The People's Hammer

Yves Engler’s Jailing Signals Increasing Reaction of Quebecois Imperialism – By Daniel H.

, , ,


On February 20, Yves Engler was jailed for his posts on X critical of pro-Israel commentator Dahlia Kurtz.1 Engler is a popular left-wing writer in Montreal who writes with a generally petite-bourgeois criticism of imperialism.2

Kurtz had reported Engler to the police several months ago following his criticism of her writings against Palestine and her calls for the deportation of pro-Palestine protesters.3 Engler was charged with harassment despite having never attempted to communicate with Kurtz.4

When the Montreal Police informed Engler of their intention to arrest him, he wrote an article on his blog that led to thousands writing the Montreal police to drop the charges.5 The letter writing campaign led to the police leveling additional charges against Engler of intimidation, harassment, harassing communication, and interference with the officer who initially called him.6

After Engler was arrested, he was held overnight to prevent him from continuing to write about his charges.7 The police sought release conditions that would have prevented Engler from discussing the charges against him.8 Engler spent five days in jail after which he was released on bail.9 His bail conditions allow him to continue his criticism of Kurtz if he does not tag her, however, he is prevented from making any references about the police complainant.10

The situation of Engler is similar to an earlier one I wrote regarding Samidoun.11 Both Samidoun and Engler are highly opportunist. Samidoun is a shill for any fascist landlord-bureaucrat dictatorship willing to denounce American imperialism (never mind if they are subservient to Russia or China). Engler was exposed by the CWF(OC) in 2023 for his knowing collaboration with the “Communist Party of Canada” in the middle of its crisis over the harbouring of rapists in its ranks.12

The workers need to resist the increasing turn to reaction of Canadian and Quebecois imperialism even if it is being levied against opportunists such as these. At the same time as the state is jailing and listing these opportunists as terrorists, they are sending strikers back to work,13 and mobilising secret militarised police units against the oppressed nations and protesters.14 As the workers increasingly organise themselves into a party, army, and united front, the reaction used against those like Engler will be used a hundred times over against the masses.

In fighting against this increasing reaction, the workers cannot ally with a seemingly less reactionary faction of the bourgeoisie.15 The principal political element of imperialism is that it is fully reactionary, and the differences between the factions of the bourgeoisie is one of quantity and not one of quality. That is, while one faction will openly repress the workers politically and another will use more subtle means, all factions are united on the need to exploit the proletariat and maintain the bourgeois dictatorship. While we can and must resist this increasing reaction, it cannot be prevented altogether until the economic base it is built on – imperialism – is eliminated.

  1. https://electronicintifada.net/content/montreal-police-arrest-yves-engler-criticizing-supporter-israel/50434
  2. The CWF(OC) has written an article previously explaining the different lines in the anti-imperialist movement: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2022/12/28/lines-in-the-anti-war-movement/
  3. https://yvesengler.com/2025/02/18/im-being-charged-for-responding-to-anti-palestinian-hate-on-x/\
  4. https://electronicintifada.net/content/montreal-police-arrest-yves-engler-criticizing-supporter-israel/50434
  5. https://electronicintifada.net/content/montreal-police-arrest-yves-engler-criticizing-supporter-israel/50434
  6. https://yvesengler.com/2025/02/19/police-angry-at-my-writing-about-ridiculous-charges-so-add-more/
  7. https://yvesengler.com/2025/02/19/police-angry-at-my-writing-about-ridiculous-charges-so-add-more/
  8. https://yvesengler.com/2025/02/19/police-angry-at-my-writing-about-ridiculous-charges-so-add-more/
  9. https://x.com/EnglerYves/status/1894221884423602579
  10. https://www.montrealgazette.com/news/article775096.html
  11. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/11/15/oppose-the-ban-on-samidoun-by-daniel-h/
  12. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/05/24/yves-engler-would-you-please-respond/
  13. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/01/26/canada-post-strike-in-review-by-cliff-z/
  14. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/03/rcmp-attempt-to-rebrand-c-irg-by-daniel-h/
  15. Both the “(N)CPC” and the “CPC” advocate some level of unity with the middle bourgeoisie in a fight against the big bourgeoisie: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ and
    https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/08/the-liquidationist-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada/