The People's Hammer

Oshawa General Motors Layoffs and the Myth of Deindustrialization – By Cliff Z.

, ,


The General Motors (GM) plant located in Oshawa, Ontario recently issued a six month notice of termination for 750 employees.1 According to GM spokesperson Marie Binette, these layoffs are in response to the Trump administration tariffs and “These changes will help support a sustainable manufacturing footprint as GM reorients the Oshawa plant to build more trucks in Canada for Canadian customers.”1 The logic behind bracing for tariffs is especially curious considering auto parts compliant with the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) will not be impacted by the approaching tariffs.2 GM’s second claim, that these changes are to support Canadian manufacturing, is impossible to spin as truthful. It is nearly certain that these layoffs are a means for GM to partially pull out of Canada to brace itself for the inevitable losses in revenue being caused by the current crisis in the market. If GM was interested in building more trucks in Canada, why would they be drastically cutting down production with no plans for later expansion?

GM is an American company with American interests. Putting 750 Canadians out of work does not mean anything to the American shareholders who dictate the company. Lana Payne, president of Unifor, the union which represents the Oshawa workers, has been weak in her response to these layoffs so far. Payne has asserted that GM is abandoning its commitments and that the workers have strongly supported GM in the past.3 Unifor is coming at this from the wrong direction. GM, as an American company, has no true commitments to Canadian workers. GM does not even have commitments to American workers. GM is committed solely to the profits of its shareholders. The exact same as any other publicly traded company. To accuse GM of being disrespectful and reckless and urging Prime Minister Carney to meet with the heads of the major automakers does not organize the workers at the Oshawa plant that Unifor has direct access to! If Unifor wants to protect the jobs of these 750 workers, the whole plant must be militantly organized to fight against management and demand job security. Unifor has not made public any plans beyond their call on Mark Carney and stating that GM is required to meet with Unifor in accordance to their collective agreement.3 Time will tell if Unifor truly has their worker’s interests in mind, but so far, the response indicates no.

While losses in manufacturing such as this are not foreign to Canadians, there is an incorrect notion among Canadian communists which claims that Canada is facing deindustrialization. What is deindustrialization? No one seems to have a scientific definition! Bourgeois economists have only ever described these trends in quantitative ways, such as through the three-sector model. This model pays no mind to imperialism and simply paints the development of “affluent” nations’ economies as a straight line from raw materials, to manufacturing-based economies, to service-based economies.4 This outline of deindustrialization is lacking. It is particularly not helpful when analyzing nations like Aruba, where the bulk of the nation’s economy is derived from tourism (a facet of service) despite being subject to US imperialism.5 Aruba’s economy went from oil refining to tourism, with no manufacturing step in between.5 Clearly, service-based economy is not something which emerges from amassing wealth through a manufacturing-based economy and then deindustrializing.

To understand the modern industrial landscape, we must understand imperialism as described by Lenin. The transition from capitalism to imperialism is characterized by the shift from a free-market economy to a monopolized market economy.6 Through the increasing efficiency of the productive forces, production became more and more centralized. Industrialization accelerated this concentration to the degree that competition became an impossibility as each crisis of capital forced smaller producers out of work and the larger, industrial producers concentrated their forces even further.6 This was the process among the most advanced capitalist nations in the early 20th century which marked a qualitative change from a market dictated by competition, to a market dictated by monopoly. In order to understand why deindustrialization is entirely incompatible with the modern understanding of imperialism, the details of monopolization need to be further clarified. Monopolization is completely opposite to competition. In a monopoly, industry is controlled and centrally planned through the company which owns it. In competition, industry is split up among multiple companies and has no central control. Once a nation undergoes monopolization and has concentrated its productive forces, in order to continue expanding and reap further profit, the monopolists must export bank capital to nations where the productive forces are not concentrated. The capital exported emerges in the new nation through the construction of railways, mines, power plants, oil rigs, factories, and other industrial forms of capital in order to outpace the local productive forces and quickly corner the market. This is finance capital: bank capital transformed into industrial capital. Now the question arises: under what condition would an imperialist nation (such as Canada) be interested in deindustrialization?

