The People's Hammer

The (N)CPC and the Drug Trade – by Bessy

, ,


A couple years ago, the “Revolutionary Initiative”-sponsored journal Kites carried an article by Aiyanas Ormond called Seven Theses on Imperialism and the Drug War.1 Ormand is a former paid staff leader in the NGO Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users (VANDU), a long-time leader of the International League of People’s Struggles – Canada (ILPS Canada),2 and is today also associated with the “(N)CPC” newspaper North Star.3 His article was an attempt at a Marxist analysis of drugs, the drug industry, and the war on drugs.

The present document will focus on the final four of Ormand’s theses as it is these where the complete detachment from reality that seems to be the ideological line of Kites, “RI”, and today the “(N)CPC” can best be found.

Thesis Four

Ormond’s fourth thesis is very short, as such it is quoted below in its entirety to ensure it is accurately represented:

“4. Drugs aren’t innately good or bad, and drug use has two sides.

“Years ago, veteran drug war resister Deborah Peterson Small described drug addiction to me as ‘a good relationship gone bad,’ and it took me years of trying to understand my own experiences and daily interactions with habitual drug users to understand what she meant by this.

“People become habitual or compulsive users of drugs to deal with the trauma, pain and alienation that are produced and reproduced daily in a sick imperialist society. This includes family and sexualized violence, workplace injury, the alienation and boredom of work or unemployment, parental neglect, racism, forced migration, social exclusion, and stigma and many other forms of physical, psychological and social violence meted out as a predictable consequence of a system that puts profit and power for the few ahead of the needs of the many.

“In this context, using drugs isn’t a bad thing—it’s a rational response to a shitty situation. In most instances, people will use drugs in ways that are effective for managing their pain over the short, medium or long term, and cease using (or cease using habitually) as the process of healing advances. This is true even for those drugs that are popularly conceived of as ‘the most addictive,’ like heroin, cocaine and crystal meth.

“Drug use becomes ‘a good relationship gone bad’ when the drugs are no longer salving the suffering, but become a source of suffering, and are perpetuating the pain. People frequently describe this as ‘when you stop using the drugs and the drugs start using you.’ When purposeful drug use, even if it is very habitual, becomes compulsive and starts to shape your behaviour and interfere with other aspects of your life, it’s definitely a good relationship gone bad. And this isn’t a permanent condition, but it can be one that’s very hard to escape.”4

This thesis relies on the false assumption that what Ormond heard from his friend once is an accurate description of reality. That is, there is a “good” and a “bad” way to use drugs. Ormond’s “good” usage is where an individual prescribes themselves drugs in order to manage pain and uses drugs without addiction.

Ormond’s “good” drug use does not exist. Even when one is not addicted and the supply is “safe”, self-medication harms the individual. One of the negatives is that “good” use can easily lead to addiction, hence Ormond’s description of “a good relationship gone bad”.

The brain consists of cells called neurons which are organized into circuits with receptors and transmitters. Within each neuron, an electrical current travels down the axon. To transmit a signal to the next neuron involves a chemical process. While the neurons themselves don’t connect to each other they have neurotransmitters they send across synapses (the spaces between neurons). As a signal travels down a neuron, the electrical charge of the signal causes the vesticles of neurotransmitters to fuse with the nerve cell membrane at its end. When one neuron wants to communicate to the next one, it releases these neurotransmitters. Each neurotransmitter has a specific receptor for it on the other end of the next neuron that can only fit it like a specific lock and key combination. Neurotransmitters transmit one of three actions: excitatory, inhibitory, or modulatory.

Drugs interfere with the way that neurotransmitters are naturally sent and as a result, how they are received. Alcohol, for example, is an inhibitory drug because it alters “the balance between inhibitory and excitatory neurotransmission. Specifically, alcohol can act as a depressant by increasing inhibitory neurotransmission, by decreasing excitatory neurotransmission, or through a combination of both.”5

Cocaine on the other hand, in the short term, creates a build up of dopamine in the brain. We naturally produce dopamine that regulates our bodily functions, but when someone uses cocaine, it “interferes with this latter control mechanism: It ties up the dopamine transporter, a protein that the dopaminergic cells use to retrieve dopamine molecules from their surroundings. As a result, with cocaine on board, dopamine molecules that otherwise would be picked up remain in action. Dopamine builds up and overactivates the receiving cells.”6

The intermediate responses to cocaine use involve dopamine responsive cells which are highly concentrated in the limbic system, which includes important memory centres located in the hippocampus and amygdala. When someone experiences a cocaine high, these regions “imprint memories of the intense pleasure as well as the people, places, and things associated with the drug. From then on, returning to a place where one has taken cocaine or merely seeing images of cocaine-related paraphernalia triggers emotionally loaded memories and desire to repeat the experience. Scientists believe that repeated cocaine exposure, with its associated dopamine jolts, alters these cells in ways that eventually convert conscious memory and desire into a near-compulsion to respond to cues by seeking and taking the drug.”7 As someone keeps taking cocaine their tolerance increases and so does the dose reinforcing reliance on the drug- or an addiction.

