The People's Hammer

The Temporary Foreign Workers’ Programme Must be Abolished – By Daniel H.

, ,


The oppression and super-exploitation of workers in Canada through the Temporary Foreign Workers Programme (TFWP) was described this summer in the UN special rapporteur’s description of the programme as “modern slavery”. The Canadian bourgeoisie have responded to this report by slashing visas and tightening the programme, an act which will harm tens of thousands of workers.

The amount of workers brought to Canada under the TFWP has doubled since 2018 with there being 239 646 workers in 2023.1 This massive spike was the result of the bourgeoisie’s attempt to cure the supposed labour shortage during the Covid-19 pandemic by loosening the programme’s restrictions.2 As stated in a previous article, this labour shortage is a myth peddled by the bourgeoisie in order to boost their own economic recovery by super-exploiting a segment of the proletariat3 – immigrant workers in this case. The same workers that were laid off in 2020 were still around. The Trudeau government’s changes in 2022 included doubling the proportion of low-wage workers that could be hired under the TFWP to 20% generally or 30% in the food service, construction, and healthcare industries.4

Workers brought to Canada under the programme are mainly in low-wage and low-skill positions.5 Agriculture, in particular, is heavily reliant on these immigrant workers with them making up as much as 15% of the workforce of the industry.6

Long before the UN report, immigrant workers have fought hard against their super-exploitation. In the summer of 2022, a Jamaican farm worker in Niagara wrote the Jamaican minister of labour for support against what they described as “systematic slavery”.7 That same summer, a Jamaican worker was killed in an accident with a tobacco harvester in Norfolk County.8 In August 2023, Jamaican workers held a one-day strike against their living conditions that were heavily crowded and flooding from the toilets. One worker had been working the same farm for six years.9

By December 2021, the workers had placed sufficient pressure on Trudeau for him to promise permanent resident status for immigrant workers and students.10 However, this has not been followed through on.

The bourgeoisie are the only ones to benefit from the programme. The immigrant workers may receive wages higher than in their home country, but they are often super-exploited. Canadian workers also lose out as the bourgeoisie use the TFWP to expand the supply of labour-power and thereby bring down wages and labour conditions. While both domestic and immigrant workers lose out in this arrangement, the bourgeoisie through the Conservative Party are attempting to split the proletariat along national lines. Rather than two parts of the same class being exploited by a common enemy, the bourgeoisie present the immigrant workers as the reason for the increased poverty, unemployment, and worse conditions among the workers in Canada. At the same time as the bourgeoisie benefit from the TFWP, they are attempting to rally the workers against it in an effort to prevent a united proletariat.

While the TFWP workers face horrific conditions, the state has proven time after time that it only serves the bourgeoisie. In 2023, there was only $2.1 million in fines handed out and only 12 capitalists were banned from the programme.11 With conditions described by immigrant workers and the UN report being as wide-spread as they are, why have so few capitalists been punished? Because, Canada is a bourgeois dictatorship and it will always further the interests of that class until the workers unite and establish their own dictatorship.

Among the worst conditions the UN report highlighted as evidence of “modern slavery” were:

  • TFWP workers are tied to their employer meaning they can be deported if fired;
  • Workers in industries like caregiving and agriculture are barred from organisation and other workers simply have no knowledge of their rights;
  • There are high rates of debt-bondage either to pay off their trip to Canada or recruiters;
  • Workers are often denied healthcare by their bosses; and
  • There is wide-spread poor housing conditions often linked to the boss.12

The immediate response from the Trudeau administration was Immigration Minister Marc Miller rejecting anything like slavery existed.13 Miller also indirectly acknowledged the super-exploitation of the TFWP workers when he said that changes were needed, but the government wanted to be careful so as to not further spike food prices.14 As mentioned above, agriculture is one of the largest sites of TFWP workers.

Further changes were announced by Employment and Workforce Development Minister Randy Boissonnault who said that they may cut low-wage applications which would apply to those paid below the median hourly wage in a given province or territory.15

The bourgeoisie’s solution to this problem has been criticised by the Migrant Workers Alliance as “restricting low-wage temporary foreign worker work permits to one year will mean workers will have to leave the country and pay vast sums of money to return.”16

In areas of high unemployment, the Canadian state will no longer process LMIA applications, employment duration is restricted now to one year from the previous maximum of two years, and in all industries, except healthcare and construction, TFWPs will be limited to 10% of a capitalists’ workforce.17

What these changes will mean for the current immigrant population in Canada has been calculated by the Migrant Rights Network as “300,000 fewer international students, 175,000 fewer post-graduation work permit (PGWP) holders, 100,000 fewer foreign workers, An additional 200,000 PGWP holders already in Canada will be forced to leave.”18

In all of this, it is important to note that TFWP workers are not slaves like the UN claims. The way the bourgeoisie use this term often flattens a wide-variety of productive relations. The reason for this is mainly ideological to oppose the supposedly mutually beneficial and free exchange of labour-power for a wage to the “evils” of slavery and feudalism. However, even the domestic proletariat in the imperialist countries labour under force and coercion. Coercive measures taken against workers in the form of back-to-work legislation are only the most dramatic form of this. The regular worker is forced by their economic conditions into a system of wage-slavery.

