The People's Hammer

Oppose the Ban on Samidoun – by Daniel H.

, ,


Pro-Palestinian national liberation organisation, Samidoun, was banned in October in a joint action by the Biden and Trudeau administrations.1

This is the culmination of a long campaign to ban the organisation that can be seen as early as two years ago when The National Post published an article in favour of a ban.2 More recently, Charlotte Kates, one of the main Samidoun leaders, had been arrested in a hate-crime investigation related to her support of the Palestinian offensive of October 7.3 This campaign sped up with a recent rally in Vancouver to mark the one-year anniversary of the Palestinian offensive. At the rally, participants were heard chanting “we are Hamas and we are Hezbollah”.4 Immediately following this, Poillievre called for the ban.5 This was followed by the public safety minister’s request for an expedited review of Samidoun.6

Samidoun has now been added to Canada’s terror list. This list was created in response to 9/11. It provides the government with the power to ban organisations without a high burden of evidence and essentially no opportunity to present a defence.7

In their official statements regarding the ban, Canada and the USA linked the organisation with the already-banned Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. The US specifically called Samidoun a sham charity.8 The US also listed Khaled Barakat as involved in the PFLP’s leadership and fundraising.9

It is important to note that Samidoun’s ban enjoys complete support from the main representatives of the Canadian bourgeoisie. The ban came from the Liberal government under Conservative pressure. Even the NDP has come out in support of it through BC Premier Eby.10 Eby’s support for state repression against organisations supporting national liberation struggles, should wipe away any remaining legitimacy the NDP has to its claim of being a workers’ party. The oppressed nations of the world are a key ally of the workers in the world proletarian revolution. In fact, it is the new democratic revolution that is required in many of these oppressed nations that makes up the base of the world proletarian revolution today. The NDP’s action is only one in a long line that place in-step with the other bourgeois parties.11

The specific effects of the ban mean that Samidoun will no longer be able to collect donations, their funds will be blocked, and their property may be seized.12

Samidoun’s terrorist designation must be understood by the workers beyond the superficial level. It marks the increasing decay of Canadian imperialism and its increasing reactionisation. An organisation like Samidoun poses no threat to the Canadian state. Samidoun’s work in Canada is largely confined to protest hopping and agitation for Palestinian national liberation. It is certainly the most visible of the many groups of its type in Canada, but even assuming that a threat to the bourgeois state was a justifiable reason for repression in the eyes of the workers, Samidoun clearly does not even rise to this. Samidoun’s ban must be recognised a canary in the coal mine – a sign of future repression on the masses of Canada. If an organisation like Samidoun can be banned for so little, what will happen when the workers move closer to the reconstitution of the communist party?

For this reason, the workers must demand Samidoun’s removal from the terror list. At the same time, we cannot ignore the reactionary and highly opportunistic character of Samidoun. Charlotte Kates is an open supporter of the fascist regime in Iran having both praised the recently deceased president and accepting a human rights award from Iran.13 Domestically, Samidoun has knowingly protected rapists like Brendan Copegog-White.14 Samidoun was also key to the attempted rehabilitation of the reactionary organisation Fire this Time15 by bringing them into the recent wave of pro-Palestine protests in Vancouver.

With respect to Samidoun’s the ban, the workers need to avoid two errors. The first would be to reject the need to fight the ban on Samidoun because of its reactionary character. The second would be to uncritically support Samidoun because we oppose the ban. Both of these errors will lead to opportunism. Samidoun is fully reactionary. We must keep this in mind and regularly expose its character. At the same time, the main question is the reactionisation of the Canadian state that the ban represents and what Samidoun was advocating for that resulted in the ban. The fight against the repression of support for the Palestinian national liberation movement and the repression of the broader popular movement it paves the way for must be our chief focus.


Responses to “Oppose the Ban on Samidoun – by Daniel H.”

  1. Samidoun’un Yasaklanmasına Karşı Çıkalım – Daniel H. Tarafından – The People's Hammer
  2. Yves Engler’s Jailing Signals Increasing Reaction of Quebecois Imperialism – By Daniel H. – The People's Hammer
  3. L’emprisonnement d’Yves Engler indique la croissance réactionnaire de l’impérialisme québécois – par Daniel H. – The People's Hammer