The People's Hammer

Interview with a Canvasser – by Cliff Z.

,


 

Cliff: What is your current position?

Canvasser: I’m a canvasser. I raise money for charities. Door to door, on the street, other people in the company do phone calls.

Cliff: What are your working conditions like?

Canvasser: It can be harsh this time of year. You’re out for hours in the cold and dark. I got very sick recently as a result of the low temperatures.

Cliff: What are your hours like?

Canvasser: Pretty reasonable. 30-35 hours a week, 7 hour shifts.

Cliff: What about the wages?

Canvasser: Thankfully, the company I work for pays hourly, though I know that isn’t the standard across the industry for this type of position. The problem, however, is you are still evaluated by how much you collect, so you have all of the downsides of a commission system without receiving commission.

Cliff: No bonuses or anything?

Canvasser: There are, but you have to get a lot of donations and its only around a dollar. They try as much as possible to get as much out of you as they can

Cliff: What is management like?

Canvasser: There isn’t much to say. They’re not uniquely bad or uniquely good. The problem is that they’re particularly pushy not only about meeting targets but going above and beyond. They try to give you tips and tricks on how to go above your expected collection. It is usually very manipulative.

Cliff: Can you expand on how it is manipulative?

Canvasser: A lot of emotional tactics. Telling a potential donor “did you know that 40k children have died in Gaza in the last year?” to make them feel bad about not giving you their money, things like that.

Cliff: Do you believe that the charities are worthwhile?

Canvasser: If you look on the surface level, of course the charities don’t do anything you’re going to disagree with. We should deal with the youth mental health crisis for example, but the question is never “why are things like this going on in the first place?” They like band-aid solutions rather than actually getting to the root of problems. In fact, it would be bad for them if the various charities that they contact for stop existing because they take a cut of every donation people give. In effect, they profit off of the various horrible things happening in the world.

Cliff: Do you think the fact they indirectly profit off of these problems influences their willingness to manipulate donors?

Canvasser: It is funny you say that, because they explicitly tell you not to lie to potential donors, but then they tell you lots of ways to not lie which end up being effectively lies. For example, one of the charities that I was collecting for, their CEO has a salary of several hundred thousand dollars. We were explicitly told how to deflect that issue if it was brought up. So to answer your question, I don’t think they particularly care about the causes because they do not tell you how to better educate people about the causes, they just tell you how to get more money.

Cliff: Do you think if people were better educated they wouldn’t donate to these charities?

Canvasser: I think if they were better educated they would be doing things other than just trying to throw money at the problem. I am not trying to put the blame on the average person, of course. They are deliberately kept out of the know on these sorts of issues. An educated person understands that the solution is not an amount of dollars, but correcting concrete political problems which need to be solved.

Cliff: What sort of concrete political problems?

Canvasser: It all stems from imperialism and its decaying culture. The youth mental health crisis is not a bizarre thing when you understand that our society does not care about the well being of the youth, but instead only sees them as potential workers to exploit. Beyond that, all of the war related charities are trying to solve an issue at the leaves rather than at the roots. Imperialist wars are going to continue to happen and the only thing which can change that is socialism, not philanthropy.

Cliff: Moving back a step, whats the typical response from a potential donor?

Canvasser: Most people are completely indifferent and ignore you outright, which is totally understandable because I myself wouldn’t want to be stopped in the street or disturbed in my home by someone begging for money. Some people are outright hostile. On my first day I had a woman say she was going to kill me. Of course, there are nice people. This is the exception though, not the rule.

Cliff: Why do you think that is?

Canvasser: The average person understands generally, I would think, that charity as a concept is silly. We have all of these major problems and instead of trying to enact any sort of proper change, we go and harass regular working people for their money. Suppose the solution was a simple problem of money, you have many people in our society who sit on piles of millions or even billions of dollars and yet the best we can do is $15 a month from a single mother or a student working two jobs. The whole thing is irrational and I think most people understand that and rightfully don’t want to engage with us.

Cliff: Do your coworkers feel similarly?

Canvasser: A lot of my coworkers are people who are new to Canada, so I think a lot of them are less worried about that and more focused on just trying to make it by. Obviously on the part of the company, they probably hire more vulnerable people because they are less likely to take issue with their practices.

Cliff: What change would you like to see in this line of work?

Canvasser: Frankly, I don’t think anyone should be subjected to a job like this. It is all very pointless once you understand that these charities are essentially money pits to make people feel good and get tax write-offs. Not to be pessimistic, of course. Obviously there needs to be an improvement in, for example, the situation in Gaza. The proper course of action for Canadians on this particular issue would be a total embargo on Israel. Millions of our tax dollars are sent to fund that horrible war. It’s not good for us and it’s not good for Palestinians.

Cliff: How do you think people who understand that charity as a concept is misguided can go about enacting the change they’d like to see?

Canvasser: A big problem with charity is the individualism of it and what we instead need is forms of collective power. Things like unions and other progressive political organizations. For example, I could imagine my job being, instead of soliciting donations, going around and trying to start union drives or form tenants unions. That would do so much more good than just collecting dollar bills from people.

Cliff: Do you feel satisfied with the unions and tenant unions we have today?

Canvasser: No. At a previous job of mine I tried to get in contact with a union, but they said they couldn’t do anything because it was too small a shop. A lot of friends and family of mine who are in unions tell me about all of the bureaucratic nonsense they have to deal with.

Cliff: But you don’t believe this is a flaw of unions in and of themselves?

Canvasser: No. The unions that we have aren’t really focused on the average member and more so cater to those who are in the cushy positions within the union.

Cliff: Moving back again, is there any particular reason you went into this line of work?

Canvasser: It was the only thing that I could get. I have been applying to jobs pretty consistently for the last six months. It isn’t as though I lack experience or anything like that, but it seems like a lot of the job postings that get put up are phony. I hear plenty of people talking about companies putting up fake job postings either when they already know who is going to be picked for the position or to meet some government related hiring quota.

Cliff: Do you know other people in similar situations?

Canvasser: Absolutely. Everybody that I know has either been working their current job for a few years or are unemployed. It seems like particularly within the last year all basic minimum wage jobs have completely dried up and when it comes to getting more skilled work, you need to already have several years of experience in order to be a real candidate.

Cliff: Do you have any thoughts on unemployment across Canada?

Canvasser: I think everything I’ve just said covers my thoughts pretty clearly. Its really hard to get work, at least in Toronto, and from everything I can tell its like that across the country too.

Cliff: Thanks for your time today. Is there anything else you’d like to say to other workers across Canada?

Canvasser: As working conditions continue to get worse, I think there is no better time than now to get organized. I think what you guys do is really beneficial in times like these. Thanks a lot for giving me the opportunity to share my experience.