Drug use gradually deteriorates the body and mind of the user. Infections and other ailments are an obvious outcome when one is puncturing their skin and blood vessels without the necessary knowledge of how to do so and how to treat the wounds left behind. Xylazine, which is increasingly flooding working-class neighbourhoods leaves the user with horrific wounds.

Drug use further disrupts the regular function of the prefrontal cortex, the basal ganglia, and the amygdala. These disruptions enable visual cues to trigger substance seeking, reduce sensitivity of the brain towards dopamine reception, and reduce regulation in a person’s actions, emotions, and impulses.

Further, in trying to explain long term cravings even after withdrawal from cocaine use, “Scientists have identified one potentially key type of cocaine-related change that appears to last for many months after the last cocaine exposure, and perhaps longer: an alteration in the NAc [Nucleus accumbens]. Chronic cocaine exposure causes these cells to extend and sprout new offshoots on their dendrites. Dendrites are the branch-like fibres that grow out from nerve cell bodies and collect incoming signals from other nerve cells… more dendrite branches in the NAc theoretically will collect a greater volume of nerve signals coming from other regions… This will give those other regions an enhanced influence over the NAc, which could drive some of the very long-lived behavioural changes associated with addiction.”8

A final major negative of all drug use is that it is an escape from the everyday oppression, exploitation, and alienation in the lives of the proletariat. Communists are quick to note that religion is the “opium of the people”.9 But, you know what else is an opium to the people? Opium! It is a means to escape reality rather than confront and reshape it through class struggle.

Marx’s description of the abolition of religion applies equally to the question of drugs:

“The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.”10

When communists organise against drugs, it is likewise against the illusion that drug use may provide the individual of relief from exploitation towards the end of a true end to exploitation that drive one to drug use in the first place.

Communists should not split between a “good” and a “bad” drug use because from the only measure that matters – does it help or hinder the construction of communism – both of Ormond’s categories turn the workers away from revolution. What is “good” in the worker being misdirected from the class struggle? Only a group operating with a bourgeois worldview can see this as “good”. The path Ormond idealises of the individual turning to drugs in order to cope with reality is an individual response to the questions of exploitation, oppression, and alienation. What is communist in describing this kind of individualism as “good” in any way? These questions are fundamentally social in nature and therefore require a social resolution. In Canadian society this means socialist revolution.

Ormand describes using drugs as a response as rational. How is this the case? The use of drugs can wreck the body and mind of the worker and takes them out of the struggle for socialism. Drug abuse can lead to greater use as the worker becomes addicted. This addiction then replaces the initial aspects of the workers reality they were trying to escape as the chief reason for use. It is irrational to run away from reality, the rational response that communists must convey to those turning to drugs is to join the class struggle and eliminate the causes that drove them to drug use in the beginning.

The argument that drug use is a rational response does not reflect the interests of the addict or the workers generally. It is a position in line with the bourgeoisie of the drug trade alone as the only social class that benefits from this position.

Ormond’s claim that drug use is effective pain management and naturally ends when the user has finished healing is equally ridiculous. It is important to note that addiction is not only a mental phenomenon, but is a physical one in many cases where withdrawal can result in serious medical issues. This means that one cannot simply stop usage when they no longer feel they need to use and need to gradually ween themselves off the substance. Many drug users want to stop, but cannot because they have become addicted in the process of prolonged use.

Even beyond the direct effects of taking drugs, meta-analysis written on the topic of non-fatal opioid-related overdoses shows that respiratory depression (the lack of oxygen being delivered to the brain) is a defining characteristic of opioid overdose and that this lack of oxygen to the brain may cause brain injuries and/or neurocognitive impairments that last for a lifetime.11

Thesis Five

Ormond states:

“The use of substances to alter our consciousness or perceptions is extremely normal (almost universal) behaviour at the historical and social level. But that doesn’t mean that addiction is normal, inevitable or okay. Compulsive use of substances that becomes unhealthy, undermines other aspects of our lives and feels out of control has long been recognized as a real problem. And we can recognize it as a problem without pathologizing it, or characterizing it as an individual failure or as a condition of permanent broken-ness.”12

Drug use and addiction are both natural and unnatural in a sense. In the sense that it is part of human nature, neither are natural and to paint use as such and addiction not shows Ormond’s subjectivity. It is not human nature to seek out an escape from reality. Use is natural only in the sense that as human society develops and investigates its surroundings, it comes into contact with the substances around them.

