The People's Hammer

Commentary on the U.S Election – by Mels G. & Cliff Z.



The United States federal election, held on November 5th 2024, has concluded with the decisive victory of former President Donald Trump. Many supposed Communists are shocked and dismayed over this result, such as the so-called “Communist” Party of Canada, the “Communist” Party USA & “Marxist-Leninist” Party of Germany.1,2,3 The outrage from such groups poses a question to any self respecting Marxist. What is the purpose of elections in Bourgeois democracy and why do the CPC, CPUSA, & MLPD care so much about their outcome? Beyond the issue of the false narrative being promoted by the revisionists, a proper analysis of the impact of this election will have on Canada is in order.

Political Power & Elections

Political power is the material expression of the rule of a class. It manifests itself in the use of force by the ruling class. If a ruling class does not have any way to enact its interests through force, it is not a ruling class at all. As Mao Zedong stated “Political Power grows from the barrel of a gun.”4 Currently, within the era of imperialism, political power is in the hands of the imperialists. The imperialists have their armies and their police forces, and this is where they derive their political power from.

Political power is not some abstract idea like the revisionists above will try to have you believe. CPUSA claims that the election is two mass movements fighting for political power, but is this really the case?5 No, it is not. Both the Democrats and the Republicans are in full control of political power within the United States, as they are both supported by the imperialists of the US. Millions of dollars come in from various corporations to financially support each party, some corporations even choosing to support both parties at once!6 Of course, the bourgeoisie has its own internal contradictions like any other phenomena, and so the purpose of elections within bourgeois democracy is to allow the various factions of the bourgeoisie to duke it out every few years to enact their specific preferred policy. On the whole, it does not matter which particular representative of the bourgeoisie the people vote on, as they are at the end of the day all a part of the same class that will oppress the people.

Why then do these so-called Communists care so much about their outcome? This is because these organizations are not representative of the proletariat. As stated elsewhere, the so-called “Communist” Party of Canada is a party which represents the interests of the petit-bourgeoisie and middle bourgeoisie, not the proletariat.7 The efforts of these revisionist parties against a particular grouping within the bourgeoisie is an attempt to unite themselves with another grouping within that same class. The CPUSA will openly admit to supporting the Democrats.8 Even though they may claim that they support more than just voting blue no matter who, they do nothing to prove to the people that this is in any way a priority for them. They use issues like the oppression of LGBT people and women to smuggle their stale ideas into the workers movement. The only proper solution to these issues isn’t begging for their preferred member of the ruling class to make more concessions, but instead building a legitimate movement of workers to win power through revolution. One may notice that in none of the articles from the revisionist groups is the word “revolution” used once!

The Results

What then do the results of this election actually represent? The revisionists claim that the election of Donald Trump means a clear path toward American fascism.1,2,3 This analysis, however, does a great disservice when it comes to understanding the danger of liberalism. Donald Trump is a liberal, perhaps a particularly reactionary liberal, but a liberal nonetheless. We cannot understand fascism as being a particular set of reactionary policies, this would prevent us from understanding that liberals are perfectly capable of engaging in repression.The analysis of the revisionists also does a great disservice to the millions of Americans who voted for Trump. Are there fascists and other reactionaries who voted for Trump? Certainly! But this does not mean that 75 million Americans are all white supremacists ready to commit acts of reactionary violence. The average Trump voter is likely someone who is rightly frustrated with the group of uncaring bourgeois politicians who administrate the country. Unfortunately, they have been deceived into believing that Trump is the solution to their problems, but this is obviously not the case. These people may hold reactionary beliefs, but this does not mean that they are somehow unworthy of being involved in the workers movement. Many of them are regular workers who suffer under the same exploitation as others, and so they too must be won over by the communist movement.

Furthermore, Trump did not win as a result of a huge surge of voters for himself, but instead as a result of a mass exodus of voters for the Democrats.9,10 About 9 million people chose to not vote for the Democrats from 2020 to 2024, and Donald Trump only received an additional 1 million votes from the prior election.9,10 This development indicates that millions of Americans have correctly decided that the election is a farce for the people and that it will not do anything to improve their conditions. Of course, it is born out of apathy for the bourgeois political system and not a newfound revolutionary spirit. But this is something that can and should be seized upon in the efforts to reconstitute the Communist Party of the United States.

Post Election Fallout

In a desperate scramble, the Liberals are attempting to steer the upcoming Trump administration away from Canadian tariffs and have voiced that they strongly stand with the United States in regards to Chinese tariffs.11 The Liberals are trying to ensure that Canadian steel and aluminum exports remain untouched by the returning Trump presidency in order to avoid the brief, but still damaging tariffs imposed in 2018.12 The rhetoric the Liberals use against Canada’s over reliance on Chinese manufacturing loses much of its weight when who is responsible for Canada’s reliance on China is questioned. The Liberals have rocked back and forth on their position on China, constantly trying to appease both the US imperialists and the Chinese imperialists so that the Canadian bourgeoisie is not completely bullied into submission.13 While the Trudeau government has generally been viewed unfavourably by China,14 this is not because they have been sticking up for Canadian manufacturing. It has primarily been because the Liberals wish to ensure Canada’s allegiance with US imperialism remains stable and secondarily because Trudeau’s negotiations for Canadian-Chinese free trade failed miserably.15Ultimately, the federal government’s continued failure to properly invest in domestic industry is the sole factor to blame for Canada’s economic instability and reliance on foreign markets.

