The Progressive Conservative government of Ontario has passed Bill 212, which aims to improve traffic congestion in the Greater Toronto Area by fast-tracking construction of several priority infrastructure projects, by restricting the installation of new bicycle lanes, and by removing the three busiest bicycle lanes in Downtown Toronto.1 The new bill allows for land expropriation and early construction work to begin on Highway 413 before an environmental assessment or indigenous consultation are completed.1 Municipalities are now required to seek permission from the province before installing new bicycle lanes where they would remove a lane of vehicle traffic.1 Bicycle lanes will be removed from Yonge Street, Bloor Street, and University Avenue – the three busiest cycling corridors in Downtown Toronto.1 It is not yet clear whether the province will remove the full length of those bicycle lanes or only a portion of them.
Highway 413 is a controversial project that is supposed to cut through protected Greenbelt lands, destroy farmland, forests, and watersheds, cross 85 rivers and streams, and further endanger at least 10 at-risk species on its route.1 Eight powerful real estate developers with close ties to the Progressive Conservative party own thousands of acres of property along the proposed route of the highway. When completed, the highway will form an outer ring-road around Brampton and Vaughan, massively raising the value of the land nearby, allowing for lucrative developments and furthering urban sprawl. Ford’s government is keeping the estimated costs of Highway 413 secret, however the auditor general has estimated that such a project would likely cost more than $4 billion.2 It is no surprise that Doug Ford wants construction on this highway to begin before its environmental toll is revealed to the public. This is not the first time Doug Ford has passed legislation that allows his personal projects to bypass required environmental assessments. Bill 154, passed in 2023, gave LiveNation developments a blanket exemption from the Environmental Assessment and Heritage Acts to build Therme Spa at Ontario Place.3 So, what is the point of all these legal protections if one can simply override them by passing a new bill?
From now on, new bicycle lanes can only be built if the municipality can prove to the province that the proposed bicycle lane will not impede traffic flow.1 The Association of Municipalities of Ontario has criticized the new legislation as “a significant overreach into municipal jurisdiction.”1 Transport minister Sarkaria claims that the province will review all bicycle lanes built in the past five years using a “data-driven process.”1 It is not clear what this process actually entails and critics from the opposition have argued that it is based on anecdotal evidence and complaints from local business owners.1 The decision to demolish bicycle lanes on Toronto’s three major streets have sparked rallies organized by activist groups such as Fight for Bikes.4 The City of Toronto has estimated the costs of the demolition to be as high as $48 million, a price tag that Doug Ford has dismissed as “hogwash.”5 In a last-minute amendment to the bill, legislators have made it impossible for hurt cyclists and their families to sue Ontario for damages.1 This addition demonstrates that lawmakers are well aware of the dangers of removing bicycle lanes and are willing to sacrifice the safety of cyclists’ in favor of vehicle flow.
Neither building a new highway through Bolton, nor removing bicycle lanes from Downtown Toronto will improve traffic congestion. In fact, it will only make it worse. This is because of induced demand, an economic phenomenon whereby an increase in supply results in an increase in consumption.6 In other words, when road capacity is expanded, conditions for driving become more favorable, causing more people to chose to drive. With more vehicles on the ground, newly expanded roads quickly fill up to capacity again. But where do these new drivers come from? Prior to expansion, they could have relied on other means of transportation, like bicycles, busses, trains, or carpool. They could have chosen to travel outside of peak hours, or chosen to travel shorter distances to spend less time in traffic. Once roads are expanded and motorists are falsely promised a reduction in traffic, these “latent” drivers suddenly decide to take advantage of the new conditions and begin driving when and where they otherwise would not have.
