The People's Hammer

Ontario’s 2023-24 Budget: Ford’s Incompetence on Full Display – by Cliff Z.

,


Ontario has wrapped up 2023-24 with a “nearly” balanced budget. What the Ford government deems “nearly” balanced is a $600 million deficit.1 The only reason the deficit is not larger is because of higher than expected revenue from international student tuition. The Ford government originally projected to come out worse off, tailing the horrendous 2023 $1.3 billion deficit, but was bailed out by an unexpectedly large amount of wealthy international students willing to be price gouged by Ontario colleges and universities.1 The province’s colleges and universities cannot continue to rely on international students to keep them afloat. Certainly, the provincial government itself should not be relying on international student tuition. Ontarians do not need a provincial government that cannot plan even a 1 year budget properly and must be bailed out by wealthy international students willing to pay ludicrously inflated tuition rates. Ontarians need a government which will plan their budget according to the needs of workers, create better conditions for these workers and ensure Canadian citizens are the first in line for the province’s internationally acclaimed education. The federal government’s plan to reduce international student visas by 10% doesn’t do anything to help financially struggling Ontario youth in their educational pursuits.1 Exorbitant tuition costs can never and will never be a suitable replacement for the economic growth Ontario would reap from investing long term in expanding and developing domestic industry, manufacturing and agriculture, something the federal and provincial governments continue to refuse to do.

Ford’s government continuously displays their lack of concern for the conditions of workers. The closure of the Ontario Science Centre was not only a huge blow for the residents of East-Toronto where it had become a cultural facet and educational treasure, it has also put more Ontarians out of work.2 Canada’s unemployment rate is at a seven year high with a 10.4% rise in Employment Insurance (EI) beneficiaries between June 2023 and June 2024.3 Ontario’s increase in EI recipients within this 12 month period is staggering, with 30,380 new people receiving benefits.4 This is substantially worse than any other province, with Alberta, the second largest increase in EI recipients, at a significantly lower 5,680 people.4 No one should have to rely on EI to survive, let alone the total 151,370 Ontarian beneficiaries.4 Ontario is undeniably in dire straits, but Ford’s provincial spending certainly doesn’t reflect the masses’ need for relief. Getting Ontarians out of EI, back on their feet and working for the long term is only possible through eliminating the private ownership which directly benefits from keeping a reserve of unemployed workers while cheap, foreign labourers can be prioritized and exploited. With collectivized workplaces organized by workers, for workers, with the goal of meeting the needs of the masses rather than individual profit, the widespread unemployment the province currently faces would become a near impossibility. There would be no need to downsize to curb inflation and no private owners to benefit from cheap foreign labour. A market-based economy cannot reliably curb inflation through collective expansion because of its individualized, private nature. It will always be in private owners interest to solve their problems as cheaply as possible rather than as effectively as possible, and in a market economy that means sacrificing the needs of the working masses. Transforming Canada from a market-based economy to a needs-based economy through worker revolution is essential for the nation’s continued growth and development.

Ford’s alcohol expansion plan is a notable sore on this year’s budget balancing failure. $225 million were sunk into breaking the LCBO’s exclusivity contract.5 The LCBO, because it is a public organization, generates revenue for the Ontario government. Without this contract, the Ford government is deliberately sabotaging public industry in order to line the pockets of private owners, such as Ford himself, his close associates, and his family. The Financial Accountability Office is conducting an investigation to uncover the total projected losses in tax dollars attributable to the mishandling of the LCBO by the Ford government.5 Beyond just the economics, there is the matter of what widespread alcohol availability does to workers.

During the July LCBO strike, People’s Hammer went to the picket lines to listen to the concerns of LCBO workers. Beyond their frustrations with the Ford government restricting what can be discussed at meetings and then attempting to pin the blame for the lack of progress on OPSEU, the LCBO picketers voiced concerns for the convenience store, grocery and other retail workers who would now be selling alcohol. “These workers don’t have the same training us LCBO employees receive. They do not have the skills to deal with belligerent customers demanding alcohol and its a serious concern for their safety. It is all needless and shortsighted.” One picketer said.

Ford spent $225 million to cut into Ontario’s LCBO revenue, threaten the job security of LCBO workers thanks to the LCBO’s inevitable dip in revenue, and threaten the safety of workers not trained to sell alcohol. Ford did this needless spending entirely with private bourgeois interest and with full lucidity that this was another chunk of Ontario taxpayer money he was happily willing to throw to the wind while the province remains millions in the deficit and with thousands in desperate need of work.

Highway 413’s construction is another major misstep from Ford. According to Ford’s new, giant propaganda signs littering roadsides, highway 413 is part of Ford’s “$28 billion plan to build roads and highways.”.6 The provincial government has spent approximately $16,000 per sign and have continuously torn them down to replace them with even larger signs, all for the purpose of securing Ford’s reelection.6 Ford’s misunderstanding of what causes gridlock and how to solve the commuter issue is less a misunderstanding and more a concession to the automotive industry owners. Whether Ford understands or doesn’t understand that new highways, roads, and lanes are ineffective means of curbing commuter congestion is somewhat irrelevant. Ford is making these decisions because the result he is looking for is increased automotive sales, not more efficient commute times. If getting people into their place of work quickly was a priority of the province, the giant luxury condos and tiny studio apartments sitting empty in urban centres would be transformed into reasonable, affordable places of dwelling, which would allow for the movement of giant swaths of the working population into the urban centres they must spend hours commuting to and from everyday. Instead, Ford is willing to carelessly buy up and destroy thousands of acres of farmland, threatening the province’s agriculture7 and threatening irreversible damage to the province’s watersheds8, which will only cost taxpayers more and more.

