The People's Hammer

LiUNA, Whose side are you on? – by Ivan D.

,


Unions should be a central organisation for workers defense and education, however the Labourers International Union of North America (LiUNA) is content to be more and more an appendage of the bosses. Instead of LiUNA struggling against the bosses for workers rights, it is content to adopt a business model and act on behalf of the boss. Instead of expanding its reach through union drives and workers struggle, it appeals to the bosses, and is increasingly stifling its democracy. This company unionism cannot stand

The LiUNA, particularly in its work in British Columbia and the Yukon under Local 1611, is increasingly orienting itself to be a company union within the construction industry. The principle issue is the leadership of the union is deciding the union must sustain itself by essentially treating workers unions as a business that works collaboratively with companies, rather than a school for class struggle, for workers to beat back the boss. This is seen through its mixed structure. In the construction industry, it is strictly a craft union. In low or no skill industries like warehousing, LiUNA is more of an industrial union. However, in both sectors, LiUNA increasingly a company union. Where LiUNA is attempting to “organise” workplaces in construction, it does so through appealing to the bosses to voluntarily unionise their companies to gain access to the union’s hiring hall of specialised construction workers. A union organiser for LiUNA stated this has even been the main strategy and method for growth in the construction industry. Furthermore, the organiser said that the approach taken towards relationships with the boss is generally a partnership, and that antagonism with the bosses is only with their industrially organised unions constituting a minority of their growth. This is part of a growing trend amongst construction unions in Canada in which companies will form hiring halls with highly qualified workers as a means to entice a company to voluntarily unionise to gain access to skilled workers. This trend also needs to be exposed for what it is, open collaboration between the union leadership with the boss.

As workers we need to understand that our relationship with the boss will always be an antagonistic one. Workers want to have their exploitation eliminated. The bosses want to increase the exploitation of their workers to the greatest extent possible to increase their profits by lowering the cost spent on workers through mainly wages, and pushing their workers to do the most work in the least time possible. There is no room for compromise here. So how could a union that is supposed to represent the side of the workers be accurately representing them, when they are so quick to cozy up to the boss and making hiring for them easy? If construction workers want antagonism with the boss, if they recognise their exploitation and want to fight it, how would LiUNA ever justify this? They would be the first to shut it down. This is laid bare with a company of Traffic Controllers they represent in the Universal group. Several years ago these traffic controllers wanted a strike for higher wages and safer working conditions. LiUNA turned down this demand, forcing workers to try an organise a wild-cat strike which was crushed by Universal before it could begin. On top of this, the union has an outrageous dues structure with a monthly due of $35, all of which goes to the international headquarters in the US. On top of this they have working dues of 30 cents/hour for the local. Why is so much of their money going to the international, taking Canadian workers’ money to handle union business that does not affect them.1 2

Other despicable acts of LiUNA are demonstrated with their overconcern of union jurisdiction, further business-like treatment of organisation, and their lack of democratic practices. LiUNA has had multiple workers coming to them recently asking for help to form a union in their workplace, only for them to turn workers down due to other unions having jurisdiction over the industry or company. LiUNA recently turned down organising a warehouse in Metro Vancouver for the pure reason that the Teamsters had organised another warehouse belonging to the same company. This is clear evidence that LiUNA is more concerned to not stir the boat between unions over organising workers who are ready to struggle. This is a clear call for the need to have broad industrial unionism where unions do not worry about wars between each other over who gets to represent what worker, but a single union for all workers in an industry to fight the bosses together.

LiUNA is also quick to apply its business model to expanding beyond just appeals to the bosses for voluntary unionisation. Their vision of growth is mainly sports advertising and sports charity for teams like the Vancouver Canucks.3 LiUNA also employs tactics like raffles for tablets to do headcounts at work places, and has little initiative to expand to union drives. What this demonstrates is a very business type approach to expansion, where they think that by taking out ads and trying buy workers over with electronics, they can generate engagement. What truly generates engagement is union employees diving into the struggle of the workers they represent, ready to hear their concerns and fight on their behalf. But instead, LiUNA is content to treat its union like another company trying to advertise its product, rather than demonstrate itself through fighting for workers. This is also a clear manifestation of its willingness to collaborate with the bosses rather than be a true workers union ready to struggle.

Lastly, LiUNA has been increasingly engaging in anti-democratic practices towards its workers. The 1611 Local of LiUNA was created by merging all locals across BC and the Yukon.4 This has thus centered most of 1611’s work in the major populations centers in BC like Vancouver. The result is workers in places like Whitehorse that are represented by LiUNA are largely pushed out of participating in union activities because of the vast geographic distance they would have to undertake to be a part of them.

An even more opportunistic display is a report from a construction worker represented by LiUNA in New Westminster who gave an account of LiUNA’s treatment of a shop steward for their union. The worker reported that the shop steward was generally good at their job of informing workers of what was happening in the union. This shop steward had also become known amongst these construction workers as someone who was more than willing to voice disagreements with the union when they became sluggish on addressing complaints, or would happily name and criticise union bureaucrats who were failing to do their jobs. This resulted in LiUNA trying to push them out by having organisers show up to the worksite, ask for complaints about the shop steward by name, and engage in spreading rumours about the shop steward to other workers. This effort by LiUNA bureaucrats worked to silence the shop steward as it resulted in them leaving the workplace and union altogether. The worker summarised this by correctly characterizing LiUNA as a union that “will get you good benefits, but strike you down if you have anything bad to say about them.” This behaviour of rumour spreading is not that of a union of the workers, but of bureaucrats looking to crush dissent through any means necessary. A truly opportunist behaviour that has no place in workers struggle.

What all of the above demonstrates about LiUNA is that it is a union willing to toss away workers concerns and interests in favour of expanding its influence, including open collaboration with the bosses, and a willingness to cast aside any dissent from the workers they supposedly represent. All of this is a cry for the desperate need for the working-class in Canada to reclaim unions as organisations that fight for and truly represent workers interests; to transform these bureaucratic unions into organs of class struggle led by workers and not union bureaucrats.

The strength of unions like LiUNA are not from its leadership, but from the majority of the rank-and-file workers who are its members. To the workers dealing with the capitulation to the bosses by LiUNA, and to all workers in Canada, conquer and retake unions away from the bureaucrats, transform them into weapons for the working class of Canada! Join the independent workers organisation willing to help you organise this fight, contact the Workers United Front of Canada.5 We as workers built these unions, and we can retake them for ourselves. It is about time the bosses and their puppets in union leadership learn that it is the workers together who truly hold power.

 


Response to “LiUNA, Whose side are you on? – by Ivan D.”

  1. Interview with a Vancouver Ironworker – By Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

    […] 3 A similar attitude has been reported in Ivan D.’s recent article on the Labourers International Union of North America: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/28/liuna-whose-side-are-you-on-by-ivan-d/ […]

    Like