Building highways through previously undeveloped lands encourages urban sprawl that creates suburbs that are ever more distant from places of employment, leading to even more reliance on driving. Removing bicycle lanes from densely populated central urban areas gives people less options for short-distance local trips, forcing them either to drive and take up already limited road space for a very short trip, or to cram onto crowded streetcars to ride just a few stops. The inverse is also true: improving public transportation and providing people with more appealing travel options leads to less people choosing to drive, and less cars on the roads. The true solution to traffic congestion lies not in increasing road capacity, but in getting as many people off the roads as possible. This can be achieved by building safe cycling infrastructure (like protected bicycle lanes), by investing in reliable, safe and comfortable public transportation, by reducing urban sprawl and housing people closer to their places of employment thus reducing the need for long-distance travel, and by promoting work-from-home measures for workers whose jobs can allow for it to not commute to work at all.
These are not new ideas at all, in fact, transportation planners have known about induced demand for decades. Internal government documents show that even Ontario conservatives were made aware that their projects will only make traffic worse.7
A draft of a briefing document prepared for Doug Ford and his cabinet ministers has been leaked to journalists.7 The document highlighted research showing prohibiting bicycle lanes does not solve traffic congestion and often has the opposite effect: “This initiative may not reduce congestion as most research (e.g. New York, Washington, Vancouver) suggests reducing road capacity by introducing bike lanes can encourage biking and discourage car use, alleviating congestion.”7 In addition, the briefing document outlines “high risk level” issues with the proposed legislation: “The province may be seen as encroaching on municipal decision-making authority,” and there is a “risk of jeopardizing progress made through the Toronto and Ottawa New Deals.”7 “This initiative may run counter to other provincial initiatives (such as Transit Oriented Communities, first and last mile, Cargo E-Bikes, E-Scooter, and safe active transportation and support to local businesses)” the document reads.7
In 2017, an expert panel appointed by the Wynne government recommended not to build Highway 413.8 Instead, the report suggested investing in public transit, expanding existing highways, and rerouting trucks to the 407.8 The panel’s report has been conveniently removed from the province’s website, but can still be accessed through a web archive. The report found that the proposed highway would only save commuters an average of 30 seconds per vehicle trip in the Greater Golden Horseshoe region.8 Doug Ford dismisses that finding as unrepresentative, as it considers every trip in a region that stretches from Niagara to Barrie to Peterborough, which includes areas that are nowhere near the proposed site of the highway.9 In contrast, Doug Ford touts that Highway 413 will save 30 minutes per trip for drivers traveling the entire length of the highway between York and Halton regions.9 However, even this claim is misleading. Modeling data obtained from the Ministry of Transportation reveals that only five per cent of daily travelers on Highway 413 are expected to actually travel the full length from York to Halton and that the same trip via the 407 and 400 would take 16 minutes less.10 The projection that Highway 413 would “save you five hours every week” that is so commonly advertised is only true if you are part of a small minority of 1,200 people who are taking the full trip from Vaughan to Milton.10 Despite that, the cost of the highway will be covered by taxpayers from all over the province, who will never benefit from its construction. The “30 minutes a day, five hours per week” promise makes it seem like it applies to every single driver in the GTA, but that is simply not true, according to the government’s own projections.
Interestingly, the same modeling data projects that Highway 413 and all the existing highways will remain congested, except one: Highway 407.10 Highway 407 is a toll road leased to 407 ETR Concession Company Ltd. until 2098.11 The Canada Pension Plan Investment Board owns 50 per cent of the highway, the rest is owned by Cintra Global and SNC-Lavalin.12 A report conducted by Eunomia Research & Consulting found that moving trucks from Highway 401 to the 407 ETR could alleviate congestion immediately.12 Up to 21,000 truckers per day use the 401 to get from Burlington to Pickering to avoid the $1.42-per-kilometer toll on the 407.12 Subsidizing a portion of the 407 ETR trucking toll would cost $4 billion over a 30-year period, which is equal to the auditor general’s projection for Highway 413’s costs (although some media outlets claim Highway 413 could cost as much as $10 billion).12 This research is consistent with the 2017 expert panel report which suggests that diverting trucks to the underused 407 would alleviate the congestion on other highways.8
The resulting mental image is almost comical: everyone is crushed in gridlock, billions of tax payer dollars are being spent on an unnecessary highway, while the 407 remains practically empty because of a private company collecting tolls. This is the most “common sense” solution to Toronto’s traffic that the bourgeoisie can offer us. So, if legislators were made aware that Bill 212 will worsen traffic, why did they pass it? Who exactly benefits from it?