Public transport is a logical area to invest in if the province wants to see more reasonable commuter times, but Ford’s Ontario Line has ballooned out of control in cost. The subway project has had a 43% increase in cost from when it broke ground in March of 2022, with the current estimated cost at $27.2 billion.9 The provincial government continues to put large scale and integral transport projects into the incapable hands of Metrolinx. The Eglinton Crosstown LRT is fresh in the minds of Torontonians as Metrolinx has reported the project is “complete”, but because the public will not hear about the line’s opening until 3 months prior, it is expected it will not open until 2025, 5 years after its initial 2020 projection.10 This follows April 2023’s report from the Metrolinx CEO, Phil Verster, which stated that the tracks had been mislaid and that the project opening would be delayed “about a year.”11 That year has passed and still there is no solid opening date. Construction began on the Eglinton Crosstown LRT in 2011.11 The province cannot afford to sink billions of dollars into these expensive, haphazard projects. Action against Metrolinx to cough up the funds they have wasted must be taken, but will it? What interest does Doug Ford have in pursuing Metrolinx when it would be a costly legal battle that would put Ford’s terrible choice to continue doing business with Metrolinx on full display? Ford is much better off to spend money on propaganda signs to try to swindle ignorant Ontarians into voting for him so he can secure his own private interests rather than make progress on these integral public projects. Only a government operating with adherence to a needs based economy would be able to dismantle Metrolinx and create a public transportation construction organization that could efficiently complete the necessary public transport projects Ontario needs. Bourgeois politicians do not have the interest nor the ability to build these kinds of massive, collective organizations which directly threaten the existence of the bourgeoisie and private ownership.

The Federal government cannot be expected to help the province recover from the disastrous decision making of the provincial government and self absorbed bourgeoisie. When the Trudeau government sees issues arise such as too many international students in post secondary schools, they do not investigate the root of the issue. The bourgeois government does not recognize the talented Canadian youth in need of financial support for better education and prioritize their security, they simply cut off how many international students are allowed in, leaving more spots empty in lecture halls and shop classes, forcing schools out of more money with no assistance in remodeling their financial structure and leaving the masses to struggle against each other in competition just as it was before they so graciously pretended to help.

These are not issues voting for different parties can fix. These are not issues that can be placed in the hands of bourgeois politicians like Ford and Trudeau or fraudulent electoralists like the so-called “Communist Party of Canada”. These are issues which must be undertaken by the public, the working masses. The programme of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) seeks to operationalize all the measures which would curb unemployment, the sabotaging of public industry and the investment of tax dollars in cheap, foreign labour markets which workers see no return on. The CPC(RF) is currently one of the only Canadian organizations which People’s Hammer recognizes as holding a correct political line in establishing a proper republic of workers and it is because the CPC(RF)’s programme demonstrates a thorough, material understanding of the needs of Canada’s workers and Canada’s economy. Two aspects of Canada that the federal and provincial government seem today entirely disconnected from.

With a representative government of proletariat struggling for the democratic freedom of all workers, the illogical and selfish missteps of the bourgeois government would no longer need to continue. Ford and Trudeau do nothing but secure the private interests of Canada’s most wealthy, who line politicians’ pockets for continued cooperation and election support. The workers of Canada are not only leagues more capable than the bourgeois government, the workers of Canada understand the issues which are most pressing! Workers take their tax dollars seriously. Workers understand what their needs are. Never will these thumb-twiddling politicians sacrifice their time or energy for the sake of improving the lives of workers. Never will they care if the budget is balanced or if their government spending is reckless as long as they receive their paycheque and secure reelection. The workers pay for all these mistakes. Its time we organize, unionize, educate ourselves and do something about it!

References

1: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-nearly-balanced-budget-1.7328085

2: https://www.msn.com/en-ca/money/topstories/more-layoffs-coming-for-employees-who-worked-at-ontario-science-centre/ar-AA1qrgNb

3: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/240822/dq240822a-eng.htm

4: https://www.ctvnews.ca/business/number-of-people-receiving-ei-up-more-than-10-per-cent-in-past-year-statcan-1.7011782

5: https://www.msn.com/en-ca/news/politics/budget-watchdog-to-probe-ford-government-s-alcohol-expansion-deal/ar-AA1qGht9

6: https://globalnews.ca/news/10628129/highway-413-sign-replacement-costs-ontario/

7: https://ontariofarmlandtrust.ca/2020/10/01/highway-413/

8: https://www.nationalobserver.com/2024/09/19/news/gta-watersheds-threat-highway-413-pollution-health

9: https://globalnews.ca/news/10579363/ontario-line-cost-increase/

10: https://dailyhive.com/toronto/eglinton-crosstown-lrt-huge-milestone-opening

11: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/eglinton-crosstown-delays-verster-metrolinx-1.6824272


Response to “Ontario’s 2023-24 Budget: Ford’s Incompetence on Full Display – by Cliff Z.”

  1. Ontario Throws $77M at The OPP Price Hike – By Cliff Z. – The People's Hammer