Right off the heels of the Liberals’ victory in the federal election, a faction of the Albertan bourgeoisie seized on the opportunity to advance their campaign for an independent Alberta. This faction is mainly based in the governing United Conservative Party of Alberta (UCP) along with some smaller fringe parties.
Federally, both the Liberals and the Conservatives are bourgeois parties. The Liberals are generally more aligned with the big bourgeoisie while the Conservatives are more aligned with the middle bourgeoisie. While this tends to be true for the classes as a whole, there are many individual cases of the big bourgeoisie being organised in the Conservative Party or the middle bourgeoisie being organised in the Liberal Party.
The class alignment for these bourgeois parties can be seen in the tendency toward greater centralisation under the Liberals (ex. Carney’s commitment to internal free trade) and decentralisation under the Conservatives. This is why the independence faction of the UCP is pushing hard for its cause after Carney’s victory.
This faction of the Albertan bourgeoisie has led the campaign for either an American annexation, independence, or more commonly greater autonomy since at least as far back as 2001 with Harper’s “Firewall Letter.”1 This faction often attempts to portray its aims as the common cause of all Albertans, but its aim is solely to safeguard the interests of the middle bourgeoisie against the big bourgeoisie at the expense of the workers by retaining it as a site with low working conditions and a higher rate of exploitation.
Take the equalisation formula as an example. The Canadian constitution provides for the provision of federal funds to the provinces to ensure that all provinces are able to provide a similar standard of public services.2 These funds are provided based on what is deemed the fiscal capacity of a province. The funds for the equalisation formula are sourced from federal taxation and not provincial contributions. The equalisation formula has been a strong rallying point for the Albertan bourgeoisie who specifically cite the massive portion Quebec receives in comparison to the western provinces who generally receive no payments.
However, if the Albertan bourgeoisie were successful in their campaign to reform or outright abolish equalisation payments, what good would this do the workers? Would their cost of living come down? Would their wages and conditions rise? Would Alberta’s strict anti-worker laws3 be repealed? Of course not!
Currently, there is not popular support for separatism in Alberta with current polling showing only 19% of Albertans saying they would vote for independence.4 The bourgeoisie themselves are divided on the question with the mayors of both Edmonton and Calgary being opposed. The bourgeoisie of the oppressed nations in treaty six, seven, and eight territories have rejected the Albertan government’s ability to intervene or negate treaties in response to the independence campaign.5
Premier Smith has also shown the division exists even within the ranks of the UCP. Smith has stated that while she supports a “sovereign Alberta within a united Canada”,6 she wants the question openly debated in order to avoid a split in the UCP and the formation of a mainstream independence party similar to the Parti Quebecois.7 The last time the conservative movement was split into two parties, it allowed the NDP to form government which Smith wants to avoid.
The key measure the UCP introduced in support of the independence movement was legislation to reduce the bar to call for a referendum in the province from 20% of the population to 10% and expanding the limit of time to gather the signatures from 90 days to 120 days.8 Only a week after this bill was introduced, Smith stated she was committed to holding an independence referendum in 2026 if enough signatures were gathered.9
What should the communist response be to independence?
There is a clear line separating Albertan separatism from the separatism of the Quebecois and the oppressed nations. The latter two are calls for the independence of a nation – distinct historically constituted groups with a common territory, language, culture, and economy.10 A nation is not the same as a province which is simply and administrative division of the country.
Albertans are not a nation. Even the pro-independence bourgeoisie rarely justify independence on the grounds of national distinctions. The separatism of the Albertan bourgeoisie is a pragmatic one. It is for this reason that independence is the furthest thing from the spotlight when the Conservatives are in government and all the rage when the Liberals are in. It is a purely reactionary politics that the workers need to oppose by fighting for a country-wide proletarian dictatorship starting with the fight for a country-wide proletarian party.
1 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/28/ucp-administrations-drive-towards-an-albertan-provincial-police-by-daniel-h/
2 https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/federal-transfers/equalization.html
3 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/02/28/resist-albertas-anti-worker-laws/
4 https://www.ctvnews.ca/calgary/article/experts-wont-count-out-alberta-separation-referendum-despite-low-support-in-recent-poll/
5 https://globalnews.ca/news/11165096/alberta-danielle-smith-address-may-5-2025/
6 https://globalnews.ca/news/11165096/alberta-danielle-smith-address-may-5-2025/
7 https://www.ctvnews.ca/calgary/article/experts-wont-count-out-alberta-separation-referendum-despite-low-support-in-recent-poll/
8 https://globalnews.ca/news/11165096/alberta-danielle-smith-address-may-5-2025/
9 https://globalnews.ca/news/11165096/alberta-danielle-smith-address-may-5-2025/
10 While Quebecois and oppressed nations’ separatism share this trait, Quebecois separatism is objectively an imperialist project while this is not always the case for the oppressed nations.
Responses to “Alberta Sovereignty and Referendum – By Daniel H.”
[…] 9 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/23/alberta-sovereignty-and-referendum-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 4 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/23/alberta-sovereignty-and-referendum-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 5. “The Canadian constitution provides for the provision of federal funds to the provinces to ensure that all provinces are able to provide a similar standard of public services. These funds are provided based on what is deemed the fiscal capacity of a province. The funds for the equalisation formula are sourced from federal taxation and not provincial contributions. The equalisation formula has been a strong rallying point for the Albertan bourgeoisie who specifically cite the massive portion Quebec receives in comparison to the western provinces who generally receive no payments.” https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/23/alberta-sovereignty-and-referendum-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/23/alberta-sovereignty-and-referendum-by-daniel-h/%5B4%5D […]
LikeLike