An investigation by Torstar/National Observer has found that eight real estate developers with close ties to the PC government own thousands of acres of property along the proposed route of Highway 413.13, 14 These include John Di Poce, the Cortellucci family, the DeGasperis and the Guglietti clans, the DeMeneghi family, Argo Developments, Fieldgate, and Benny Marotta.14 Who are these people? John Di Poce, who is associated with Di Poce Management Limited and Di Poce Real Estate Holdings Limited, owns ten properties near the proposed highway, covering 663 acres in total.14 One of Di Poce’s contract consultants was Tony Miele, who simultaneously presided over the PC party’s fundraising arm.14 Before that, Miele was president and CEO of the Ontario Realty Corporation, which managed the province’s real estate portfolio.14 The Cortellucci family, which owns Zancor Homes, Fernbrook Homes, and other real estate development companies under the Cortel Group umbrella, has more than 600 acres of property near the proposed highway.14 In 2019, Doug Ford facilitated the renaming of a hospital – the Cortellucci Vaughan Hospital.14 His brother, Rob Ford, hosted a political fundraiser at a Cortellucci-owned banquet hall.14 In 2018, the founder of the Cortel Group, Mario Cortellucci, ran for a seat in the Italian senate, alongside a coalition of right-wing parties that agitated for closing mosques and deporting migrants from Italy.14 Ironically, Mario Cortellucci is a migrant himself. Two families come from the same town in Italy and are related by marriage: the DeGasperis and the Guglietti clans.14 The Gugliettis are known for Melrose Investments Inc., Rosehaven Homes, and Tamarack Lumber, and they own nearly 500 acres of land near the proposed highway.14 The DeGasperis own Metrus, Condor, DG Group, Aspen Ridge Homes, Vineland Estates Winery, Arista Homes, various TACC (The Amazing Construction Company) corporations, and 168 acres of land near the proposed highway.14 Michael DeGasperis has hosted Doug Ford and Stephen Leece in the DeGasperis family’s luxury box at the BB&T Center in Miami, where they watched a hockey game and definitely did not discuss any government business!14 One of the DeGasperis’ TACC corporations employs federal conservative MP and former Ontario PC party president Peter Van Loan as a lobbyist registered with the Ontario government.14 He states his aims as a lobbyist are to influence the “impact of proposed highway on Client’s lands.”14 Van Loan also lobbies for a company owned by Fieldgate – a developer that owns property together with the DeGasperis family in a consortium.14 Two more of the DeGasperis companies, Condor and DG Group, employ former PC MPP and former Ontario transport minister Frank Klees.14 According to Klees’ registration, his lobbying goals are focused on highways, housing, and infrastructure.14 The De Meneghi family owns Lormel Homes and 234 acres near the proposed highway in Vaughan.14 Jim Burnett, assistant to former Ontario PC leader Tim Hudak, has lobbied for Argo Development, a developer that owns property together with the DeGasperis family in a consortium.14 All of these developers have donated a total of $753,000 to the Progressive Conservatives, $350,000 to the Ontario Liberals, and $28,000 to the Ontario NDP.14 These are the “people of Ontario” that stand behind Highway 413 and the suburbia that it will create.
