The People's Hammer

Leadership and Opposition in the Context of the Two-Line Struggle – By Maoist Perspective

, ,


The following article is a repost from Maoist Perspective (
Maoist Perspektif). It can be found in its original Turkish here: https://maoistperspektif.com/iki-cizgi-mucadelesi-baglaminda-onderlik-ve-muhalefet/

– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer

“Nature is the testing ground of dialectics, and in honor of modern natural science, which provides this testing ground with an ever-growing harvest of facts, we must say that it thereby proves that in the final analysis, everything in nature happens not metaphysically but dialectically — that nature does not move in the eternal monotony of a perpetually repeating cycle, but undergoes a real history.”


(Friedrich Engels, Anti-Dühring, Sol Publications – p. 62)

The Anti-Dühring quote cited at the beginning of this article is of great significance for the topic we will be addressing. While Engels refers to Darwin in the excerpt above, we too, by this occasion, commemorate both Darwin and the principal struggle for communists.

At the heart of this principal struggle stood Eugen Dühring and those sympathetic to his ideas within the German Social Democrats. Engels took action to eliminate these bourgeois tendencies that had infiltrated the social democratic ranks. While attempting to construct his own system, Dühring tried to introduce bourgeois modes of thought—especially metaphysical and idealist approaches—into the party. Thus, Engels had to engage in both a theoretical critique (polemics) and a political struggle.

In the face of this bourgeois ideology gaining serious ground within the party, Wilhelm Liebknecht requested Engels’ support. In response, Engels developed an external opposition to the party through the writing of Anti-Dühring. However, Engels found support only among Liebknecht and the lower ranks of the Social Democratic Party. The party leadership at the time, including the first generation of Marxists (Bernstein, Bebel, Most, and Fritsche), took a negative stance toward Engels. In fact, they even attempted to censor the publication of Anti-Dühring in the party’s press organ, Vorwärts.

This attitude toward Engels, one of the founding figures of Marxism, was a reflection of the political struggle’s realities. Although the German socialists identified themselves as Marxists, the ideas they advocated were in fact reflections of bourgeois thought and the ideological influence of Eugen Dühring. The opposition to Engels and the attempts at censorship reveal how some of the early Marxist cadres of that time had already begun to drift ideologically. However, with the emergence of scientific truth, this deviation was prevented from spreading into the broader class struggle and helped the German socialists regroup.

Engels stood out as someone who could establish a strong opposition within the socialist movement and who maintained the correct line in the face of illusions contrary to scientific reality. Anti-Dühring, which systematically presents the philosophical, economic, and political dimensions of Marxism, remains one of the key works that bequeaths this understanding to us. In all circumstances, maintaining a scientific approach—and grounding opposition in scientific principles—has been, and must continue to be, one of the core principles for Marxists. Lenin, Stalin, and Mao did not neglect this scientific principle in their inner-party struggles over political line. Whether in positions of leadership or in opposition, they acted based on scientific reality throughout history. For this reason, their perspectives within the class struggle today remain both real and scientific. The development of opposition within the party and the transformation of contradictions into antagonisms leading to splits are among the contradictions that must be analyzed within communist movements. We too aim to present our thoughts as thoroughly as possible in this light.

From Social Contradictions to Intra-Party Contradictions

The economic structure of social contradictions determines the character of classes. Each class approaches social events and phenomena through its own segments, contradictions, and ways of life. These contradictions inherently carry a progressive content. The oppressed, upon experiencing alienation, enter a comprehensive process of analysis filled with contradictions. This situation becomes evident not only for the oppressed but also for intermediate classes during periods of economic upheaval.

However, economic shocks do not always lead to an immediate reaction from society. For example, in Turkey and Northern Kurdistan, the earthquake that occurred alongside the economic crisis created expectations for a rapid social response. We generally foresee this response taking one of two forms: either a spontaneous movement or the organized intervention of the communist party. If the communist party fails to develop an organized response, we then expect a spontaneous movement to emerge. If this too fails to materialize, the reason must be sought in the ingrained habits within the social consciousness of the people (in a state of persistence). Often, society’s inertia is criticized. Yet at this point, the true inertia lies with the communist party itself.

