A reader enquired us about the (N)CPC. We believe this criticism of the (N)CPC’s Programme by the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) aligns with our line. We are reposting it here to share it with our readers.
– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer
The “(New) Communist Party of Canada” [(N)CPC], a merger of old revisionist groupings in Canada released their programme to the public. While we reject much of what this programme contains, it should be studied and criticised by all workers interested in the reconstitution of the Communist Party of Canada.
The “(N)CPC” programme must be understood in relation to the PCR-RCP programme. This is because the majority of the organisations that have united to form the “(N)CPC” once upheld this programme as the path to socialism in Canada. This programme was flawed and incomplete but is far more advanced than the “(N)CPC” programme as it claimed allegiance to Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, the universality of people’s war, and the need for cultural revolution. With respect to all three of these elements, the “(N)CPC” programme represents a liquidation.
The present document is not an extensive criticism of the “(N)CPC” programme. Instead, it is confined only to its most egregious deviations from Marxism. Specific refutations of the concept of the “complete communist party” put forward by the Continuator-faction of the PCR-RCP that are taken up in this programme as well as the presentation of the national question are too large to be dealt with here.
On Ideology
The programme presents no ideological line. From its founding organisations, we can assume that the “(N)CPC” is at least inspired by Maoism, however, there is no declaration of its ideological basis in this programme. Nowhere can the term Maoism be found in their programme. There is also no ideological founding document that has been publicly released that we can gauge the “(N)CPC’s” ideological basis from. A lower basis of unity on Marxism-Leninism is not mentioned either. We must ask then, is the “(N)CPC” based on Marxism-Leninism-Maoism? If not, what is its ideological basis of unity? Ideological demarcation is among the most important steps in the reconstitution of the party and the “(N)CPC” have absolved themselves of this responsibility.
Even the most liquidated parties in Canada today such as the “Communist Party of Canada” understand the importance of ideological demarcation and openly state their ideological basis on what they claim to be Marxism-Leninism:
“The more effectively the Communist Party works for left and democratic unity and strengthens its independent political activity, putting forward its Marxist-Leninist program and policies, the more the left forces, both within and outside the NDP, can be brought into united struggle for genuine progressive policies.”1
The Middle Bourgeoisie
The “(N)CPC” takes a firm stand against the big bourgeoisie as the principal enemy of the socialist revolution in Canada. This is positive and we fully unite on this position with them. However, they take a vacillating attitude towards the middle bourgeoisie. At times the middle bourgeoisie are also to be combated, other times they are omitted altogether, and in a few occasions they are described as a potential ally of the proletariat. The “(N)CPC” must take a clear stand, is the middle bourgeoisie a friend of the proletariat or its enemy?
This question arises first in their description of their ideal new state’s political structure. In it, they state:
“Such a confederacy would need to establish new processes of treaty-making and nation-to-nation negotiations which would no longer be carried out under the constant threat of the ruling class’s repressive apparatus. Indeed, we believe that by excluding the monopoly bourgeoisie from this process entirely, we solve much of the existing problem. People from the working class and from oppressed nations and national minorities need to create their own constitution, establish a new multinational State which preserves the sovereignty of its component parts, redraw Canada’s internal borders according to really-existing national divisions and renegotiate or reaffirm existing treaties. Without the monopoly bourgeoisie and its representatives and lieutenants, we can find common ground and build a confederacy where we thrive and respect each others’ needs and prerogatives [emphasis original].”2
We fully agree with the “(N)CPC” on the need to prevent the participation of the big bourgeoisie in the new socialist state. However, we believe that this must be extended to the middle bourgeoisie as well. While not the principal enemy, they are a definite enemy of the revolution. This is because Canada is an imperialist country where the tasks of the democratic revolution are complete. The task today is to wage socialist revolution. In oppressed nations it is often possible to unite with the middle bourgeoisie because in these nations the development of capitalism is a progressive development that opens the door to socialist revolution. This is not the case in Canada. The “(N)CPC” makes no effort to justify reducing the enemies of the revolution to the big bourgeoisie alone.
Elsewhere the “(N)CPC” provides a definition of the middle bourgeoisie:
“Below them [the big bourgeoisie] is a much vaster section of the bourgeois class: those who own means of production and exploit labour power (but not to the extent of monopolies), within which we can count: minor industrialists, small shareholders with no ensuing decision power and the whole array of small and medium-sized business owners. They are a significant class in Canada, representing about 5–10% of the total population and serving as the main base for the open ideological and political defence of capitalist, free market policies. Also part of the bourgeoisie are the “lieutenants of capital” who have amassed their wealth on indirect exploitation by serving as intermediates, senior managers, major technocrats, ideologues and politicians working in defence of bourgeois class interests for the bourgeoisie. They are those who lead the state-owned monopolies and government ministries, those who act as the upper executive structure of large corporations, as well as those hired to protect capital, such as non rank-and-file policemen and soldiers. Though the middle bourgeoisie and the lieutenants of the bourgeoisie hold less power than the financial oligarchs, they often appear as the front-line or most immediate enemies of the proletariat on the field of economic and political struggle. As a whole, the bourgeoisie can be described as the class accumulating wealth within the present capitalist-imperialist system: they are the ones profiting from, directly and indirectly, the exploitation and suffering of the world’s majority.”3
Here, the “(N)CPC” presents a better understanding of the middle bourgeoisie and correctly identifies them as often being the most immediate enemy of many workers. This statement of fact that the middle bourgeoisie is an enemy, however, is not carried forward into strategy as is seen above. The proletarian dictatorship must practice democracy among the workers and its allied classes while practicing dictatorship against its enemies including the middle bourgeoisie. How does the “(N)CPC” justify both the recognition of the middle bourgeoisie as an enemy of the socialist revolution while only calling to restrict the big bourgeoisie from participation in the new state?