In October of 2023, when bicycle lanes on Bloor Street were extended into Etobicoke, Cody MacRae, founder of an anti-cyclist organization called Balance on Bloor, started a petition to remove bicycle lanes from Bloor Street in Etobicoke, citing “scarce usage”, “reduction in traffic flow”, and “loss of business revenue.”15 Only eight days later, Doug Ford urged Olivia Chow to “get rid of those bike lanes on Bloor in Etobicoke.”15 “I know the businesses are just losing their hair over having those bike lanes in Etobicoke on Bloor Street” he said.15 Balance on Bloor is not your regular activist grassroots organization. Its board of directors includes Cody MacRae, Sam Pappas, Simon Nyilassy, and Ron Sedran.15 Again, who are these people? Nyilassy was a Progressive Conservative candidate back in 2011 and he has donated a total of $18,827 to the PC party since 2014, with the most recent donation in October 2024.15 Sedran has donated a total $5,935 to the PC party.15 Sam Pappas is the owner of Crooked Cue, a famous bar on Bloor Street in Etobicoke – the same bar where Sarkaria has announced new bicycle lane restrictions on October 15.15 Christine Hogarth, Etobicoke-Lakeshore MPP, has held two election night victory parties at Crooked Cue.15 Doug and Rob Ford were also regulars, according to Pappas.15 The former governor general Adrienne Clarkson has held a book-signing event at the Etobicoke bar.15 Olivia Chow and Jack Layton played pool there when they were on city council.15 It seems that there really is a connection between Balance on Bloor and Ford’s government. According to Pappas, “nobody really responded” to their anti-cyclist initiatives at first, until the local MPP Hogarth reached out to them last December.15 “From there, it kind of took steam” said Pappas.15 In September, Hogarth arranged for Pappas to present at a government press conference.15 Just one month later, transport minister Sarkaria made an announcement at Crooked Cue where he presented the new restrictions on bike lanes and called Pappas “a tireless advocate, not only for this community, but for small businesses across this province.”15 It is notable that all of Ford’s arguments against bike lanes are regurgitated talking points from Balance on Bloor. It is likely that the decision to remove bike lanes from major streets in Toronto (including the bemoaned Bloor Street) has been made over hearsay and anecdotal evidence from Ford’s bourgeois buddies, and no scientific (“data-driven”, to quote Sarkaria) analysis of traffic condition has been put forward. Had the provincial government done an actual investigation, they would have found that the local BIA on Bloor Street has experienced an increase in profits since bike lanes were installed. By removing the bike lanes from that street, the province will further alienate these businesses and restrict the flow customers.
The corruption of the Ford government, the misdirection they use to steer the masses away from empirical evidence against their claims, and the ineptitude of their decision making is in stark contrast with Ford’s attempt at a “man of the people” public image. No workers are consulted in government decisions and unfortunately, they never will be through bourgeois elections. The only people with a voice in the current electoral system are people like John Di Poce who are rich, land owning, money obsessed bourgeoisie or Cody Macrae who are reactionary, regressive opportunists who’s interests align with the bourgeoisie. As workers, it is easy to identify the folks like Di Poce and Ford who derive their income through exploitation and constantly aim to secure their private interests, but identifying the snakes in the grass like MacRae can be more difficult. Opportunists can be anyone, regardless of wealth or class position. The moment private bribery enters their life, the moment they are duped into siding with the tiny, oppressive upper strata, they conduct themselves in a fashion which is to the whole working class’ detriment. It is important that these opportunist reactionary voices are silenced just as the reactionary voice of the bourgeoisie itself must be silenced. In order to forge a path towards socialism, the truth of its scientific merit must ring out.
References
1: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/bill-212-bike-lanes-highway-413-passes-1.7392821
4: https://www.fightforbikes.org/about
5: https://globalnews.ca/news/10877114/ontario-doug-ford-bike-lane-removal-cost-hogwash/
6: https://www.wired.com/2014/06/wuwt-traffic-induced-demand/
9: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/doug-ford-highway-413-ontario-election-905-1.6207970
11: https://407etr.com/en/investors
12: https://www.nationalobserver.com/2023/11/07/news/traffic-study-shows-ontario-highway-413-not-needed