The People's Hammer

Armchair Revolutionaries: Nothing but Liabilities – By Cliff Z.

,


“I’m really busy right now.” “Oh yeah, I’ll get to it.” “Seems like a waste of time to me.” Every serious communist has heard these phrases when the time comes to buckle down and work. Once theory must turn into practice, a negative trend can occur in which some “communists” decide to relegate themselves exclusively to theoretical work. Perhaps they will do some organisational work for a study group or minimal agitation among friends/co-workers, but when events must be planned, campaigns must be outlined, contacts must be made, and the theory which they study must be tested in their material conditions, suddenly they are full of excuses. These kinds of “communists” are often referred to as “Armchair Revolutionaries.”

On the face of it, armchair revolutionaries seem fairly harmless. They are uninvolved, but still must be helpful on the theoretical side of things, right? Wrong. To understand the world dialectically, one cannot truly understand theory without practice or understand practice without theory. By failing to engage with the world before them concretely, the armchair revolutionaries cannot possibly understand what theory is relevant to their conditions. They have no ability to see what is useful. This makes their perspectives on matters mechanical and idealist, failing to ever grasp the necessary creativity needed to apply Marxism. The idealism that armchair revolutionaries’ inevitably slip into is informed and maintained by problems in attitude. Principally, passivity defines the attitudes of the armchair revolutionaries and influences them on an individual and collective level.

Individual Passivity

Passivity can emerge through excuses and/or a lack of communication. Excuses can range wildly and be more or less opportunistic in nature.

A communist stating they need some time off because they have had a friend/family member die is an example of a perfectly good reason to take a break and recuperate. Sickness, emergencies, unexpected shifts in schedules/workload. None of these are excuses, they are reasons to take time off. Because communists are not shallow individualists, we understand that the value of health and well-being is collective. “Self-care” places health separate to the social reality of the individual and seeks to depoliticize the role of the individual in maintaining a healthy lifestyle. In misunderstanding this collective versus individual nature of health, the excuses of armchair revolutionaries begin to emerge. “I’ve got a lot on my mind” is a not a reason to reject work. Practicing communists can do their best to inquire and get to the root of the problem when someone comes to them with this kind of excuse, but if the armchair revolutionaries want to be ambiguous, they are not presenting any real reason to reject work. The benefit of the doubt can only be given so many times before excuses pile up.

Sometimes, forms of opportunism emerge in these excuses. “I’m too ADHD to do that kind of work.” “I’m too socially anxious to go to those events.” “This is too difficult. I’m only a woman.” These are examples of identity opportunism. While communists dealing with someone taking on these attitudes must try to understand the particularities of the label they are choosing to use as a “free work pass”, there is a general theme we can dispel here immediately: all of these are limitations that the armchair revolutionaries are placing on themselves. In the case of mental illness, these are internal contradictions, and while external support can facilitate its resolution, the resolution of this contradiction remains entirely internal and a responsibility of the individual. In serious bouts of suicidal ideation and self harm, communists must take a break from their work if they believe it is affecting them negatively and they must make serious efforts to overcome these problems. As already stated, the health of a communist is a collective matter. To use things like anxiety or ADHD as excuses without even making an effort to try the work or adapt from past failures is pure defeatism. Life is stressful, it is anxiety filled, it is distracting. We all have different capacities for these things and some of us are better suited to cope than others. That is no reason to never challenge yourself and to hide in comfort when there are people relying on you.

Moving beyond identity opportunism “I’ve got a lot of work right now.” is another common excuse. Did this work emerge unexpectedly? Was there time to anticipate and plan around it? A full time job and a pick up basketball league do not constitute too much work to spend an afternoon or evening off helping one’s comrades. Communists must be willing to make personal sacrifices for the sake of building a revolution. If even five hours out of a week is too large a sacrifice, one must question why a person such as this is even remotely interested in Marxism.

What typically follows a long string of excuses from the armchair revolutionaries is a lack of communication. Not checking messages, avoiding the topic when meeting them outside of communist work, etc. This all leads to a drop off in any form of real involvement, in which the armchair revolutionaries relegate themselves to entirely individual study and in some cases move to social media to embarrass themselves, make public displays of their ignorance, and generally make communists look like a joke. All of this is harmful for both the real communists and the armchair revolutionaries.