The “(N)CPC” present their different economic approaches to the middle bourgeoisie and the big bourgeoisie:
“From its first day in power, the revolutionary government will proceed to the expropriation without compensation of the monopolist bourgeoisie, followed by the socialization of all major industries in natural resources, construction, manufacture, transportation, health care, education and housing. It will repudiate the national debt, abolish all imperialist financial institutions such as stock markets, banks, asset management firms and insurance companies and replace them with a single, centralized institution liberated from speculation and usury. The labour power currently allocated to finance and other parasitic sectors will be reallocated to boost productive endeavours. Small enterprise will be allowed to exist for some time after the proletariat takes power and will be gradually phased out by a combination of voluntary collectivization, replacement by state-run enterprises fully subsumed within a centrally planned economy and, in the case of individuals who actively oppose socialist development, appropriation of enterprises by the workers’ state. Restructuring the economy toward self-sufficiency will be another major task for the revolutionary government, as it cannot assume continued access to the globalized imperialist economy, especially in an era of ecological crisis and inter-imperialist conflict [our emphasis].”4
What the “(N)CPC” present here is almost identical to what is called for by the “CPC”. Quoting from our criticism of the “CPC” programme on the same question:
“The economic programme of the ‘Communist Party of Canada’ is contained in the following two passages:
“‘The functioning of the economy will require that small and medium non-monopoly businesses continue to operate for some time as part of the overall economic plan, under a variety of forms of property and of production, under conditions established by the socialist government. In addition to state enterprises and private enterprise, there will be producers’ and consumers’ cooperatives and, where conditions warrant, joint state-and-private enterprises.’
“And,
“‘The Canadian people themselves will decide, in the light of circumstances, on any compensation for the expropriated property of big capitalists.’
“What is the class character of small and medium non-monopoly business owners? The non-monopoly qualifier means that they are not a part of the big bourgeoisie or the imperialists. The ‘Communist Party of Canada’ offers no definitions beyond this. Generously, the middle non-monopoly business owners may be the middle bourgeoisie, and the small non-monopoly business owners may be the lower middle bourgeoisie and sections of the petite-bourgeoisie. If this is the case, then we fully agree on the necessity to protect the property rights of the petite-bourgeoisie. However, we view it as necessary to immediately begin organising them in a communist way through the formation of cooperatives. These cooperatives alongside state-owned industries are the two bases of socialist economics. Gradually, cooperatives must cease to exist and their property must become the property of the people as a whole. The middle bourgeoisie, however are in no way allies. The aim of the ‘Communist Party of Canada’ to secure the property rights of the middle bourgeoisie further highlights the alliance they aim to forge with the bourgeoisie. They even leave some wiggle-room on whether the imperialists will be compensated for what is rightfully the proletariat’s.”5
We are in full agreement regarding the measures to be taken towards the big bourgeoisie with both the “CPC” and the “(N)CPC”. We disagree on the approach taken towards the middle bourgeoisie. The “(N)CPC” programme like the “CPC’s” confuses the middle and petite-bourgeoisie by combining them into one. The “(N)CPC” treats both classes as non-antagonistic to the proletariat despite earlier claiming that the middle bourgeoisie are enemies. We agree fully that the petite-bourgeoisie, particularly the small farmers, should not be expropriated. We call for the reorganisation of their property into collective ownership passing through a variety of stages.
Under socialism, the economic root of capitalist restoration will be found among the petite-bourgeoisie. By gradually developing collective ownership among this class, this economic basis for class society can be done away with. While the petite-bourgeoisie are a middle element that can be won to the revolution or to reaction, the middle bourgeoisie is firmly in the camp of reaction. By providing a legal basis for their existence in the new state and protection of their property rights, the bourgeoisie are given a head start in their struggle to restore capitalism under the “(N)CPC” programme.
Later, the “(N)CPC” again shifts position declaring as an immediate task:
“the privation of the political rights of the overthrown ruling class and of the remaining elements of the middle-bourgeoisie and the reservation of the right to vote to those who work, those who have worked before and are unable to do so through no fault of their own, and to those who contribute to the building of socialism;”6
Here, the “(N)CPC” puts forward a revolutionary demand in contradiction to what is stated throughout much the rest of the programme by now calling to oppress the middle bourgeoisie.
A final shift in approach is found toward the end where they list as another immediate task:
“the immediate expropriation with no compensation of the monopolist bourgeoisie, the socialization of all major industries and the progressive, voluntary socialization of small industry; the expropriation of all surplus housing stock controlled by the monopolist bourgeoisie for speculative and other purposes and its conversion to inexpensive housing to be distributed to the proletariat;”7
The “(N)CPC’s” previous position on the middle bourgeoisie was uncompromising and revolutionary. This one again lumps the middle and the petite-bourgeoisie together treating both as allies of the socialist revolution. The example given by the “(N)CPC” of housing is a curious example of this. While the majority of real estate is held by the big bourgeoisie, the middle bourgeoisie own a significant portion. Under socialism, are the middle bourgeoisie to be allowed to keep their real estate and continue to collect rent from the workers?