“Modern socialism, in terms of its content, is above all the product, on the one hand, of the awareness of the class antagonisms prevailing between possessors and non-possessors, between wage-workers and capitalists in modern society, and on the other hand, of the anarchy reigning in production.”
(Friedrich Engels, Anti-Dühring, p. 55, Sol Publications)

This awareness expresses the ability to grasp and guide the inter-class contradictions and the current social dynamics they produce. This is not merely a matter of being organized; it is a fundamental condition of being a genuine communist party. Therefore, reacting cannot be explained solely by the existence of organizational structures. In this context, communist parties exist within the social contradictions created by the economic structure, and they also experience these contradictions within their own ranks. For this reason, it is not possible for a party to have a monolithic structure. Indeed, since the party is not a uniform whole, every individual who joins from different classes and strata brings their own contradictions with them, making the party a composite of diverse contradictions.

Even though the proletariat forms the backbone of the communists, under certain conditions this majority may fall into a minority position within the party hierarchy. This contradictory picture is a reflection of economic development, and from it a vanguard content can emerge.

Mao, by stating “All classes, strata, and social groups that support, uphold, and work for the cause of socialist construction belong to the category of the people,” draws attention to this dialectical relationship. If these dialectical conditions are ignored, metaphysical structures can arise in the dynamic spaces within the party. Lenin saw the tendency among representatives of the German Social Democrats to shift the struggle into the bourgeois sphere. To prevent a similar tendency from developing among the Russian Social Democrats, he argued that the revolutionary struggle had to be conducted on Marxist foundations with a strong cadre and a clear cadre perspective.

(Mao Zedong, Selected Works, Vol. 5, p. 419, Kaynak Publications)

The vanguard exists to ensure that the backbone of the party is organized and capable of self-governance. If the vanguard lacks this content, the movement rests on different foundations. Communist parties have frequently experienced such contradictions throughout history. For example, within the German Social Democrats, a “bourgeois majority” gave rise to a labor aristocracy. These tendencies, which sought to revise Marxism in order to preserve their own class character—disconnected from the essence of Marxism—only reinforced this situation. Conversely, opposition factions within the party also bring their own contradictions. Engels, for instance, directed his criticism not only at the leadership of the German Social Democrats but also at opposition groups of similar nature. İbrahim Kaypakkaya’s emergence is another such example, representing a rupture both from the deviations of the leadership of his time and from the corresponding errors of the internal opposition.

Communist parties are not structures independent of or purified from social contradictions—nor can they ever be. Urban, peasant, and intellectual strata all exist within the workers’ party. Even if they claim to have abandoned their class character, they may once again display their backward traits over time or come to dominate the party through the rise of bureaucratism. As long as privileged classes exist in society, it is inevitable that such elements will emerge within the communist party. To say, “No, this is impossible!” is to drift away from scientific reality. Throughout history, we have seen bureaucratism develop within communist parties and even observed the emergence of privileged class elements within them. Had these examples not occurred, Mao would not have become the subject of a “qualitative leap in the scientific sense,” nor would the Soviet Union have collapsed.

Today, similar problems and conditions continue to exist. This does not demonstrate the backwardness of communists or a flaw in the scientific character of Marxism; on the contrary, it reflects the concrete reality of Marxism’s scientific nature. The struggle continues at this point. That is why we began by recalling Engels’ struggle. Even though the struggle develops by pushing forward and backward, a strong substance capable of standing on its own feet is forged amid these stumbles. Marx and Engels explain this situation as follows:

