The People's Hammer

Gonzalo Thought: Parts 6-8 – By Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)

, ,


The following article is a repost of parts 6-8 of the Gonzalo Thought document by the CPC(RF). The originals can be found here: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2025/01/16/gonzalo-thought-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-part-5-2/

https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2025/02/08/gonzalo-thought-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-part-7/

https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2025/03/18/gonzalo-thought-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-part-8/

– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer

B. Scientific Socialism

XI. Proletarian Feminism1

The Communist Party of Peru has developed the Marxist line in the women’s movement to its current level with the document Marxism, Mariategui, and the Women’s Movement. This section will provide a brief analysis of this document as well as other developments of Gonzalo Thought to the women’s question.

The document opens with a critique of the theory of the “deficient female nature” which has surfaced throughout the history of class society to justify the exploitation and oppression of women. The PCP shows how the theory of the “deficient female nature” acts as a complement to the theory of human nature. Both put forward an unchanging nature regardless of society or position within society. Rather as the PCP states humans are a set of social relations that change as a function of the social process. Women like men are a social product and their transformation requires the transformation of society itself. The oppression of women cannot be reduced to their genitals or the reproductive role they largely play, but due to their relation to father-right. That is, women’s oppression is bound up with the existence of property relations.

Building off the work of Engels, the PCP states that the oppression of women is based in the family, the state, and private property and that capitalism provides the material basis for the emancipation of women by bringing them into production and therefore class struggle, i.e. women from proletarian families are fully proletarianised. With the emergence of capitalism, the women’s movement became largely directed by the bourgeois suffragettes fighting for democratic rights. This revolutionary position that capitalism sets the basis for the emancipation of women should not be confused with the opportunist position that emancipation can be achieved under capitalism.

The PCP traces the history of class struggle and how the status of women has developed with each revolution. In doing so the PCP show that the women’s movement is a part of the popular movement. When the people advance the position of women has advanced, but when the new ruling class has consolidated as a reactionary class as is the case with the landed aristocracy and the bourgeoisie, the popular movement including the women’s movement has regressed. Therefore, in order for women’s emancipation to be completed, the popular movement must be carried to its end, communism. Only with the liberation of the proletariat, will women’s emancipation be fully completed.

One important contribution of the PCP is the phrasing of women’s liberation versus women’s emancipation. The former phrasing is linked to bourgeois feminism which sees an antagonistic relationship between men and women with women needing to liberate themselves from men. The latter phrasing is the position of proletarian feminism that recognises that women are in the same class as their husbands and fathers, but due to the patriarchal oppression and exploitation they face, they are placed in an inferior position. They will emancipate themselves through liberation from class society.

The women’s movement poses three questions for communists:

  1. Feminism. Feminism emerges with the incorporation of women into productive labour and therefore thrives most among women who labour outside the home. The two fundamental centres for the development of feminism is in the unions and the universities, principally the unions;
  2. Politicisation of women. The politicisation of women is essential for the mobilisation and organisation of women. Where the communists neglect politicisation they serve reaction; and
  3. Organisation. Women must be incorporated into the class struggle. Like all proletarians, women need organisation, which in the last analysis must be organisation under the leadership of the communist party.

These three questions broadly correspond to the three levels in which we carry out the construction of the broader revolutionary movement, being ideological, political, and organisational.

In Canada, women represent around half of the proletariat and therefore represent one of the fundamental fronts for the communist party to build generated organisations within to lead the movement similar to the process that must take place in the labour movement, and the youth and student movement, among others.

Recently, a dogmatic line has emerged in the international communist movement opposed to proletarian feminism. In synthesis, their argument is that proletarian feminism is a new ideology generated to answer questions already answered by Marxism. This argument relies heavily on the formalist analysis of the term’s ending with “-ism” which they say denotes an ideology separate from Marxism. However, the same opposition is not raised against proletarian internationalism or revolutionary optimism which no Marxist will deny are integral parts of Maoism.

XII. Reconstitution of the Communist Party

While the Communist Party of Peru was not the first communist party to undergo reconstitution with earlier examples occurring in countries like Russia when Lenin led the Bolsheviks to reconstitute the RSDLP for example among others, what the PCP does contribute is a systematisation of the process.

One of the most important contributions which must be taken as the basis of the entire process is the question of building a new party versus reconstituting a party. This question is addressed by Chairman Gonzalo in his 1988 interview:

“As a result of this struggle the Faction had to assume the task of reconstituting the Party by itself. Lenin said that there comes a time when it’s necessary for a genuinely revolutionary Faction to rebuild the Party. This is the task that the Faction assumed. Here one might ask, why did the Faction shoulder the task of reconstituting the Party? Why didn’t it found another Party as was the fashion, and still is today? The first reason is because the Party was founded in 1928 on a clear Marxist-Leninist basis, and so it had a great deal of experience, experience drawn from both positive and negative lessons. What’s more, Lenin said that when one is in a Party that is deviating, moving off course, or falling headlong into opportunism, one has the duty to strive to put it back on the right course. Not to do so is a political crime. So the importance of the Faction is that it carried out this role, contributing to the reconstitution of the Party, beginning with laying the ideological and political foundation. We based ourselves on Maoism, which at that time was called Mao Zedong Thought, and on the establishment of a General Political Line. The Faction has the great distinction of having reconstituted the Party, and once that was done, the instrument then existed: the ‘heroic combatant’; the Communist Party of a new type, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist; the organized political vanguard—and not a ‘political-military organization’ as it is often incorrectly put, but the Party required to launch the struggle to seize Power with arms in hand through People’s War.”1

To build a new party in a country where a communist party has previously existed means to build it without concerning oneself with the guiding thought, general political line, and programme that were developed by the historical party. This cuts the proletariat off from their past forcing them to relearn lessons already learned, take up two-line struggles that have already been resolved. In Canada for example to take up the slogan of “Build the Communist Party!” would be incorrect as it would isolate us from the positive elements of the historic Communist Party of Canada as well as organisations like In Struggle!, Socialist Action, and the PCR-RCP.

With this basis, the next important element is in identifying, retaking, and developing the red line of the historic communist party as its guiding thought. This has three components: 1) identification; 2) retaking; 3) developing.

Identification requires the search for the historic red line, studying the history of two-line struggle in the communist movement, and when the party was taken over by revisionism and/or liquidated. In Canada for example, it is important to investigate the process that lead to the first congress of the CPC in 1921, the major two-line struggle that lead to the expulsion of the Trotskyist line of Maurice Spector and the expulsion of Jack MacDonald. We must also study the two-line struggle brought forth against Tim Buck that ultimately led to the expulsion of the red line headed by Fergus McKean and the formation of the Organisation Committee for a Communist Party of Canada. Secondarily, investigation must be made into the development and decay of In Struggle and the other ML-MZT organisations of the time as well as the struggles between them. We must investigate the decay of these organisations that led to the formation of Socialist Action and later the PCR-RCP. In analysing all of this and most importantly providing a synthesis, we are able to identify the red line in the Communist Party of Canada and post-1943 within the general communist movement.

Retaking the red line is of obvious necessity. It means to take the path of revolution as opposed to revisionism.

Development of this red line is the principal component in identifying, retaking, and developing. The PCP explains it this way:

“It was not enough to reclaim him for two key reasons: the development of Marxism-Leninism by Chairman Mao Zedong, and the development of bureaucratic capitalism in Peru. This phase took place during the struggle against Khrushchevite revisionism and its manifestations in various spheres of Party life and ended with the January 1969 6th Conference which approved ‘the reconstitution of the Party’ ‘on the basis of Party unity around Marxism-Leninism-Mao Zedong Thought (as was said in those days, now it is Maoism), Mariátegui’s Thought and the General Political Line.’”2

The development of the red line takes into account the new subjective and objective conditions. It would be impossible for us to take the red line from the founding of the CPC in 1921 and mechanically apply it to 2023. This is because the scientific ideology of the proletariat has developed beyond Marxism-Lenin Thought, and imperialism has decayed greatly and is no longer in its strategic offensive but is now in retreat. Today development must take in mind: 1) Marxism-Lenin Thought is today Marxism-Leninism-Maoism-Gonzalo Thought, principally Gonzalo Thought; and 2) Canadian imperialism is on its decline as a part of the general crisis of imperialism internationally and the strategic offensive of the world proletarian revolution.

The above deals with the ideological-political aspect of reconstitution, but around this must be generated the organisational aspect of reconstitution. This includes three broad measures: 1) structure; 2) system; and 3) work.

The organisational aspect of reconstitution is addressed by the PCP as:

“The first is to develop a single organizational structure that is countrywide, unified and centralized, as a whole subject to the leadership of the Central Committee, the key expression of centralism; this is the question of structure. The second is the problem of the distribution of forces, that of centering the activity in the peasantry to develop the main forms of struggle and organization and is the problem of following a path of accumulation of forces in the cities; this is the question of the Party system. The third, is the problem of secret work, of clandestine activity, of the framework that guarantees the constant functioning in any circumstance; it is the problem of open work; of the mass work, which in the country poses the need to ‘turn the triangle’, that is, to put peasant work as the basis of the revolutionary struggle, the problem of the need to have tenaciously and firmly as the direction of the workers’ movement the struggle for the seizure of power leading the peasantry in the revolution under the leadership of the Party, it is the problem of “our duty to go lower and deeper” to forge the masses in the need to make the revolution and fight revisionism, to mobilize, politicize and organize workers and peasants, who are the basic masses, to incorporate intellectuals, women and youth into the struggle, and it is the obligation to develop the struggle for daily demands in terms of power; it is, finally, the problem of the necessity of secret and open work and of their indispensable interrelation, subject to the orientation that the first is the main and guides the second; all this is the question of Party work. The structure, the system and the Party work are three fundamental questions of the organizational line and are of vital importance for the construction of the Party; but, as in everything, the application of these questions subject to the correct line is given in struggle with contrary lines; in short, a correct organizational line cannot be applied nor developed but in struggle and at present its application and development can only be given by fighting revisionism as the main danger.”3

The final major component contributed by the PCP on the process of reconstitution is the need of an organised red fraction to lead the struggle. This red fraction is the subjectively organised force that identifies, retakes, and develops the red line of the communist movement and on this basis generates its structure, system, and work. In synthesis, the red fraction is the party in nucleus whose work culminates with the reconstitution of the communist party.

XIII. Low-Intensity Warfare:

Low-intensity warfare as a strategy is counter-revolutionary and protracted warfare.

Low-intensity warfare has its precursors in previous counter-revolutionary wars waged by imperialism, but these elements that would later be developed into this new strategy were largely complementary to conventional warfare. In fact, in a US army report from 1983, it is stated that what was previously referred to as unconventional warfare by the counter-revolution is now called low-intensity warfare. This strategy of principally conventional warfare eventually became ineffective as the world proletarian revolution advanced with the US facing its most embarrassing defeat in Indochina and the USSR in Afghanistan. Conventional warfare proved ineffective in crushing the national liberation movements in these countries among others as they spawned large resistance movements. These types of conventional wars had also become increasingly unpopular among the masses in the imperialist powers. For these reasons, imperialism produced this new strategy of low-intensity warfare aiming to capture the hearts and minds of the masses in the aggressed nation as well as at home.

As part of the plot to capture the hearts and minds of the masses, imperialism has purposely branded low-intensity warfare as “low-intensity conflict”. This is to obscure what is going on behind a less belligerent face. A similar tactic has been carried out in Russia’s invasion of Ukraine where the state initially refused to acknowledge it as a war or invasion and instead call it a “special operation”. The example of Russia and Ukraine is one of principally conventional warfare, but the general principal of the aggressing power obscuring its actions through these labels remains.

There is also a need to conduct fewer covert operations that can be unmasked before the public as they are unpopular. The Communist Party of Peru gives the example of US intervention in Chile to overthrow Allende. In place of covert operations, imperialism has shifted to conducting open operations with a large degree of deception to gain domestic support. Imperialism must secure the masses at home which requires extensive propaganda. This can again be seen in the case of Russian propaganda around Nazism in Ukraine as it escalated its low-intensity war against Ukraine into a conventional war. The same can be seen in Iraq with US propaganda around its supposed weapons of mass destruction.

In the country where the low-intensity war is being waged, the masses form a battleground between the two forces each aiming to secure the support of the masses to achieve their class goal. For example, in a socialist revolution, the proletariat and the imperialists each employ their own approach to mass work in order to unite the respective classes and win over the middle elements. For this reason, those in power carry out a campaign to legitimise the government or state, while the opposition aims to delegitmise the government or state in the eyes of the masses. Legitimisation often includes a policy of superficial improvement of human rights. The Communist Party of Peru explain this problem as follows:

“Finally, there is the so-called ‘legitimization’ as a political objective of the counter-insurgency war, in its form known as ‘low-intensity warfare’, which seeks governments produced by elections as a mean of providing them with ‘legitimacy’ and ‘authority’, which should be recognized as such by the people. In addition, according to them, they would ‘serve to satisfy the needs of the people’. In that way, elections are nothing but a tool of the counter-revolutionary war.”1

Imperialism then, aims to make use of liberal-democracy in particular over fascism as the system of government in the countries where low-intensity warfare is applied in order to win over the masses.

Low-intensity warfare is one of three categories of warfare alongside medium-intensity warfare, and high-intensity warfare. As the Communist Party of Peru explains:

“According to this text, low-intensity warfare would be the lowest end of the spectrum. The problem when he speaks of the spectrum refers to the fact that when the atomic bomb was used, they had a weapon of immense destructive power that surpassed everything known up to that time, August ‘45; from there comes the conception that it is feasible to classify wars according to the intensity of the weapons, of the means used and they classify them in low intensity, medium intensity and maximum intensity, the latter using the atomic bomb; The medium intensity, conventional warfare weapons, all non-atomic means; and the low intensity, those in which simpler, less powerful means are used; hence the classification of war by intensity.”2

As a theory of war developed by the imperialists, it lacks a dialectical materialist basis which is obvious in the classification of warfare by the weapons involved alone neglecting the most important element in warfare, people. Whether the imperialists carry out a low, medium, or high-intensity war it is always reactionary and aimed at restraining the march toward communism. Another issue is the relativity of intensity. That is what is a war of low-intensity to a superpower will be experienced as high-intensity to a weak nation. For example, what is a small and weak detachment of an imperialist military is a large and powerful detachment in an oppressed nation.

Low-intensity warfare has two aspects: 1) its non-military aspect; and 2) its military aspect. It relies on the military aspect as its base in order to threaten the direct use of military force and make actual use of this force. It is not enough to threaten force if the power does not have the force to back it up or if the threat is never carried through. For the threat to be effective it must be clear to all involved that force will be used.

Where people’s democracy or socialism has been established or in a semi-colony that has switched hands, low-intensity warfare often includes coercive diplomacy such as the imposition of economic blockades and sanctions. This can be seen today with the examples of the sanctions and blockades imposed by the US against the DPRK, Cuba, and Iran who have all become principally Chinese or Russian semi-colonies.

Low-intensity warfare uses only a small portion of the imperialist power or superpowers’ total resources (weapons, soldiers, etc.) to achieve its political objectives. The total resources employed are very low compared to the importance of the political objectives. If these limited resources prove to be insufficient, they may escalate to a war of medium-intensity. The Communist Party of Peru gives the example of Vietnam. The war began as low-intensity warfare and was quickly elevated to conventional war with the constant threat of nuclear arms (high-intensity).

The imperialist power or superpower may decide to undertake direct, small, conventional operations within the general strategy of low-intensity warfare without escalating it to a conventional war. Operations of this type are very neatly defined with a rapid withdrawal such as evacuations, rescues, protection, and anti-terrorist operations.

Low-intensity warfare is carried out by an imperialist power or a superpower with the goal of pushing the targeted group to accept a position of subjugation. For this reason it is generally carried out in the the oppressed nations with the aid of local bureaucrat-landlord regimes, however it may also be carried out against other imperialist powers or superpowers.

There are three axes to low-intensity warfare corresponding to the strength of the enemy.

  1. Counter-insurgency. This is applied in countries where the insurgency threatens the existing order or there is a risk of it occurring.
  2. Reversal. In countries where the above process has been successful, the power or superpower aims to overthrow the new state or government and return the country to its previous status. The imperialist power will sponsor armed groups to complete this task with a base to withdraw into in a neighbouring country friendly to the imperialist power. Diplomatic actions such as economic blockades are openly practiced in this axis of low-instensity warfare;
  3. Counter-terrorism. With counter-terror operations by the powers or superpowers alongside anti-drug and anti-crime operations, low-intensity warfare has been generalised across the globe even in the imperialist powers and superpowers. Counter-terrorism is also used as a pretext for open intervention in a country with the understanding that if the country cannot contain the issue, it is necessary for the power to do so.

Counter-insurgency in particular has four fundamental forms of non-military action:

  1. Intelligence. This includes objective factors such as the terrain and weather, but mainly subjective factors concerning the opposition group. They aim to develop their espionage network, and their subversion and sabotage work. This all applied according to the relative level of development of the insurgency. That is, the forms of espionage, sabotage, and subversion undertaken will be different in a new insurgency, a developing one, and in one on the edge of seizing power. It will also be applied differently throughout the country according to how developed the insurgency is in any given area. Imperialism will also develop counter-guerrillas;
  2. Psychological operations. Those soldiers deployed on this front concern themselves with morale. In conducting psychological warfare among the insurgents, the aim is to have the insurgent group align with the government. Among the civilian population the aim is to strengthen their support of the government, its defences, and its development programmes. Psychological warfare has two basic objectives:
    • Modify the relationship between soldiers;
    • Modify the relationship between the armed forces and the masses.
  3. Civil affairs. These are actions done to win the masses over to support the government and the military. This consists of removing those barriers in the way such as by providing education, food, transportation, etc. This arm of low-intensity warfare is particularly tied to the economy of the imperialist powers and superpowers bringing in “aid” to develop the areas and thereby deepening the colonial relationship.
  4. Control of population and resources. This arm aims at insurgent infrastructure, destroying it and preventing its redevelopment. Control of population and resources combines the above listed non-military operations as well as military operations. This mainly consists of two points:
    • Sweep away the headquarters of the insurgency
    • Separate the headquarters from the masses.

Between the two, the first is principal as if the headquarters remains the insurgency can continue. Control of the population and resources alongside civil affairs aims to accomplish four objectives: “Objectives combined with civic action issues: 1) mobilize supplies and manpower on behalf of the government; 2) uncover and neutralize insurgent organizations and activities; 3) provide a physical and psychological environment for the people; and 4) cut off any existing support between the population and the insurgent forces.”3

US imperialism has deployed its forces in a way corresponding to this new strategy. It masses its forces mainly in Europe and elsewhere it applies economy of forces. That is in Europe, there is preparation for conventional or nuclear war, while in most of the oppressed nations, low-intensity warfare is applied.

C. Political Economy

I. Generalisation and Expansion of Bureaucrat Capitalism

Bureaucrat capitalism as a concept was first synthesised by Chairman Mao within ML,MZT most clearly in the document The Present Situation and our Tasks. Chairman Mao states that:

“During their twenty-year rule, the four big families, Chiang, Soong, Kung and Chen, have piled up enormous fortunes valued at ten to twenty thousand million U.S. dollars and monopolized the economic lifelines of the whole country. This monopoly capital, combined with state power, has become state-monopoly capitalism. This monopoly capitalism, closely tied up with foreign imperialism, the domestic landlord class and the old-type rich peasants, has become comprador, feudal, state-monopoly capitalism. Such is the economic base of Chiang Kai-shek’s reactionary regime. This state-monopoly capitalism oppresses not only the workers and peasants but also the urban petty bourgeoisie, and it injures the middle bourgeoisie. This state-monopoly capitalism reached the peak of its development during the War of Resistance and after the Japanese surrender; it has prepared ample material conditions for the new-democratic revolution. This capital is popularly known in China as bureaucrat-capital. This capitalist class, known as the bureaucrat-capitalist class, is the big bourgeoisie of China.”1

Mao presents bureaucrat capitalism as a Chinese phenomenon and fails to generalise it in investigating the political economy of other oppressed nations. While some communist movements would adopt an analysis of bureaucrat capitalism, it would be with Chairman Gonzalo that bureaucrat capitalism would have its definition and process expanded and generalised as a concept found in most oppressed nations that have a basis in a pre-capitalist mode of production either semi-feudalism or semi-slavery. In countries that have yet to develop an independent capitalism, imperialism has entered into an alliance with the reactionary ruling classes, generally the landlord class. Both the imperialists and the landlords have a vested interest in restraining the independent development of capitalism in these nations. For the imperialists, it would mean the loss of the colony or semi-colony and competition with the new capitalist industry of the country. For the landlords it would mean loss of political and economic power as feudalism is replaced with capitalism. For this reason imperialism and feudalism have entered into alliance in these countries to restrain the productive forces.2

Chairman Gonzalo explains:

“the bourgeoisies that develop in Latin America begin to link themselves more and more to the dominant country, in such a way that these weak bourgeoisies, instead of developing independently like the Europeans did, serving the national interests, they evolve as subjugated bourgeoisies, dependent, given over body and soul to the imperialist powers (England or the US) to the extent they even believe in converting themselves into rich men and developed intermediate bourgeoisies, as our history in this century shows.”3

The capitalism that develops in these countries (concentrated in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and southern and Eastern Europe) has been born in the era of imperialism and has become subordinated to it.

Chairman Gonzalo further outlines what constitutes the bureaucratic path in these countries:

“Bureaucratic capitalism develops three lines within its process: a landlord line in the countryside, a bureaucratic one in industry, and a third, also bureaucratic, in the ideological sphere.”4

That is, in the countryside, bureaucrat capitalism evolves semi-feudalism, strengthening the position of the landlord class. In the cities, it monopolises industry and commerce in service of imperialism. On the level of ideology and politics, bureaucrat capitalism generates masses to serve the further development of bureaucrat capitalism through institutions such as the church and education system. These three lines that form the bureaucratic path are opposed by the democratic path of the masses that aims to establish a democratic society.

Chairman Gonzalo underlines the connection between (semi-)colonialism and bureaucrat capitalism, stating that “This industrialization took place in a semi-feudal society whose economy developed increasingly subjected to North American imperialism, which displaced English domination. That way bureaucratic capitalism implies development of our semi-colonial condition and underscores the entire development of Peruvian society.”5

Not only does feudalism greatly benefit from bureaucrat capitalism, but so does semi-colonialism. Bureaucrat capitalism provides the imperialist powers it is subjected to with an industrial base. Because this industrialisation is meant to benefit imperialism and not the nation, what is produced is principally light industry and not heavy industry. This means that while these countries are able to produce commodities like cars, clothes, food, etc., they are not able to produce means of production to the degree necessary. This is in turn strengthens imperialist domination over the country because the country is forced to import capital in the form of means of production rather than develop them themselves. The development of bureaucrat capitalism marks an all-around development of the already existent (semi-)colonialism and backward mode of production.

In his interview with El Dario, Chairman Gonzalo explains that:

“We understand that bureaucratic capitalism began to emerge in Peru in 1895 through the three stages that I previously outlined. We conceive of it this way: capitalism developed on top of a semi-feudal basis, and under imperialist domination. It is a capitalism born late, born tied to feudalism and subordinated to imperialist domination. These are the conditions that produce what Chairman Mao Zedong has called bureaucratic capitalism. So, bureaucratic capitalism develops bound to big monopoly capital which controls the economy of the country. This capital is made up, as Chairman Mao said, of the big capital of the large landowners, the comprador bourgeoisie, and the big bankers. Thus bureaucratic capitalism emerges, bound, I repeat, to feudalism, subordinated to imperialism, and it is monopolistic. We must keep this in mind, it is monopolistic. At a certain point in its development this capitalism is combined with State power and uses the economic means of the State, uses the State as an economic lever and this process gives rise to another faction of the big bourgeoisie, the bureaucratic bourgeoisie. This gives rise to a further development of bureaucratic capitalism which was already monopolistic and becomes, in turn, State-owned. But this whole process gives rise to conditions which ripen the revolution. This is another important concept, politically speaking, that the Chairman laid out about bureaucratic capitalism.”6

Here, Chairman Gonzalo explains why bureaucrat capitalism is born dead. If we compare the development of capitalism in most of the contemporary imperialist powers with that of the these nations we can see that capitalism arose in antagonisitic opposition to feudalism, while bureaucrat capitalism arose tied to feudalism. Whereas capitalism in Europe arose in independent nations with their own old-type colonies, bureaucrat capitalism arose in countries dominated by foreign capital. Whereas capitalism in Europe developed in the revolutionary period of capitalism (mercantilist or free market), bureaucrat capitalism arose in the era of imperialism when capitalism is reactionary and dying. Whereas the democratic revolutions in western Europe largely resolved the questions of land and nation, the oppressed nations were established by botched democratic revolutions, were peacefully transferred from a colony to a semi-colony, or remain a colony today. Whereas European capitalism developed on the base of strong heavy industry, bureaucrat capitalism is based on light industry. Whereas in Europe what was established were independent dictatorships of the bourgeoisie, what arose in these countries was capitalism dominated by imperialism. For this reason, bureaucrat capitalism cannot be seen as a progressive force as it does not fulfill the role played by capitalism in abolishing feudalism, acting as the economic base of the democratic revolution, instead it strengthens both imperialism and feudalism and acts to hold back productive forces where it is active.

The capital controlled and developed by bureaucrat capitalism is produced by 1) large landowners; 2) the comprador bourgeoisie (the big bourgeoisie); and 3) the big bankers. The capital generated by these three reactionary sources makes up bureaucrat capital. As this bureaucrat capital develops in the era of imperialism and is bound to imperialism, it is monopoly capital.

In the early stages of development of bureaucrat capitalism, there exists only the comprador bourgeoisie, the comprador bourgeoisie form the big section of the bourgeoisie and are economically tied to imperialism and act as agents to facilitate the flow of foreign imperialist capital into these countries. This means that unlike the bourgeoisie that seized power in western Europe who were subordinated to no one, the big bourgeoisie of the oppressed nations are necessarily reliant on imperialism. In the development of bureaucrat capital, it merges with the state and uses it as a tool to further accumulate capital. This process splits the big bourgeoisie into two separate factions: 1) comprador bourgeoisie; and 2) bureaucrat bourgeoisie. Both factions of the big bourgeoisie are tied to imperialism and monopoly capital, but it is structured differently according to the faction. For the comprador bourgeoisie, the connection to imperialism is much more direct with this faction representing a non-state monopoly capitalism whereas the connection to imperialism is indirect among the bureaucrat capitalists who represent state-monopoly capitalism. To provide an example of these two factions in contradiction, we can look toward Chile where Allende represented the bureaucratic bourgeoisie whereas Pinochet represented the comprador bourgeoisie.

Finally, bureaucrat capitalism ripens the conditions of the revolution. This is not meant in a mechanical sense that the further bureaucrat capitalism develops the more the revolution is accelerated. Rather, it recognises the connection between the deepening of a reactionary mode of production and the development of a counter-mode of production as a necessary antithesis. In the imperialist countries the deepening of imperialism hastens the development of the socialist revolution and in the semi-feudal countries it hastens the development of the new democratic revolution.

In the Line of the Democratic Revolution, the PCP outline the five general characteristics that define bureaucrat capitalism:

“1. Bureaucratic capitalism is the capitalism that imperialism develops in the backward countries, which is comprised of the capital of big landlords, big bankers, and the magnates of the big bourgeoisie.

2. It exploits the proletariat, the peasantry and the small bourgeoisie and restricts the middle bourgeoisie.

3. It passes through a process in which bureaucratic capitalism is combined with the power of the State and becomes comprador and feudal State-monopoly capitalism, from which can be derived that in a first moment it unfolds as a non-State big-monopoly capitalism and in a second moment, when it is combined with the power of the State, it unfolds as State-monopoly capitalism.

4. It ripens the conditions for the democratic revolution as it reaches the apex of its development.

5. Confiscating bureaucratic capital is key to reaching the pinnacle of the democratic revolution and it is decisive to pass over to the socialist revolution.”7

From this we can further see that bureaucrat capitalism oppresses the proletariat, the peasantry, the petite-bourgeoisie, and the middle bourgeoisie. This differs from the capitalist mode of production in the imperialist countries which does not oppress the middle bourgeoisie who are a target of the socialist revolution. From the fifth point we understand the role played by the confiscation of bureaucrat capital in the new democratic revolution. While, the new democratic revolution aims to “clear the path for the development of capitalism”8 it also accomplishes certain tasks of the socialist revolution in the countryside with various forms of cooperation, and in the cities with the confiscation of bureaucrat capital. Chairman Mao explains:

“[The new state] will own the big banks and the big industrial and commercial enterprises.

“Enterprises, such as banks, railways and airlines, whether Chinese-owned or foreign-owned, which are either monopolistic in character or too big for private management, shall be operated and administered by the state, so that private capital cannot dominate the livelihood of the people: this is the main principle of the regulation of capital.”9

In the document On the Rectification Campaign, Chairman Gonzalo explains the development of bureaucrat capitalism in Peru with three stages which can be generalised in the investigation of bureaucrat capital globally: 1) development; 2) deepening; and 3) destruction. Further, Chairman Gonzalo subdivides each stage again into three with each stage progressing through: 1) preparation; 2) unfolding; and 3) collapse. To take the stage of development of bureaucrat capitalism in Peru as an example, Chairman Gonzalo describes the process as follows:

“For example, in its 1st Moment, there is a prologue expressed in a preparatory stage, and then during the 1920s, another stage when foundations are laid for the development of bureaucratic capitalism. Then comes a process of collapse, the intended development is not achieved, a crisis arises, and this crisis leads to further collapse. Historical facts show this to be the case.”10

The PCP discusses how neo-liberalism affects the development of bureaucrat capitalism with respect to structural reforms in Peru:

“The vast majority of decrees are economic, focused on the economy and where do they aim? They aim to reduce state activity, they aim to develop the monopoly of the big bourgeoisie, the non-state monopoly and mainly to favor the greater penetration of imperialism, especially Yankee imperialism, that is all, under the criterion of ‘for social necessity, to promote private investment’ the same criterion, in the end that is what it is, it is the transfer that they are legally concretizing of all that the State accumulated over decades, and what is pending as we have just seen since the end of the ‘70s, that is what they are doing. The appropriation of those means that State monopoly concentrated, to whom is it going to pass? To Yankee imperialism mainly, to other imperialisms in second place and in third place to the big bourgeoisie, to a small group of the big bourgeoisie, which generates problems for reaction. It seems to us that this is how we can consider it.”11

The philosophy and political-economy of neo-liberalism will be discussed more below, but what is relevant here is that in the context of bureaucrat capitalist regimes, it promotes the development of the non-state monopoly economically, which means the development of the comprador bourgeoisie politically reinstating them as the principal faction of the big bourgeoisie. This shift is not a permanent one as could be seen in the “pink tide” in Latin America, the bureaucrat faction may impose itself over the comprador faction. However, in general the promotion of neo-liberalism by the imperialist powers tends to support the comprador faction in their struggle for dominance with the bureaucrat bourgeoisie.

The last major point of development is found in Fundamental Political Questions, in which the countries that had been part of or subjugated to the USSR are discussed. The PCP states:

“The general counter-revolutionary offensive. Superpowers, powers and unique hegemonism of the United States: rotten colossus with feet of clay; collusion and contention in a general fight over the plunder of the USSR and Eastern Europe, and the development of zones of influence that sow imperialist wars of plunder all over the world, targeting the 3rd World which today is broader than yesterday (including the semi-colonies and colonies of what was the Soviet Union). The European Community: imperialist union to dominate the world: Franco-German collusion and contention. Japan: ‘Asia for the Asians’, co-prosperity, base for Japanese world hegemony. The general bankruptcy of revisionism. Decomposition of the USSR, Great Russian nationalism, Pan-Slavism, unbridled bourgeois nationalism and “worshippers of the West”. Albania collapsed and is subjected to Italy. Revisionism […] develop capitalism, influences in Asia and be future great power.”12

Eastern Europe and the USSR’s former colonies in Central Asia as well as countries like Albania and the former Yugoslavia have become oppressed nations again and have become the subject of imperialist domination. In many of these countries, bureaucrat capitalism again emerged.

II. Expanded Definition of Fascism

Gonzalo Thought has contributed greatly to the Marxist understanding of fascism. This began with Mariategui who wrote extensively on Italian fascism. In The Ideologues of Reaction, Comrade Mariategui addresses the qualitative leap that characterises pre-World War One and post-World War One reaction. He states, “their theses, disjointed and fragmentary, had the character of a romantic protest, or of a crisis of pessimism in democratic institutions and principles, not that of an affirmative and belligerent system or doctrine that it has acquired after the fascist march on Rome.”1

The romantic nature of pre-World War One reaction is tied to the the state of the world at the time. Up until 1871 when the world proletarian revolution began, capitalism had been a progressive force. It faced mainly two enemies: 1) the proletariat who wanted to resolve the contradictions of capitalism and move toward communism; and 2) the old landlord classes who wanted to restore their dictatorship. In the case of the landlords who had been overthrown, they promoted a romantic ideology that looked back at the feudal life as simple and idyllic compared to modern heavily mechanised capitalist production. This was the form of reaction that largely predominated until World War One. This romanticist reaction also found its way into the socialist movement with the populists in Russia among others. By the time of the war and especially after the October Revolution, romanticism waned in popularity as the common threat to both the bourgeoisie and the remaining landlords was the advance of communism.

Comrade Mariategui further outlines the two fundamental criteria that allowed fascism to arise in Europe:

“In order for reactionary ideology to thrive in such a way, it was necessary, on the one hand, for fascism to proclaim and propagate its coups d’état and, on the other hand, for General Dawes and the Yankee bankers to impose their economic control on the defeated Europe, the same as on the victorious Europe.”2

The first criterion listed is a politico-military criteria emphasising the need of fascism to take action. The second criterion outlines the economic base that allowed for the growth of fascism. As with World War Two, America entered World War One late and imposed itself economically on the continent. It exported massive amounts of capital to Europe as a part of the reconstruction effort giving the US increased power in the region. It would be the similar process following World War Two with the Marshall Plan that would allow the US to arise as a superpower.

Following this, the theories of fascism developed in a two-step process.

1) “When Europe appeared to be shaken by revolutionary turmoil, and torn apart by its economic contradictions and its nationalist passions, the Intelligentsia was inclined to adopt an ominous and pessimistic attitude.”3 and 2) “Only after Europe entered a stage of capitalist stabilization, with the operation of the Ruhr settled and the revolutionary threat of Italy and Germany averted—and when, with some surprise, the intellectuals felt momentarily protected from the danger of confiscation or rationing—were theories developed and disseminated, from all corners, calling for and consulting with the reactionary dictatorships.”4

Mariategui shows that the changes in the economic base of Europe with the entrance of US capital in the region generated a pessimism among the petite-bourgeoisie who feared revolution from the proletariat and being crushed by the bourgeoisie and now US imperialism. At this point the fascists were nationalist and self-contradictory fighters with very little guiding ideology. They were actively promoted by the old state in the fight against the proletariat eventually leading to them taking power in a number of countries. As Mariategui says, only then did fascism begin to develop ideologically and politically. This is what is meant by the opening phrase of the essay “the reactionary deed has led to the reactionary idea”.5 Fascism is principally action and secondarily theory. It is developed when the bourgeoisie are in crisis and threatened by proletarian revolution. Only when it seizes power does it actually develop a theory to guide it.

Elsewhere Mariategui writes on the two wings of fascism, saying:

“two antithetic souls and two antithetic mentalities. One extremist or arch-reactionary faction proposing the integral insertion of the fascist revolution in the Statute of the Kingdom of Italy. The neoliberal State had, in its view, to be replaced by the fascist State. While a revisionist fraction instead called for a more or less extensive political rectification.”6

Within fascism two wings present themselves. The second wing which is relatively moderate is not fully broken from democratic liberalism and occupies a space between it and fascism. Its main purpose is to safeguard the state. The extreme faction aims to completely do away with the democratic-liberal system of government and replace it with the fascist-unitary state.

In 1935, Comrade Dimitrov would produce a synthesis of fascism drawing on the writings of other leaders of the proletariat such as Zetkin and especially Stalin. Dimitrov provided the following definition for Fascism:

“Fascism in power was correctly described by the Thirteenth Plenum of the Executive Committee of the Communist International as the open terrorist dictatorship of the most reactionary, most chauvinistic and most imperialist elements of finance capital.

“The most reactionary variety of fascism is the German type of fascism. It has the effrontery to call itself National Socialism, though it has nothing in common with socialism. German fascism is not only bourgeois nationalism, it is fiendish chauvinism. It is a government system of political gangsterism, a system of provocation and torture practised upon the working class and the revolutionary elements of the peasantry, the petty bourgeoisie and the intelligentsia. It is medieval barbarity and bestiality, it is unbridled aggression in relation to other nations.”7

At the first congress of the PCP, Chairman Gonzalo elaborates the development of the communist understanding of fascism:

“The origin of fascism is in Japan, this is never told. The action is polarized between revolution and counterrevolution and the demo-bourgeois forms and the demo liberal ideas are insufficient to contain revolution, there is the necessity for fascism. In 35, the 7th Congress of the Communist International would take place and Dimitrov would analyze the problem of fascism, would put forward that fascism is the state expression of the financial bourgeoisie, of the financial oligarchy that applies the most shameless terror. A definition like this focuses on terror. Before that, Dimitrov would analyse fascism together with Clara Zetkin and the proposition is that one has to see the negation of bourgeois liberties which fascism represents. There is a quote from Stalin in which is put forward that it is a shameless terror and there is also more written works by him and there is the need to Study what was said by Stalin. In this Congress, Dimitrov would put forward the possibility of unity of the demo-liberal against fascism. That make us see that not everything was terror, to understand that fascism was the negation of the demo-liberal, but the party said that this does not fit us, because the situations are different. Dimitrov considers fascism as the state that represents and defend the interests of the financial bourgeoisie (big bourgeoisie), rejecting the demo-liberal criteria, its principles, introducing the fascist criteria of negation of its own demo-liberal principles, rejecting demo-bourgeois parliamentarian order to put forward corporatism and that besides they use terror, soft politics and hard politics. Terror, what fascism does is to develop further violence as a paralyzing instrument for domination to achieve the application of their fascist goals and the corporatist order (political goals). Stalin put forward the union with bourgeois democrats (alliance of certain sectors to smash fascism). In the process of the bourgeois state, the demo-bourgeois system carries on with the danger of taking bad measures to restrict and hinder the struggles, it is not that the demo-liberal make a leap toward fascism, but, with the restriction laws they make, they prepare the path to it. Dimitrov would analyze that fascism is not the same everywhere, it has concrete forms according to the conditions in which it develops and the degree of revolution, and it can coexist with parliament for some time. But it has some general things that are common, it sweeps away everything that is bourgeois democracy, potentiate nationalism, use social demagogy (struggle against the rich), points out to the banks, is a clear expression, even by their buildings, of wealth. Great offerings to the masses, to the workers, they offer employment to the unemployed, land to the peasants, study to the youth, education to the intellectuals, capacity to develop their faculties (anything like that…). They are cynical and base themselves in the most shameless lie.”8

Here, Chairman Gonzalo provides a criticism of the Comintern definition of fascism that is based mainly on violence without seeing the special quality this violence has in comparison to that of the democratic bourgeoisie against the proletariat.

Gonzalo Thought has overcome the weaknesses of this definition. Gonzalo Thought introduces the understanding of three fundamental components of fascism:

1. The negation of liberal democracy. This is the component elaborated by Dimitrov, that it is tied to the most deeply reactionary elements of imperialism. It does away with democratic rights and freedoms or maintains them only on paper;

2. Centralisation of power to the executive. The democratic-liberal division of power into an executive, judicial, and legislative branch is eliminated. Power becomes concentrated in the executive branch with the other two branches serving the executive. This component of fascism is found in its most concentrated form with the führerprinzip;

3. The negation of parliamentarianism and the restructuring of the state along corporatist lines.9

Regarding the role of corpratism and its relationship to fascism, Chairman Gonzalo specifies:

“Some identify fascism and violence. Violence is a method to have the masses subjected; violence is a manifestation of every state. Dimitrov is badly interpreted. The state has a process of development: the bourgeoisie builds a demo-liberal state, but when imperialism comes, such state becomes outdated … Violence is an ingredient but the essence of fascism, its essence is the questioning of the demo-liberal order and thus, it develops a frame from the past, renewed, to oppose the struggle of the masses; carry out the implantation of institutions acknowledged as ‘natural’, its fundamental norms are: personality, property, family and together with these the State, the Church, ‘magnifier of men’, and the Army as the ‘living spirit of nationality’. Fascism is not a simple problem of military and civilians, but the efficiency to fulfill it. it must be clarified the character of the corporate state. The government is not openly presented as fascist nor corporate to avoid its discredit; however, its measures show its ideology and its goals.”10

Like Dimitrov and Mariategui, Chairman Gonzalo outlines that one of the sole universal ideological components of fascism is its rejection of liberal democracy. Chairman Gonzalo points out the incompatibility of liberal democracy as a political form and imperialism as an economic form. From here lies the financial capitalist class basis of fascism. Fascism’s rejection of liberal democracy unites with reactionary romanticism in this moment of looking back to systems of government to replace parliamentarism with in corporatism.

III. Indigenous Question

Comrade Mariategui has contributed greatly to the understanding of the national question in the Americas. Mariategui’s line on the national question was upheld and furthered by the red fraction of the PCP and later the PCP itself. His analysis is best suited to the context of Latin America as it largely concerns the Indigenous people in countries with the following characteristics: 1) Indigenous people form the majority of the country; 2) they were former colonies of other feudal countries who imposed feudalism in their colonies. Countries like Canada and the US have the opposite characteristics with: 1) Indigenous populations being very small; and 2) they were former colonies of developing capitalist nations who imposed capitalism in these specific colonies. Despite these differences in particularity, Mariategui’s analysis holds several answers broadly applicable to any country with a broadly similar situation such as anywhere in the Americas, Australia, New Zealand, among others.

Mariategui begins by establishing the difference between his approach to the question and the approach taken by reactionary politicians, economists, and philosophers by stating that:

“Those of us who approach and define the Indian problem from a Socialist point of view must start out by declaring the complete obsolescence of the humanitarian and philanthropic points of view which, like a prolongation of the apostolic battle of Las Casas, continued to motivate the old pro-Indian campaign. We shall try to establish the basically economic character of the problem. First, we protest against the instinctive attempt of the criollo or mestizo to reduce it to an exclusively administrative, pedagogical, ethnic, or moral problem in order to avoid at all cost recognizing its economic aspect. Therefore, it would be absurd to accuse us of being romantic or literary. By identifying it as primarily a socio-economic problem, we are taking the least romantic and literary position possible. We are not satisfied to assert the Indian’s right to education, culture, progress, love, and heaven. We begin by categorically asserting his right to land. This thoroughly materialistic claim should suffice to distinguish us from the heirs or imitators of the evangelical fervor of the great Spanish friar, whom, on the other hand, our materialism does not prevent us from admiring and esteeming.”1

We must analyse the question through the lens of dialectical materialism as one with a political-economic root and a resolution in scientific socialism. The reactionary intellectuals on the other hand attempt to obscure the issue by painting the indigenous question as one of administrative, educational, moral, or ethnic roots. These all attempt to place the base of the question in the superstructure rather than the base. Mariategui associates the Indigenous question with that of land and by extension with that of feudalism, saying that, “the agrarian problem is first and foremost the problem of eliminating feudalism in Peru, which should have been done by the democratic-bourgeois regime that followed the War of Independence. ”2

Mariategui identifies the Indigenous economy in Peru as one that is and has historically been agricultural. He states:

“The subordination of the Indian problem to the problem of land is even more absolute, for special reasons. The indigenous race is a race of farmers. The Inca people were peasants, normally engaged in agriculture and shepherding. Their industries and arts were typically domestic and rural. The principle that life springs from the soil was truer in the Peru of the Incas than in any other country.”3

This starting point was true elsewhere on the continent including much of North America prior to European colonisation. This includes Canada where the agrarian economic base of the Indigenous nations in the plains have been analysed by Howard Adams among others.4

In its relation to the question of the Peruvian nation, Mariategui writes that “the problem of the Indians is the problem of four million Peruvians. It is the problem of the three-quarters of the Peruvian population. It is the problem of the majority. It is the problem of the nationality.”5

He continues:

“The Indian is the foundation of our nationality in formation. Oppression makes the Indian an enemy of civilisation. It practically annuls an element of progress. Those who impoverish and repress the Indian, impoverish and repress the nation.”6

This holds in all countries where like Peru there is an internally oppressed nation who constitutes the majority of the country’s population. Peru which is itself a semi-colony will not be able to uplift itself by the strength of the white quarter of the population alone, it requires an end to the oppression of the other three quarters. It is impossible for any nation to progress that is oppressing the majority of its population. Despite the population of the oppressed nations in Canada being small, it is impossible for the Canadian revolution to achieve socialism while still oppressing nations.

Mariategui provides an analysis of the conquest of the Americas by Europe, the economic base that allowed this conquest to take place, and how the different levels of development among the colonising nations led to different results in North America than Latin America.

On this first point, Mariategui combats those who try to justify the conquest of the Americas on ethnic grounds (a racially superior group defeating a racially inferior group) and those who base themselves on Aristotelian reaction of master races and slave races. He again puts forward a dialectical materialist understanding stressing the economic bases of the two civilisations involved. Mariategui states:

“The Indian race was not defeated in the conquest wars by an ethnically or qualitatively superior race; it was defeated by technology that was superior to that of the aboriginal peoples. Gunpowder, iron, and cavalry were not racial advantages; they were technical advantages. The Spanish arrived in remote areas because they possessed means of navigation that allowed them to cross oceans. Shipping and trade later allowed them to exploit the natural resources of their colonies.”7

The Spanish (as well as the English and French in Canada) were able to conquer the Indigenous nations based on their advanced mode of production relative to the Indigenous people.

An issue that arose in both North America and Latin America was that the colonising powers “had a rather exaggerated idea of the economic value of natural wealth, but almost no idea about any of the economic value of people.”8

This led to the eradication of much of the Indigenous nations’ institutions and their depopulation. This removed much of the native population that could be worked in order to access the natural wealth that the colonising powers had valued. For this reason, new populations were imported such as black slaves and Asian coolies. While, slavery was extensive in Latin America and the agricultural southern United States, it was present to a much smaller degree in Canada where Chinese labour and European settlers were much more commonly exploited.

The difference in the colonisation of Latin America and North America comes down to the different levels of development between Spain and Portugal who colonised much of Latin America and France, England, and the Netherlands who colonised North America. Spain and Portugal imposed feudalism in their colonies. England, France, and the Netherlands were all in a period of developing capitalism if still initially in Feudal trappings. Mariategui synthesises this understanding saying:

“Whereas in North America colonization planted the seeds of a spirit and an economy then growing in Europe and to which the future belonged, the Spanish brought to America the effects and methods of a declining spirit and economy that belonged to the past.”9

This also reflected in who was sent to colonies by these powers. As Mariategui puts it “The Spanish did not have the Anglo-Saxons’ conditions of colonization. The creation of the United States is considered to be the work of the pioneer. After the epic of the conquest, Spain sent us almost nothing but nobles, clergy, and villains.”10

In Latin America, the colonisation process involved little settlement and mostly involved sending people to secure the country for Spain or Portugal. However, in Canada and the United states, what was sent was principally ordinary people to settle the land, farm it, engage in the fur trade, develop industry, etc. These settlers also contained many individuals fleeing religious persecution in their home countries most notably the puritans and the Jews. Both of these religious groups are significant to the development of capitalism in North America.

In the case of the puritans:

“The New England colonizer was a Puritan expelled from Europe for a religious rebellion that was the

first act of bourgeois assertion. The United States thus emerged as a manifestation of the Protestant Reformation, which was considered the purest and most original spiritual manifestation of the bourgeoisie, that is, of capitalism.”11

The anti-feudal role of the Jews was due to their “radical exclusion of any ―noble activity from which he was excluded in the Middle Ages.”12

Finally, Mariategui writes on the resolution of the Indigenous question. He criticises the racism of Indigenous people in the struggle against colonialism. He writes:

“From the prejudice of the inferiority of the Indigenous race, one begins to pass to the opposite extreme: that the creation of a new American culture will be essentially the work of autochthonous racial forces. To subscribe to this thesis is to fall into the most naïve and absurd mysticism. It would be foolish and dangerous to oppose the racism of those who despise Indians because they believe in the absolute superiority of the white race with a racism that overestimates Indians with a messianic faith in their mission as a race in the American renaissance.”13

This failing can still be seen today with many groups and individuals raising the contradiction between the Canadian and Quebecois nations with the Indigenous nations to an antagonistic contradiction. These groups will often romanticise the communal nature of the Indigenous nations before colonisation, but neglect the primitive aspect of these communities. The groups that do this in the modern day often come from a postmodernist understanding of the world.

Finally, Mariategui writes on how the resolution to the Indigenous question is being developed. He states:

“The solution to the problem of the Indian must be a social solution. It must be worked out by the Indians themselves. This concept leads to seeing the meeting of Indigenous congresses as a historical fact. The Indigenous congresses have not yet formed a program, but they do represent a movement. They indicate that the Indians are beginning to gain a collective consciousness of their situation. The least important aspect of the Indian Congress is its deliberations and its votes. The transcendent, historic aspect is the congress itself. The congress is an affirmation of the will of the race to make their own claims.”14

Here, Mariategui emphasises that the liberation of the Indigenous nations cannot come from without, but must be the work of the Indigenous nations themselves. Further, he points to the convening of a congress by Indigenous activists to tackle the Indigenous question as showing the increasing consciousness of the Indigenous masses of their task. The actual results of the congress is inconsequential in comparison to the start of Indigenous organising. In Canada, we can see this as well. The Indigenous nations have increasingly been creating organisations to represent and fight for their interests, however these have often come under bourgeois leadership.

IV. Neoliberalism

The democratic revolutions in Europe were largely guided by the bourgeois philosophy of liberalism. Liberalism emerged out of the economic base of free market capitalism which was becoming principal in the feudalism-capitalism contradiction. The concentration of these free market ideas in the realm of politics produced the tenants of modern liberal-democracy such as emphasis on the individual, securlarism, rule of law, universal human rights and freedoms, etc. When free market capitalism degenerated into imperialism, the economic base that had produced liberalism had changed. The free market was replaced with monopolies, the bourgeoisie had gone from revolutionary to reactionary, among other changes. By the time of the great depression many imperialist countries adopted Keynesian economic policies which emphasised the need for a larger degree of direct and overt state involvement in the economy. Keynesianism was an attempt by the bourgeoisie to prevent the economic crises endemic to capitalism. The Keynesian myth was blown apart by the 1970s economic depression revealing that crisis is endemic to the capitalist mode of production. In response to this, an anti-Keynesian faction of the imperialists began to take hold in a number of countries such as Thatcher in the UK, Reagan in the US, and Brian Mulroney in Canada. These factions aimed to undo the economic restructuring of the post-great depression order in order to return to the liberalism of free-market capitalism. The issue with this is that the economic base of old style liberalism had disappeared with the birth of imperialism. By attempting to graft the political economy of free-market capitalism in the era of imperialism what was produced was neo-liberalism.

Neo-liberalism is not only being applied in the imperialist countries, but also in the oppressed nations. As Chairman Gonzalo explains:

“Like their imperialist masters, weighed down by their ideology which becomes more rotten everyday and lacking in perspective, they have no other choice but to raise banners from the 18th and early 19th Century — such as liberalism. If, on the other hand, these banners were already dirty rags by the time of the 1st World War, as has already been demonstrated, then socialism really does represents the future. Meanwhile, capitalism is a corpse, and like so many corpses, needs to be buried.”1

The imperialists make use of institutions like the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank to deepen and extend neo-liberal reforms throughout the oppressed nations. In doing so, they are generally favouring the comprador bourgeoisie over the bureaucratic bourgeoisie. Chairman Gonzalo explains:

“they impose as a main condition, that Peru submit to the Yankee plans to develop the market economy, their neo-liberalism so much in vogue today, and impose that Peru carry out a program of solid ‘structural adjustment’ and ‘structural reforms’ within those criteria, which constitutes an open violation of Peruvian sovereignty.”2

These reforms open up the economies more to plunder by the imperialists thereby deepening their colonial or semi-colonial status.

The Peru People’s Movement has further shown how neo-liberalism fits within the general counter-revolutionary offensive:

“This offensive has intended to sweep away the proletariat as a class, aiming at its heart, its ideology: marxism. In this way they sought to turn around the historical and political tendency of revolution. This general counterrevolutionary offensive in its zeal to dupe the unwary has spread such ideas as ‘capitalism is eternal’ and that the United States will take humanity to a ‘new age of peace’ and ‘stability’, that socialism and communism are ‘utopian’, that the dictatorship of the proletariat is ‘repressive’, that ‘marxism is obsolete’, and that we are witnessing the ‘end of ideology’, etc. They have deployed the so-called low-intensity warfare with the political objective of ‘legitimizing’ governments ‘through elections’ and promoting the so-called ‘human rights’. In the economic sphere they are applying ‘neoliberalism’, privatizations and are using religion as an organizational and ideological shield.”3

From this we can understand that neo-liberalism is forming the economic base of the current general counter-revolutionary offensive. The political and ideological expressions of this base take a variety of forms, however one common in the imperialist countries are post-modernism and libertarianism/anarcho-capitalism. The relation of libertarianism/anarcho-capitalism to neo-liberalism is very clear, neo-liberalism’s hailing of 18th century capitalist values of freedom individually and economically is concentrated in the libertarian/anarcho-capitalist calls for maximum freedom in these two spheres. They call for neo-liberalism policy of privitsation of state institutions and the artificial creation of markets without bounds. For the libertarian/anarcho-capitalist very little to nothing should be state-run. This line was a powerful one within the bourgeois “right” for much of the 2000s easily seen with the American Tea Party movement, but since the 2008 economic crisis it has dwindled in popularity.

While neo-liberal policies aim to favour the non-state monopoly faction of the bourgeoisie, this does not imply a split between finance capital and the state. The merger of state power and capital that marks the imperialist state is not undone through neo-liberal policies, but it is wielded differently.

