On May 3rd, the Labour May Day Committee (LMDC) held its 6th annual May Day Rally & March from City Hall at Nathan Philips Square to the Provincial Parliament at Queen’s Park in Toronto. Unfortunately for the workers of Toronto, and Canada at large, the event can only be described as stagnant at best, and a failure at worst. The issues with this event are eerily similar to issues pointed out in prior articles on the Toronto activist scene, as well as across the country.
Centralism
Due to the large number of groups with various opposing ideologies, the event suffered from a severe lack of centralism. This sort of issue was illustrated in the article Report from the Abolitionist Pride Rally,1 which states “The organizational structure of the rally is focused on decentralism, resulting in many moments where it is unclear who should be speaking, where the rally is moving, and how to arrange their pieces of propaganda. All of the various organizations involved have their own leadership and membership structures, resulting in incongruity at the coalition level. If instead it was a centralized body, issues of leadership and organization could be handled internally rather than manifesting as public disorganization during the rally.” The May Day Committee needs to play the role of central authority at the event which they organized! Instead, the “marshals” of the event could be seen lazily guiding traffic while the cops actually run the show. Prior to public events like this, roles and their responsibilities need to be clearly laid out, and people need to be appropriately assigned said roles.
Issues of centralism are already bad enough for any large public event, but it is particularly egregious for supposedly Communist organizations. The various organizations present are seemingly uninterested in struggling with each other, as they all have settled into their respective revisionist niches to chew up and spit out young, enthusiastic communists. Looking at just the Trotskyist organizations present, there were about 4 or 5. Socialist Action, Trotskyist League, Marxist Workers Group, Bolshevik Tendency, and perhaps others. Notably missing from the event was the Revolutionary Communist Party (Formerly Fightback). Why is it that so many organizations which supposedly hold the same/similar ideological lines continue to not interact or be outright hostile with each other? It is quite simple, the leaders of these organizations are happy to continue to leech off of their members with dues and magazines which no one bothers to read! Why would these organizations try and rock the boat when they have a reliable stream of income to leadership in order to risk begin usurped by another similar group.
Another major issue of centralism is the problem of general security. At the event, all of the different organizations as well as some individual photographers could be seen taking dozens of photos. This may not seem like an issue at first, however this can pose a severe security risk to attendants. This manifested most obviously in the case of police officers taking photos during the march section of the event. The identity of progressives and communists must be protected as best as possible. It is foolish to believe that even though presently there is little to no state repression of such people, this will absolutely not be the case in the future. Photos taken during periods of relative safety will certainly be used against activists once the rebellion of the masses enters a more advanced stage, as the organizations present hope to create. A marshal should absolutely be responsible for taking official photos which remove identifiable information like faces & clothing, and also for preventing any random person from taking identifiable photos as well. Some attendees noted their discomfort about this situation.
Slogans
As a result of the unprincipled unity which was forged by the committee, the slogans present for the rally were weak. This manifested as ideological weakness and organizational weakness, much like the rally itself.
Ideological Weakness
The principal slogan used both on the posters for the rally and as chants during the rally was “Food! Homes! Jobs!” This slogan (Particularly the variant “Socialism means? Food! Homes! Jobs!) reduces the aims of the working class to mild social-democratic reforms. It can also be seen as a shallow attempt to echo the Bolshevik slogan “Peace, Land, Bread!” Slogans at a socialist-led event should reflect the interests of the workers, principally in the form of taking control of industry from the bourgeoisie. Another example of a slogan at the event with a weak ideological position is “When I say worker, you say power! Worker! Power!” The issue of the slogan “Workers Power” was skillfully dissected in the article “Workers’ Power” and Economism.2 With the presence of so many groups with contradictory ideological positions, it is no surprise that the politics of the event have taken quite a blow.
Organizational Weakness
Some of the slogans present were either very similar or identical to each other, causing confusion among the crowd during chants. The principal examples of this were “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free!” & it’s counterpart “From the river to the sea, overthrow the bourgeoisie!”, as well as “1, 2, 3, 4, Time to win the class war! 5, 6, 7, 8, Overthrow the bourgeois state!” & it’s counterpart “1, 2, 3, 4, Time to win the class war! 5, 6, 7, 8, Forward to a workers state!” The crowd would hear the beginning of the slogan, but one half would chant the first version and the other half would chant the second. This caused everyone to be confused, and stop chants for a few seconds while the speakers tried to get things moving again. This could’ve been easily avoided. Beyond this, the chant leaders were so ineffective at their role that members of the Philippine organizations started to take over and do a better job than the actual organizers! However, the organizers wouldn’t cede to the crowd-borne chants, leading to two chants happening simultaneously. It was very disorienting, and a poor display of unity to passerby.
Bad Location
The May Day Rally has consistently been held at Nathan Philips Square to Queens Park for the past 6 years. This may not seem to be a problem at first thought, however it reveals a strategic failure of the committee. If this event is supposed to be targeting workers in order to agitate them to socialism, why is the event not organized in a proletarian neighborhood? One cannot image an area of Toronto with any less workers than Queen & Bay Street. Luckily for the committee, there are many ongoing construction projects in the area such as the Ontario Line for the TTC & renovations to buildings around the Square. Unfortunately, the committee did not use this as an opportunity to rally the workers on the site, and instead continued with the same route they use every year. This issue was also dissected in the article On Movementism.3
Conclusion
All of the issues with the event culminated in a low turn out compared to previous years. Unfortunately there are no official figures for the attendance of the rally, however in 2023 the event was big enough to be picked up by local news.4 No such coverage was given in 2024 or 2025. One may believe this is because the bourgeois media outlets such as CBC do not stand to gain from this coverage. This is true, however attendants from previous years also remarked on the small size comparatively.
All of the criticism in this article is not made with the intent of bashing the committee, but instead to push it onto the correct path instead of its continued stagnation. It is a positive thing that this event is being put on year after year, Toronto workers (and Canadian workers at large) need to take control of their own events, which the LMDC is attempting to do. Of course, there are a host of issues which have stagnated their efforts which need to be corrected before progress can be made.
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/07/26/report-from-the-abolitionist-pride-rally-by-mels-g-cliff-z/
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/01/07/workers-power-and-economism-by-daniel-h/
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/10/18/on-movementism-by-mels-g/
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/toronto-ontario-may-day-2023-1.6827582
Responses to “Report from Toronto May Day – By Mels G.”
[…] 6https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/16/report-from-toronto-may-day-by-mels-g/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 6 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/16/report-from-toronto-may-day-by-mels-g/ […]
LikeLike