These rules were only explained to management and merely overheard by workers tearing down the site. The shift time rule was also tossed out two days after OHS had visited. OHS gave no follow up, just outlined those rules and proceeded to make note of the complaint, meaning OHS was realistically of no use.

The impact of all of the above conditions was expressed by the workers as well. The consequences in some cases were quite dire. All of the safety violations added up and it resulted in injuries that were frequent. Significant cuts, scrapes, and bruises were frequent. One worker received a significant crush injury to their finger resulting in a hematoma under his finger nail. Another worker ended up falling through insecure scaffolding within which he was carrying heavy fridges, causing significant bruising to their midsection. Another worker ended up getting a concussion after being hit in the head by another carrying scaffolding and reporting immediately feeling feint and seeing stars. When injuries did happen the response was generally apathetic. Many workers reported having to give each other first aid. One worker was witnessed getting stabbed in the head by old guide wire. One supervisor helped him wash his face off with water, that was the only real treatment given. Other workers had ended up helping him make sure it was disinfected and covered. Some of them remarked that when supervisors were informed of a bleeding worker, two of them did not even look up from their phones they were scrolling on. Upon seeing this, a labourer noted at just how disposable working for Cowboys made them feel. In the case of the worker hit with scaffolding, he was told to sit down for 20 minutes, given some pain killers and an icepack, and allowed to keep working. This case was brought up to an unaffiliated ex Construction Safety Officer. Upon hearing this story they were appalled and stated “if that was my site, I wouldn’t have cared if the worker said they were feeling okay, if it didn’t look bad, whatever. If someone gets hit in the head without a hat, I am getting someone to drive them to emergency immediately or an ambulance is being called right away. You can’t fuck around with head injuries.” The worker who got hit ended up having a concussion and was unable to do tasks like be in a room with lights on, much less work, for weeks. What makes this all the more ironic is that a worker who had laboured for CMF for multiple years noted safety had somewhat improved this year. Even more ironic is a supervisor on the first day bragged that he had never had an injury on this site in any year he managed. With this information it is clear that instead of the supervisor making the site safe, he was just turning a blind eye to injuries that did happen.

The menial labour and constant hounding, lack of coordination, confusion, and micromanagement from supervisors led many workers to feel like the work they were doing was worthless with the menial sweeping and cleaning. The treatment from many of the supervisors added a layer of feeling constantly observed and harassed to what already felt like pointless standing around.

Particular panic was expressed by many workers around the low wages and last minute notice many of them received that their contracts would be cut short. It led many to have to quit the contract part way through to find other work. Other workers spent time on site collecting many bottles and cans to return at bottle depots for extra income to supplement the low wages.

And who were these labourers the CMF foist these conditions upon? They are young workers, many were new immigrants, or refugees from Ukraine seeking a better life in Canada. They are landscapers, movers, construction workers, soldiers, and others, many of which had noted that due to the job market in Alberta this was the first job they had had in months after being laid off from their last company due to lack of work. Many expressed initial excitement at being able to labour again, only to have the conditions of working at CMF attempt to crush their spirits quick. Perhaps most depressing is that when asked about what it was like working for CMF in comparison to other employers they have had, had expressed that the conditions at CMF were on par with, or even better than other companies they have worked for. This trend speaks to the disgusting state of workers organisation (or lack thereof) that currently exists in the province in Alberta, and speaks to the need for workers to band together and unite against these trends by fighting for unions to protect them in times of work, and things like non-contributory employment insurance to protect them in times of unemployment. Sadly, CMF is not exceptional in its abuses of workers.

Not just Cowboys

It seems the province of Alberta itself is in desperate need for worker unity and organisation that the CMF seems to be a microcosm of. Workers not from CMF in related industries like construction and landscaping had noted similar issues with safety, management, and pay in other jobs, and that is where they could get work. Alberta for many decades has been experiencing a gutting of labour rights such as new moves to implement a “youth minimum wage” lower than the provincial minimum wage, and stripping the workers of strike rights5. Unionisation is also the lowest in Alberta of any province in the country and has been for many years, particularly in the private sector.6 Where unions do exist, many are sluggish and under-deliver adequate representation of workers, such as recent teaching and education staff deals which gut education staff of their main demand, higher wages.7 8 On top of this, Alberta has seen some major changes to its two major cities, Calgary and Edmonton which contain the vast majority of the provinces population. There has been an influx of Canadians moving to these cities for cheaper living costs9 10 causing a spike in inflation in these cities, combined with a lack of infrastructure to support the many new members of the city. Combining this with greater use of temporary foreign workers by companies,11 this has greatly increased the labour pool in the province, and caused unemployment to skyrocket, and is a large cause for why so many of the CMF workers were laid off from their previous jobs.12 In addition to all of this, Alberta is losing a significant amount of full-time jobs and current job growth in the province is mostly in the form of part-time or gig-style jobs, much like the CMF contract. All of these factors combine to allow the bosses to exploit workers more heavily, pay less, and threaten firing as those with low to no job skills (the majority of those moving to Alberta in recent years) can be easily replaced. This point was underpinned in that many workers interviewed noted that unionisation would likely greatly mitigate the worst of CMF conditions and pay, what is to stop them from scabbing out as much of the work as possible? A company like CMF would also likely see large assistance from the state as it is a part of Stampede. Stampede is the largest money making event for the City of Calgary and a huge economic boom in the province every year. State interests to this end were demonstrated in a water crisis involving multiple water distribution pipe leaks leading the city to be put on water restriction in the lead up to Stampede. However, the city diverted resources to move heaven and Earth to have the pipes fixed in time for Stampede,13 only for water restrictions and further maintenance to continue shortly after Stampede finished.14 There is major opposition to workers organizing in general in the province of Alberta, and particularly at an event like this. However, for the workers of Alberta, this should only push you to unite and fight more. Conditions in the province are horrid for workers, and in the absence of change things will only get worse. There will be no economic miracle, no philanthropist or government official waiting to fix these conditions.

Workers of Alberta, it is time to fight together, and fight hard now, because it is only the working-class who can lead an end to the exploitation of the working-class.

1. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/05/01/the-proletariat-will-not-pay-for-the-imperialist-crisis/

2. Dixon, Joan; Read, Tracey (2005), Celebrating the Calgary Exhibition and Stampede, Canmore, Alberta: Altitude Publishing Canada Ltd.

3. https://www.reddit.com/r/Calgary/comments/1dxvjyn/cowboys_tent_is_a_fire_hazard/

4. Linktr.ee/calgaryworkers

5. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/02/28/resist-albertas-anti-worker-laws/

6. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1410012901

7. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/28/reposted-articles-from-the-calgary-section-of-the-workers-united-front-of-canada/

8. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/07/12/its-about-damn-time-pt-2-by-calgary-united-workers/

9. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-70-thousand-people-exodus-1.7159382

10. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-alberta-move-migration-population-outflow-1.6778456

11. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/temporary-foreign-workers-business-alberta-1.7243593

12. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-unemployment-rate-6-6-per-cent-1.6786540

13. https://calgaryherald.com/news/local-news/live-updates-watch-morning-update-water-restoration-possible-by-july-1-canada-day-fireworks-to-proceed

14. https://calgary.citynews.ca/2024/08/07/calgary-water-feeder-main-stage-4-restrictions/