The People's Hammer

Interview with an ex-member of the Canadian Armed Forces in Calgary – by Daniel H. and Ivan D.

, ,


An interview was recently conducted with an ex-member of the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF). This ex-soldier brought to light the harrowing conditions many soldiers in the Canadian military face while actively serving, and the glaring issues many see post service. The conditions described are a call for an urgent need for Canadian soldiers and the movement for workers to unite to help free each other from the exploitation they face.

Daniel H: Why did you join the military? How long were you a member?

Ex-CAF Member: First thought about joining the military at 13 and joined Cadets at 16. I made the decision to join the CAF when I was still in high school. After high school, the Alberta job market was poor. I decided to pursue both passion and opportunity by joining the military at the time.

Daniel H: What was the job market like when you joined?
Ex-CAF Member: There was a down turn in the oil and gas market which affected the rest of the province given the importance of that industry to Alberta. This meant jobs were scarce and unemployment was starting to rise.1 I was also just out of high school so I had no work experience or a drivers license and so the CAF provided opportunities to get ahead in the difficult economy.

Daniel H: What position did you have in the military?
Ex-CAF Member: I was a rank-and-file NCM (Non-Commissioned Member) in the Regular Force. I joined the Army Engineers before transfering to a Combat Support occupation.

Daniel H: What were the conditions like in the military? How was your pay?
Ex-CAF Member: The conditions were generally deteriorating. We have stark shortages of federal funding, personnel and working equipment. There are shortages in virtually every CAF NCM trade at the moment.

A recent news article from the CBC stated that only 50% of the CAF’s equipment still works.2 Some of our vehicles would break down en-route to field training areas from the base. At my unit, sometimes we inspected the same defective vehicles, multiple times a month. They weren’t moved away and nothing happened to them otherwise. Defective vehicles were essentially left rotting in place.

Collective training at both the training schools and units is suffering from poor funding, defective equipment and outdated everything. Sometimes in training, soldiers will yell “bang!” instead of shooting, if blank rounds aren’t available.

Infrastructure is also suffering. Many base barracks are decades old; specifically from the Cold War, and some such as CFB Kingston have stood since the 1930s. They haven’t all been torn down. The remaining ones have simply been renovated and remodeled over the decades.

Canada’s military bases also have housing communities. Houses are called PMQs, or Permanent Married Quarters. Many of these homes are also old and present with numerous issues.

Military barracks offer the cheapest living costs in Canada. For a so-called “closet room” and meals, you can pay as little as $725 monthly. However, federal income taxes can be significant, and you can lose up to $1200 of monthly pay to them.3

Some soldiers and their families are financially struggling today. They’re accessing external services, such as Habitat For Humanity and food banks, to support themselves. The CAF’s pay and benefits are no longer enough to support their families.

Daniel H: How were the relations between NCMs and Officers?
Ex-CAF Member: I frequently worked with Officers as an NCM. My interactions with them were largely positive, and I’d say even sometimes better than with other NCMs. However, some NCMs disliked Officers and vise versa. It’s a mixed bag. However, as far as the bigger picture is concerned, there definitely is distrust among the rank-and-file towards the General & Flag Officers in Ottawa.

Daniel H: What are other concerns among rank-and-file members in the CAF?
Ex-CAF Member: I’d say that the main concerns among the NCMs are with regards to payment, housing, leadership, other life quality factors and receiving adequate training. Our low funding and bad equipment state aren’t inspiring any confidence, either. Right now, there are CAF members struggling to make ends meet for their families, as stated earlier. If life quality and living standards keep going down, then the attrition rate will only get worse.

Ivan D: You mentioned prior to the interview that you were a part of a program in the CAF called “Helmets to Hard Hats”. Can you tell us about what that is and what your experiences with it were?

Ex-CAF Member: Helmets to Hardhats is an organization that helps veterans find trade union placement as laborers and apprentices. Personally, I used them to find potential employment with the union, LiUNA, in my area. The trade that I wanted was seasonal, so it didn’t work through the winter. I was told that my “resume was at the top of the pile” and to expect movement in the late spring. One thing led to another, and when I inquired then, I was never called back. I was already jaded from the military’s bureaucracy and wasn’t motivated to pursue this any further. So instead, I found employment elsewhere.