“The proletariat and wealth are opposites. As opposites, they form a whole. Both are products of the world of private property. The question is which specific position each occupies within this contradiction. It is not enough to say they are two sides of a whole. As private property, as wealth, private property must maintain its own existence and, for that reason, must also maintain the existence of its opposite, the proletariat. Private property, which has found satisfaction in itself, is the positive side of the contradiction. In contrast, the proletariat, as proletariat, must abolish itself and, in doing so, also abolish its opposite—which makes it a proletariat—namely, private property. The proletariat is the heart of the contradiction, the sorrow within it, the vanished and self-abolishing private property. The propertied class and the proletarian class represent the same human alienation. But the former sees in this alienation a confirmation of itself, it sees its own power and finds in it a semblance of human existence; while the latter feels itself destroyed in this alienation, sees its own powerlessness and the reality of an inhuman existence. To borrow a phrase from Hegel, it is rebellion in the midst of degradation. What makes its human essence a contradiction with its condition in life is the contradiction’s clear, definite, and comprehensive negation of that essence, which inevitably drives it to revolt. Within this contradiction, then, the owner of private property is the conservative party, the proletariat the destructive party. The activity that preserves and sustains the contradiction comes from the former; the activity that destroys it, from the latter.”
(The Holy Family, Marx & Engels, pp. 60–61, Sol Publications)

In light of the above quote, this contradictory situation may also manifest within the party as a struggle over political line.

In general terms, the struggle between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie also occurs, in a narrower sense, within the party itself. If the relationship between leadership and opposition is not properly addressed, it can transform into either a “conservative” or a “destructive” element. In such a situation, an intense struggle within the party becomes inevitable. On this matter, Mao emphasizes the importance of line struggle by stating: “Without ideological struggle, there can be no clarity and depth, and that is not a good thing.”

If struggles over political line are not grounded in ideology, and if the distinction between right and wrong is not made according to scientific criteria, the conflict may become irreconcilable. Such antagonistic contradictions are often the product of metaphysical conditions stemming from bureaucratism. The party leadership must not shy away from using correct ideas as a driving force to guide incorrect or mistaken thoughts toward self-criticism.

(Mao Zedong, Selected Works, Vol. 5, p. 240, Kaynak Publications)

On the other hand, instead of simply asserting “there are only two lines of struggle,” the essential task is to examine the dynamics of these two lines, how they should be addressed, and how the deepening struggle between leadership and opposition can be channeled in favor of the class struggle. Mao acted in this spirit and, when necessary, even encouraged the masses to oppose and mobilize against the party.

At the same time, a communist party that merely accepts the existence of internal opposition under the label of “democratism,” and that praises “two-line struggle” without any connection to its essence, in reality harbors a bureaucratic organization and leadership. Those who adopt this stance have strayed from the core of communism.

“Trotsky says the party does not make mistakes. This is wrong. The party frequently makes mistakes. Ilyich [Lenin] taught us that the party must learn to lead correctly on the basis of its own mistakes. If the party never made mistakes, there would be nothing from which the party could learn. Our task is to identify these mistakes, expose their roots, and show the party and the working class what mistakes we made and how we can avoid them in the future. Without this, the development of the party would be impossible. Without this, the training of party leaders and cadres would be impossible, because they are educated and formed through the struggle against their own mistakes and by overcoming them…”
(J.V. Stalin, On Opposition, Vol. 1, p. 79, İnter Publications)

Reducing internal divisions in the party to personal faults or minor differences of opinion makes it harder to grasp the essence of the issue. The task of communist parties is not to ignore these contradictions, but to resolve them within the framework of scientific method and revolutionary praxis. The contradiction between leadership and opposition must be evaluated based on which class interests it serves and which revolutionary line it strengthens. Therefore, inner-party democracy should neither be absolutized nor strictly rejected; what matters is creating a dialectical unity that preserves the revolutionary essence and ultimate goals of the proletariat. This can only be achieved by theoretically internalizing and practically applying Marxism-Leninism-Maoism (MLM).

Ignoring social contradictions and the course of class struggle inevitably gives rise to a “cult of the leader.” Those who do not conform to what the leader says are labeled anti-party, and the opposition may face increasingly harsh repercussions. If banning all forms of party opposition or unconditionally encouraging every form of dissent is done without evaluating whether it serves revolutionary aims, the party will inevitably regress.