These failures in practice often begin to affect the attitudes of the armchair revolutionaries. This typically leads to apathy. By separating one’s self from material conditions and failing to conduct work among the masses, apathy towards the struggles of the masses is inevitable. “People are stupid anyway. They’ll never learn.” “Look at all those people voted for Donald Trump. They deserve everything that’s coming to them.” These errors in judging the will and desires of the masses cause armchair revolutionaries to slip further into passivity. Pessimistic remark after pessimistic remark, they begin to deem all efforts to help improve conditions and drive the revolution forward entirely a waste of time.

As communists, this apathy must be combated in every instance it occurs. The masses cannot be blamed for being lied to by the bourgeoisie. When a proletarian truly believes that people like Donald Trump, Mark Carney or Pierre Poilievre have their interests in mind, that is not a failing of that individual, it is a failing of us as communists for not illuminating the truth. Armchair revolutionaries who blame the struggling working class people of the United States for honestly believing that Donald Trump would make their life more affordable are egotistical maniacs with no understanding of the responsibilities of communists. There is an insufferable trend among social-media addicted armchair revolutionaries insisting they are “so intelligent” and “truly advanced communists” when all they do is look down on others and sit in their own filth. If all you are interested in is nursing your insecurities and belittling the efforts of others, consider reading Nietzsche instead of Engels.

Collective Passivity

When armchair revolutionaries do become inclined to organise, they often do so in the form of paper organisations. These are organisations which do nothing beyond occasional meetings and promoting themselves (typically through other organisations and events which they had no part in organising). They do not engage in or create serious campaigns, they do not make inquiries into workers’ conditions or attempt to help them in their struggles, and they hold no serious form of membership or organisational structure. This trend is most observable among the Trotskyist organisations which will often have myriad paper orgs representing workers’ circles, women’s fronts, etc. These paper orgs are just the masks of the larger Trotskyist organisation attempting to catfish sympathizers into supporting the parent group. Paper groups are highly damaging because they lead the public to believe that communists are unserious and deceptive. All it takes is for one worker to earnestly approach an organisation like this with the hopes of making change for the worker to become demotivated, bitter, and decide that communists are of no help to the Canadian proletariat all because they were duped by a group which is a sham and does not truly care about worker struggles.

Collective passivity also manifests in failure to conduct two line struggle. When communist groups similar in ideology fail to launch debate over matters of contention, plans for large scale collective organisation become impossible. The former Revolutionary Communist Party of Canada, one of the country’s most advanced communist efforts, split and ultimately liquidated due to these exact problems of passivity regarding two line struggle.1 These failures cannot be repeated if Canada wishes to see socialism. Idealism must be cast aside, liberal attitudes must be combated, and matters of the material conditions of the Canadian proletariat must be brought to the forefront of all political matters.

In Summary

Armchair revolutionaries soil the reputation of true communists by dragging the historical titles and symbols of the vanguard of the proletariat through the mud and warping communist philosophy to fit their egocentric attitudes and lifestyle. Not every armchair revolutionary is a selfish and malicious person, driven by insecurities and social isolation to desperately cry for attention while contributing nothing to the world. Some armchair revolutionaries are simply misguided or hesitant. These are the people true communists must focus on. These are the armchair revolutionaries who are capable of standing up. It is our responsibility to help them. We must listen to their troubles, their hesitations, their doubts, their fears and we must lift them to new heights they never knew they were capable of. I was once an armchair revolutionary. Now, I am a communist. If there is one thing my practice has taught me, it is that anyone with the right attitude is capable of contributing to the revolution.

Citations

1. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2021/07/28/political-critique-of-party-leadership/


Responses to “Armchair Revolutionaries: Nothing but Liabilities – By Cliff Z.”

  1. What is Selflessness? – By Cliff Z. – The People's Hammer

    […] Armchair Revolutionaries: Nothing but Liabilities – By Cliff Z. […]

    Like

  2. SICA: A Liquidation of the Mass Line – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

    […] 13 We have previously published an article addressing the issue of creating paper organisations such as these: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/armchair-revolutionaries-nothing-but-liabilities-by-c… […]

    Like