The People's Hammer

BC Introduces Gig Worker Regulations – by Daniel H.

, , ,


The BC NDP government has introduced a new set of regulations for gig workers in the province. These workers will now be recognised as employees under the Employment Standards Act and the Workers Compensation Act.1 These regulations will come into force on September 3 2024.2

These new regulations state that these workers will be excluded from many rights and protections other workers have won. These include overtime pay, statutory holidays and holiday pay, paid sick leave, and vacation time.3 This will add them to the massive group of workers in 100 different occupations that are denied these rights under the current NDP government4 such as farm workers and domestic workers.5

What the new regulations provide are:

  • a minimum wage for engaged time (this explicitly excludes time between assignments). This wage is pegged at 120% the regular minimum wage beginning at $ 20.88;6 This minimum wage will be adjusted annually with inflation.7

  • a minimum per-kilometre vehicle allowance of ¢ 35-45 per kilometre;8

  • coverage of workers under WorkSafeBC;

  • workers will be able to see locations and estimated pay before accepting an assignment;

  • workers must be given a reason why they are fired and if there is no reason they must be given notice or compensation; and

  • workers will receive 100% of their tips.9

Workers will not be paid for the time worked while they have logged on, but are waiting for an assignment.10 According to a study by the BC Federation of Labour, this will leave up to 60% of the average drivers’ work-day unpaid.11

Another crucial area where the NDP has betrayed these workers is by not providing them with eligibility to either the Canadian pension plan and employment insurance.12

When workers sell their labour-power through these apps, they rarely receive comparable hours to workers who sell their labour-power more directly to the bourgeoisie. Gig workers often lack stable hours and they often only receive payment equivalent to part-time work. However, because much of their time is spent looking for assignments, they may work longer hours.13 According to the BC Federation of Labour, almost ¼ of gig workers work over 60 hours per work.14

The capitalists who own companies like Uber often boast about how their drivers have more flexibility and freedom than workers in companies where workers directly sell their labour-power. However, Statistics Canada has “found self-employed gig workers are often dependent on a single company for their jobs, with very little freedom to set their own hours or prices and without access to key benefits and protections.”15

Union rights for these workers remain murky. Reclassification as employees by the state will make it easier legally. However, in a company where the workers often do not know each other and the total number of employees is known only to the state and the bourgeoisie, a regular union drive becomes very difficult. Uber has thrown another wrench into the process by introducing a company union for the workers through the UFCW. UFCW’s “historic deal” with Uber has been a bigger betrayal of the workers than any contract pushed through by CLAC.16 Under the deal, Uber drivers are denied the right to even participate in UFCW elections as the workers are not considered members of the union.17

Both Uber and Skip the Dishes have responded to the regulations by calling on the Eby-government to reconsider. Keerthana Rang, the Canadian communications lead for Uber stated:

“In the middle of an affordability crisis, a ridesharing expense rate that is over 50% higher than the comparable rate in California is unreasonable — and we encourage the government to reconsider the consequences for British Columbians who rely on rideshare and delivery”18

Skip the Dishes communications manager Melanie Fatouros-Richardson stated the regulations will raise the cost-of-living.19

This attempt by the bourgeoisie to stir up anger against the workers on the basis that it will increase the cost of services is entirely baseless. The cost of a service reflects the labour-power used in the process. What the extension of a minimum wage will mean is that the profits of the bourgeoisie will be lower. This is because when the bourgeoisie attempt to raise costs above the value of labour expended without any change in the supply or demand of the service, the consumer will simply turn elsewhere or go without. These companies do not have a proper monopoly over these services either as in many parts of Canada the price of an Uber is equivalent or above that of a taxi. Because of this, their ability to inflate the price of services and maintain clientele is relatively low.

Workers for these delivery and ride-sharing apps are distinct from other workers in terms of their productive relations. The majority of the workers – the proletariat are defined as follows:

  1. They only own their labour-power and do not own private property;

  2. They are exploited by the bourgeoisie who purchase their labour-power for less than it is worth in the form of a wage; and

  3. They labour socially. No individual worker produces a whole commodity or sees it through from being thought up to being sold. Many workers labour together throughout the entire process.

The workers in question are semi-proletarian. That is, they share some of the productive relations of the proletariat and some of those of the lower petite-bourgeoisie. In order to work for one of these companies, the worker must own more than their labour-power. They need to own a car, a scooter, or a bike that they enter into this economic process. They are often forced to buy additional equipment such as a insulated bag for deliveries. This ownership of their means of labour distinguishes them from much of the rest of the proletariat.

At times, the bourgeoisie exploits the labour-power of the semi-proletariat rather than that of the proletariat due to the lower costs associated. Compare Uber to a company like Dominoes. Uber does not need to spend much on labour costs. Most Uber drivers, even with the new minimum wage, will likely make less than an average worker in a day. Uber also needs to allocate less capital to cars and can allocate it to forms that yield more profits. Dominoes on the other hand needs to hire a worker, purchase a car, and carry out maintenance.

The semi-proletariat are the closest allies of the proletariat as they share very similar conditions and productive relations. However, the semi-proletariat are almost entirely excluded from the labour movement. The organisation of the semi-proletariat alongside the proletariat in a workers united front is a fundamental task facing the workers today. The demands of the semi-proletariat are essentially demands that will fully proletarianise them. These are demands like regularisation, the right to unionise, and the same basic rights and conditions as the proletariat.

To whatever extent this is achieved under capitalism, it will be completed with the construction of communism. Among the workers first tasks in power will be the nationalisation of the middle and big bourgeoisie’s private property. The semi-proletariat’s working conditions will be regularised and become essentially proletarian labour. The distinctions between the proletariat and the semi-proletariat will be abolished as part of the general abolition of class.

1. https://www.policynote.ca/bill-48/

2. https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2024LBR0011-000900

3. https://www.policynote.ca/bill-48/

4. https://www.policynote.ca/bill-48/

5. https://www.policynote.ca/bill-48/

6. https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2024LBR0011-000900

7. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/uber-lyft-door-dash-minimum-wage-1.7233199

8. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/uber-lyft-door-dash-minimum-wage-1.7233199

9. https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2024LBR0011-000900

10. https://www.policynote.ca/bill-48/

11. https://bcfed.ca/news/briefs/submission-bc-ministry-labour-regarding-proposing-employment-standards-and-other#_ftn6

12. https://www.policynote.ca/unfair-platform-work/

13. https://www.policynote.ca/bill-48/

14. https://bcfed.ca/news/briefs/submission-bc-ministry-labour-regarding-proposing-employment-standards-and-other#_ftn6

15. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/uber-lyft-door-dash-minimum-wage-1.7233199
https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/11/20/christian-labour-association-of-canada-and-company-unionism-in-canada/

16. https://jacobin.com/2022/02/ufcw-representation-collective-bargaining-independent-contractors-gig-drivers

17. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/uber-lyft-door-dash-minimum-wage-1.7233199

18. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/uber-lyft-door-dash-minimum-wage-1.7233199

19. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/uber-lyft-door-dash-minimum-wage-1.7233199