Similarly, addiction is unnatural in the sense that without the introduction of addictive substances there is no opportunity for addiction to develop. However, it is natural in the sense that it is a consequence that follows form drug use in many cases. Addiction has existed as long as these substances have existed.

The “naturalness” of an action does not mean that it is something that communists should promote. Wage-slavery is natural in the same sense as drug abuse is natural. They are the products of the development of human civilisation, but there is nothing about “human nature” that calls them into being.

Ormand proceeds to ask the following question:

“The question is why, of the many people who use drugs, only a small subset end up with this harmful relationship with the drugs they consume?”

It is important to note the assumption that workers escaping reality is not a bad thing continues to be assumed by Ormond at the base of this question. The actual numbers differ by drug, but it is not a small subset that become addicts. It is a minority, but to hand wave 25.4%13 as Ormond does is just agitation for drug monopolies.

Thesis Six

This thesis is dedicated to identifying who Ormond views as the friends and the enemies of the people with respect to the war on drugs. The enemies include:

“At the top of the list of enemies is the imperialist ruling class and their states, who have unleashed this murderous drug war for more than a century knowing full well that it had nothing to do with improving the lives of people. Quite the opposite: it is a targeted and purposeful attack against internally-colonized people, the poor and oppressed nations. A subset of this group is those who directly profit from the misery of the drug war: the banks that launder the super-profits of the criminalized industry, the shareholders of the jails used to lock people up for drug offenses, owners of private treatment clinics and the bureaucrats and police chiefs who build bureaucratic and institutional empires on public funding allocated to the war on drugs.

“Next up on the list of enemies are the big bourgeoisie of the criminalized drug industry. These are the scumbags who, in their quest for maximum profits, will flood our communities with an unsafe and unstable drug supply, allowing hundreds of thousands to die in the ‘market adjustment.’ They use murder, rape, torture, humiliation and other forms of violence to collect debts, discipline workers and secure their profits, and will unleash literal wars in our communities to secure their turf from their capitalist competitors.”14

There is no real disagreement here on the enemies listed. What is important is that despite the “scientific” appearance of this analysis it is empty of political economy. This is seen in the description of why the drug bourgeoisie are enemies. It has nothing to do with exploitation and oppression of workers and peasants. It is not because they pacify the masses and keep them from taking up class struggle. They are enemies because the drugs they flood proletarian neighbourhoods is unstable and cut with other substances. Ormond has no real antagonism with the drug bourgeoisie. He does not like how they do business, but has no problem with the business itself.

One other glaring issue in this section is the failure to mention NGOs like VANDU. While the bourgeoisie say neoliberalism shrinks the state, in reality it has expanded it a hundred times over. Where it has cut out functions it directly administers, it has financed a legion of NGOs – like VANDU who now operate as arms of the state. VANDU has been heavily funded by the state. In 2022, the city canceled a $320 000 six-month contract with VANDU to clean the area they operate in.15 In 2023, VANDU was also cut off from city funds of $7 500 for an art table.16 The closely related organisation the Drug User Liberation Front (DULF) was revealed to have received $200 000 in funds from Vancouver Coastal Health.17

Ormond later lists “organizations and networks of drug users”18 as part of the people. This is true where these organisations fight the bourgeoisie and break their members’ addiction. The above-mentioned DULF actively distributed cocaine, heroine, and meth in Vancouver for nearly two years and VANDU is reliant on the state.19 Organisations such as these need to be considered arms of the state and not part of the people.

Ormond describes the middle forces as follows:

“The middle forces are on the one hand the mid-level managers of the criminalized drug industry (gang bosses, regularized enforcers and debt collectors, local and regional supply coordinators) and, on the other hand, the drug warriors who institutionally benefit from and perpetuate the drug war (cops, prosecutors, health care workers and recovery industry managers). They’re not necessarily getting rich off the drug war, but it provides them with a relatively comfortable and stable ‘middle class life.’ A small subset of these folks are potential allies, particularly mid-level ‘dealers’ who came from the streets and might have experiences of racism or exploitation that make them sympathetic to proletarian class struggle, or doctors and nurses who come to understand their patients and can no longer pretend that individual illness is the root of the problem. In the imperialist countries, the cops are really paid well and have been delegated class power that ties them very tightly to the imperialist ruling classes of their various countries—they are class enemies. But in the context of the oppressed nations, it might not always be like that. We shouldn’t rely on these middle forces, but some elements may be allies in particular campaigns, struggles or contexts.”20