However, when addressed on the correct basis and in the light of the dialectical method, internal opposition can help clarify the party’s revolutionary line and eliminate incorrect tendencies. The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution can be cited as an example in this context. Conversely, approaches that are unscientific, sectarian, dogmatic, or liberal in the sense of “all opposition is good” may sharpen contradictions and weaken the party.

Qualified opposition also reflects the development of the party in the class struggle. The internal struggles of the Bolsheviks after the revolution are an example of this. Likewise, the line struggle led by Lenin and the Bolsheviks before the revolution clearly illustrates what qualified opposition should look like. Engels’ struggle through Anti-Dühring within German social democracy also demonstrates how internal party contradictions, if not channeled in a revolutionary direction, can lead to fragmentation. Lenin’s Bolshevik-Menshevik split, Mao’s internal line struggles within the party, and Stalin’s battle against internal factions can all be understood as dialectical expressions of such contradictions.

In the Footsteps of Line Struggle: Lenin in the Intra-Party Struggle

The Bolshevik Revolution has always held a significant place for us—not only due to its exhilarating aspects but also because it represented a “step of hope” for the liberation of humanity. This enthusiasm provided us with a constant drive throughout the struggle. However, the difficulties of the revolution, the internal party struggles, and many other aspects often remained secondary or marginal topics. We usually only became aware of these aspects when confronted with a “malfunction” (that is, a theoretical or organizational inconsistency), and when faced with an unexpected contradiction, we often fall into shock and quickly stumble.

Yet, foreseeing the possible shortcomings that might arise during the implementation of any revolutionary theory or organizational model, and developing solutions to address them, should be a natural part of the struggle process. If we find it difficult to believe from the outset that such malfunctions can occur, we will also struggle to fulfill even the minimum requirements of revolutionary activity.

It is necessary to learn from the negative aspects as well as the positive ones. When utopian tendencies dominate or excessive confidence takes hold, it can lead to a rapid collapse in the face of adversity. This is one of the dangers of constantly emphasizing only the positive aspects. Learning the hardships of struggle requires being prepared for everything—from how an activist behaves during detention to internal organizational friction.

That’s why when we examine Lenin’s inner-party struggle, we see how complex—and at the same time instructive—the problems encountered truly were. It is useful to recall Lenin’s efforts to maintain unity among the Russian Social Democrats and the developments during the Bolshevik-Menshevik split. These experiences remain instructive today, offering guidance on how to navigate inner-party conflicts and where potential pitfalls lie.

Lenin fought hard to ensure unity among the Russian Social Democrats. His foremost priority was to eliminate any obstacle to the advancement of the working-class struggle. However, this unity was not easily achieved. Following the Second Congress of the party, the Mensheviks’ subversive actions—such as forming a secret factional leadership within the party and persistently obstructing the implementation of congress decisions—led to a deepening crisis. Lenin tried to act in the right direction against the Menshevik opposition, but due to the Mensheviks’ uncompromising and destructive stance, their harsh accusations against Lenin, and attempts at expulsion, a definitive split between the Bolsheviks and Mensheviks became inevitable.

*(Toward the end of the party congress, the “Iskra” opposition—consisting of the Economists and Bund supporters—had left the Congress, leaving Martov’s supporters in the minority. This enabled Lenin to form the editorial board of the central publication and the composition of the Central Committee in a way that ensured ideological coherence and practical leadership. See: Selected Works, Vol. 1, p. 38, İnter Publications.)