V. Decay and Collapse of Revisionism

It is with Chairman Gonzalo that an understanding of the process of revisionism is first synthesised in 1991 in the document from the 2nd plenum of the PCP entitled Fundamentals of Political World Outlook. This document analyses the decay and collapse of revisionism across different formerly socialist and people’s democratic states and from this synthesises the general process of revisionism.

The first general principle is “the law that first the political power is usurped in order to change the social relations for exploitation, is being fulfilled” in the restoration of capitalism.1 Here the PCP bases themselves firmly in Maoism. Any revolution that is apart of the world proletarian revolution is unable to seize power without revolutionary violence, similarly if the old state wants to restore itself fully it requires the use of reactionary violence. This is because in neither case will the ruling class (proletarian or bourgeois or bureaucratic-feudal) peacefully allow for their removal of power. The proletarian revolution pushes toward the abolition of property whereas the reactionary classes aim to preserve it. Therefore in order for the the overthrown classes to reassert themselves they must be assisted by armed force. This has been seen in the USSR with Krushchev’s coup, in China with the Hua-Deng coup, in Democratic Kampuchea with the Vietnamese invasion, and in every other example in which restoration of capitalism or bureaucrat capitalism occurred.

The second general principal is the struggle between two factions of the bourgeoisie tied to two different paths of restoration. The first faction is the liberal-democratic faction that seeks rapid opening of the economy to the bourgeoisie. This is the faction that seized power in the USSR in 1956 and again came to power with Gorbachev. The second faction is the fascist faction that seeks to create a fascist system of government with a socialist face. The fascist faction generally restores capitalism and liberal-democratic norms over a longer period of time. Examples of the fascist faction holding power are the Brezhnev era of the USSR, China under Deng, and Albania following 1978. Both the fascist and the liberal-democratic factions are revisionist but they represent different interests within the same class. That is, their principal aim is to restore the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie and crush the popular classes. Secondarily their struggle to impose different systems of government. The fascist faction is generally tied to state-monopoly capitalism and corprativism whereas the liberal-democratic faction is generally tied to non-state-monopoly capitalism and parliamentarianism. The fascist faction has also shown an ability to learn from past mistakes with every collapse in order to slow the process of restoration. For example we can compare the relative rates of decay in the USSR, China, and Albania.

The third general principle is the general outline of the process of fascism. It is a movement from general decay toward collapse which coincides with the return of liberal-democratic norms. The process generally begins with a stage of fascism following the seizure of power. As the restoration of capitalism deepens, that is the growth of the non-state monopoly, multipartyism, etc. the relative strength of the liberal-democratic faction increases until the eventual collapse of revisionism and restoration of liberal-democracy as the system of government.

Notes

B. Scientific Socialism

XI. Proletarian Feminism

1. Marxism, Mariategui, and the Women’s Movement

XII. Reconstitution of the Communist Party

1. https://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-interview-with-chairman-gonzalo/

2. https://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-develop-the-peoples-war-serving-the-world-revolution-2/

3. https://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-develop-the-construction-mainly-of-the-party-serving-the-armed-struggle/

XIII. Analysis of Low-Intensity Warfare

1. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-elections-no-peoples-war-yes/

2. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-may-the-strategic-stalemate-shake-the-country-more/

3. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-may-the-strategic-stalemate-shake-the-country-more/

C. Political Economy

I. Generalisation and Expansion of Bureaucrat Capitalism

1. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-4/mswv4_24.htm

2. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_23.htm#p3

3. http://the-red-flag.org/en/chairman-gonzalo-the-national-question/

4. http://the-red-flag.org/en/chairman-gonzalo-the-national-question/

5. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-retake-mariategui-and-reconstitute-his-party/

6. https://the-red-flag.org/en/interview-with-the-daily/

7. https://the-red-flag.org/en/bases-of-discussion/

8. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_26.htm

9. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_26.htm

10. https://the-red-flag.org/en/on-the-rectification-campaign/

11. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-may-the-strategic-stalemate-shake-the-country-more/

12. Fundamental Political Questions, PCP

II. Expanded Definition of Fascism

1. https://maydaystudentorganization.com/2019/11/18/the-ideologues-of-reaction-by-jose-carlos-mariategui/

2. https://maydaystudentorganization.com/2019/11/18/the-ideologues-of-reaction-by-jose-carlos-mariategui/

3. https://maydaystudentorganization.com/2019/11/18/the-ideologues-of-reaction-by-jose-carlos-mariategui/

4. https://maydaystudentorganization.com/2019/11/18/the-ideologues-of-reaction-by-jose-carlos-mariategui/

5. https://maydaystudentorganization.com/2019/11/18/the-ideologues-of-reaction-by-jose-carlos-mariategui/

6. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-retake-mariategui-and-reconstitute-his-party/

7. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/dimitrov/works/1935/08_02.htm

8. Uphold the Red Flag of the Communist International and its 7th Congress, Communist Party of Brazil (Red Fraction)

9. http://the-red-flag.org/en/chairman-gonzalo-the-national-question/

10. Uphold the Red Flag of the Communist International and its 7th Congress, Communist Party of Brazil (Red Fraction)

III. Indigenous Question

1. https://www.marxists.org/archive/mariateg/works/7-interpretive-essays/essay03.htm

2. https://www.marxists.org/archive/mariateg/works/7-interpretive-essays/essay03.htm

3. https://www.marxists.org/archive/mariateg/works/7-interpretive-essays/essay03.htm

4. Howard Adams, Prison of Grass

5. Jose Carlos Mariategui, Peru’s Principal Problem

6. Jose Carlos Mariategui, Peru’s Principal Problem

7. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Problem of Race in Latin America

8. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Land Problem

9. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Land Problem

10. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Land Problem

11. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Destiny of North America

12. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Destiny of North America

13. Jose Carlos Mariategui, The Problem of Race in Latin America

14. Jose Carlos Mariategui, Peru’s Principal Problem

IV. Neo-liberalism

1. http://the-red-flag.org/uncategorized/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-on-the-rectification-campaign-with-elections-no-peoples-war-yes/

2. http://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-concerning-the-two-hills/

3. http://the-red-flag.org/en/peru-peoples-movement-the-peoples-war-in-peru-is-leaving-the-bend-in-the-road-under-chairman-gonzalos-leadership-and-all-powerful-thought/

V. Decay and Collapse of Revisionism

1. https://the-red-flag.org/en/central-committee-of-the-communist-party-of-peru-2nd-plenum-fundamentals-of-political-world-outlook/


Responses to “Gonzalo Thought: Parts 6-8 – By Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)”

  1. Translation: Gonzalo Düşüncesinin – Kanada Komünist Partisi (Kızıl Fraksiyon) Tarafindan – The People's Hammer

    […] Repost: Gonzalo Thought Parts 6-8 – By CPC(RF) […]

    Like

  2. The Alliance of Sahel States is not Anti-Imperialist – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

    […] 8 The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) has published a summary of bureaucrat capitalism and these two factions of the big bourgeoisie in the oppressed nations. The comprador faction is associated with non-state monopoly capitalism while the bureaucrat faction is associated with state-monopoly capitalism https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/repost-gonzalo-thought-parts-6-8-by-cpcrf/ […]

    Like

  3. Socialism of the 21st Century, a New Path for Oppressed Nations? – By Beatrix – The People's Hammer
  4. State Intervention in the Steel Industry – By Daniel H. – The People's Hammer
  5. L’Alliance des États du Sahel n’est pas anti-impérialiste – par Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

    […] 8 Le Parti communiste du Canada (Fraction rouge) a publié un résumé du capitalisme bureaucratique et de ces deux factions de la grande bourgeoisie dans les nations opprimées. La faction compradore est associée au capitalisme monopolistique non étatique, tandis que la faction bureaucratique est associée au capitalisme monopolistique d’État https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/repost-gonzalo-thought-parts-6-8-by-cpcrf/ […]

    Like

  6. The “(N)CPC” and Independence from the State – By Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

    […] They have also produced a longer explanation of neoliberalism that can be found here: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/repost-gonzalo-thought-parts-6-8-by-cpcrf/ […]

    Like