The governments of Newfoundland and Quebec have reached a new deal over the power generated at Churchill Falls. The revised deal comes after decades of Newfoundland and the Innu pushing for changes as the original deal is rigged in favour of Quebecois imperialism.1 This included a failed challenge at the Supreme Court of Canada which upheld the original deal.2
Among the many examples of the one-sidedness of the deal is that while the plant is owned by Newfoundland, its revenue goes mainly to Quebec.3 This is because the deal allocates up to 85% of the power generated for Quebec to purchase and only 15% to Newfoundland or export markets.4 Another issue is the cost of energy purchased at the plant compared to the price it was sold at by Hydro Quebec. In 2023, Hydro Quebec purchased energy at a rate of ¢0.2/kWh and sold energy at a rate of ¢10.3/kWh – a 510% markup.5 From the massive Churchill Falls plant, Newfoundland only receives $100 million per year.6 The lopsided deal gets worse every year as the contract has fixed the cost of energy and did not tie it to market prices or inflation.7 This makes the deal especially bad in times of high inflation, but keep in mind that the state considers 2% inflation healthy8 meaning that even when times are “good” the deal gets worse.
When the new deal is formalised in 2026,9 it will terminate the original 1969 deal retroactively set to January 1 2025 as well as develop other projects.10 The estimates associated with the new deal are projected to bring Newfoundland and Quebec at least $200 billion over the next 50 years.11 The deal increases the cost of energy from ¢0.2/kWh to ¢5.9/kWh.12 Quebec will continue to sell at a markup -though reduced at ¢11/kWh.13 This cost will include a price escalator based on market value which is a major gain in comparison to the previous deal.14 Newfoundland will earn from this new arrangement $1 billion per year through 2041, $2 billion per year through 2056 and $4 billion per year afterwards.15
Newfoundland is among the most impoverished parts of Canada. Its last provincial budget was a meager $10.4 billion.16 As such, even $1 billion of extra revenue per year will contribute a great deal to the province. Despite the fanfare associated with the new deal, the workers of Newfoundland must recognise that this bigger slice of the pie will be enjoyed by the bourgeoisie of Newfoundland, not the workers. Newfoundland’s harsh labour code cannot be written off to a lack of funds to ensure that the workers have what they need to survive. The bourgeoisie have purposefully kept Newfoundland from properly industrialising and diversifying its industry beyond primary resources in order to keep it as a region of relatively high exploitation. This has benefited the bourgeoisie in other parts of Canada as well, especially in the oilfields that are so heavily reliant on workers from Newfoundland to the point that drillers can joke that Fort Mac might as well be part of Newfoundland. The workers of Newfoundland will need to organise and seize any gains they want to see from the bourgeoisie.
The new developments set out by the project will raise Labrador’s capacity by 3900 MW.17 This is through a Gull Island generating station with a capacity of 2250 MW and a new powerhouse at the Falls that will provide a new 1100 MW.18 Both of these projects will be funded entirely by Quebec.19 Newfoundland will be leading the development of another development set to increase the capacity of the Falls by 550 MW.20 Newfoundland and Quebec will bare the responsibility for building $2-3 billion21 of transmission lines in their respective jurisdictions.22 After construction, the total production is expected to be 9190 MW with 7200 MW purchased by Quebec and 1990 MW purchased by Newfoundland.23
Overall, these developments are set to cost $25 billion and will create the second largest hydroelectricity project in North America after Quebec’s Baie-James.24 These developments will also require 9500 jobs including those indirectly created.25 The Gull Island project is set to be commissioned in 2035.26
The new deal is important to the national question in the region. This involves three groups: the Innu, the Quebecois, and the Newfoundlanders.27 For just as long as the government of Newfoundland has argued they have received a bad deal, the Innu have been demanding to just be included in a deal. There was not even the pretense of negotiation with the Innu either in 1969 or in the modern day as they were completely uninvolved in the developments. The nation had previously claimed they would block any development at Gull Island if their demand was not addressed.28 The Innu have now signed on to the MOU between Newfoundland and Quebec, however, seemingly the only benefit they will receive is preferential hiring for construction.29 The deal places the priority on hiring Innu, followed by residents of Labrador generally, then those from Newfoundland.30
The Innu are only being brought into negotiations after the provinces have come to an agreement.31 The only other “concession” other than preferential hiring and an after-the-fact seat at the table is a commitment from Quebec and Newfoundland to respect existing agreements with the Innu and consult with them going forward.32 This was enough for the Innu bureaucrat bourgeoisie, however, and Innu Nation Grand Chief Simon Pokue signed the MOU.33
For Newfoundland, the new deal provides a larger share than before, however, the deal is still in favour of Quebecois imperialism. Since Newfoundland was annexed in 1949 with the full support of the social-fascist Joey Smallwood, Newfoundland has remained unindustrialised. The province depends entirely on investment from the rest of the country as it is unable to develop itself. This new deal is entirely inline with this. According to the allocation of the project under the new deal, Newfoundland will only be receiving a portion a few points higher than currently. Quebec will be receiving a relative decrease, but an absolute increase in energy purchased. This means it will continue to make vast sums off of the project through Hydro-Quebec’s export market that includes the USA and New Brunswick.34 Quebec will also own 40% of the new Gull Island development35 and maintains 34% of the Churchill Falls Labrador Corp.36
The Quebecois bourgeoisie remain the ultimate beneficiary of the Churchill Falls development even if on its surface it now appears more fair. What is occurring is a massive export of capital from Quebec to Labrador that will rely on the Newfoundlader and Innu labour and will boost Quebec’s strength in the industry. It should be remembered that the Quebecois imperialists have never acknowledged Labrador as part of Newfoundland. Deals like the Churchill Falls one allow the Quebecois imperialists to reclaim Labrador economically if not yet politically.
1 https://www.hydroreview.com/hydro-industry-news/new-development/canadian-provinces-reach-multi-billion-dollar-deal-over-power-from-churchill-falls-hydroelectric-plant/
6 https://www.thealbertan.com/atlantic-news/a-look-at-details-of-the-quebec-newfoundland-and-labrador-churchill-falls-energy-deal-9949406
9 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-quebec-new-churchill-falls-agreement-1.7408663
11 https://www.hydroreview.com/hydro-industry-news/new-development/canadian-provinces-reach-multi-billion-dollar-deal-over-power-from-churchill-falls-hydroelectric-plant/
13 https://news.hydroquebec.com/en/press-releases/2143/an-important-step-towards-securing-quebecs-energy-future/?fromSearch=1
15 https://www.hydroreview.com/hydro-industry-news/new-development/canadian-provinces-reach-multi-billion-dollar-deal-over-power-from-churchill-falls-hydroelectric-plant/
16 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-quebec-new-churchill-falls-agreement-1.7408663
21 https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/investing/commodities/2024/12/12/quebec-newfoundland-reach-a-27-billion-energy-supply-deal/
23 https://www.hydroreview.com/hydro-industry-news/new-development/canadian-provinces-reach-multi-billion-dollar-deal-over-power-from-churchill-falls-hydroelectric-plant/
24 https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/investing/commodities/2024/12/12/quebec-newfoundland-reach-a-27-billion-energy-supply-deal/
25 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-quebec-new-churchill-falls-agreement-1.7408663
26 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-quebec-new-churchill-falls-agreement-1.7408663
27 The Innu and the Quebecois can definitively be termed nations. The continued existence of a Newfoundland nation or its assimilation into the Canadian nation is a question that still needs to be investigated further.
29 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-quebec-new-churchill-falls-agreement-1.7408663
30 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-quebec-new-churchill-falls-agreement-1.7408663