Interviewer: What is your experience with the encampments here in Montreal? (McGill University and Université du Québec à Montréal)
Asini: It’s kind of a mixed bag, everything from your grad school, law school, or graduated alumni who are into the plan for negotiations, and anarchists who are basically here to escalate, they see BDS (Boycott, Divestment, & Sanctions) as the floor. The UQAM camp split off from the main McGill one due to those differences, with the UQAM camp being the more radical of them.
I: When you say BDS is the floor, what do you mean by that exactly?
A: I think BDS shouldn’t be the end goal in itself, it should be a springboard to something beyond simple divestment in universities. I think the UQAM camp proves that by demanding to shut down the Quebec government’s office in Tel Aviv. I think that is a good example of stepping out, making it more than just a student thing. I think that was the weakness of the McGill encampment, the people there emphasized that “this is a student movement” and I never saw why it should end at that point. There are some people who were saying “we don’t want to be here forever”. This is an occupation, isn’t it? You just want to be here for three days and then pack it up? They’re going to be experiencing a slow siege from the courts and the SPVM (Service de Police de la Ville de Montréal), and in a slow siege you can’t just sit there and do nothing or else you will lose steam. The McGill encampment followed the BDS national committee (BNC) by demanding that nobody is explicitly in favour of armed resistance, even though the BNC has since retracted this statement after criticism by the PFLP (Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine). I don’t know if any of the other resistance groups have, but I know the PFLP has and so they kind of silently took it back but it has already wrought its damage. It brought up a lot of silly talking about agent provocateurs and agitation out of the same playbook as Ferguson honestly. It’s been quite an experience being here and seeing the counter-insurgency propaganda take hold like that its been a huge learning experience. I still don’t know what lessons I’m drawing from it necessarily, but I don’t know.
I: Did you get the message from the McGill encampment that they thought that students were the revolutionary class?
A: I think they viewed what they were doing as revolutionary but I don’t think that the vast majority- the leaders and the people who are taking word for word what BDS is telling them to do- BDS is a flawed organization in and of itself- it doesn’t support the Mapping Project and doesn’t take direct orders from- there’s an organization in Palestine that’s actually based on the ground there- they don’t take directives. So they’re kind of a diaspora, they don’t have direct links to resistance. So what they say can be liberal like that as you can see. As far as revolutionary goes, I don’t know. Would they think what they’re doing is revolutionary but they don’t understand what revolution actually means?
I: We’ve seen the kind of centrism that comes out of following BDS 100% from the likes of IJV (Independent Jewish Voices) and other organizations that don’t take a fervent stand for the national liberation of Palestine especially through people’s war. What can the workers and unions do to support the goals of this encampment?
A: Honestly, I’m not all that that well versed in labour struggle and union stuff so I’m going to give you like your 101 answer which is obviously threatening to go on strike, walkouts, or escalating actions up to and including a strike across the board.
I: What are the goals of this particular encampment in your perspective?
A: For me, continual escalation even if best case scenario the demands are met to keep making more demands and keep showing people what you can win if you act militantly. It’s kind of like when you do things like this-
I: Inspire courage in people to resist-
A: It also shows them how to do it. Like, if they see you doing it, they’re curious, they come around to see how it works, they learn a thing or two, politically, tactically.
I: It’s my understanding that the encampment has specific goals with regards to their university. They want to divest, they want to disclose certain investments they have in Israel and weapons. So what if the workers and their unions were to go on strike how would that particularly assist in acquiring those goals for the disclosure and divestment?
A: I think it would put a lot of political pressure on an already tense situation. I think Quebec is in a strange position because it’s not using intense repression so if it continues to go that way I think that there might be a chance that they acquiesce to something. Whether or not that continues into something more is kind of dependent on how the movement goes and energy levels and if something went down. I feel like for me personally what I want to get the most out of this camp is meet new people and form relationships and bonds with other revolutionaries in order to build a group that actually has the potential to be a kernel of something that can become more a larger thing. At least that’s my goal personally especially with other colonized people that’s kind of what I’m here with. There are libraries here, I know people run presentations and 101’s on stuff. The educational portion is more like what do you call it, popular revolutionary education, I think. And then also like considering how this can kind of play out as the summer ends depending how long this is, it could be here all summer who knows how that’s going to play into once school comes back into play. I imagine that if the encampment is still here and demands are not met and the war is still happening in Palestine then I only see it intensifying once the school year comes back.