In one of his letters, Lenin described the split as follows:

“Dear comrades, we are unable to convene the editorial board to respond to your question, so I see no harm in replying to you in my own name. The Zurich Bolshevik group asks us, ‘What is our attitude toward the central organ and the Central Committee—do we regard them as legitimate bodies acting illegitimately, and are we in opposition to them, or do we completely reject their status as central party organs?’ … The central bodies (the central organ, the Central Committee, and the Council) have broken with the party, sabotaged the 2nd and 3rd Congresses, deceived the party in the most disgraceful way, and seized their petty offices in a Bonapartist manner. How can their legitimacy be upheld? Is a swindler who forges documents to get some money the rightful owner of it? So what are we to do? Convene the 3rd Congress? Even in this regard, we were deceived. There is only one thing left to do: to separate from the Mensheviks as completely, as quickly, and as sharply as possible (openly, in front of everyone)… I repeat, the central bodies have placed themselves outside the party. There is no middle ground: who stands with the central bodies? Who stands with the party? The time has come to separate and to respond openly to the Mensheviks’ provocations—unlike them, who secretly split the party: yes to a split, because you have already carried out the split to its end. Yes to a split, because we have exhausted all deadlines and all remedies proposed by the party decision (by the 3rd Congress)…”
(Lenin, Letter to the Zurich Bolshevik Group, Geneva, 18.01.1905 – Collected Works Vol. 5)

Lenin found it increasingly difficult to maintain unity in the party due to constant disruptions from the opposition. Plekanov, initially considered one of the most prominent Marxists in Russia and in the party, had aligned himself with the Bolsheviks. However, during a meeting of the “League Abroad,” tensions escalated after harsh accusations by Menshevik spokesman Martov against Lenin. Plekanov began to move closer to the Menshevik position. He insisted on including Martov and Axelrod on the editorial board of Iskra, and when this demand was made, Lenin resigned from the board. He then began organizing the opposition within the party to convene the Third Congress. In the process, he faced numerous intrigues and was briefly expelled from the Central Committee as a disciplinary measure for his efforts to convene the Congress. Following these events, he authored one of his most important works on internal party struggles and crises: One Step Forward, Two Steps Back. Although the Mensheviks tried to block its publication, they failed. After the split, Lenin proved that the Mensheviks were acting opportunistically in political terms and had deviated from Marxism. The factional disputes abroad and the self-centered attitude of many social democrats became a serious challenge for him.

Lenin explains the situation as follows:

“Is the party an ideological and material force organized intelligently enough to act as the true leader of the revolutionary working-class movement in our country? The refugee minority abroad, through all its actions, answers: no! And they continue to act this way with confidence, relying on Russia’s distance, the frequent changes of militants here, and the irreplaceability of their own leading-writer cadre.”
(Lenin, On the Split, pp. 67–68, Yar Publications)

Similarly:

“The sense of isolation in Russia and the stifling atmosphere of the émigré swamp have such a heavy impact here that living contact with Russia is our only salvation.”
(Lenin, On the Split, p. 116, Yar Publications)

After the split, Lenin continued to struggle against internal opposition emerged in the Bolsheviks and differing views without compromising on scientific principles. By defending Marxism against metaphysical ideas, he sharpened the Bolsheviks’ class struggle. Scientific approaches allowed the Bolsheviks to grow stronger both theoretically and practically within the working class. In this context, tendencies such as Liquidationism, Otzovism, and Ultimatism were all manifestations of class struggle within the party. In these line struggles, Lenin pursued a Marxist direction and method, demonstrating that Marxism was a real, scientific, and political orientation not only in Russia but worldwide. Marxism was advancing, and the proletariat was developing itself through its vanguard role.

Lenin summarized the situation in a letter to Maxim Gorky on April 11, 1910:

“It is revolting to sit in the midst of this strife and scandal, this torment and murky froth… At the same time, observing all this is also disgusting. But one must not give in to moods. Emigration is a hundred times more suffocating than it was before the revolution. Strife and factionalism are inseparable in exile; but the strife and factionalism will vanish. In contrast, the party’s development and the progress of the social democratic movement continue relentlessly, overcoming all the cursed difficulties of the present. The party is advancing irresistibly on the path of purification from dangerous ‘deviations,’ from Liquidationism and Otzovism. We had already dealt with Otzovism ideologically before the Plenum; the matter of Liquidationism was not yet resolved at that time. The Mensheviks managed to conceal the snake for a while back then; but now the snake has been exposed, everyone sees it, and we will destroy it—and we will succeed.”
(Lenin, Selected Works, Vol. 1, pp. 64–65, Inter Publications)

During the same period, Machism—a trend akin to Dühring’s—inspired by Austrian physicist Ernst Mach, began to gain influence within the party. In response, Lenin published Materialism and Empirio-Criticism (Notes on a Reactionary Philosophy), successfully discrediting Machist tendencies within the Bolsheviks and simultaneously exposing the errors in Plekanov’s interpretations of Marxism.