Many of those described by Ormond as “middle forces” are fully the enemies of the working-class. This includes the list of middle bourgeois and lumpen elements Ormond describes as “gang bosses, regularized enforcers and debt collectors, local and regional supply coordinators”. It should be noted that the sympathy Ormond has with the middle bourgeoisie in the drug industry is fully in line with the “(N)CPC” vacillating attitude on the question.21

Ormond lists those he labels “drug warriors” as middle forces. Ormond recognises that the police are enemies, but only in an imperialist country like Canada. In other cases Ormond is unsure. The reason he lists them as enemies is because of “delegated class power” and high wages. However, the police across the world have the function of ensuring the rule of one class over all others. This is what is fundamental in labeling the police enemies and not friends. The fact that they make elevated wages does not factor into this as many workers make very high wages. Class is a qualitative relationship to the means of production it is not a quantitative measure of wealth. Prosecutors can also be considered enemies as like the police their role is the oppression of the workers.

Recovery industry managers can be friends or enemies according to their class position. Those that are workers that make schedules can be allied with while those at the top cannot.

Finally, the labeling of healthcare workers as middle forces, demands what class position Ormond is making this analysis from. An analysis that places the workers in any camp aside from the people is a bourgeois analysis by definition. It is also worth noting that hospitals and clinics are in no way reliant on drug treatment to keep their job going, it is only a small segment of the hospital cases and of clinics that exist.

On the question of dealers, Ormond lists them as a potential ally not for their productive relations, but for their potential past experiences with racism and exploitation. We cannot base our alliances on one’s “lived experience.” There are a number of success stories the bourgeoisie tout of imperialists who rose to their position from a proletarian background. Does their past as a worker mean anything? We can also assume that Chrystia Freeland has faced some misogyny in her life, does this mean we could ally with her? The workers can unite with the lumpen only through their transformation into the proletariat.

Finally, we have broad agreement with Ormond’s list of friends. However, at the end of his list he states:

“Finally, and in the long term, we need to include the waged and piecemeal workers in the criminalized drug industry, many of whom are slinging a lot of dope with no hope of ever getting rich off it. These folks are assailed on two sides: by the criminalized drug industry that wants to exploit their labour and by the bourgeois state that wants to use them as a propaganda prop and as fodder for police department budgets, prisons and the rest of the bloated criminal justice system. There are definite contradictions here, because these are people whose livelihood and short-term economic interests are aligned with the criminalized industry they work in, but they also face some of the worst violence and exploitation of the drug war.”22

Reading this very generously, if Ormond is speaking about workers working in the production of drugs as in the example of the large-scale Mexican plants he cites, then we fully agree. However, if Ormond is speaking about small-scale drug dealers then we disagree.

Conclusion

Ormond’s article is typical of the pessimism we find among the petite-bourgeoisie. Where communists recognise the disintegration of imperialism and emergence of communism in the world today, many among the petite-bourgeoisie believe the world cannot get better qualitatively, and we can only fight for a quantitatively better world. As such, they no longer fight for an end to drug use and only fight to blunt its edges. It is the same mentality of the electoralists who are sure to guilt the workers every election to vote for harm reduction and the lesser evil.

5 Valenzuela, CF. “Alcohol and neurotransmitter interactions.” Alcohol health and research world vol. 21, 2 (1997): 144-8

6 Nestler, Eric J. “The neurobiology of cocaine addiction.” Science & practice perspectives vol. 3,1 (2005): 4-10. doi:10.1151/spp05314

7 Ibid.

8 Nestler, Eric J. “The neurobiology of cocaine addiction.” Science & practice perspectives vol. 3,1 (2005): 4-10. doi:10.1151/spp05314

11Winstanley, Erin L et al. “Neurocognitive impairements and brain abnormalities resulting from opioid-related overdoses: A systematic review.” Drug and alcohol dependence vol. 226 (2021): 108838. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2021.108838.


Responses to “The (N)CPC and the Drug Trade – by Bessy”

  1. Postal Workers and Tenants Unite! Block Party & Outdoor Movie Night – By Vancouver Tenants Union – The People's Hammer

    […] “Workers’ Power” and Economism – By Daniel H. Submission: Lessons of the Quebec Amazon Campaign – by Quebec Supporters of the People’s Hammer The (N)CPC and the Drug Trade – by Bessy […]

    Like

  2. SICA: A Liquidation of the Mass Line – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer
  3. DULF and the Opioid Crisis – By Bessy – The People's Hammer
  4. The “(N)CPC” and Independence from the State – By Daniel H. – The People's Hammer