A question that arises in times of renewed enthusiasm for Communism is the question of organizing. It is a question of acute importance; how do we communists build the foundations for proletarian revolution? One strategy which continues to reemerge is entryism. Entryism promotes entering existing organizations in order to take control of leadership positions and steer it in the direction the entryist advocates for. Entryism as a formal political strategy was created by Leon Trotsky in the 1930s.1 Entryism can be done in any organization, whether it be a union, political party, or special interest group (such as a Palestine or Women’s organization). Entryism at a strategic level is predominantly practiced by Trotskyists.
One of the chief targets of entryists in Canada, historically and currently, is the NDP. As has been illustrated on the People’s Hammer and elsewhere, the NDP is a thoroughly reactionary party. Why then do so many supposed communists flock to the ranks of the NDP in order to transform it into a party for the workers of Canada? The reason is two-fold, which reflects both the blatant capitulationism of these so-called communists and the duplicitous character of the NDP.
Entryism – A Capitulationist Strategy
Entryism as a political strategy focuses on capturing key roles within the target organization in order to take control and move it left. This, however, poses a problem. In order to capture leading roles within the target organization, the entryist must disguise their true political line in order to be a member in good standing that can rise in the ranks. As Marxists, we understand that merely holding communist thoughts does not make someone a communist; it is only when someone puts these ideas into practice that they become a real communist. The notion that one can remain a communist while practicing the political line of a social democratic party is pure fantasy. The entryist will lose their conviction overtime, will themselves become a social democrat, and mirror the politics of the organization they are immersed in.
Entryism is the strategy of capitulation because of these contradictions. Communists, in practicing entryism, cast aside a genuinely revolutionary line in order to surround themselves with reformism for an extensive period of time. The entryist line also poses as the direct antithesis of the mass line. If one practices the correct political line it will be adopted by the people as their own. If the political line of entryists is the correct one they would not need the membership of this or that reformist party in order to prop themselves up. Having so-called “communists” at the head of an organization means nothing if this organization is not connected to the masses. This attitude understands history as being moved by individuals or organizations, rather than correctly understanding history as being moved by the struggle of the masses.
This line does serious damage to the image of communists among the people. They will be seen as working in tandem with the social-fascists, or being back-stabbers who betray their principles and the people for personal gain. It is for this reason that communists must be open about their goals and aspirations with the people. Communists should absolutely strive to lead popular organizations, such as unions, but they must do so by making their political line clear so as to rally the membership of the popular organization around the communist line. This method, called boring from within, must not be mistaken for entryism as it does not place emphasis on official roles in organizations, but instead on mobilizing the people openly to the support of communism.
The NDP Socialist Caucus – Doomed To Fail
As mentioned previously, the NDP and the organizations in its orbit are the main targets of entryists in Canada. The main expression of this at the present is the NDP Socialist Caucus (NDP-SC), an extension of the Trotskyist organization Socialist Action. In their article What Is Trotskyism, Socialist Action states “Trotskyism today is manifested in the NDP Socialist Caucus. While the NDP is not socialist, never was and never will be, it is the only existing mass labour-based political party in North America. Its three million voters, its 100,000-plus members, and hundreds of thousands of affiliated unionists, represent a break with the parties of Bay Street. The inherent conflict of interest between the working class base and the party’s pro-capitalist officials make the NDP a field of struggle for the revolutionary left.”2 One must ask the question, how exactly is the NDP a “break with the parties of Bay Street?” The NDP is being cast aside by the union bureaucracy rapidly,3 progressive organizations are calling for the people to abandon them,4 and they are being exposed for their anti-worker outlook.5
The impetus for the founding of NDP-SC is “NDP activists who were concerned about the right-wing drift of the party leadership.”6 This then begs the question, what has the NDP-SC done in order to impede the rightward drift of the party? Since the founding of the NDP-SC in 1998, the NDP has completely dropped socialism (which was already a petit-bourgeois understanding of socialism) from party documents.7 They have spent the last 3 years propping up the liberals in parliament in the hope of minor concessions.8 They continue to lose popularity with the people as time goes on. The only thing that it seems the NDP-SC is good at is losing leadership races and endorsing candidates who steal from the people like Niki Ashton.9,10 When they get nominations, the party simply makes up bureaucratic reasons to rescind them!11 This comes as no surprise to a genuine communist, who recognizes that this party is no different from the Liberals or Conservatives. But for the entryist, it means that they simply need to push harder and focus more time and energy into this doomed endeavor.