In summary, Lenin:

  • Always conducted his struggle on Marxist foundations and applied the dialectical method within this framework.
  • Responded to all forms of opposition (even the defamation he faced during periods when he himself was in the opposition) with a scientific approach, rooted in the dialectical application of Marxism within the party.
  • Continuously reflected on how to advance the class struggle and worked tirelessly to maintain the party as an unshakable unity.
  • Viewed all internal opposition and divisions not as “disruptive” elements, but as natural reflections of social contradictions and class struggles.
  • Approached every crisis and split within the organization as part of historical and social processes, emphasizing the importance of critical assessment.
  • Refused to reduce internal party conflicts to personal or superficial differences, instead interpreting them as expressions of the broader class struggle.
  • Sought to expose deviations from Marxism through scientific analysis, explaining every faction and tendency that emerged within the Bolsheviks in terms of their economic and social roots.
  • Identified tendencies such as Liquidationism, Otzovism, Ultimatism, and Machism as hindrances to revolutionary class struggle and fought against them guided by dialectical materialism. He rejected tactics of “divide-dismantle-dissolve” in dealing with opposition.

Lenin’s experiences clearly show the critical importance of ideological clarity and a scientific approach in internal party debates. He sought to create the conditions for uniting forces inside and outside the party in ways that would serve the interests of the class struggle. Every phenomenon, for him, was part of a whole; even if deviations occurred, that unity could endure. The inability to preserve this unity within a rigid hierarchy did not necessarily mean total fragmentation. Lenin’s stance reveals his deep understanding and application of dialectical materialism.

Two-Line Struggle in the Shadow of Bureaucratism: The Consequences of Breaking Away from the Masses

Should the struggle serve the interests of the class or bureaucratic interests? Of course, it should serve the interests of the class! Yet opportunists do not hesitate to use the struggle for the benefit of bureaucratic interests. Ignoring the real issues, they cling to their desire to rule, obscuring genuine problems and deriving power from falsehoods. When they realize that structural change cannot be achieved through scientific debate, they resort to dissimulation to seize leadership. This is precisely what the term Menshevik signifies: those who avoided a line struggle with Lenin, who played shadow games through intrigue and scheming, concealing their true identities.

In general terms, a revisionist structure is in the minority within the leadership. This minority organizes itself in an effort to become the majority and focuses structurally on achieving such dominance. In order to change the programmatic line, it must establish comprehensive hegemony. Therefore, it adopts forms derived from the development of bourgeois contradictions and crafts new tactics accordingly. For example, it oversimplifies the issue of cadre becoming property-owners; under the guise of a “new world conjuncture,” it creates mass organizations built upon “balance theories.” In this view, the class struggle—being the main driving force of social development—is relegated to the background. This gives rise to the metaphysical problem of being “organizationally present.” Clarity in ideology and principles is suspended in favor of forms shaped by opportunist leadership.

In contrast, Mao states: “A clear distinction must be drawn between right and wrong, because the discussions of principles within the Party reflect the class struggle within society, and ambiguity on this matter should not be tolerated.” With this, he emphasizes steadfastness in principles. At this point, the historical elements of the communist party’s development begin to be systematically purged. It becomes the sharpest subject in the fight against dissent. It positions itself as the farthest left—left of the left. It clings most tightly to the very program it so desperately seeks to change.

