The People's Hammer

Lessons of the Quebec Amazon Campaign – By Quebec Supporters of the People’s Hammer

, ,


Recently, 300 workers at an Amazon warehouse in Laval were unionised under the CSN (Confederation of National Trade Unions) with participation from the “(N)CPC-”led AO, or Alliance Ouvrière (Workers’ Alliance).1 This was the first successful union campaign at an Amazon warehouse in Canada.2

Amazon has responded to the union by closing all its warehouses in Quebec and firing thousands of workers between February 8 – March 22.3 Amazon will be contracting out its work to third party logistics companies going forward.4

In response to the firings, the Amazon workers have called for action to prevent the firings and warehouse closures. The workers at different warehouses have set up pickets to defend their livelihood. In doing so, these workers have broken with the union bureaucrats and AO who have attempted to direct the workers towards more passive ends. They have even taken the initiative to hold meetings outside the jurisdiction of these two organisations to discuss a more direct response.

One of these meetings, called by the most advanced warehouse workers in the Revolutionary Action against Amazon (ARCA) coalition was attended by other worker and progressive organisations, including the Workers’ United Front – Montreal, SLAM-MATU, and Partisane. At this meeting, AO stated that their goal was to build a broad base of support that could eventually be drawn to assist pickets. While AO is willing to consider the possibility of a picket, they have effectively followed the line laid down by the CSN and are calling for a consumer boycott.5

The CSN bureaucrats are calling for a consumer boycott of Amazon that includes:

  1. buying Quebecois instead of from Amazon;

  2. asking the state to boycott Amazon;

  3. canceling Amazon Prime; and

  4. asking one’s boss to boycott Amazon.6

At the same time, the CSN is aiming to challenge the closures legally. AO is faithfully following the bureaucrat’s lead.

The Economism of the “(N)CPC”

While many organisations today claim otherwise, there is no communist party in Canada. The most important element of the communist party which all organisations are missing is the rallying of the vanguard of the proletariat. Because of this, the principal task of the communists, in the labour movement as elsewhere, is the uniting the most advanced workers with communism in a communist party. This requires extensive propaganda and mainly agitation to expose bourgeois ideology and develop class consciousness.

The work of reconstitution cannot be artificially divided from our other tasks of building the red army and the united front. In the case of the united front specifically, we must unite the workers against the bourgeoisie and overthrow our reactionary leaders in the union bureaucracy and build a strong centralised united front of the proletariat on the basis of workplace committees. However, as noted by the leader of the Red International of Labour Unions, Lozovsky, this can only occur when communism has conquered the unions.7 Therefore, our fight to build the united front requires the same ideological struggle. The masses must be drawn out of purely economic struggles to engage in the political struggles of reconstitution and the formation of the united front.

AO and the “(N)CPC” disagree with this understanding of our present tasks.

Some members of AO have even lashed out on social media to accuse the workers of ultra-leftism for pushing beyond the constraints imposed by AO and the bureaucracy. Some self-claimed communists among AO have denounced the support of the groups involved in the ARCA coalition on the grounds that there is already an organisation in existence on the ground (AO). Among their criticism of independent action is that those in the ARCA have not taken into account that some in AO had slowed down their careers through the Amazon campaign.

AO’s attempts to demobilise the workers to fight for passive demands would not be the subject of special attention if it were not one of the main mass organisations of the “(New) Communist Party of Canada”. Like the “(N)CPC” and its other mass organisations, AO adheres to a fundamentally economist line. The Amazon campaign shows AO’s complete political subordination to the union bureaucracy. AO members at their demonstrations will even approach workers to inquire them to ask their union delegate to reach out to them, rather than organizing the worker directly, since the union delegates “already have influence over their group of workers”.

The “(N)CPC’s” economism goes so far as to hide its existence from members of its mass organisations. Whereas we understand our principal task in the workers movement to be agitation and propaganda to rally the advanced workers to unite with the communist movement, the “(N)CPC” prioritises organisational and economic action. In this work, they hide their “party” from the masses, they do not agitate, and they do not lead. In effect, they separate the economic struggle and the political only seeing the masses as capable of the former.

Their central organ, North Star, makes scarcely a single mention of communism.

Their other Montreal-based group League 33 ignores the need for offensive actions by the workers and confines them to purely defensive actions.8

In Vancouver, the “(N)CPC’s” mass organisation United in Struggle similarly follows the lead of the union bureaucracy. United in Struggle’s “Bosses behind Bars” campaign, like the Boycott Amazon campaign entirely tails the union bureaucracy. Their campaign is little more than a replica of the USW’s campaign “Kill a Worker, Go to Jail”.9

Consumer Boycotts

Consumer boycotts generally require a very well-organised labour movement in order to be successful. It is possible to carry out a boycott in the case of a small business. This is because they generally only have a small handful of fronts that can be picketed. If the company is both a small company and one that markets itself to socialists, feminists, and progressive people, it is even more simple to carry out such a boycott. This is because their clientele are more ready to support a boycott over labour conditions.

