The “American Communist Party” (“ACP”) was founded in the summer of 2024.1 Those who are not familiar with this party by name may be familiar with the movement behind it. Over the past couple years, a social-fascist and nationalist movement in the United States has been developing within the American communist movement whose two most prominent labels have been “patriotic socialism” and the more sensational “MAGA Communism”.
As Lenin points out in What Is To Be Done?:
“Incidentally, in the history of modern socialism this is a phenomenon, perhaps unique and in its way very consoling, namely, that the strife of the various trends within the socialist movement has from national become international. Formerly, the disputes between Lassalleans and Eisenachers, between Guesdists and Possibilists, between Fabians and Social-Democrats, and between Narodnaya Volya adherents and Social-Democrats, remained confined within purely national frameworks, reflecting purely national features, and proceeding, as it were, on different planes. At the present time (as is now evident), the English Fabians, the French Ministerialists, the German Bernsteinians, and the Russian Critics – all belong to the same family, all extol each other, learn from each other, and together take up arms against ‘dogmatic’ Marxism. In this first really international battle with socialist opportunism, international revolutionary Social-Democracy will perhaps become sufficiently strengthened to put an end to the political reaction that has long reigned in Europe?”2
There is no purely national deviation in the communist movement. Opportunism, like Marxism, spreads and develops among the international communist and workers movements through the parties, unions, and other organisations blending with local conditions. As such, the “American Communist Party” line has developed from a problem facing comrades south of the border to one that needs to be fought in Canada as well.
While the specific form of opportunism the “ACP” has brought forth is new, the general line is not. It gained heavy prominence in the 1930s, when the Buck-led revisionists of the Communist Party of Canada (CPC) attempted to forge a similar “patriotic socialism” claiming that “Communism is as Canadian as the maple leaf”,3 flying the Union Jack, singing God Save the King,4 and Buck committing to swear fealty to the then-king.5 The “CPC” to the modern day continues to flirt with Canadian nationalism when discussing the relationship between American imperialism and the Canadian bourgeoisie.
Buck’s same attempt to appeal to the Canadian bourgeoisie was mirrored in his attempt to appeal to the French-Canadian bourgeoisie by hiding the contradictions between communism and Catholicism.6 In the modern day, this tradition has continued with groups like the former “Charles Gagnon Cell” and “Young Communist Patriots” in Quebec who openly aligned themselves with most chauvinistic elements of Quebecois finance capital.7
The “ACP” has taken advantage of this existing domestic opportunism to plant roots in BC,8 Ontario,9 and Quebec.10
What is Fascism and Social-Fascism?
Fascism in Canada can be summarised as the movement for an open terrorist dictatorship of the most reactionary sections of finance capital on the basis of corporate groups under an absolute executive. While this is the ultimate result of the movement, not all fascists are conscious of it. United under this basic definition, within fascism there is a revisionist line and an integralist line.
The revisionist line does not necessarily aim to replace the institutions of liberal democracy. There may remain a division between executive, legislative, and judicial authority within the state, but it is a pure formality. Corporate groups may not formally replace the parliament, but in effect they are the centre of the state. Democratic rights and freedoms may not be outright abolished, but they offer no protections. An example of the revisionist wing today is the dominant faction of the BJP in India. The integralist line is what is generally recognised as fascism seen in the Axis powers. It aims to formally restructure the state on a fascist basis.
Fascism also manifests in a “right” and a “left” form. The “right” form is what is usually considered when fascism is discussed as its face is less hidden behind appeals to socialism than the “left” form. While this is the case, it is the “left” form of fascism, social-fascism, that has been more prominent and dangerous than the “right” form in Canada.
Social-fascism arises out of the “right” of social-democracy. This phenomenon has been described in an earlier article with respect to the New Democratic Party (NDP):
“The election of a new NDP leader is playing out in the midst of a two-line struggle in the NDP that has been particularly intense in the Alberta branch of the party. This two-line struggle is part of the general liquidation of social-democracy. The split that occurred in the international communist movement in the first world war produced those who maintained the principles of Marxism reunited under the Communist International and the broad group of social-democrats united in the Labour and Socialist International. Among the social-democrats a left-wing and a right-wing existed. The left generally supported socialism and was willing to build a united front of workers, but opposed the strategy and tactics of the international communist movement and the dictatorship of the proletariat. The right-wing often rejected socialism completely and fought for a united front with the bourgeoisie against the rank-and-file, unemployed, and unorganised workers and their allies. In Canada, the right-wing of social-democracy gradually defeated the left-wing entirely. Today, these left-wing social-democrats are not found in the leadership of the NDP and other social-democratic parties. Despite this, social-democracy as a whole has had its basis in the labour aristocracy and the union bureaucracy.”11
The “right” of social-democracy is synonymous with social-fascism. Like the “right” of fascism, the “left” has its revisionist form as can be seen in groups like the NDP, Bloc Québécois (BQ), and Québec solidaire (QS). These groups do not see it as necessary to fully negate parliamentary democracy to carry out their aims. On the other hand, many of the “communist parties” of Canada fall into the integralist faction of social-fascism. The “ACP” is a social-fascist party of this latter type. All the “communist parties” in Canada call for some form of collaboration with the bourgeoisie,12 however, it is the “ACP” that is the most open about this position.