The NDP-SC are only the most modern example of this activity in the NDP. One of the more prominent examples of similar activity in the past was The Waffle. The Waffle was a “democratic socialist” faction within the NDP between 1969-1974. The NDP-SC consider themselves to be a successor organization to The Waffle, and this is an accurate assessment. In 1971, The Waffle briefly took control over the New Brunsick NDP. This only lasted for 2 months before the Federal NDP broke up the branch.12 The parallel between this event and the rescinding of Barry Weisleder as candidate for Thornhill should be obvious, though of course the influence of the NDP-SC is far less than The Waffle ever had. This is unsurprising, as The Waffle existed in a time where the NDP was quantitatively more “left” then it is in the modern day. Thus the pleading of NDP-SC fall on the deaf ears of the capitalist party leadership. In Struggle put it quite succinctly in their 1981 analysis of The Waffle. “The Waffle’s history shows that, despite a few minor defeats, the NDP leadership was sufficiently powerful to prevent its policies from being seriously challenged by its most progressive members. It fought the Waffle with the party bureaucracy’s near-absolute control of daily policy decisions and its close ties with the bourgeois media that allowed it to publicize its positions. It also had various ways of controlling party conventions, from its power to appoint the resolutions committee through to outright intimidation of opposition delegates. Furthermore, NDP parliamentary members were free not to apply policy voted at party conventions. Finally, the bureaucracy of the Canadian Labour Congress and especially of the big American unions could in practice veto decisions they did not like.”13 Socialist Action, the organizers of NDP-SC, could learn quite a lot from this now 40-year old text.
Report From Socialist Action’s May Day
On May 2nd, Socialist Action held its 39th annual May Day celebration. The event was generally unworthy of reporting, however some speakers chose to talk about the NDP-SC in light of the recent electoral thrashing of the NDP. All of what was said about the party was negative, with the most shocking declaration of one NDP-SC member stating that “There is next to no democratic structures within the party.” Other speakers, including NDP-SC/Socialist Action leader Barry Weisleder, remarked on how the NDP had completely capitulated to the Liberal Party. One speaker even sarcastically referred to the party as the “Orange Liberals.”
With all this bashing of the party from entryists in said party, one would think that they would either have a clear plan moving forward on how to correct these errors or finally see this as the breaking point from which to finally abandon this sinking ship. Of course, this was not the outlook expressed by the NDP-SC. Instead, they continued spewing their usual trite about how the NDP is the only mass labour party in North America and how now more than ever they need to fight to return it to its roots (with no plan of how to actually go about doing this of course).
What was even more damning at the event was a conversation between Barry and another attendee, in which he declared that “These young people really think that they are going to be able to make a new party, but its just not going to happen. They need to understand that this is the best option we have.” This is the most obvious and open admission that entryism completely pushes aside proletarian politics in favour of dead-end social democracy.
Conclusion
Entryism continuously proves itself to be a strategy that is completely against the interests of the proletariat. All that can come from it is stagnation and social democracy. The workers of Canada, now more than ever, need to reject the open opportunism of the NDP and all those who try to dress it up in a coat of red paint. Socialist Action is not the only organization which engages in this behaviour, however it is one of the most prominent. Entryism should be rejected in whatever form in comes in. The workers of Canada cannot leech off of parties uninterested in their struggles. They should instead struggle to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada, a party with the interests of the proletariat at its heart.
Citations
1. https://www.marxists.org/archive/cliff/works/1993/trotsky4/10-frtrot.html
2. https://socialistaction.ca/2023/04/22/what-is-trotskyism-2/
5. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/25/report-from-an-ndp-conference-by-mels-g-cynthia-m/
6. https://socialistaction.ca/our-initiatives/ndp-socialist-caucus/
7. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-votes-to-take-socialism-out-of-party-constitution-1.1385171
8. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/jagmeet-singh-ndp-ending-agreement-1.7312910
9. https://ndpsocialists.ca/niki-ashton-address-to-the-ndp-socialist-caucus/
10. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-mp-niki-ashton-17k-trip-quebec-1.7233256
11. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ndp-drops-thornhill-candidate-1.1071170
12. https://journals.lib.unb.ca/index.php/Acadiensis/article/download/12471/13393/16798
13. https://www.marxists.org/history/erol/ca.secondwave/is-waffle-1.htm