Throughout its discussion of the middle bourgeoisie, the only through-line is that economically, the middle bourgeoisie are allies. Politically, the “(N)CPC” wavers between restriction to simply having no position on the question. Compare this to the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)’s firm position on this question in its programme:
“Confiscation of all industrial, transportation, communication, agricultural, retail, real estate, resource extraction, banking, and other capital held by the big and middle bourgeoisie, directly or through the state, without compensation;
“Establishment of the first phase of communist economics based on state ownership and collective ownership. State property will be formed through the nationalisation under workers’ control of all seized capital. Collective ownership will be developed through the formation of cooperatives among the petite-bourgeoisie, mainly the small farmers;”8
This vacillation towards the middle bourgeoisie as a whole is made most explicit in the “(N)CPC’s” attitude towards the Indigenous national bourgeoisie. In discussing the united front, the “(N)CPC” state:
“The united front is the temporary alliance of all classes necessary to accumulate the critical mass to be stronger than the enemy and render possible its overthrow. In the broadest term, it is comprised of all those whose interests are in sufficient contradiction with capitalism-imperialism so that they have something to win in a socialist revolution. The core and leading part of the united front is the revolutionary proletariat and its new institutions of political power, bringing with itself: sections of the lower petty-bourgeoisie and small farmers often living in conditions very similar to the proletariat; sections of the petty-bourgeoisie; and perhaps of the small national bourgeoisie of the Indigenous nations united on the basis of defeating colonialism and achieving national liberation; and finally, anyone who realizes the urgent needs of our epoch and is ready to sacrifice his or her own class interests to join the revolutionary camp. The component parts of the united front take organizational forms and eventually assume the character of a formal political alliance. In this way, it is the united front that progressively forms the embryo of the new state [our emphasis].”9
The middle bourgeoisie as a whole is not included in the united front the “(N)CPC” aims to build, but the door is explicitly held open to the Indigenous middle bourgeoisie. This raises many questions. Why the isolation of the Indigenous national bourgeoisie? If their opposition to colonialism is the deciding factor as it is presented by the “(N)CPC”, then why not the Acadian middle bourgeoisie? More importantly, is the revolution socialist or not? There are splits between the Indigenous national bourgeoisie with the big bourgeoisie that we can take advantage of, however this is distinct from an alliance with them. National liberation in these nations is no longer tied up with the democratic revolution as it was in the past or still is in oppressed nations overseas. It requires socialist revolution in the oppressed nations as in the rest of the country.
The development of Canadian and Quebecois imperialism and bureaucrat capitalism among the oppressed nations of Canada has led to a situation where the majority of Indigenous people today live off of the reserves. When we add to this number those who live on reserve, but where the reserve is urban such as the Tsawwassen, the Tsuut’ina, and the Kanesatake reserves, then the number of Indigenous masses being principally exploited as workers in Canadian and Quebecois companies rises significantly. These workers are not fighting colonialism principally, they are fighting capitalist exploitation. To propose an alliance with the national bourgeoisie of these nations is detached from the reality of the situation and only serves to hold back the participation of the Indigenous workers in the fight for socialism. The “(N)CPC’s” support for the formation of “revolutionary representative associations of Indigenous peoples” would mean the prevention of the Squamish workers in Vancouver from participating in workers’ councils and socialism only to participate in the bourgeois councils of their nations. This approach to the oppressed nations in the midst of a socialist revolution was criticised by Stalin as follows:
“As to the other regions, their labouring elements have proved to be rather inert in the matter of the national movement. But the greater their inertia the greater was the activity displayed by the bourgeoisie. Nearly everywhere, in all the regions, bourgeois autonomous groups were formed which set up ‘National Councils,’ split their regions into separate national curiae, with national regiments, national budgets, etc., and thus turned their countries into arenas of national conflict and chauvinism. These autonomous groups (I am referring to the Tatar, Bashkir, Kirghiz, Georgian, Armenian and other “National Councils”)—all these ‘National Councils’ were out for one thing only, namely, to secure autonomy so that the central government should not interfere in their affairs and not control them. ‘Give us autonomy and we shall recognize the central Soviet power, but we cannot recognize the local Soviets and they must not interfere in our affairs; we shall organize ourselves as we wish and can, and shall treat our national workers and peasants as we please.’ That is the sort of autonomy—essentially bourgeois in character—aimed at by the bourgeoisie who demand full power over ‘their’ working people within the framework of autonomy.”10
Can there be any doubt that the relation between a federal socialist state and “revolutionary representative associations of Indigenous peoples” would not follow the same path as the “national councils” described by Stalin?
The “(N)CPC’s” Military Line
The military line of the “(N)CPC” marks a liquidation from that of the PCR-RCP. Despite the serious flaws of the PCR-RCP’s military line, it recognised people’s war as the military line of the proletariat applicable universally. It also recognised the necessity of armed struggle prior to its initiation, though it would break with this as time went on. The “(N)CPC” programme does not contain a single reference to people’s war. The “(N)CPC” has adopted the military line favoured by opportunists – dogmatists and revisionists alike – insurrection after long period of accumulating forces through peaceful means.
The “(N)CPC” describes its strategy as follows:
“(1) Accumulating forces in the revolutionary movement. We conceive of the period preceding armed confrontation not as a wholly distinct period, but as a preparatory period for the next, a period of accumulation of forces. This implies that from the onset the Party remains clandestine, conceiving itself as being at war with the enemy, even long before the first bullet is fired. To be able to face open war with a force so mighty as the AAIA, tens if not hundreds of thousands of people need to be recruited to the Party and its people’s army, constituting the core of its revolutionary firepower.