The fight against social-fascism is often dismissed as sectarianism. However, communists must recognise that social-fascism is 1) the dominant form of fascism in Canada and 2) often the precursor to the classic “right” fascism.
The first point is easily seen when we consider the level of organisation and influence the two wings of the fascist movement have. The social-fascists are organised into several parties such as the “CPC”, “Communist Party of Canada (Marxist-Leninist)”, “(New) Communist Party of Canada”, Fightback, NDP, QS, and the BQ as well as a number of municipal parties. Many of these parties are represented in parliament and some have even formed government like the NDP. The bourgeoisie have managed to capture the majority of the labour movement through the integration of the Canadian Labour Congress unions into the NDP. This extends to other social movements as well. This is the state of social-fascism today.
This level of organisation and influence cannot be found among the “right” fascists. This wing has embedded itself among many conservative movements, however, they are rarely the dominant faction. They have largely failed to corporativise the mass movements of the people, they rarely agitate, and their militia-type organising has waned since the late 2010s with their last big action being the Ottawa protests.
The second point can be seen most clearly in the example of Italy. Prior to the first world war, Mussolini was a member of the Italian Socialist Party. Following the war, he launched the precursor to the National Fascist Party, the Italian Fasces of Combat. Its manifesto represented the interests of the Italian imperialists, but it carried demands that could be found in an Italian communist party’s minimal programme. These included demands for universal suffrage, abolition of the senate, minimum wages, a level of workers control, nationalisation of arms manufacturing, and a defensive militia.13 These demands were used by the Italian fascists to hide their allegiance to the big bourgeoisie which was gradually revealed as the National Fascist Party was launched and government was formed.
Italian fascism’s “right” period was directly preceded by a long social-fascist one. Even long into government, the Italian fascists would make use of social-fascist language in an attempt to rally the masses. In Mussolini’s declaration of war against France and the UK he referred to the enemy as “the plutocratic and reactionary democracies of the West” while describing Italy as “proletarian and fascist”.14
The Idealism of the “ACP”
The “ACP’s” ideological line is based in idealism and not materialism. In the article The Rise of MAGA Communism, Haz Al-Din describes politics without respect to the economic basis they are built on. This is seen in quotes such as:
“However, before class distinction, it is necessary to understand the more fundamental metaphysical difference that gives rise to modern political difference. Modern political difference, while related, predates the modern class struggle.”15
In quotes such as these, Al-Din puts materialism on its head. A materialist recognises that economics is the basis of the politics of society and ideas are the cultural reflection of these politics and economics. Al-Din says that politics precedes class struggle, which plays out in the final analysis in the realm of economics and philosophy gave rise to these politics. That is, for the Materialist: economics → politics → ideology; for Al-Din: ideology → politics → economics.
The Politics of the “ACP” Leadership
The two main leaders of the “ACP” are Jackson Hinkle and Haz Al-Din. They led this movement before the creation of their party and are today on its plenary committee. The official programme of the “ACP” is relatively tame and less explicitly fascist than the public statements of these two leaders.
As their movement was beginning to gain popularity, Jackson Hinkle released a basic programme to describe the aims of “MAGA communism”.16 Much of the points in the modern “ACP” programme have their root in this earlier one, however, it has been removed of some of the more populist language.
Like the San Sepolcro programme of the Italian fascists, it contains many positions that even advanced workers may support, however, we also find within it a call to “Ban ANTIFA Street Terrorism”. This position gives the game away. The “ACP”, like all fascism, is a reaction to a growing threat to the bourgeoisie in the form of the communist, workers, and national liberation movements. Communists may disagree with the tactics used by the masses when they rebel, but our aim is not to prevent their rebellion. Our aim is to integrate with the masses, take leadership, and direct them towards socialist revolution. On this question, Hinkle aligns himself fully with the bourgeoisie in defence of their dictatorship.
Their commitment to the defence of the state reached its highest point in their approach to the most recent American elections. The “ACP” entered Chris Helali as a write-in candidate for the high bailiff of Orange County, Vermont which they won.17 Rather than fighting against the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, the “ACP” has taken leadership of the repression of the masses in this county.
