The People's Hammer

Sean Orr’s Election Shows Bankruptcy of Electoralism – By Daniel H.

, , ,


On April 5, two “left” candidates won seats in the Vancouver City Council by-election. Both of these candidates, Sean Orr and Lucy Maloney are associated with “left” and “right” splits from the Coalition of Progressive Electors (COPE) respectively. COPE has been the principal “left” party in Vancouver since it was founded with backing from the union bureaucracy, independent unions, Trotskyists, the progressive petite-bourgeoisie, and many other “communist” parties and organisations.

The Democratic Socialists of Vancouver was not a formal split from COPE, but included many of its “left” members and had support from some other left-wing groups such as the Vancouver Workers Assembly who had just prior to the 2022 election split from the “Communist Party of Canada”.1 COPE, Maloney’s party OneCity Vancouver, and Sean Orr’s party DSV all essentially share a common programme with minor disagreements surrounding personalities separating them.2

Recently, supporters of The People’s Hammer met members of Socialist Action who took great offense to the idea that DSV, COPE, and OneCity are social-democratic parties. They argued that DSV was a genuine socialist party, seemingly on the basis that they are active participants. This defence of DSV was exposed as a sham in this year’s by-election. Yes, these parties ran against each other in 2022. Yes, DSV has ‘socialist’ in their name and the all-important support of Socialist Action. Even with such a principled basis, Sean Orr was run as a COPE candidate on a COPE platform with the DSV’s full support.

The DSV has justified this heel-turn by citing Mayor Ken Sim’s A Better City party’s sweep in the 2022 election. They argue that because of this, what is needed is a “united front” and “left unity”3 – an open liquidation of the united front from a fighting alliance of the oppressed classes under proletarian leadership aimed at the seizure of power to an electoral alliance.

Orr’s election will no doubt invigorate some reformists who will see it as validating their strategy. We need to look at these results more deeply than the fact that a self-described socialist was elected to the city council. Orr was elected, but in order to be elected he had to further liquidate his programme and run as a COPE candidate.

For communists, participation in elections is not mainly about securing reforms. It is about using this period when the masses are openly discussing and debating politics, to agitate them for communism. Running communist candidates and running boycott campaigns have been the two options communists in Canada have chosen between depending on the concrete conditions of the time. Before the liquidation of the Communist Party of Canada in 1943, the two would often be combined with boycotts or spoiled ballots organised where the party was weak. Since then, In Struggle carried out a large-scale “spoil your ballot” campaign in response to the 1980 Quebec independence referendum.

Regardless of the specific form communists have chosen to engage with bourgeois elections, wide-spread communist agitation has always been the purpose. Running a socialist under a liquidated programme of a non-socialist party is the exact opposite of this. They may succeed in electing a candidate, but because they liquidate their politics to do so then they are unable to develop class consciousness. Because holding office is the most important point of the reformist strategy, this socialist cannot fight for socialism once elected as they rely on the support of the petite-bourgeoisie for their seat. They can keep claiming to be a socialist all they want, but if it talks like a social-democrat and walks like a social-democrat…

There is no need to speculate on the bankruptcy of DSV’s strategy. It is a well chartered course throughout the international workers movement and can be seen in Canada through the continued liquidation of the New Democratic Party (NDP) from the 1933 Canadian Commonwealth Federation (CCF) Regina Manifesto4 to today5. The CCF, the predecessor of the NDP, at the time was a party of farmers and the union bureaucracy that aimed to achieve socialism, or a “cooperative commonwealth” through elections. Because of this, the CCF constantly had to purge its “left” to make itself more appealing to the bourgeoisie leading to massive liquidation of its programme in the Cold War in the form of the Winnipeg Declaration.6 In the founding of the NDP by the Canadian Labour Congress and the CCF, it was transformed into a party of the union bureaucracy, labour aristocracy, and the petite-bourgeoisie. Over the next several decades, the NDP made compromise after compromise and the demand for socialism faded to the background in order to broaden their electoral base and win more seats. Under Mulcair they officially abandoned socialism7 and are today mainly based among the urban petite-bourgeoisie while the union bureaucracy are increasingly abandoning the party.8

The NDP has held government in many provinces and has held key positions of support in different parliaments to keep a Liberal government afloat. Despite this, they have never attempted to implement the relatively “left” goals of 1933 as they see holding on to their seats as more important than serving the class.

This is the path of any electoral “socialist” party. It always tails the bourgeoisie as it requires their support to form government and carry through their strategy. By the time that support comes, the party has been entirely hollowed out in to just another liberal party with some hammer and sickles or red roses as decoration.

The workers have only ever been betrayed by Sean Orr-type parties. Our class will only realise its class interests when united under the leadership of the reconstituted Communist Party of Canada. This party will not rely on bourgeois support and will not hollow out its programme to secure seats in parliament. It will lead our class in socialist revolution.

1 This organisation emerged with a number of others following this party’s protection of the abuser Jay Watts: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2022/06/29/communist-party-of-canada-protects-abuser-jay-watts/

2 Members of the Communist Workers Front (Organising Committee) in BC wrote the following criticism of the DSV in the last general municipal elections: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2022/10/12/submission-against-the-democratic-socialists-of-vancouver-boycott-the-elections/

3 https://votesocialist.ca

4 https://www.socialisthistory.ca/Docs/CCF/ReginaManifesto.htm

5 On the state of the NDP in Toronto: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/25/report-from-an-ndp-conference-by-mels-g-cynthia-m/

6 https://www.socialisthistory.ca/Docs/CCF/Winnipeg.htm

7 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-votes-to-take-socialism-out-of-party-constitution-1.1385171

8 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/21/the-ontario-election-and-growing-division-in-the-labour-movement-by-daniel-h/


Response to “Sean Orr’s Election Shows Bankruptcy of Electoralism – By Daniel H.”

  1. Albertan NDP Splits from National Party – By Daniel H. – The People's Hammer