“(2) Building the organs of political power. The transformation of the political order cannot happen overnight, even if reaction faces military defeat. History teaches us that the proletariat needs to be thoroughly prepared to wield power, as socialism is only a new phase in the class struggle. Before political power is conquered, the institutions that will form the new power need to be built at least in their preliminary forms, and the people need to have gained political experience in wielding those institutions. These are mainly comprised of workers’ (and, more broadly, proletarians’) assemblies and councils (what were known, in the October Revolution, as ‘Soviets’) based on geographical areas or workplaces, as well as all the political expressions of the united front — revolutionary representative associations of Indigenous peoples, for example.
“(3) Acting on the objective conditions to precipitate them towards revolutionary crisis. We will not stand idle and wait for these conditions to appear but act so as to create them ourselves. The main component of this is to lead the people to revolutionary conclusions through political work. In intervening in the broad people’s movement, communists do not mainly seek reforms — though they welcome them — but rather the sharpening of social contradictions between the people and the enemy. It is through their own experience in struggle, combined with the impulse provoked by the vanguard party, that the people will embrace socialism as the only solution to the sum of their grievances. As the saying goes, it is only when the people move that they feel the full weight of their chains [emphasis original].”11
The “(N)CPC’s” military line is metaphysical in that it depends on quantitative developments in place of a qualitative one. The revolution is only possible when a set threshold of cadres and soldiers are formed not on the qualitative developments to the objective and subjective factors. In this, they have proved themselves worthy students of the late chief revisionist, Sison. Sison regularly described the transition between the strategic defensive and the strategic equilibrium in the exact same terms:
“The perspective and plan of the revolutionary movement is to advance from the stage of strategic defensive to that of the strategic stalemate by increasing the number of guerrilla fronts to 200, CPP membership to 250,000, the number of Red fighters with automatic rifles to 25,000, the membership of the mass organizations by the millions and the strength of the organs of political power at the village, municipal and provincial levels.”12
On a very practical matter, the “(N)CPC” sees it as necessary to form a party and army of up to hundreds of thousands prior to the revolution. We must ask, how? 1) How will the state allow for the peaceful formation of an armed force of hundreds of thousands intent on its overthrow right under their nose? The bourgeoisie do not even allow union workers to go on strike in the public sector without a back-to-work order anymore. To imagine the formation of an army bigger than any the Canadian state has mobilised since the conscripted army of the second world war without a crack-down by the state is completely unimaginable. 2) The “(N)CPC” maintains that the party will be clandestine all while this massive military apparatus is being constructed. How, will these troops be trained in their hundreds of thousands all while remaining under the radar of the state? Surely the state will get wise to even a small portion of this army conducting training.
We fully agree that right now there is no option for people’s war. However, we hold that armed struggle must be carried out as a complement while people’s war is prepared. This will both win the masses to communism, educate them in revolutionary violence, and practically train our troops and cadres. Armed struggle is an invaluable weapon that can be used today in strikes. Sabotage of machinery, workers’ defence groups to prevent strike-breaking, armed agitation can achieve the above goals while also winning the real demands of the workers on strike.
The “(N)CPC” say the reason we need to form a party and army composed of up to hundreds of thousands is in order to meet “a force so mighty as the AAIA”. However, this is just what Mao, Zhu De, Gonzalo, among other have developed people’s war to resolve. It is a military theory that allows a weak and small force to develop into a strong and large force. However, the “(N)CPC” asks the proletariat to throw away this theory that has successfully guided every successful proletarian revolution. We must ask the “(N)CPC” where has this strategy worked in practice?
Regarding the formation of workers’ councils, we are in full agreement. Communists must lead the workers to conquer leadership of the existing labour councils, break their sectarianism, and reorganise them as general bodies of the working-class in every area. Where they do not exist, we need to establish them. It is beyond idiocy and pure sloganeering for communists to discuss workers’ control of production without forming the bodies – the workplace committees and the workers’ councils to carry out these tasks. Where we disagree with the “(N)CPC” is on the necessity of revolutionary violence in the construction of these councils. We believe the united front must be built around the party and army as it is the nucleus of the new state. The mere existence of bodies of the united front is meaningless. The united front must be able to both conquer new ground and defend against attacks by the enemy. If the united front is built in the absence of revolutionary violence it can do neither of these things. With that being the case, what is its purpose? Workers councils and workplace committees have existed throughout Canadian history. Labour councils exist today in every major city in Canada. However, these bodies have been conquered by the union bureaucracy and labour aristocracy and subordinated to the NDP. The “(N)CPC’s” dual workers’ councils will inevitably follow the same path if they are not backed up by revolutionary violence and a tactical offensive against the bourgeoisie. To the rank-and-file of the “(N)CPC”, how does this strategy differ in anyway from the strategy of “dual-power” and “base-building” that captured the communist movement in North America throughout the 2010s? And, what have the workers gained from this line?
As stated regarding the vascilitating stand of the “(N)CPC” towards the middle bourgeoisie, the organs of power in their programme advocates class-collaboration in the call for “revolutionary representative associations of Indigenous peoples”. This only serves to split the proletariat along national lines. Indigenous workers should be organised into the same party, same army, same unions, and same councils as the Canadian, Quebecois, Acadian, and immigrant workers. The policy of the “(N)CPC” forces a policy of self-determination on the Indigenous masses as opposed to a right to self-determination. For our part, we support the formation of workers councils and farmers councils regardless of nationality on the basis of class alone.