Calling for a boycott of a large business is very difficult because it requires much greater coordination between workers of different shops and industries, not all of whom are union, over a large territory. The issues of consumer boycotts on large companies can be seen in the example of BDS which has only a small group of partial victories to its name after decades of work.

Calling for a boycott of one of the largest companies in the world requires a level of organisation that does not exist. This is especially true since the vast majority of consumers only interact with Amazon from their homes and there is no physical picket they are confronted with. In order to carry out a consumer boycott of Amazon large enough to harm the company, it is necessary to organise the campaign at a global level. This is not being pursued by AO and the union bureaucracy.

AO and the “(N)CPC” adhere to a bourgeois view of political economy that is based on the primacy of distribution over production. A boycott can only ever be a complement to the main struggle on the shop floor. Strikes, occupations, and organising drives are the only way these struggles are won. While a consumer boycott is not likely to make a difference, expanding the Amazon union nationally in connection to the campaign in the US and mobilising workers in affiliated industries of manufacturing and logistics can.

AO’s Demands

AO is distributing a leaflet as part of the boycott campaign. The leaflet contains two sets of demands. The first is to keep the warehouse open and the workers employed. This is good and we fully agree with it. However, the second set of demands reveals a lack of faith of AO in their own campaign. These demands are a worst-case scenario set of demands to be rallied around if the warehouses are closed. As communists, how can we expect to rally the workers to support the first set of demands if we do not believe in them ourselves? This makes for poor agitation and lowers morale among the workers.

It must also be pointed out that in AO’s second set of demands is the call for the seizure of Amazon’s property, if they go through with the closures. This demand has two basic errors. The first is that it lacks any kind of call for workers control either in the form of the warehouses being turned over to the workers or nationalisation with workers’ control. The second error is that this demand is completely disconnected from reality. If we cannot force the state to block the closures, how are we going to force them to take the much more aggressive measure of nationalisation (even without workers’ control)? Without the means to actually achieve this much more militant demand, this is nothing more than “writing to strike a pose” – “left-”opportunism.

Industrial Organisation

AO and CSN made a crucial error in their campaign to organise the Amazon workers by only organising a single plant. In organising workers of a very large company like Amazon, McDonalds, Starbucks, and others, it is necessary to carry out a nation-wide organising drive. This is because when the bourgeoisie have multiple locations, they will cut their losses by closing operations in the area temporarily in order to crush the union.

In carrying organising drives at these sorts of companies, we should learn from American workers, who have shown the necessity of country-wide campaigns in organising these companies. This is best seen in the Starbucks campaign.

As it is, the workers are highly isolated in an industry that is poorly organised against one of the largest companies in the industry.

Necessity of Struggle against Bosses and Bureaucracy

AO attempts to align the workers’ interests with those of the bureaucracy despite the fact that in most cases the bureaucracy are themselves aligned with the bourgeoisie. This is seen in their call for a passive consumer boycott, instead of mobilising the workers or expanding the union.

In the majority of cases, the bureaucracy are no friend to the workers. In our work to build the united front, we need to expose the bureaucracy at every turn in order to lead the workers to overthrow this reactionary headquarters and reorganise the unions.

If the “(N)CPC” were a real party, they would agitate against the bureaucracy’s call for passivity. But, the “(N)CPC” is not a real party and are instead supporting the bureaucracy in this struggle.


Responses to “Lessons of the Quebec Amazon Campaign – By Quebec Supporters of the People’s Hammer”

  1. Postal Workers and Tenants Unite! Block Party & Outdoor Movie Night – By Vancouver Tenants Union – The People's Hammer

    […] Power” and Economism – By Daniel H. Submission: Lessons of the Quebec Amazon Campaign – by Quebec Supporters of the People’s Ham… The (N)CPC and the Drug Trade – by […]

    Like

  2. SICA: A Liquidation of the Mass Line – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

    […] 12 An earlier article from Quebec noted the following: “The Amazon campaign shows AO’s complete political subordination to the union bureaucracy. AO members at their demonstrations will even approach workers to inquire them to ask their union delegate to reach out to them, rather than organizing the worker directly, since the union delegates ‘already have influence over their group of workers.’” https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/28/submission-lessons-of-the-quebec-amazon-campaign-by-q… […]

    Like

  3. Interview with an Ex-Logistics Worker – Ivan D. – The People's Hammer

    […] Lessons of the Quebec Amazon Campaign for more on this […]

    Like