The federal government wants to frame levying tariffs against Chinese steel, aluminum and electric vehicles not as a peace offering to maintain good standings with Donald Trump (which it is), but as a measure which will curb the damage to Canada’s manufacturers and workers as Deputy PM Chrystia Freeland has put it.11The problem here is that tariffs alone do not create, nor bolster national industry which Freeland’s statement seems to imply. It must be understood that regardless of how great the losses in revenue caused by Chinese tariffs are, the Canadian bourgeoisie is not going to suddenly pivot to investing long term in Canadian manufacturing and ensuring the jobs of Canadian workers. The owning class’ interest is that of entirely individual profit, and so when the cheapest source of goods is taken from them, they will simply move to the next cheapest and cut any losses through layoffs or cutting worker’s wages. The Liberals can try to paint a beautiful, fraudulent picture of Canada’s allegiance with the US against Chinese manufacturing fostering a growth in national industry, but it does not make the true intentions of their capitulation to Trump and US imperialism any less transparent.

Growth in national industry is something which is necessary for Canada’s working masses and Canada’s growing population of unemployed workers.16The reason the Liberals’ propaganda surrounding these tariffs is effective is because they are correct in their statements that Canada must become more economically independent. Canada needs to be more self reliant and stable for the continued growth and development of the working masses. However, the Liberals obstruct the truth that it is the interests of the Canadian owning classes which hinder collectivization and development of the Canadian masses and they instead pin the blame solely on the foreign markets. The foreign markets which Canada’s domestic bourgeoisie is directly responsible for creating a reliance on. Because the Liberals never reach the root of this problem, they can continue to misdirect the masses when they propose trade policies while they attempt to hide their true intentions to shift foreign reliance around rather than strive for true economic independence.

As was outlined in People’s Hammer’s coverage of the NDP’s break form their coalition with the Liberals, the trend of these bourgeois parties attempting to appeal to workers and claiming that they are representative of the working masses’ interests is a farce.17The class interests of the Liberals, Conservatives, NDP, BQ,Green Party, and any other electoral party are fundamentally identical as they are all interested in furthering Canadian imperialism and maintaining bourgeois dictatorship. This is the exact same case for the Democrats and Republicans, and even so-called “alternatives” like the Libertarian and Green Party in the United States. To grow national industry and support Canada’s working masses, we must not be fooled into believing that workers’ interests are truly being considered by these parties. We must devote ourselves to reconstituting a proletarian Communist Party of Canada so that the bourgeois dictatorship can be done away with and the workers needs can be met. People’s Hammer is optimistic about the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) in their continued efforts to reconstitute the party so that the Canadian masses may begin establishing a proper democratic republic of workers. The promotion of the CPC(RF)’s correct political line is an important first step in doing away with Canadian imperialism entirely.18

Conclusion

The working classes of Canada and the United States must not be fooled by the false democracy that is put on for show every few years. Democracy within the era of imperialism has and will continue to be as Lenin put it “a democracy for the minority, only for the propertied classes, only for the rich. Freedom in capitalist society always remains about the same as it was in the ancient Greek republics: freedom for the slave-owners.”19 Every worker should reject the fraudulent elections in Canada, the United States, and anywhere else around the world.

1. https://communist-party.ca/us-elections-a-lesson-for-canada-mobilize-against-the-far-right-raise-wages-and-living-standards/

2. https://www.cpusa.org/article/dont-believe-the-hype-no-trump-mandate/

3. https://www.mlpd.de/english/2024/government-breakup-in-germany-fascist-trump-elected-in-the-usa-mlpd-to-run-nationwide-in-new-elections

4. Mao Zedong, “Problems of War and Strategy” (November 6, 1938), Selected Works, Vol. II, p. 224.

5. https://www.cpusa.org/article/a-marxist-analysis-of-the-trump-victory/

6. https://www.washingtonpost.com/elections/interactive/2024/biggest-campaign-donors-election-2024/

7. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/08/the-liquidationist-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada/

8. https://www.cpusa.org/interact_cpusa/why-does-the-cpusa-support-democratic-party-candidates-for-the-presidency-instead-of-running-their-own-candidates/

9. https://edition.cnn.com/election/2020/results/president

10. https://edition.cnn.com/election/2024/results/president

11. https://globalnews.ca/news/10860888/donald-trump-canada-us-trade-chinese-tariffs/

12. https://globalnews.ca/news/7258571/trump-tariffs-timeline-since-2017/

13. https://globalnews.ca/news/9287337/china-canada-relationship-respectful-mary-ng/

14. https://www.reuters.com/world/china-is-open-contacts-dialogue-with-canada-chinas-foreign-minister-2024-01-11/

15. https://www.reuters.com/article/business/canada-drops-free-trade-talks-with-china-the-globe-and-mail-idUSKBN2692QB/

16. https://www.ctvnews.ca/business/number-of-people-receiving-ei-up-more-than-10-per-cent-in-past-year-statcan-1.7011782

17. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/11/01/ndp-break-coalition-with-liberals/

18. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/

19. https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1917/staterev/ch05.htm


Response to “Commentary on the U.S Election – by Mels G. & Cliff Z.”

  1. Translation: ABD Seçimlerine Dair Yorumlar – Mels G. ve Cliff Z. Tarafından – The People's Hammer