Hinkle and Al-Din have also associated themselves with other fascist movements around the world. This includes praise of Aleksander Dugin18 and support of Putin’s invasion of Ukraine.19 Domestically, Hinkle has praised the Nazi Nick Fuentes in the past.20
In an interview with Al-Din from 2022, he recognises that the MAGA movement in the USA is at most a “reactionary socialism”, but justifies support and integration with it on the basis that it “at least has the aesthetics of a socialist movement.”21 This is in itself an admission of the social-fascist nature of the movement the “ACP” represents. It does not matter what the content of this reactionary movement is so long as it is covered with a working-class coat of paint.
“ACP’s” Opportunism and the Mass Line
The “ACP’s” main leaders often mention that Trump supporters are largely workers and that they need to integrate with their movement. In this, the “ACP” is carrying out a mockery of the mass line. It aims to unite the backward instead of uniting the advanced. The “ACP” correctly identify liberalism and postmodernism as alien ideologies to the proletariat. However, when they rally the masses against these ideologies, they criticise them from the right and not from the left. This can be seen in Hinkle’s pitting of “trans ideology” against “tradition”.22
The “ACP” also obscures the enemy using labels like “elites”, “globalists”, “Zionists”, etc. This is because the “ACP” does not oppose the bourgeoisie – only its more liberal factions. In doing so, they misdirect workers from struggle against the bourgeoisie as a class to unite with the most reactionary elements, including Peter Thiel, against the liberal faction.23
Even if the “ACP” were not committed social-fascists and genuinely felt this was the path to socialism, the tactics of skipping over the advanced to unite with the backward has only ever led to failure. When communists liquidate their politics to win bourgeois allies, they do not end up winning the bourgeoisie to their line, rather the communists only liquidate further.
We can see this historically with the CPC. In the early 1930s, the CPC recognised the Canadian Commonwealth Federation, the social-credit movement, the Hepburn and Mackenzie-King Liberals, and Duplessis’ Union nationale as fascist. As the CPC looked to win over the bourgeoisie in a struggle against the “50 big-shots” (or, “globalists” for those that speak the language of the ACP), they slowly united with these fascists. By 1945, the CPC (then the LPP) had at some point fought to elect all of these formerly-labeled fascists with the exception of Duplessis.
The Economics of the “ACP”
Haz Al-Din’s explanation of MAGA communism contains this gem explaining his movement’s approach to the question of private property:
“The critique of private property entailed by Communism does not mean that Communists seek to voluntarily change all property relations. Rather, it means an opposition to economic nihilism, according to which the productive forces of society serve inhuman, alien, and antisocial ends. The reign of the institution of private property is not what guarantees peoples liberty to have their own homes, land, farmsteads, businesses, or things that they actually use in general in the pursuit of happiness. It is what destroys them. The ruling class has deceived the American people into thinking ‘private property’ means having your own shit. But what it actually means are banks and blackrock stealing your shit.”
“Communists do not want to ‘socialize’ people’s actual belongings or even businesses. The way in which actual relations of production will develop will be a matter of history. Marx & Engels that through the course of the actual development of the productive forces, the institution of private property will become superfluous, because productive relations will develop as forms of free association – production will have a substantive human quality based on relations between people, rather than abstractions like money. Communists do not want to force this outcome on people, but allow it to happen. It could not happen at the expense of what the people want, it could only happen as a result of the people’s own historical development. In the meantime, what Communists seek is the overthrow of the monopolists, the bankers, big pharma, big agriculture, big tech, and others – which have hijacked the American republic in the name of the ‘sacred institution of private property.’”
“The Communist critique of private property allows for pro-people policies, including lowering taxation, ending government subsidies for the monopolists, and removing red tape – to actually happen, because it places the interests of the people above the interests of money and so-called ‘private property.’ Communists want the people to have more things, not less – more wealth, more businesses, and more prosperity. If the people have more of these things, than the productive forces accelerate faster, unleashing human prosperity and creativity to the point where things like Wall Street, the City of London, and other enemies of the people will never have the chance to take power again. The critique of private property doesn’t mean taking property away from people. It means using political power in a way that serves the common interests of the people, rather than the private interests of money. The contractual forms of association between the people – which allow people to secure their rights of ownership – will continue to exist far into the future, and will only disappear when they are rendered unnecessary by the productive forces – when no institutional challenge to their ownership will even exist.”24
The essence of their economic policy is:
- Communism does not mean the abolition of private property;
- The workers can unite with the middle bourgeoisie against the “globalists” in New York and London;
- The revolution will not be made, but will happen; and
- The Chinese and Russian imperialists are not enemies.