How does the “(N)CPC” understand revolutionary situations? We understand them as Lenin described them:
“To the Marxist it is indisputable that a revolution is impossible without a revolutionary situation; furthermore, it is not every revolutionary situation that leads to revolution. What, generally speaking, are the symptoms of a revolutionary situation? We shall certainly not be mistaken if we indicate the following three major symptoms: (1) when it is impossible for the ruling classes to maintain their rule without any change; when there is a crisis, in one form or another, among the ‘upper classes’, a crisis in the policy of the ruling class, leading to a fissure through which the discontent and indignation of the oppressed classes burst forth. For a revolution to take place, it is usually insufficient for ‘the lower classes not to want’ to live in the old way; it is also necessary that ‘the upper classes should be unable’ to live in the old way; (2) when the suffering and want of the oppressed classes have grown more acute than usual; (3) when, as a consequence of the above causes, there is a considerable increase in the activity of the masses, who uncomplainingly allow themselves to be robbed in ‘peace time’, but, in turbulent times, are drawn both by all the circumstances of the crisis and by the ‘upper classes’ themselves into independent historical action.
“Without these objective changes, which are independent of the will, not only of individual groups and parties but even of individual classes, a revolution, as a general rule, is impossible. The totality of all these objective changes is called a revolutionary situation. Such a situation existed in 1905 in Russia, and in all revolutionary periods in the West; it also existed in Germany in the sixties of the last century, and in Russia in 1859-61 and 1879-80, although no revolution occurred in these instances. Why was that? It was because it is not every revolutionary situation that gives rise to a revolution; revolution arises only out of a situation in which the above-mentioned objective changes are accompanied by a subjective change, namely, the ability of the revolutionary class to take revolutionary mass action strong enough to break (or dislocate) the old government, which never, not even in a period of crisis, ‘falls’, if it is not toppled over.”13
A revolutionary situation exists independent of any individual’s will. They develop as a result of the natural contradictions in imperialism. We can forge the subjective conditions so as to be ready to act on a revolutionary situation when it appears. The development of the subjective conditions for revolution will also deepen the development towards a revolutionary situation, but will not cause it itself. Even if we assemble 100,000 cadres and soldiers and have formed a system of workers’ councils, if these objective conditions do not exist than the revolution will not succeed. The early attempts at revolution in Germany should be enough proof of this.
The “(N)CPC” state that they do not seek reforms but welcome them. How do you plan to accumulate your hundreds of thousands in this case? Reforms can only cause relative relief for the masses, but this does not make them a bad thing. We must strive for reforms that 1) strengthen the position of the proletariat 2) weaken the bourgeoisie, and 3) lighten the oppression of the masses. In rejecting this work as well as armed struggle, does the “(N)CPC” see its role to be only one of education and general activism prior to the initiation of people’s war?
The International Situation
The “(N)CPC’s” analysis of the international situation is a watered down of Mao’s three worlds. In the theory developed by Mao, the world is divided principally into imperialist powers and oppressed nations. Among the imperialist powers, there are those that are relatively weak such as Canada and those that are relatively strong such as the US. Countries like the US form superpowers that are politically, militarily, and economically stronger than the other imperialist powers. They dominate even the economies of the imperialist powers. The superpowers form the 1st world, the middle and lower imperialist powers form the second world, and the 3rd world is composed of the oppressed nations of the world.
The three worlds of the “(N)CPC” are composed of imperialist blocs, dealt with as homogeneous groups without competing interests, a second world of lesser imperialist powers, and a 3rd world of oppressed nations.
Dealing with the “(N)CPC’s” claimed superpowers first, they are Russia, China, the “Anglo-American Imperialist Alliance”, and the European Union.
Regarding Russia and China, the “(N)CPC” claim the following:
“All in all, there are four imperialist great powers in the world today. They are divided into two groups: the new, up-and-coming great powers and the old, well-established ones. The two new great powers are China and Russia, formerly socialist countries which were under working class rule for many years only to have the bourgeoisie take back power and return to the capitalist path. Russia re-entered the capitalist path with only a limited area of influence: among former Eastern Bloc countries. Russia is a great military power, but its economic power relies mainly on a small number of energy sector monopolies and on a modest periphery of Eastern European and Central Asian countries where its monopoly finance capital is being challenged by European and American capital’s ever-encroaching influence. Russia aims to consolidate and expand this area of influence in the face of Western challenges to it and is therefore willing to commit to military action. China, a formerly colonized country, re-entered the capitalist path with virtually no foreign ‘holdings.’ China is both an economic and a military powerhouse, but it is still in the process of shedding its former role as ‘factory of the world,’ asserting its new role as a full-fledged imperialist power and moving to build up its influence in many areas, notably Southeast Asia and Africa. It is therefore still wary of open confrontation, though it is visibly preparing for it. Russia and China are neither the evil ‘totalitarian’ great powers of the world as liberals and reactionaries would have us believe, nor are they some kind of ‘alternative’ to Western imperialists. Rather, they are merely up-and-comers challenging the established masters of the world for supremacy and economic dominance.”14
The “(N)CPC” claim that Russia is a great military power. What is the basis for this claim? Its military is impressive on paper, but the illusion of its strength has been shattered in the invasion of Ukraine. Since 2014 and especially since the most recent push into Ukraine, Russia has been unable to secure much beyond its immediate border region. Its troops have been slaughtered in Ukraine and its army is today composed of those with little experience or skill. Russia has the largest stockpile of nuclear weapons, but without a monopoly on these, they have become significantly less effective as a threat. As the “(N)CPC” has stated, the vast majority of Russia’s former colonies have been conquered by the USA and we agree. There is no material basis to make the claim that Russia is a superpower.