I: Do you see students in Canada being supportive of an armed struggle against our imperialists here in Canada who fight national liberation movements all over the world such as in Palestine and all over the world?
A: I think people in UQAM probably have a more friendly disposition towards that although the struggle in Montreal is definitely more like a street fighting kind of anti-cop mass demonstration or occupation nature. As far as armed struggle goes I don’t know anybody talking and if I did I wouldn’t be telling.
I: Yeah, they sort of want to fight the cops right, when really the main target should be finance capital class so what can we do to politicize them to that end, to direct their anger away from sort of the visible agents of oppression to the more fundamental pillars of these oppressive structures?
A: I guess we could start talking about imperialism in more than just a subtle way, making those real connections between how modern finance capital works and how modern day imperialism functions. Honestly it’s something I could get better at, it’s not something I’m fully up to date on.
I: Teaching about imperialism seems to be a necessary component that has to be developed because everyone kind of knows what capitalism is, they know they hate their boss, but they don’t really know why their boss is financially driven to act the way he does. You see this with a lot of liberals who dislike capitalism who might be involved in this encampment as well. You know, they see the genocide, they see the exploitation, they see the enslavement, and they see these as individual or moral problems when you know, they’re attacks on our class. Workers, oppressed nations, we have a common interest in overthrowing that and advancing society forward. So to do that is to target imperialism directly. Have you seen any harassment by Zionists or fascists or even the police on these encampments?
A: Mostly from Zionists, fascist types, reactionaries.
I: Any specific reactionary organizations or people that you thought had a particular goal that wasn’t just the protection of Israel?
A: No specific organizations come to mind, the only thing that there was was that rally that happened which went off without any direct confrontation. This is all at McGill, I haven’t experienced any harassment or at least know of any that has happened at UQAM. So there was the rally, and people who come to door to just like go off. Some guy got mad that we were flying the Viet Kong(Vietnamese National Liberation Front) flag. Other than that, Zionists who just pass by to snap pictures of people to try to dox people probably that’s about it. The people at the encampment have had a pretty strict none interaction policy when it comes to interacting with Zionists. I don’t necessarily know how I feel about that, it seems to me that it is more of a “we’re keeping it peaceful so we don’t get kicked out” or you know give evidence to allow an injunction to go through. I’m not necessarily sure how I feel about that, I think at a certain point you do have to fight fascists which is what Zionists are. But I do think it should definitely be more than a screaming match between two people.
I: What sort of tactics would you consider to resist police or Zionist attacks on the encampment? Do you take inspiration from any particular other encampments across North America or across the world. You know we’ve seen people lock down buildings, hit police with water jugs, and using umbrellas-
A: Yeah, your general riot stuff. The general how to, you see all these little magazines in the anarchist circles about reinforced barriers, helmets, goggles, the whole nine yards. There are definitely people who do know how to defend the camp and how to repel police if we’re all working in unison obviously, its fundamental.
I: The Tribal Council of Kanawake recently gave the students permission to be on their historic land but we know that the Canadian bourgeois state doesn’t respect the will of any of the nations that it has colonized. So what can the student movement do to mutually support the Mohawk national liberation struggle along with the other ones.
A: About the council thing, apparently it was from some weird unrecognized council but the Mohawk Mothers and people from the Louis Hall Foundation did visit the camp and give their blessing. And Mohawk Mothers are, as far as traditional governance goes, are the most legitimate keepers of the land. They’re in active struggle against McGill for the royal vic and for the graves behind the pools which I guess that kind of reminds me I found it quite a bit insulting for people to be like “we don’t want to be here forever” when there’s very clearly another glaring extremely related case of violent settler colonial institutions denying people dignity even in death. I mean it goes to show this one sided silo-ed version of solidarity or whatever is useless. I do enjoy the slogan “we’re not free until we’re all free” but it kind of goes to show the narrowness, almost self-interest, to get their “activist credit” like that. They have to mention “I’ve been organizing for five years, I’ve been organizing for ten years” I’m like ok and its the first time you’ve done something like this? Sad, honestly. But as far as to support Mohawk people its an idea but if anyone actually does get arrested you could try the good old tried and true Mohawk nation tactic of refusing to recognise the court and demanding that the Mohawk Mothers be your judges in front of the court- it’s just an idea- I don’t know if it flies for anyone that’s not Mohawk themselves because I’ve only ever seen Indigenous people do that but its an idea.