On the first point, Marx makes the position of communists very clear in the Manifesto of the Communist Party, “In this sense, the theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property.”25 This is reiterated in The Programme of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction):
“Abolition of private property, transformation of state and collective property into the property of all of society, administration of the economy by and in the interests of the whole of society.”26
Regarding the second point, both Canada and the USA are imperialist states where the middle bourgeoisie can no longer be considered a progressive class. This is because the tasks of the democratic revolution have long been completed in Canada and the task before the workers is to move towards socialism.27
The third point is an old mechanical view of the transition to socialism. This view is based on the idea that the communists can sit back as the inherent contradictions of capitalism will spontaneously give rise to revolution. The experience of the communist movement has proven that this approach leads nowhere. In this country, the Socialist Party of Canada similarly held that they could not organise a revolution which led to them not taking advantage of the revolutionary situation that emerged in the late 1910s. Even after the workers take power they cannot just expect the construction of communism to just happen, this approach will lead to the restoration of capitalism as can be seen in socialist countries that failed to continue to the revolution under socialism. This position of Al-Din would lead to a passivity among the workers as they no longer need to fight and can just wait for things to change on their own.
On the fourth point, communists recognise that that the big bourgeoisie globally are the enemy of the workers. Our principal enemy in Canada is the Canadian big bourgeoisie as that is the faction that holds power in Canada. However, that does not mean that the big bourgeoisie of other countries become our allies. We need to fight the Chinese and Russian imperialists where ever they are present in Canada just the same as we would the Canadian imperialists. We must also support the Chinese and Russian workers in overthrowing their own bourgeois dictatorships and re-establishing socialism.
Conclusion
To the members of the “American Communist Party” in Canada, join the struggle to reconstitute a real communist party. Not a party of struggle against a small group of “globalists”, but a party that will lead the workers as a class to establish a dictatorship of the proletariat over the bourgeoisie as a class.
1 https://youtu.be/nv9dv9S2O-M?si=aq2BPmlT5ucXdvIi
2 https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1901/witbd/i.htm
3 The Communist Party in Canada, Ivan Avakumovic
4 Class Struggle, The Communist Party, and the Popular Front in Canada, 1935-1939, Martin Shoots-McAlpine. This author was the former leader of the most openly opportunistic faction of the former “Revolutionary Communist Party”. He led his faction into launching the short-lived “Revolutionary Workers Party”. Regardless of the class alignment of the author, this thesis is a good source on factual information related to the gradual liquidation of the Communist Party of Canada beginning in the mid-1930s. His conclusions are not always sound.
5 Ibid.
6 The Communist Party in Canada, Ivan Avakumovic and Communists Love Canada, John Manley
7 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2021/05/29/criticize-jd-criticize-jmp/
11 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/
12 The CWF(OC) and the CPC(RF) have produced a number of criticism on these groups that can be read for more information:
- On the “(N)CPC”: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/12/02/questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/
- On the “CPC”: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/08/the-liquidationist-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada/
- On the Fightback: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/01/17/crush-fightback-and-destroy-trotskyism/
13 https://arplan.org/2019/10/06/fasci-di-combattimento/
14 https://archive.org/details/benitomussolinideclareswarongreatbritainandfrance-june101940esqrmexajf8
15 https://showinfrared.substack.com/p/the-rise-of-maga-communism
16 https://x.com/jacksonhinkle/status/1572273376219254784/photo/1
17 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FyL6luy89mY
18 https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=122156922392184636&id=61555539104234&_rdr
19 https://x.com/rusembnz/status/1832289839024320695?mx=2
20 https://x.com/themattdimitri/status/1698478889280962914?mx=2
21 https://platypus1917.org/2024/02/01/the-epoch-of-empires-an-interview-with-haz-al-din/
22 https://x.com/jacksonhinklle/status/1867940349286789231?mx=2
23 https://platypus1917.org/2024/02/01/the-epoch-of-empires-an-interview-with-haz-al-din/
24 https://showinfrared.substack.com/p/the-rise-of-maga-communism
25 https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/communist-manifesto/ch02.htm
26 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
27 A long criticism of this same position shared by the “(New) Communist Party of Canada” can be found in the following document: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/
Responses to “Social-Fascism and the “American Communist Party” – By Daniel H.”
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/04/25/social-fascism-and-the-american-communist-party-by-da… ↩︎ […]
LikeLike
[…] The document refers to the “American Communist Party” a social-fascist party that is active in Canada’s major cities as well. We have published our own criticism of this group available here. […]
LikeLike
[…] which is in BC, Quebec, and Ontario. We have published two criticisms of this group in the past Social-Fascism and the “American Communist Party” and The Unity of Opportunism by The […]
LikeLike
[…] 7More on this diistinction can be found in the article Social-Fascism and the “American Communist Party” […]
LikeLike