China, unlike Russia is a power on the rise. While we maintain it is not a superpower today, it is making strides in this direction. However, China too lacks the characteristics of a superpower. From The International Line of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction):
“Among the second world imperialist powers it is China alone that has the real potential to compete for hegemony with the United States. China has grown as a power most visibly in the third world and some imperialist powers. The most clear example of the latter is in its relations with Russia. We maintain that China is not yet a superpower for a number of reasons. First among these, China has no ability to coerce other nations outside of its immediate region. In Africa, Latin America, and Europe, China’s influence is mainly economic and does not extend to political-military or ideological dominance. The sole location where China has this sort of dominance is in South-East Asia. China has been unable to capture the leading imperialist institutions such as the WTO and the IMF. China has been experiencing a contraction in its one belt one road initiative and general lending. While China is building-up its military, it has not been able to deploy them globally in the same way that the USSR and the USA have been able to.”15
We ask the “(N)CPC” to present the data to the masses they have used to reach their conclusion regarding Russia and China. Conclusions such as these with serious implications to the international strategy of the world proletarian revolution must be based on concrete conditions. What is presented in the programme lacks any kind of synthesis of the political-economic standing of these powers.
The remaining two superpowers are even more detached from reality. The EU is described as follows:
“The old, well-established imperialist blocs are the European Union (EU) and the Anglo-American Imperialist Alliance (AAIA) (often referred to together as the Western imperialist powers, but we should note the competing interests among them). The European Union is a supra-national union of former European colonial powers headed by Germany and France. It is dominated by powerful monopolies and relies on an internal periphery in southern and eastern Europe and on neo-colonial relationships with its former colonies and other peripheral countries. Militarily, however, it is divided, used as staging grounds by US troops (mainly in Germany and Italy) and is relatively speaking less powerful overall than the three other great powers. It is therefore, like China, wary of open conflict.”16
This is all the “(N)CPC” gives for its explanation of the EU as a superpower. The EU is made up of a number of imperialist powers, with France and Germany competing for hegemony. Like the “(N)CPC” state, the EU is militarily divided. There are those that wish to push for further integration politically, economically, and militarily so long as it allows for the extension of that country’s dominion. The EU as a whole continues to be dominated by US imperialism. It is lazy for the “(N)CPC” to note the competing interests between the “western imperialist powers”, but only carry this through by breaking the “western imperialist powers” into two smaller camps. However, no competing interests are recognised within these blocs. The delineation between the “AAIA” and the EU is not explained in any way, their existence as distinct blocs are just declared.
The “(N)CPC” explain the “AAIA” as follows:
“The AAIA is the main imperialist alliance in the world today — a loose alliance of powerful countries coming out of the former British Empire and consolidated around the United States of America (USA) after its emergence as a hegemonic power following the end of WW2. The leading power in this alliance is the USA, followed by the United Kingdom and Canada. Its next few layers include other regionally powerful countries that have been in close alliance with the AAIA over many decades, such as Australia, New Zealand, Israel and Saudi Arabia (the last two being largely propped up by the AAIA as outposts of its imperialist policy in the Middle East). Japan, one of Asia’s two major imperialist powers, is also closely associated with this alliance and serves as a forward military base of US imperialism.
“The AAIA is the political expression of the main monopolies in the world today: it holds sway over key transnational institutions (the UN, NATO, the World Bank, the IMF, the Commonwealth, etc.), and it maintains its own central institutions, such as the ‘Five Eyes’ global mass surveillance system. As the main imperialist bloc, it stands to lose the most from the rise of new great powers and imperialist competitors, hence its active and open preparation for military confrontations with Russia and China, while trying to consolidate its alliance with the EU.”17
Again, like Russia, China, and the EU, the “(N)CPC” provide no rationale for why the “AAIA” constitutes a superpower itself rather than US imperialism. The level of integration among the “AAIA” is even less than that of the EU. Compare the level of integration between Saudi Arabia and Canada to that of the Netherlands and Belgium for example.
Following the superpowers, the “(N)CPC” describes the lesser imperialist powers:
“Under these four main great powers, there are lesser imperialist or lesser imperialist regional powers: certain non-EU European countries, certain “developing” powers such as Brazil, India or Turkey, etc. Such countries are to various degrees beholden to the main imperialist powers while also pursuing their own interests and attempting to become major players in their own right. In doing so, they usually exert influence over and dominate small areas of influence, usually made up of neighbouring countries (one example being India’s influence over Nepal). Regional powers and major satellites of the main imperialist powers fall into this category.”18
These powers are defined by vagueries. They are dominated by imperialism, but have some level of autonomy. What economically distinguishes these from other weak imperialist powers or the oppressed nations broadly is not explained. Any relatively large semi-colony can be lumped into this category of lesser imperialism with a weak imperialist power like Canada. This is especially the case in the model presented where Canadian imperialism has no separate existence, instead being part of the “AAIA”.
The countries given as examples have not reached the stage of imperialism – they have not even developed an independent national capitalism. They are entirely oppressed by imperialism. That they also engage in national oppression is secondary to this. What feature of imperialism does the “(N)CPC” believe India has developed?
In opposition to the view that these countries are lesser imperialist, Siraj Sikder described India’s relationship to Bangladesh as expansionist. Its actions were at the behest of the powers oppressing India. The existence of countries like India, Turkey, and Brazil who are weak relative to imperialism, but strong relative to other oppressed nations is due to the uneven development of capitalism. This is the same law that has allowed for the stratification among the imperialist powers between countries like the US and countries like Canada. These expansionist powers are manipulated by the imperialists to act for them in a region.
Following from the “(N)CPC’s” conclusion that India, Brazil, and Turkey are lesser imperialist powers, what should the attitude of the communists in Canada be to the CPI(Maoist), the TKP/ML, and the Communist Party of Brazil (Red Fraction)? All of these organisations hold to a programme of new democratic revolution and in both Turkey and India this is being put into practice. From the perspective of the “(N)CPC”, these parties would be counter-revolutionary as they are rallying the masses to the democratic revolution rather than the socialist revolution.
