The People's Hammer

The Canadian State imposes the will of the Cartel of Port Exploiters – By Michael B.

,


Montreal dockworkers have been working without a contract since December 31, 2023. In other words, there has been no agreement between the capitalists of the port and the workers on what constitutes a “fair deal” for the past year. This breakdown of negotiations is always bound to happen at certain points in the labour struggle because of the antagonistic contradiction between the interests of capital and labour in the current age of advanced monopoly capitalism, or imperialism. Let us take a look at what has happened in the absence of a diplomatic solution to this struggle.

On October 10, CUPE local 375’s Longshoremen’s Union began an “overtime strike”, meaning the workers would no longer work overtime hours, and would only work 8 hour days.1 Since the capitalists of the port typically overwork their workers to an incredible extent, this refusal of overtime was expected to “slow down or disrupt the handling of around 50% of goods”.2 With such intense effects from such a minor job action, it has to be wondered what took the union bureaucracy at CUPE (SCFP in French) over 10 months to consider undertaking it. The workers have been left without a contract for so long unnecessarily, while the bureaucracy debated and deliberated with the enemies of the workers who won’t give in on very minor demands of stable schedules and to not have a two-tier workplace.3

On October 27, the union announced a 24 hour strike at the port, from Sunday 7am to Monday morning 7am.4 Despite being a “complete work stoppage”, shipments of grain and the supply of Newfoundland and Labrador were maintained according to a July decision by the Canadian Industrial Relations Board. This is because the CIRB has determined that these particular activities of the port are an “essential service” which means the struggle between the workers and capitalists must be put aside in this instance for the “good of the economy”. This is where the corporatist structure of the state under fascism comes from, serving the bourgeoisie by smashing any struggle by workers against their exploiters. The bourgeoisie maintains the right to use this power even in periods of liberal democracy using organs like the CIRB because the proletariat’s power to halt all production in key industries can easily topple imperialist governments that allow it to be exercised.

The bourgeoisie knows that the more class struggle is shoved under the rug and the workers’ resistance is made impossible, the more they can continue exploiting and reaping profits. That is why the Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses, an association of the middle bourgeoisie, said that the union’s actions are “affecting small and medium-sized businesses, especially ahead of the busy holiday shopping season”.5 The appeal to the masses of the threat to their “holiday season” betrays the deep cynicism the bourgeoisie is using to disguise their need for commodities to increase their capital, and the labour that must be exploited to get those commodities where they need them to be.

On October 31, the union targeted a specific employer at the Port of Montreal, Termont, who load and unload cargo at two particular terminals of the port, the Viau and Maisonneuve terminals. The workers at those terminals launched an unlimited strike since Termont in particular gave them unstable schedules and refused to budge on that demand.6 Not only was Termont not deterred by this, but the Maritime Employers’ Association began a lockout against all the workers of the Port of Montreal and Vancouver since they did not accept their “final offer” by November 10.7

This “final offer” was refused by the workers at a rate of 99.7%8, so the capitalists locked them out in order to both take revenge, and attempt to force the federal government to intervene, since they couldn’t bribe the workers with mere crumbs. Since the shutdown of the two biggest ports in Canada affects many sectors of the economy, it was very likely the latter was going to be successful, and the bourgeois media echoed this demand wherever it could. On November 12, after only two days of complete shutdown of the ports, the CIRB announced it was intervening to impose binding arbitration.9 This will most likely not be used by the state to force the employers to adopt the workers’ overwhelming demand for stability in scheduling, but instead to force a contract on workers without that demand being met. We can assume this based on previous uses of this power by the state to force unsatisfactory contracts on workers, such as with the Railway workers over the summer.10

The bourgeoisie has constructed its state for the purposes of managing its system of exploitation. It has developed the CIRB as its organ to maintain “industrial peace” within that system, i.e., the liquidation of class struggle at the most opportune time where the proletariat is likely to win by disrupting profits on a massive scale. Each capitalist struggles against their particular workers, but have united in associations such as the Maritime Employers Association in order to defend their class interests against the labour movement in their particular industry. The workers’ movement started by unionizing by employer and by particular craft, and those unions grew to the scale of the workers of entire industries and united in centres across industries.

Canada is a country where sympathy strikes are illegal, as well as striking while a contract is active, so the dockworkers at the Port of Halifax for example would not have been able to strike at the same time as the others, despite identical interests as the workers of the same industry. This makes the need for industrial unionism -one union in the shipping and receiving industry Canada wide- an urgent task for the workers.11 The amalgamation of all shipping and receiving unions in the country will be resisted by the union bureaucracy, who would prefer to remain in competition with one another and to raid each other’s workers. The rank-and-file must be empowered through democratisation of the union as a key demand in the amalgamation process, and the union bureaucracy’s maximum salary tied to the average wage of the workers they represent.

1. https://www.port-montreal.com/en/the-port-of-montreal/news/news/press-release/overtime-strike

2. https://www.port-montreal.com/en/the-port-of-montreal/news/news/press-release/overtime-strike

3. https://cupe.ca/longshore-workers-port-montreal-deserve-fair-deal

4. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/montreal-dockworkers-hold-one-day-strike-to-put-pressure-on-employer-1.7088642

5. https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/montreal-dockworkers-hold-one-day-strike-to-put-pressure-on-employer-1.7088642

6. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-port-strike-continues-1.7369833

7. https://globalnews.ca/news/10863641/port-of-montreal-lockout/

8. https://globalnews.ca/news/10863641/port-of-montreal-lockout/

9. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/labour-arbitration-ports-montreal-bc-1.7380960

10. https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2024/06/21/calgary-canadian-railway-workers-ready-to-strike-halted-by-union-bureaucracy-and-canadian-state/

11. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/04/01/indusrial-unionism-and-the-class-struggle/