The People's Hammer

What is Selflessness? – By Cliff Z.



This article is a follow up to Armchair Revolutionaries: Nothing but Liabilities available below:

In Armchair Revolutionaries: Nothing but Liabilities, a paragraph in the section on individual passivity is concluded with the following line:

“If even five hours out of a week is too large a sacrifice, one must question why a person such as this is even remotely interested in Marxism.”1

This statement requires expansion and clarification for armchair revolutionaries to properly become reincorporated in the communist movement. Why is sacrifice necessary? What constitutes sacrifice?

Selflessness, in regards to the revolutionary movement, can be defined as the following: To sacrifice things that would enrich one’s self in personal ways in order to take on responsibilities that further the revolution. Selflessness is often misunderstood thanks to Hollywood romanticization and even fellow communists lauding over martyrs. Selflessness in reality is very difficult. It requires strong judgement and making decisions that can truly hurt and feel wrong. Communists must sacrifice relationships with friends and family, jobs and positions which would inhibit their ability to carry out revolutionary action, time with people they love, and places they call home all for the liberation of the proletariat. These sacrifices are a necessity because of the antagonism between classes. Bourgeois ideology permeates throughout all of the world as they are the ruling class. A key way it manifests among the masses is selfishness.

Many people consider any action within the law that furthers one’s position to be the logical thing to do. “You ought to go to university,” “you should turn your art/hobby into a small business,” “why not just switch to freelance work?” are all relatively common sentiments which encourage furthering one’s position. In capitalist society, the only means of furthering one’s position is by further alienating one’s self from the working masses. This is true even among the proletariat. The higher in skill the position is, the better paid it is, and in turn, the more isolated it is. A foreman is not as immersed among the workers as the construction labourers subordinate to them. For a communist, it is a contradiction to pursue both revolutionary efforts and high prestige, isolated positions. This is not to say communists cannot take on high skill labour. It is simply that communists cannot let their professional pursuits inhibit their revolutionary efforts. Personal sacrifices in terms of class, position, and wealth are inevitable for any revolutionary. Careerists across Canada be warned! You’re better off in grad school than trying to reconstitute the communist party!

Personal selfishness beyond one’s career is another matter. Hiding one’s position as a communist with family that does not approve of communism or friends/coworkers who spout reactionary rhetoric with no effort in trying to correct these errors is entirely against the principles of a communist. In Mao Zedong’s Combat Liberalism, he had this to say:

“To let things slide for the sake of peace and friendship when a person has clearly gone wrong, and refrain from principled argument because he is an old acquaintance, a fellow townsman, a schoolmate, a close friend, a loved one, an old colleague or old subordinate. Or to touch on the matter lightly instead of going into it thoroughly, so as to keep on good terms. The result is that both the organization and the individual are harmed. This is one type of liberalism.”2

This process can lead to hurt feelings and frustrations. Non-communists (and even some unadvanced communists) do not have a complete material understanding of politics and ideology, and this causes inconsistencies when exploring these topics. When people are corrected or challenged they are presented with two options:

1) Make an effort to try to understand why they might be wrong and determine what is correct.

2) Become defensive and attempt to angrily or sulkily spin out of the argument.

The latter is unfortunately very common. This is what leads many communists to sacrifice their social standings with others and their relationships. If friends and family wish to consistently be incorrect and they resent being challenged, they will eventually push the communists in their life away. To bury the hatchet without at least attempting to come to a position where the reactionary friend or family member is willing to respect the communist’s position is an act of selfishness. This is saying to the reactionary “sorry I desired to correct your incorrect position. I was wrong for trying to elevate your understanding. I value your relationship with me more than communist philosophy.” This statement should make it very obvious as to why this is not revolutionary practice.

As previously eluded to, a problem in understanding selflessness among communists is the issue of martyrdom. Martyrdom is distinct from selflessness. Martyrdom is the act of sacrificing one’s life for a cause. Among communists, it must be understood that martyrdom is never something that should be sought out. The death of any good communist is never to the benefit of the revolution. No one can be as powerful in death as they are in life. While laying down one’s life is seen as some kind of “ultimate sacrifice” it truly is not. The best communists all struggle to live long and dedicate their time to the revolution, only ever dying due to accident or old age. The true communist does not say “I will die for the people,” what they really say is “I will live for the people!”

Let’s look to our friend from Gravenhurst, Norman Bethune. His death was not what made him such a strong communist. Of the sacrifices Bethune made, his life should never have been one of them. Bethune was a surgeon and could have lived a quiet and comfortable life in Canada. Even as a communist, he could have decided not to aid the efforts of the Communist Party of China during the Second Sino-Japanese war and instead focus on building the revolution in Canada. But this was not Norman Bethune. In his eulogy, Mao stated the following:

“[Norman Bethune] made light of travelling thousands of miles to help us in our War of Resistance Against Japan. He arrived in Yenan in the spring of last year, went to work in the Wutai Mountains, and to our great sorrow died a martyr at his post. What kind of spirit is this that makes a foreigner selflessly adopt the cause of the Chinese people’s liberation as his own? It is the spirit of internationalism, the spirit of communism…”3

Here, Mao exhibits clearly that Bethune’s selflessness and his martyrdom are two distinct characteristics. His selflessness was not the fact he died in the Wutai mountains struggling with the communists, his selflessness was that he had traveled thousands of miles to support the communist effort in a country completely foreign with comrades he had never met before against an enemy with no interest in attacking the Canadian people. Bethune sacrificed every comfortable, easy decision he could have possibly made to push further the efforts of the international proletariat. As a petite-bourgeois surgeon, he sacrificed all of the benefits of his class position to use his skills for the proletariat. His death was to the sorrow of the communists. Had Bethune not died accidentally operating in the field, he would have saved more lives and would have further advanced the communists of China through his personal actions rather than just through the words of others about his life and death. No true martyr is celebrated in their death. They are mourned. Their death is a loss to all the people.

To work one’s self to exhaustion and to make unnecessary risks which endanger one’s well being is not selflessness. To desire that one’s work brings them a glorious death where their sacrifice carries the revolution to victory is pure delusion. Real sacrifice is so much more challenging than laying down and dying. Real selflessness requires constant, vigilant effort. Real martyrdom is a tragedy which we must learn from and not repeat.

Our greatest tool as communists in our efforts to be selfless is self criticism. When communists are faced with difficult decisions about careers, friends, and family, time must be taken to reflect on the options, what the outcomes would be, and how it will impact their role as a revolutionary. When decisions have already been made, jobs turned down, family cut off, risks taken in revolutionary action, one must reflect again and determine if this was the right decision. Selflessness among communists is a delicate balance. We cannot run ourselves thin and burn ourselves out, but we cannot over indulge and take the easy option every time. Consistent self criticism is a necessary step for any communist who wants to nip selfishness in the bud.

Citations

1: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/armchair-revolutionaries-nothing-but-liabilities-by-cliff-z/

2: https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_03.htm

3: https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_25.htm