Below all of this, the “(N)CPC” describes the oppressed nations as follows:
“Below all the above, we find the oppressed countries and nations of the world. When the world is being re-divided, the great powers are doing the dividing and these countries are being divided because their resources and their people’s labour power is absolutely necessary for the imperialist system to survive. They form the absolute majority of all countries and their subordination is key to the imperialists’ continued power. Their local ruling classes either collaborate with one great power or another, or else they try to carve out some limited measure of “independence” by slipping into the cracks between the powers’ areas of influence Some of these countries are fully capitalist, while many remain locked into semi-feudal, semi-colonial relations of production. Many oppressed countries, regional powers or imperialist satellites and all four major imperialist powers have within their borders oppressed nations or nationalities deprived of their own state power, a phenomenon which adds yet another layer of complexity to the imperialist world-system. Among most or all of these categories of subordinate countries and nations, low standards of living, state or paramilitary violence in defence of exploitation and out-bound migratory waves are the norm [emphasis original].”19
| Country (Imperialist and Lesser Imperialist) | Most Recent Population Count |
| Russia | 146,150,78920 |
| China | 1,409,670,000 21 |
| Germany | 84,432,67022 |
| France | 68,428,00023 |
| United Kingdom | 67,596,28124 |
| Canada | 40,769,89025 |
| Australia | 27,287,75726 |
| New Zealand | 5,338,90027 |
| Saudi Arabia | 32,175,22428 |
| Israel | 9,892,00029 |
| Japan | 123,930,00030 |
| Turkey | 85,372,37731 |
| India | 1,400,744,00032 |
| Brazil | 203,080,75633 |
In the above-table we list the most recent population counts of every country the “(N)CPC” claim are either imperialist or lesser imperialist. When added together this gives a total population of 3,704,868,644. The global population is currently: 8,110,474,000 people.34 This means that the imperialist and lesser imperialist countries amount to over 45% of the global population. It must be noted here that this ratio is based only on the countries explicitly described as imperialist or lesser imperialist by the “(N)CPC” in their programme. Imperialist countries like Italy and Austria are not included for this reason. If imperialist powers such as these and others were included, the oppressed nations would fall to a minority of the total population. The shifting of the weight of the masses to the imperialist countries as the “(N)CPC” describes would mean the imperialism-oppressed nations contradiction would cease to be principal globally for the proletariat-bourgeoisie contradiction. Despite their own description of the world, they simultaneously maintain that the oppressed nations are far in the majority. Which one is it? Either their analysis is faulty, or the oppressed nations are becoming a minority in the world.
Aside, from the issue of the weight of the masses in the world, we have no issue regarding the description of the oppressed nations.
The Proletarian Dictatorship and Communism
The socialist state that the communist party will lead the masses in building is a proletarian dictatorship. This is a state where the workers are the ruling-class and the bourgeoisie are oppressed. Under this dictatorship, the workers will have control of production through their elected workers’ councils. The workers will participate in management and the managers, technicians, bureaucrats, and others will participate in production.
The “(N)CPC’s” view of the dictatorship of the proletariat is as a technocratic state run by technicians and scientists. In their programme there is only one highly descriptive section regarding the administration of the economy:
“Under socialism, democracy will be installed in workplaces. Manual workers will be invited to speak and think, and intellectual workers will be invited to get on solid ground. Simultaneously, anarchy in production will be abolished. Individual factories, mines, hospitals, etc. will not be left to themselves but will have to work within the frameworks of central plans decided upon democratically by the higher organs of working-class power following the recommendations of scientists and experts. Democratization of the economy will be the order of the day.”35
The following of scientific and expert recommendations is a practice followed by many states and does not differentiate a proletarian from a bourgeois state. Trudeau has made a point of appointing such individuals to the senate to give it technocratic legitimacy. We of course agree that a socialist economy should be run scientifically, but above all it needs to be put into the hands of the workers as a means of achieving communism. The workers will not be invited to speak and think. They will conquer power and direct production country-wide. They will not follow the recommendations of scientists and exerts, who on their own may recommend a capitalist or a communist road. Rather science and expertise will be utilised to construct communism.
Similarly, the fundamental tasks in this period according to the “(N)CPC” are defined as healthcare, education, and culture. Again, these are all important, but are they fundamental? In our view, the fundamental role of the socialist state is to construct communism. Healthcare, education, and culture are all superstructural elements of this, but to construct them in a communist manner the key is to develop a communist economy. The first stages of this are specified in the draft programme of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction):
- “Destruction of all imperialism in Canada, domestic and foreign;
- “Confiscation of all industrial, transportation, communication, agricultural, retail, real estate, resource extraction, banking, and other capital held by the big and middle bourgeoisie, directly or through the state, without compensation;
- “Establishment of the first phase of communist economics based on state ownership and collective ownership. State property will be formed through the nationalisation under workers’ control of all seized capital. Collective ownership will be developed through the formation of cooperatives among the petite-bourgeoisie, mainly the small farmers;
- “Allocation of the products of society in the first place towards the reproduction and expansion of the means of production, in the second place to administration, collective needs, and social insurance, and in the third place to those who produce on the basis of the labour they contributed.”36
By ignoring the importance of the economic transition to communism for improvements to education, healthcare, and culture the “(N)CPC” misdirects the workers from the fight for communism.