I: Notably, the People’s Hammer has reported that this was tried by a Wet’suwet’en chief and it did not work. (https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/04/01/chief-dstahyl-found-guilty-of-criminal-contempt-by-b-c-supreme-court-by-kale/)
A: A bit more of a tradition, maybe you could get away with it in Quebec law but I don’t know. Might seem like contempt of court on top of everything else but yeah.
I: What do you believe is the goal of a revolutionary newspaper in the development of class and national liberation struggle?
A: I guess to showcase the cutting edge of the militancy on display. Because it is really the only driving force. These occupations wouldn’t even be going down. I forget which was the first one but the more militant ones are proving their willingness and tenacity in the fight. I mean Columbia got f***ed up but I know there’s still people there and I guess that would be the role because the media don’t want to interview people in anonymity.
I: Do you think that the workers need to be the leading class in the revolution. Why or why not?
A: It’s a tricky one. I’m personally partial to the perspective that working class, colonized people need to be. As far as like the main driving force for revolutionary potential, destruction, I do believe working class is significant but this is not something that I have like personally puzzled out yet with regard to- definitely a revolutionary class- but not sure if it should be the leading one especially in settler colonial countries like the US and Canada. I lean towards colonized people. Obviously.
I: Is there a particular class of the colonized people that-
A: Lumpen working
I: The lumpenproletariat?
A: Lumpen and working
I: Lumpen and the working? You think they have similar revolutionary potential?
A: I think it depends on what kind of lumpen we’re talking about. There’s a lot of different types of lumpen…
I: Certainly not, you know, thieves and muggers-
A: No no, but the rehabilitation of such people is a necessary step because if you look at Indigenous communities in Canada and the US there is no avoiding it. In working class dirt poor neighbourhoods you always have half a dozen cousins who are in some way in or out of that world and women in particular are kind of in a strange position because these are usually their brothers, husband, or boyfriends, kids, and even if they themselves are working they are kind of forced into that world and at times participants in it through like survival means. And these are the people I think of when I think of revolutionary potential. So I guess I’m more on the side of like old Black Panther kind of perspective but I do think there needs to be a great deal of care when dealing with lumpen people especially the ones who have descended far into anti-social behaviour even if it is for survival anti-social behaviours are anti-social and generally destructive.
[Editors Note: While the rehabilitation of lumpen proletariat is an important step in guiding the Canadian masses towards revolution, it is not principal. People’s Hammer holds that the guiding class of the revolution is the proletariat, and while the proletarianization of all non-proletariat classes is a key goal of revolution, principally the proletariat must organize its most advanced workers into a Communist Party before these efforts can be made to the fullest.]
I: [I believe] that yes, [lumpen individuals], have a lot to gain from the revolution and it sort of seems like they should be the most inclined to join and be active in the revolution but they’re sort of the least motivated in practice and they also have less of a capacity to actually set up the new society… There’s nothing working class about oppressing other nations it doesn’t benefit the working class in general, it might benefit one certain segment of the… working class who want to be more bourgeois or who want to have these privileges but the fight against colonialism is a working class issue and that doesn’t mean that colonized people freeing themselves have to be communist. But typically if the bourgeoisie is the one in charge of that liberation struggle they tend to just subjugate them to a different imperialist. That’s what we’ve seen in history. Any final thoughts to share to communists and workers across Canada, and if we have readers across the world, who are struggling against capitalism imperialism for a better world?
A: It’s so cheesy but like patiently explaining is a big one. I see a lot of people at each other’s throats at these things a little bit, there’s a lot of fear which is like the whole point that’s what the police do. A lot of what the police do is just psychological f*** with your mind. Even with someone’s kind of short rude like whatever with you, its valuable to kind of check in and think was that something real or was that stress because of the intensity of the situation, and it is kind of emotionally interpersonal thing but it helps so much when it comes to getting people to listen to what you want to say and it is so important. I do think it has been a bit of a problem considering the ages of the participants so it’s to be expected. But it is number one, that’s what I’ve been trying to like mantra in my head whenever I get all miffed up by some random person being rude or something or what I perceive as rude. Patient explanation and shut the f*** up if you don’t know what you’re talking about. That’s it.