With every passing day, the crisis in Capitalism is growing larger and larger. In Canada, Toronto in particular, the average person is only barely getting by due to the affordability crisis.1 Internationally, conflicts such as the war in Palestine are being escalated with participation from more belligerents such as Iran & Hezbollah.2 As a result of the general crisis, the masses are increasingly voicing their frustrations over their shaky situation. This has manifested itself through an ever increasing protest movement in Toronto. All across the city, you can find dozens of posters promoting various different demonstrations from Palestine rallies to indigenous solidarity events and many things in between. This is a positive development, and the masses are right to express their anger in a popular movement. There is, however, many issues with the protest movement, henceforth referred to as “Movementism”, that need serious rectification before the people are able to win over their demands.
Optics Over Organization
At any given protest in Toronto, you will find hundreds if not thousands of people participating. What you will not find however is any sort of organization among attendants.3 Why is this important? One may think that mobilizing the masses is enough to achieve a political goal. This is half of the truth, you do need to mobilize the masses, however they must be organized. The state which the people find themselves in opposition to is highly and effectively organized specifically to crush the people and prevent a popular uprising. If these protests are disorganized they will not be able to out mode the state, they will be slow, clumsy, and with no sense of direction. Why then do the various protest organizers not take the time to actually organize the people? The simple answer is that it is difficult, and they are not willing to put in the effort to do so. The photos and videos of thousands of people, the optics, is good enough for them, it gives the veneer of organization without actually having to put in the work. What do most of the protesters do after the event? They go home with a sense of satisfaction, feeling they have “made a change” without actually having gone through any amount of struggle. The people have creative spirit and a desire to struggle, and it is necessary to organize the people under the banner of the reconstituted Communist Party of Canada to harness this energy.
Popular Support Or Petty Politics?
Many protest organizers find themselves in an awkward position between two poles. Do they want to derive their strength from the people or focus on swaying the minds of the bourgeois politicians? Many of the protests that happen in the city occur at strongholds of the capitalist class, such as City Hall & Queen’s Park. These Movementist demonstrations often pride themselves on being organic representations of the people, so why then do they focus so much on the most anti-people areas to conduct their rallies? You certainly are not going to win over the hearts and minds of the business men and pencil pushers who tend to operate in those settings. The correct line of action would be to conduct actions in popular areas, places where average workers are going to see you and be won over to your cause. This issue stems from a strategic failing of many of the organizations involved, they genuinely believe that the system of bourgeois democracy that exists in Canada can be used to benefit the people. This also shows a lack of faith in the strength of the masses, which they claim to believe in.
Sloganeering
This issue has been partially covered in two prior articles3, 4, however it requires some elaboration. One of the most common occurrences is the invocation of shame towards the bourgeois politicians & their allies. At the closing of the UofT protest, mentions of the crimes of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) were met with repeating chants of “Shame!” towards the IDF and the politicians that support them. One protester correctly stated “Why do we care about shaming them? They have no shame whatsoever.” Moralism is one of the last issues on the minds of the Imperialists, they will do what is beneficial to them as a class no matter how vile. Another issue is that chants are often so long winded or unconventional that the protesters do not know how to keep everyone in sync. One solution to these problems are distribution of slogan cards to attendants. Other slogans are simply uninspired, at any event you can hear any variation of “Hey hey, ho ho, *blank politician* has got to go” or “*blank politician* you can’t hide, you are funding genocide.” One cannot escape the feeling that the protest organizers thought to themselves “Protests have chants, so we need to have a chant!” It is indicative of a copy-and-paste mentality, a mindset of simply going through the motions rather than actually trying to build a movement to win demands.
Other Issues Of Practice
At the recent protest for Grassy Narrows5, there were many additional issues not discussed above. Firstly, the event had a corporate sponsor in Ben & Jerry’s. This immediately calls into question the intentions of the organizers, as a private company will generally only do something if it is profitable to them. This shows that moguls of business felt as though the protest did not harm their interests and in fact was beneficial to them! Secondly, one of the only actions taken during the event other than the march on Queen’s Park was getting the attendants to use the internet to pressure Trudeau. A speaker announced to the crowd “Everyone get on your phone and tweet at Justin Trudeau.” When everyone was rightfully confused by the request, the speaker reiterated “I’m not seeing enough phones.” This is a most laughable “action”, how does sending the Prime Minister mean messages over the internet in any way pressure him into taking action on this issue? Thirdly, the organizers of the event explicitly requested that the attendants self-segregate the march. Journalists of the People’s Hammer in attendance were yelled at by organizers holding banners to get into the proper section of the march which matched their race. What does this do to benefit the event? It is one thing to amplify the voices of people who are directly affected by the issue, it is another to isolate groups that don’t fall into the affected group. What is needed in this country is unity of workers, not a division of races. If a protest of reactionaries was being segregated by the organizers, we would rightfully call them racists. Why is it any different even if the cause of the Grassy Narrows protest is correct and progressive? It is a divisive practice that can do no good.
Conclusion
Canadians are ready to rebel, and the current leaders of Movementism are incapable of leading the masses for struggle. Only the reconstituted Communist Party of Canada is capable of leading the masses to victory. It is the responsibility of any politically advanced worker to take up the task of struggling for the reconstitution of the party, as well as to organize their fellow workers toward this end. We must break from liberal Movementism and fight for revolution!
Citations:
1: https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/inflation-political-parties-solutions-1.6586736
2: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/israel-hezbollah-lebanon-ground-invasion-1.7338032
5: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/grassy-narrows-mercury-justice-rally-2024-1.7327222
Responses to “On Movementism – by Mels G.”
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/10/18/on-movementism-by-mels-g/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/10/18/on-movementism-by-mels-g/ […]
LikeLike