If we understand deindustrialization to be the erasure of manufacturing within a nation (in this instance, the imperialist nation of Canada), monopoly makes this prospect an impossibility. Imperialist nations only export capital once the concentration of production in their home nation is to the point where there is no more competition and there is no room for further, immediately profitable expansion. A monopoly exporting capital and expanding its reach while erasing its domestic industry would invite competition in the home nation to emerge and retake the productive forces abandoned by the aforementioned monopoly. Certainly, there are instances in which manufacturing particular commodities is cheaper for the imperialists in foreign nations, but if that production then ceases in the home nation, the productive forces will be re-concentrated into new industries in order to maintain the monopoly. The imperialists have no reason to entirely abandon all manufacturing established domestically because it would force them to eventually re-centralize domestically and abandon their foreign markets.

If we observe Canada’s manufacturing output from 1997 to 2020, we see growth from $105.09B USD to $149.27B USD, with significant spikes in-between those years, but never dips so significant that they would indicate a steady erasure of industry.7 These changes in output are not caused by deindustrialization, but by inter imperialist competition. There are times where it is not as profitable for Canadian imperialists to invest in domestic manufacturing, but that does not mean the monopolists intend to abandon it and cause Canadian industry to recede into a decentralized, competitive market. This would only lose the imperialists money and threaten their position. There is no explanation for the steady growth of Canadian manufacturing and the current state of Canadian imperialism abroad with the belief that Canada is experiencing deindustrialization. This demonstrates clearly deindustrialization is a complete fabrication.

Some Canadian communists make errors in their analysis of domestic manufacturing due to an assumption that all closures and layoffs are a trend which moves in one singular direction. This has lead certain groups to take on a position that the Canadian imperialists want to deindustrialize the country rather than understanding materially that industry is simply changing and moving around as the imperialists lose or gain capital. In Toronto for example, the historical industrial sites in the heart of the urban centre such as the Distillery District and Harbour District transformed into service focused areas as the city developed and the productive forces moved outwards to areas like Weston and Scarborough, and then to the Durham and Peel regions, continuing to shrink in old areas and grow in new areas, moving further from where the imperialists keep their central hold. It is an easy mistake for a Torontonian who does not get out much to assume that manufacturing is simply disappearing, but a half hour drive out of the downtown core will quickly prove otherwise.

What the workers in Oshawa are facing is not deindustrialization, but inter imperialist deals with the United States going sour. The workers in Oshawa now must fight against GM for their jobs, but in the long term, the workers of Canada must fight to oust all US operated Canadian production. The short term goals and long term goals of the Canadian working class require the same careful planning and organization. Corrupt unions, the repression and coercion of workers, exclusion from production, and state violence against the proletariat are all symptoms of bourgeois class dictatorship. A liberal democracy is no longer representative of the masses who hold no capital to twist “democracy” to their will. The workers of Canada must forge true democracy in their workplaces through establishing a united front of workers and fighting to abolish private ownership. When Canada is transformed into a republic of workers, crises of overproduction, bourgeois repression, and the exploitation of the broad masses will all finally cease. To realize this goal, action must start now!

Citations

1: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/oshawa-general-motors-plant-cutting-jobs-union-says-1.7524665

2: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/us-cbp-cusma-auto-parts-tariffs-1.7524359

3: https://www.unifor.org/news/all-news/unifor-calls-swift-action-gm-cuts-shift-due-tariffs

4: https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.223779

5: https://arubapapers.com/the-historic-legacy-of-lago-refinery-in-aruba/

6: https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ch01.htm

7: https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/CAN/canada/manufacturing-output


Response to “Oshawa General Motors Layoffs and the Myth of Deindustrialization – By Cliff Z.”

  1. Tenants Are Not a Class – by Daniel H – The People's Hammer