Ivan D: Is this common for soldiers trying to get post-service benefits and services?

Ex-CAF Member: It can be difficult for veterans to receive benefits. Getting everything documented, medically, was strongly emphasized when I was in. If you don’t document any medical issues while serving, then getting assistance from Veterans Affairs can be quite difficult. While some members struggle to get benefits, others are receiving them. Tinnitus is an example of something that can be hard to attribute to military service without prior documentation. I knew-of a couple people who got addicted to illegal drugs while serving. They were paid-out for their issues, and with that money, promptly overdosed after releasing.

Daniel H: It is known that the military is a place that fascists will often join. Did you run into any in your time in the military?

Ex-CAF Member: I’ve never really encountered them in the Regular Force. Many politically-minded people I met in the military acted and spoke like social media, 4chan and Stormfront comment sections. They were chronically online before joining. They all washed out and failed training.

Daniel H: Are there any other things being faced by rank-and-file members worth noting?

Ex-CAF Member: Yes. Kit deficiencies. Depending on your formation (Division, Brigade & Regiment), you may or may not be allowed to buy your own personal kit. Typically this is limited to patrol packs, tactical vests, gloves and toques. We’re allowed to do this because our issued personal kit is outdated and unpopular. We are able to buy better stuff from military surplus stores. One particular unit made the national news for buying their own helmets for usage on deployment.4 Following this, they were forced to wear their issued helmets, as it poorly reflected on the CAF.

Daniel H: How do you think the rank-and-file in the military could go about improving the poor conditions they face? Do you think unionisation would be beneficial?

Ex-CAF Member: Unionization of the military could potentially mitigate some of these systemic problems. Some European armies, such as the Dutch, have done this. It provides rank-and-file soldiers with better input through the system. I don’t think that the government would accept or allow a unionized CAF, however.

Daniel H: Do you think there is any benefit for workers in the military and Canada generally from participation in wars abroad or other operations they conduct?

Ex-CAF Member: The military helps within Canada through Operation LENTUS, which is disaster relief. I cannot speak from personal experience, but the Afghanistan War did contribute to disrupting and weakening global terrorism groups. But the average Canadian was disconnected from and unaware of the results of the war. Some civilians who I’ve spoken with were under the impression that we’d never even left Afghanistan.

In the broader picture, I think that Western military action in the Middle East had significant destabilizing affects, especially as the years went on.

Daniel H: Going back to your experiences with unions like LiUNA and the union bureaucracy that you experienced, how do you think unions could be restructured to serve interests of workers and soldiers after service?

Ex-CAF Member: I don’t know of any specifics but unions seem to be good for small scale workplace advocacy and issue resolution. Beyond small disputes though, there is no real advocacy or defense done by unions for workers.

[Post-interview, the soldier gave more info to be included about his experience in the military and conditions that he faced.]


Ex-CAF Member: The internal state of Canada’s military is considerably poor. When I was releasing, there were over ten thousand other soldiers who’d done the same, in just a year. We didn’t recruit nearly enough to replace all of them. In Canada, you’re allowed to quit the military anytime. Chronic injuries and mental illness, rampant infighting among the ranks, culturally encouraged substance abuse, sexual harassment/assault and criminality are all problematic at the training schools and some units. Exposure to these problems over my five years, along with what I already hated, is what caused me to release. The bad ultimately outweighed the good.

I personally hated the low funding, outdated equipment, blindly incompetent bureaucracy, meaningless garrison routine, shitty leadership and social toxicity. I also hated the limitations to my individuality.

———-

Underscoring all of this is a blatant attempt from the Canadian military to save face on these details. When becoming a member of the CAF, one waives their rights for the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms meaning a limitation on speech, movement, and association, during and up to 24 months after leaving.5 Deviating from this can be taken as “Section 129” or Insubordination which can land a soldier with heavy punishment and damage to any further career they have in the military.

