The People's Hammer

Albertan Agriculture and the Threat to Small Farmers – By Gordon C.

, ,


2024 marked a difficult year for Albertan agriculture. Popular coverage has labeled the causes of these difficulties as sporadic and out of our control, but there were undeniable methods of prevention that are being ignored. The drought is being chalked up to an unexpectedly dry winter affecting snowpack and reservoir storage1 and the massive cattle shortage that drove many herders to sell their land to the agricultural monopolies2 is being pinned on the drought, kneecapped supply chains, and inflated feed and fuel prices.3 These issues are certainly out of the hands of the small farmers and general agricultural labourers, as the proletariat working in monopolized farms have no control over the means of production and do not yet have the programmes and organising bodies necessary for combating these issues. We must ask then, what of the owning bourgeoisie who dictatorially controls all of this production? The bourgeois monopolists who squeeze the life out of the smaller farmers and force them out of their livelihood when their reckless decision making affects the entire province? Should the large owners not be held responsible for the incompetence of their management?

Across all of Canada, the bourgeoisie lags behind in agriculture because it simply is not as profitable as industrial development. With farming being difficult, volatile, and less capable of consistently producing a massive profit because of its seasonal dependencies, the bourgeoisie cannot invest in agriculture beyond what is necessary to keep the system afloat, and this creates the kind of crises experienced in 2024. This in turn leads to even the agricultural owning members of the bourgeoisie focusing on exporting agriculture to maximize profits rather than meeting domestic demands, as reflected by RJ Sigurdson’s priorities as Alberta’s Agricultural and Irrigation Minister.

At the beginning of the year, Sigurdson addressed the concerns of US Tariffs under the Trump administration along with the 2024 droughts, the state of international trade for the province, and the provincial plans moving forward in an interview with CBC.4 Sigurdson demonstrated at length the provincial government’s ignorance to the needs of farmers, inability to efficiently create plans or begin construction on the dams which the province needs, and piqued interest in prioritizing foreign trade as the Trump administration could disrupt their usual US affairs. Sigurdson has positioned himself in direct opposition of the agricultural proletariat and rural petit-bourgeoisie of Alberta. His statement on trade solidified this position:

“We understand that being too heavily dependent on one country as your major export [market] can be problematic when you come into times like this when tariffs do pop up… And that’s why we’ve started over in Asia to be able to have conversations on how we can continue to diversify our export markets. And more recently, I was down in Mexico to have the same conversations as well. [We’ve] met with the Port of Vancouver and are looking at how we continue to work with them hand in hand to increase how much we can export. So my focus as minister of agriculture is looking at every opportunity that we can to be able to continue to diversify and strengthen shipping routes to give more options to our farmers and ranchers on where they sell their commodities.”4

Expanding into Asian markets should come as no surprise with the Canadian bourgeoisie’s recent developments in Indonesia as part of their Indo-Pacific strategy to gain the upper hand against Chinese imperialism.5 Sigurdson is entirely open about his prioritization of maximizing the profits of the agricultural bourgeoisie over meeting the needs of the struggling agricultural workers and this is compounded by his statement on inter-provincial trade which was nothing more than flaunting paper pushing plans to adjust the inter-provincial trade barriers and provincially differing food safety regulations.4 All these issues of inefficient bureaucracy and decentralization stem from the individualism of the bourgeoisie. The solutions to these problems, such as a worker-farmer alliance and mass collectivization of agriculture, would probably make do-nothings like Sigurdson faint.

The Albertan masses must understand that it is for a good reason that Sigurdson is a do-nothing. Crises like the cattle shortage are in fact to the benefit of the large monopolists, as it means the smaller owners will be forced to sell at a loss in order to avoid bankruptcy, tightening the monopolists’ stranglehold on the industry. These times of strife in farming reveal all too clearly who is to blame for the declines in agriculture Canada is experiencing. The bourgeoisie is more than happy when agricultural ministers remain totally inactive and concern themselves only with how to expand into foreign markets because it allows the large agricultural owners to maintain their growth and build up their profits. These days, small farmers are left with no option but to sell. Some may be able to hold out longer than others, but inevitably the monopolists will capitalize on enough crises that no petit-bourgeois farmer is capable of maintaining their property. What can be done?

The only way the small farmers of Canada can stand up against the bourgeois monopolists is through the establishment of a systematized mutual aid between farmers. A system in which small farmers collectivize their production process in order to reap larger harvests and insure themselves against poor farming conditions. This in turn can lead to the development of cooperative production, or farming co-ops. Without a collective banding, the organisation of farmers will remain divided and easy for the bourgeoisie to conquer. This collectivization process not only creates a shield to protect farmers against the bourgeoisie, it allows for increased levels of production thanks to the merging of different strata of small farmers and agricultural proletariat. Collectivizing land, implements, livestock, and machinery allows farmers to pool their resources together at a level that, through political action and the creation of a worker-farmer alliance, will eventually surpass the bourgeois agricultural monopolies.

It cannot be understated how necessary political action is in addition to economic action. These two must operate hand in hand. For many Canadian farmers, creating an alliance with the urban proletariat and aligning with communism may seem daunting and threatening. Genuine concerns about livelihood and being forced to surrender property are entirely within reason. In their commentaries on the organisation’s programme, the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) states the following:

“The socialist revolution will preserve and strengthen the worker-farmer alliance. It will not develop antagonism between these two classes through the forced seizure of the farmers’ property. Instead, the communist party will strengthen this alliance and resolve the contradiction between the worker and the farmer by introducing socialist relations among the farmers. The development of mutual aid between farmers, which exists today in an unsystematised way, will be quickly transformed into cooperative production. Throughout this process, the state will provide the farmers with the necessary implements, seed, livestock, among other necessities needed to work the land. Under the leadership of the proletariat, the gradual elimination of property relations in the countryside will lead to the resolution between state and collective property as both become the property of society as a whole.”6

The bourgeois propaganda which paints communists as thieves is a farce. The party would have no use for seizing land if the most capable of working said land were to resist. Unlike the bourgeoisie, communists do not have an interest in manufacturing crises and outsourcing labour because these are only beneficial to private owners chasing individual profit. The communist party will be comprised of the proletariat who’s best interest is in eliminating the market economy and its exploitative mode of production, goals which entirely align with the small farmers of Canada.

While Alberta is perhaps the province most ripe for these changes today in Canada, farmer co-ops and a worker-farmer alliance must emerge across every province. The bureaucratic walls the Canadian government builds between each province to prevent the masses from national economic and political action must be destroyed. The crises the bourgeoisie is entirely complacent with will continue to force small farmers to abandon their way of life while bourgeois pawns like RJ Sigurdson continue to push for a focus on the international market rather than domestic development. It is only the rural masses who are capable of developing national agricultural to a state of abundance for all of Canada.

1: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-drought-alison-davie-trevor-hadwen-agriculture-1.7306354

2: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/prairies-drought-farmers-alberta-1.7134770

3: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/canada-s-cattle-herd-is-the-smallest-in-decades-here-s-what-that-means-for-alberta-ranchers-1.7311013

4: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/agriculture-alberta-tariffs-water-rj-sigurdson-1.7413268

5: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/01/07/canadian-imperialism-sinks-teeth-into-indonesia-by-daniel-h/

6: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/12/03/commentaries-on-the-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/


Response to “Albertan Agriculture and the Threat to Small Farmers – By Gordon C.”

  1. Manitoba Wildfires: Climate Change and Class Relations – By Gordon C. – The People's Hammer