When such a form of leadership arises within the party, inevitable consequences follow. For this minority leadership does not tolerate the existence of any other force; it absolutizes its own existence to the point of blindness. Rather than approaching opposition through ideological accumulation, it chooses the path of “divide, fragment, assimilate, and impose your own line.” Under such conditions, it is essential not to detach from ideological engagement in the two-line struggle. The opposition, too, must uphold this principle. Otherwise, approaches based on insult and scheming will flourish. However, where bureaucratism cannot be broken, bringing contradictions to the surface and clarifying the waters becomes impossible. Bureaucratism prefers murky waters. In such a context, splits become inevitable.

The two-line struggle and its development are closely tied to the movement of the masses. But without eliminating bureaucratism, a genuine two-line struggle cannot be realized. Any opposition that arises under such conditions will also develop as a reaction to the bureaucratic structure. This is why the struggle against opportunism and revisionism is extremely difficult. Oppositional forces that emerge in this process often rely on metaphysical arguments. The leadership, being in a minority, alienates itself from the party masses and frequently encounters “non-antagonistic” contradictions during its work; but these can evolve into “antagonistic” contradictions as various groupings emerge. This is precisely why the leadership remains in the position of a minority.

(Mao Zedong Selected Works, Volume 5, p. 326 – Kaynak Publishing)

On the other hand, it is also important to understand the various forms of opposition that may arise within the party. Because even with ideological clarity, if the connection with the masses is weak or if bureaucratism dominates the organizational structure, very different typologies of opposition may emerge.

Alienation, the Savior Figure, and Structures of Opposition

In the communist party, the alienation between the organization and the masses gives rise to a search for a “savior leader.” Individuals who have devoted years to the struggle, who have suffered and made sacrifices, are seen as natural saviors, and this leads to a surrender of will within the party. As a result, issues of disconnection from the masses and purges begin to emerge; concerns over security increase, the representativeness of existing cadres is neglected, and distrust toward the temporary leadership grows. A hidden desire for “cleansing” takes root, and “self-sacrificing” figures are sought out. In this ever-deepening atmosphere of distrust, the temporary leadership, unable to intervene effectively, retreats into its shell. Problems grow, but solutions shrink.

As centralization (authority) strengthens, the ties with the masses weaken. Decisions may appear implementable on paper, but they fail to have an impact within the lower-level organizations. Cadres who cannot address this disconnection internalize the sectarianism that centralization brings. The shortage of capable cadres results in the selection of individuals who are aligned with the center or who will not criticize it. Within the party line, the cadre issue goes undiscussed; the dominant atmosphere is one of mistrust. Those who offer criticism are met with hostility, distrust becomes mutual, and communication between the masses and the temporary leadership breaks down. Such a picture worsens either through the bureaucratization of democratic centralism or due to the negative conduct of current cadres. Under these conditions, the temporary leadership and current cadres, having become alienated from the party base, increasingly pursue the search for “external experts,” thereby further weakening their ties with the party.

Labor Aristocracy

Some structures that interpret tactical defeats as strategic collapse exhibit an individualistic and opportunist opposition under the guise of a “desire to search for the new.” These elements—often upwardly mobile from lower classes—know much but show no real presence in practice; they idealize their past struggles or former class backgrounds and consider themselves “advanced.” In order to secure their own positions, they establish ties with both the opposition and the leadership; during times of crisis or cadre shortages, they attempt to obtain positions. Bureaucratism offers them a space to become “important figures.” When they rise to leadership, their careerist nature leads them into constant friction, and when they become the target of opposition, they resort to individualism and try to disappear. However, when in leadership positions, they behave like “paper tigers.”

Lenin’s statement—“The refugee minority abroad… relying on their irreplaceability due to the inability to replace their leading and editorial cadres, continues to behave in this manner with a sense of security”—points directly to this phenomenon. Holding authority becomes their primary goal.

