In a recent study group on Gonzalo Thought with members of “CPC” and “(N)CPC” mass organisations, the question of “workers power” was raised. “Workers power” has become an ever-present phrase among the labour movement and among communists, but it is rarely used to refer to proletarian dictatorship. Generally, the phrase is used to refer to a well-organised proletariat and this is how it is used among the “(N)CPC” and “CPC”. Union drives and strikes are the most common examples of building and wielding “workers power”. This view of workers’ power represents a liquidation of power from something political, a social relation between classes, to something purely economic and organisational.
Power, like all things political, has an economic root, but it cannot be reduced to it. For the workers to hold power, they cannot only be well-organised. If tomorrow the workers were fully unionised and had established significant workers control across all industry in Canada, there would still be no workers power if there was not at least the beginning of the proletarian dictatorship. No class holds even a modicum of power if it cannot impose its interests on the other classes of society. It must not only be able to impose its interests momentarily, it must also be able to defend them. For example, when the masses occupy a workplace or some other area, they may be in temporary control of the building itself and refuse entry to the police and other bourgeois forces. We can see this in many of the recent student encampments for Palestine.1 In these events, there was no “student power” as the bourgeoisie were fully in control of the situation and able to re-assert control of the occupied area whenever they pleased as was seen in the assault of students in Edmonton and Calgary.2
Another example of this can be seen in the “Canadian Labour Revolt” of 1919. The workers were the most organised they had ever been up to this point with general strikes across the country. In Winnipeg, the workers had assumed control over the city. However, the rightists in leadership did not push beyond this control towards a seizure of power. They did not aim to destroy the bourgeois state, they were comfortable to merely look after it for the bourgeoisie for the duration of the strike, discouraging demonstrations, and keeping bourgeois law-and-order. When the police joined the strike, the central strike committee even asked them to remain on duty.3 What were the results of this strike wave? Workers were slaughtered by the RCMP, the state resumed control over Winnipeg, and the workers went back to their lives of exploitation. Like in the student encampments, in Winnipeg, power never changed hands.
In The Mass Line of the Communist Party of Peru, the relation of the masses to power under imperialism is discussed as follows:
“‘The masses clamor to organize the rebellion, and therefore the Party, its leaders, cadre and militants today have a peremptory obligation, a destiny: To organize the disorganized power of the masses, and this can only be done with arms in hand. We must arm the masses bit by bit, part by part, until the general arming of the people. When this goal is reached, there shall be no exploitation on Earth.’
“Here he expresses his absolute conviction in the masses, in their historical and political necessity to rebel, to arm themselves, their demand that they be led and organized. He summons the Communist Parties to fulfil the demand that comes from Marx and Engels who taught us that there are two powers on the Earth: The armed force of the reactionaries and the disorganized masses. Chairman Gonzalo propounds that if we organize this power, what is only potential shall become deeds, and what is a possibility shall become a reality. Everything is a house of cards if it is not based on the masses. Concretely, the problem is to go from the state of disorganized masses to masses that are militarily organized [My emphasis].”4
The PCP distinguish between an actual power: the organised armed forces of imperialism and a potential power: the disorganised masses. They also point out that for the potential power among the masses to be actualised it must be militarily organised. This is key. The workers will never hold any kind of power if they are only organised in peaceful, defensive forms such as unions or merely holding assemblies as is the main form of work of the “(N)CPC”. Workers power will only begin to be established with the proletarian dictatorship which at its core is armed force – a red army. To begin this process, we must begin organising the workers into the party, army, and united front.
Once the workers of Canada have reconstituted their communist party, they will turn their focus to the seizure of political power through a socialist people’s war. This will not be confined to an insurrection as the “(N)CPC” teaches, nor through a people’s parliament as the “CPC” teaches.5 It will be a long process where bourgeois power is overturned and proletarian power fills this vacuum. Concretely, this means that from the time the revolution is launched until it is won, a proletarian dictatorship will co-exist with a bourgeois dictatorship. In this sense alone it is possible to say that workers power can exist under imperialism. However, this power is militarily organised and militarily striking at the bourgeois dictatorship unlike the “workers power” that the revisionist talk so much about.
In the context of Peru, people’s power (a joint dictatorship of the workers, peasants, petite-bourgeoisie, and national bourgeoisie) was built gradually starting only with distribution committees. As the feudal-bureaucratic dictatorship was beaten back and the people’s forces grew stronger they were able to establish people’s committees and higher forms of organisation.
It is important for communists to understand power and not accept these liquidated versions of it. The consequence of accepting power as nothing more than a well-organised class is to jump fully into economism. If communists claim that they are building power in unionising workplaces, they are misleading the workers from what should principally be a political struggle to reconstitute the communist party to seize political power and instead just organise economically. This is not to say that organisation and economic struggle are unimportant, but that they are must be in service to our political aim of communism.
1: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/report-and-summation-of-the-ubc-vancouver-encampment-by-kale/ and https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/28/report-from-the-university-of-toronto-student-encampment-mels-g-cynthia-m/
2: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/18/two-articles-on-repression-against-calgary-students-by-calgary-united-workers/
3: Canadian Bolsheviks, Ian Angus
4: https://gplpcp.wordpress.com/mass-line/
5: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/08/the-liquidationist-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada/
Responses to ““Workers’ Power” and Economism – By Daniel H.”
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/01/07/workers-power-and-economism-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/wp-admin/post.php?post=553 […]
LikeLike