Engels explained the difference between the workers and the slaves in his Principles of Communism:

“The slave is sold once and for all; the proletarian must sell himself daily and hourly.

“The individual slave, property of one master, is assured an existence, however miserable it may be, because of the master’s interest. The individual proletarian, property as it were of the entire bourgeois class which buys his labor only when someone has need of it, has no secure existence. This existence is assured only to the class as a whole.

“The slave is outside competition; the proletarian is in it and experiences all its vagaries.

“The slave counts as a thing, not as a member of society. Thus, the slave can have a better existence than the proletarian, while the proletarian belongs to a higher stage of social development and, himself, stands on a higher social level than the slave.

“The slave frees himself when, of all the relations of private property, he abolishes only the relation of slavery and thereby becomes a proletarian; the proletarian can free himself only by abolishing private property in general.”19

From these definitions, it is clear that the TFWP workers are not slaves. They sell their labour-power for definite periods of time, their labour-power is only purchased when needed, they are in competition with one another and the entire class for employment, and they are regarded (to some degree) as part of society. What the TFWP workers are, is a set of super-exploited workers. These are workers where the ratio of labour-power sold to wages received is higher than for the average worker.

The workers, domestic and foreign, must fight for the abolition of the the TFWP without deportation for those already in Canada. The TFWP only facilitates super-exploitation and must be replaced with citizenship. We must fight for these workers to have the same rights as all other workers. Further, Communists must counter the chauvinism the bourgeoisie aim to instill in our class. Canadian workers are not in competition with the TFWP workers any more than they are with any other member of the class. They are not out to take jobs from Canadian workers. Instead, the bourgeoisie use the TFWP to increase the supply of labour-power in order to drive down wages and conditions for all workers. Unity of all workers in Canada as a class regardless of nationality is the only effective way to combat this. Concretely, this means building a single industrial union centre with a campaign to organise the unorganised. With this achieved, newcomer workers will receive the same wages and conditions as Canadian workers and Canadian workers will not see a drop in their wages and conditions.

Our sights must remain on our goal of communism. When the workers seize power, the only criterion for citizenship will be labour. The workers and their allies will have the same rights regardless of nationality while the bourgeoisie of all nations will be deprived of them.

  1. 1https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/un-report-abuse-temporary-foreign-workers-canada-1.7293495
  2. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/temporary-foreign-workers-1.7240374
  3. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/09/saskatchewan-chamber-of-commerce-push-to-lower-minimum-working-age-by-daniel-h/
  4. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/temporary-foreign-workers-1.7240374
  5. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/temporary-foreign-workers-1.7240374
  6. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/un-special-rapporteur-migrant-worker-program-modern-form-of-slavery-1.6958592
  7. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/jamaican-migrant-workers-open-letter-1.6557678
  8. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/jamaican-migrant-workers-open-letter-1.6557678
  9. https://www.cbc.ca/radio/asithappens/jamaican-farm-workers-sent-home-1.6947997
  10. https://migrantrights.ca/2024immigrationchanges/
  11. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/un-report-abuse-temporary-foreign-workers-canada-1.7293495
  12. https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/g24/120/97/pdf/g2412097.pdf
  13. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/un-report-abuse-temporary-foreign-workers-canada-1.7293495
  14. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/un-report-abuse-temporary-foreign-workers-canada-1.7293495
  15. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/temporary-foreign-worker-boissonnault-low-wage-1.7286123
  16. https://migrantworkersalliance.org/press/advisory-sept18/
  17. https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/services/foreign-workers.html
  18. https://migrantrights.ca/2024immigrationchanges/
  19. https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/11/prin-com.htm

 


Responses to “The Temporary Foreign Workers’ Programme Must be Abolished – By Daniel H.”

  1. Translation: Программа временных иностранных рабочих должна быть упразднена – Daniel H. – The People's Hammer
  2. Программа временных иностранных рабочих должна быть упразднена – Daniel H. – The People's Hammer
  3. Interview with Miguel, an Undocumented Brick Mason – By Toby G. and Ivan D. – The People's Hammer
  4. CBSA raids increase – By Bessy – The People's Hammer