It is also necessary to point out that the military, whilst being an institution of bourgeois rule to entrench and enforce Canadian imperialism both domestic and internationally, the missions rank-and-file soldiers are sent to are to their disadvantage, even though their job is to fight on behalf of imperialism. Firstly, the vast majority of rank-and-file soldiers in the Canadian military are pulled from the ranks of the working class. Evidence of this is shown by the large amount of recruitment from Atlantic Canada, particularly the province of Newfoundland and Labrador6 where unemployment has tended to be much higher than the rest of the country in recent decades. The Canadian military has also increased efforts to recruit from Permanent Residents7 (the military was previously only open to Canadian citizens) which has seen a significant increase in recruitment applications from this demographic, largely looking for a path to stable employment and full citizenship. Regarding Canadian deployment of troops, this is to the disadvantage of both Canadian NCMs and the international working-class. Domestically a notable example is the deployment of troops at both Kanesatake.8 Here Canadian troops were used to come to the aid to the rule of Canadian imperialism through military action to continue the national oppression of the Mohawk nation.

More recently, Canadian troops saw deployment in Afghanistan, only ending in 2014. Within this Canadian troops were deployed for supposed “peacekeeping”. The peacekeeping narrative regarding Canadian military missions internationally is a common trope that is often attributed by mouthpieces of Canadian imperialism to attempt to portray Canadian imperialism as a net-positive for the people of the world. In reality, this deployment, alongside other countries in the International Security and Assistance Forces in Afghanistan, led by the US, resulted in more than 70,000 dead Afghans,9 and over 2000 Canadian casualties, including 158 deaths.10 Now, what would be the benefit of sending troops to die in a foreign war in a country that is on the other side of the world from Canada? Contrary to the peacekeeping narrative, Canadian imperialism had a vested interest in participation in this war. Beside Canada being a junior partner in US imperialism for much of the time, Canadian capital realistically saw great benefit from the war. While direct profits are hard to track, Canadian companies like General Dynamics Land Systems and SNC-Lavalin were known for supplying both Canadian and NATO forces with a significant amount of military hardware for the conflict. There was also a likely benefit sought for companies like Centerra gold, an imperialist mining company. While Centerra Gold mainly operates in Kyrgyzstan, broader stabilization of the region would benefit Centerra Gold through a more stable environment to operate and possibilities to expand mining into the mineral rich Afghanistan.

Lastly the Canadian military has a history of sending its troops to fight efforts of workers to liberate themselves from the clutches of imperialism and create socialism. Canadian troops were sent to Russia to fight against the Bolshevik revolution in 191811. Similarly, the Canadian military was eager to send troops to fight the establishment of a socialist Korea in the 1950s.12

Ultimately, this long military history displays a ready use of the Canadian bourgeoisie to deploy members of the military (who have no say in their participation in these conflicts) for Canadian interests at the expense their time, well-being, and often, lives. These soldiers have no benefit in fighting on behalf of the bourgeoisie, nor do those who are killed by the Canadian military. Instead, it would be to the benefit of Canadian troops to turn their guns away from other members of the working class, and instead turn them towards the bourgeoisie of Canada.

What all of this lays clear is the immediate need for Canadian soldiers to fight for organisation and better conditions. Not a single worker deserves the treatment this soldier and many others has received. It is time Canadian soldiers and workers unite to fight for their interests against their common oppressor, the ruling capitalist class, and the government representatives that act on their behalf in putting workers and soldiers in the conditions they face.

1 The Albertan economy saw a downturn with a decrease in oil prices around 2018 with many in oil or oil-related industries losing their jobs. Oil is a major center of Alberta’s economy meaning downturns in the industry largely effect workers in the entire province. https://www.iisd.org/articles/alberta-oil-sector-decline

2 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/nato-canadian-armed-forces-europe-1.7135390

3 The current starting wage for NCMs in the Canadian Armed Forces is currently $3300/month

4 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadian-soliders-latvia-equipment-helmets-1.6864290

5 https://www.canada.ca/en/department-national-defence/corporate/policies-standards/acts-regulations/third-independent-reviews-nda/chap1-military-justice-system/service-offences-punishments.html#toc3

6 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/military-enlistment-atlantic-1.6394787

7 https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/military-received-2400-applications-from-permanent-residents-in-november

8 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2022/06/08/learn-from-the-kanesatake-resistance-join-the-struggle-for-indigenous-liberation/

9 https://interactive.aljazeera.com/aje/2021/afghanistan-visualising-impact-of-war/index.html

10 https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/international-campaign-against-terrorism-in-afghanistan

11 https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/canadian-siberian-expeditionary-force

12 https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/canadian-siberian-expeditionary-force