The “(N)CPC’s” programme also contains no understanding of communism as a mode of production. When it is mentioned in the programme, it is only in passing. As communists we must be focused principally on the concrete programme for the seizure of power. However, the massive defeats suffered by the world proletarian revolution have shown that the seizure of power for the proletariat is a relatively simple task to the continuing of the revolution under the proletarian dictatorship. A communist party must have an understanding of the general tasks of the socialist revolution as the concrete programme is the application of these general tasks to the immediate stage.
The understanding of the functioning of a socialist state presented by the “(N)CPC” confirms this fact. They offer nothing regarding the fundamental contradictions of class society or how to tackle them. Their programme does not even address the notion of cultural revolution. As a result, their presentation of socialism is confined to superficial demands as discussed above.
Regarding the goal of the socialist revolution, the (N)CPC offer only the following:
“In the economic sphere, our objective can best be summed up in the phrase: abolition of private property.”37
and
“With this in mind, the (N)CPC maintains that its fundamental aim is to forward class struggle until communism and that the central task to accomplish this in our context is proletarian revolution and the establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat in Canada — referred to as socialism. Therefore, the (N)CPC does not remain dogmatically attached to the strategy and tactics outlined above, but submits them to this overarching goal and to the test of practice. As the sole criterion of truth, it is practice that will be the ultimate judge of the correctness of our ideas. The following years should either see the revolutionary movement advancing, or it should see our conceptions and practice change.”38
finally,
“The (New) Communist Party of Canada openly and explicitly fights for the complete overthrow of the imperialist world order and the establishment of communism on a global scale. We are the party of the Communards of Paris, of the Bolsheviks of Russia, of the Chinese Revolution and of the heroic anti-imperialist resistance in Vietnam. We are the party of the Winnipeg General Strike, of the revolutionary days of the old Communist Party of Canada, of the Front de Libération du Québec and of the 1970s Marxist-Leninists. The (N)CPC is the party of the peoples of the world still holding high the banner of communism, of those who have never given up and never will.”39
With no understanding of what communism is beyond these vague declarations, it is not surprising that the programme of the “(N)CPC” contains nothing regarding the broad tasks necessary to achieve this. The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) has put forward the following understanding of these general tasks:
- “Abolition of all class distinctions, all relations of production at the base of these class distinctions, all social relations based on these relations of production, and all ideas based on these social relations;
- “Resolution of the contradictions between city and countryside, mental and manual labour, and industry and agriculture;
- “Abolition of the state;
- “Distribution of the products of society on the basis of need;
- “Abolition of patriarchy through the full introduction of women into productive labour, collectivisation of reproductive labour, and the equal participation of women in the administration of society;
- “Abolition of private property, transformation of state and collective property into the property of all of society, administration of the economy by and in the interests of the whole of society;
- “Abolition of national distinctions and antagonisms.”40
Conclusion
The “(N)CPC” is a new face for an ever more liquidating trend in the Canadian Communist Movement. They represent a retreat from even the positions of the PCR-RCP and “CPC”. We encourage the rank-and-file of the “(N)CPC” to read this criticism and raise the questions we have presented to your leadership.
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/08/13/programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
- https://communist-party.ca/chapter-5-the-working-class-and-peoples-struggle/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/08/the-liquidationist-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/08/13/programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1918/05/10.htm
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://maoistroad.blogspot.com/2014/01/the-communist-party-of-philippines-on.html
- https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1915/csi/ii.htm#v21pp74h-212
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- International Line of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://rosstat.gov.ru/storage/mediabank/OkPopul_Comp2024_Site.xlsx
- https://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202401/t20240117_1946605.html
- https://www.destatis.de/EN/Themes/Society-Environment/Population/Current-Population/Tables/liste-current-population.html#651244
- https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/serie/001641607
- https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/datasets/populationestimatesforukenglandandwalesscotlandandnorthernireland
- https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1710000901
- https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/population/population-clock-pyramid
- https://www.stats.govt.nz/indicators/population-of-nz/
- https://portal.saudicensus.sa/portal/
- https://www.cbs.gov.il/en/Statistics/Pages/Generators/Time-Series-DataBank.aspx?level_1=2
- https://www.stat.go.jp/english/data/jinsui/tsuki/index.htm
- https://data.tuik.gov.tr/Bulten/Index?p=The-Results-of-Address-Based-Population-Registration-System-2023-49684&dil=2
- https://main.mohfw.gov.in/sites/default/files/Population%20Projection%20Report%202011-2036%20-%20upload_compressed_0.pdf
- https://censo2022.ibge.gov.br/panorama/
- https://population.un.org/wpp/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/08/13/programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
- https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/
Responses to “Questions Regarding the (N)CPC’s Programme – By Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)”
[…] advocate some level of unity with the middle bourgeoisie in a fight against the big bourgeoisie: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ and […]
LikeLike
[…] 27 A long criticism of this same position shared by the “(New) Communist Party of Canada” can be found in the following document: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ […]
LikeLike
[…] “Workers’ Power” and Economism – By Daniel H. Submission: Lessons of the Quebec Amazon Campaign – by Quebec Supporters of the People’s Hammer The (N)CPC and the Drug Trade – by Bessy Repost: Questions Regarding the (N)CPC’s Programme […]
LikeLike
[…] niveau d’unité avec la moyenne bourgeoisie dans la lutte contre la grande bourgeoisie : https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 5 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 4 A criticism of the “(N)CPC” can be found here: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ […]
LikeLike
[…] Longer analysis on this point in both organisations programmes can be found here: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ and […]
LikeLike
[…] 1 The CPC(RF) has produced the following general criticism of this organisation: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ ↩︎ […]
LikeLike