Tradition

The long-standing experience of the Communist Party has created a strong tradition within the party. Some groups that draw upon this tradition can quickly gain mass support, seeking a synthesis for current conditions by affirming past leaderships. During periods of regression or similar phases, certain opposition groups emerge and frame their criticisms within this traditional template. It is common to see the past glorified and every political situation assessed through outdated approaches, resulting in an imitative opposition that fails to engage with the present.

At times, even the temporary leadership can fall into this mindset; backward and unprincipled elements are excessively exalted. This often develops as a result of bureaucratism, nurtured by opportunist and careerist factions. At the same time, the temporary leadership itself may become part of this process. Rumors and false information spread, past events are distorted or made ambiguous. In such an atmosphere of distrust, a minority within the temporary leadership can gain strength.

Similarities

There are also structures that, despite directing their criticism at the leadership, are in fact very similar to it. These factions, which differ ideologically only slightly, are solely focused on seizing power. They adopt a destructive stance that inevitably leads to splits, gaining support from individuals capable of offering valid critiques but unable to form an organized opposition. Though they impose principles, they act without principles when their own interests are at stake. They frequently replicate the very practices they oppose and accelerate fragmentation through factional activities. Individuals who have long been absent from the struggle may come to the fore during such times, and the resulting split is often harsh and exhausting.

Additionally, careerists chasing after status behave as follows: if the leadership is on the right, they side with the opposition. They subtly echo rhetoric about “cleansing.” During splits, they maintain a central position while also supporting the opposition. They act “more oppositional than the opposition” in the face of wrongdoings. When divisions occur, they position themselves in the vacant seats, claiming the role of a “savior.” However, they quickly lose direction or follow a path resembling the very behavior they previously criticized. They are barren both theoretically and practically. They adopt the mentality of managerial authority. Although they seem unwilling to take responsibility in any field, they are constantly on the lookout for positions—playing the “I don’t want it, but put it in my left pocket” game. They appear uncompromising, but once they gain a position, their opposition dissipates. Rather than through political clarity, they derive power from structural relationships. They sanctify the party and recreate themselves within the spiral of bureaucratism.

All these examples are reflections of the interaction between the party and the masses, leadership style, and bureaucratic tendencies. The degeneration of principles, the stagnation of work areas, and the spread of bureaucratic and liberal attitudes give rise to the typologies described above. This is also why breakaways from the communist party are a recurring phenomenon. Moreover, the fact that these splits are not program-based stems from the same root cause.

The opportunist line of temporary leadership produces this situation and deepens the purging process by feeding bureaucratism. Therefore, to continually raise the question “How can we overthrow bureaucratism?” and to develop a line of advancement in this direction is of vital importance for today’s communist parties. Without breaking bureaucratism, internal splits become an unavoidable reality, and the party cannot escape the whirlpools of liquidation.

To conclude, in Lenin’s own words:

“The proletarian, as an individual, is nothing. All his strength, all his development, all his hopes and expectations lie in the organization, in the systematic action carried out together with his comrades. He feels strong and great only when he sees himself as a part of a strong and great organism. This organism is fundamental to him; the individual means very little in comparison to it. As a part of the nameless masses, the proletarian fights wherever he is assigned, with complete devotion and voluntary discipline that envelops his entire being and thought, without seeking any personal gain or fame.”
(V. I. Lenin, One Step Forward, Two Steps Back, Sol Publications, p.157)

Footnotes

[1] This text was originally published as a series of articles.
[2] Mensheviks: The minority faction. Known for remaining in the minority during the Second Congress and later referred to as “the minority” in intra-party struggles. Figures such as Martov, Trotsky, and Axelrod led in secrecy.
[3] Bolsheviks: Means “majority.” This group, which gained a majority at the Second Congress (notably the Iskra newspaper group), saw its program adopted by other factions and thus became the majority.
[4] Liquidationists: A tendency that rejected illegal organization.
[5] Otzovism: Literally means “recall.” A faction advocating the withdrawal of deputies from the Duma.
[6] Ultimatism: Another tendency that entirely rejected the Duma or opposed any form of engagement with it.

This article was first published in Maoist Perspektif (Maoist Perspective) journal.