The following is an article from the Workers United Front of Canada. It can be found here: https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/05/17/smart-local-280-a-union-for-who/
-Editorial Board of the People’s Hammer
This article was written by union sheet metal workers in British Columbia. They discuss their experiences within their union, SMART Local 280, and some pertinent issues. What is discussed by these workers also represents general issues in all construction unions under the British Columbia Building Trades, the construction trade union center in the province. What they discuss also speaks to the pertinent need for construction workers to struggle for the creation of an industrial union in the industry; an industrial union ready to fight for workers, and one where the union bureaucrats within it have their wages tied to the average wage of their employers to ensure the position remains as a position of service to workers. If you work construction in the province and want to fight for an industrial union in the industry, contact the Workers United Front
By: Metro Vancouver United Workers
Introduction
What is a union? A union SHOULD be an organisation dedicated to the immediate defense of workers within an industry, and an organ for workers to ultimately fight for control of industry all together. This tenacity and willingness to fight is no where to be seen in our union, SMART Local 280. There are a variety of issues we have found in the union that need to be laid bare.
Firstly, any worker should understand that they have an inherently antagonistic relationship to the boss. We workers want better pay, better conditions, and less work. Our bosses want to squeeze ever dollar they give us and in exchange, pressure us to produce as much as we can. There is no peaceful, middle-ground solution. We as workers are on one side, the bosses on another. Unions should reflect this and be willing to take a firm stand against actions of the bosses. For union sheet metal workers, this is not the case.
Strikes, an important weapon tossed away
One of the most important weapons workers within a union have is the strike. It is the one major form of collective action workers can enact to defend their rights and resist attacks from the boss. In Canada, workers can only legally strike in between collective agreements and with union approval, meaning this weapon is already legally limited in Canada,1 and not something the union is looking to change. What makes this even more outrageous is the bureaucrats in charge of SMART Local 280 (along with many other unions in the BC Building Trades) are happy to sign away the strike rights of their workers on large industrial worksites in exchange for employers and contractors to guarantee work on those sites. The justification the union uses for this is that workers will always be worse off if they have to strike, as strike pay will be far lower than whatever they would earn through striking for higher pay, and that is money they would never get back. On top of this, the union bureaucrats are not only more than willing to not strike, but they state – almost as a point of pride – that the union has not had a strike since the 1980’s!
This issue is especially prevalent now with tariffs from the US2 which have already led to two union metal shops laying off workers en masse. Workers from Echo Metal and Quest Metal are currently without work. Instead of a strike or even seizing these metal shops to make them collective property of the workers, all the now ex-workers of these shops have to hope for is a severance package from the union through a legal battle, but it is uncertain whether this will happen.
This behaviour from the union is a far cry from a fierce, fighting union history that Canada has once had with actions such as the Stratford General Strike which saw workers organised under mainly the Needle Trades Workers’ Industrial Union go on an illegal strike over pay and working hours. It saw the illegal support of other unions striking in solidarity. Strikers even continued in the face of police repression by engaging in street battles against police trying to break up the strike. Ultimately this led to victory for the workers.3 It is clear in this example that willingness to challenge the law from the union, and be relentless in the strike is what won these workers their claims. And that view is what needs to be brought to Local 280.
A Union who Invites the Enemy
In fact, our union allows representatives of the bosses to be members of the union itself. To have union protections, vote in union elections and on union decisions, and for all intents and purposes, be a “worker” in the union. These people are the various superintendents in the company. Unlike a crew foreman, who often does just as much work as any other worker and cannot hire or fire workers, superintendents perform no work. Instead they are purely there to ensure work gets completed satisfactorily for the bosses, and to discipline those who do not meet their standards. These are not workers, but running dogs for our very enemy, the bosses. Furthermore, these superintendents have calls to be able to lay off workers. Particularly disgusting is in our company, it is an open secret that layoffs are an inevitability, and the choice of who gets laid off is who does not produce to the satisfaction of site foremen and superintendents. This creates a pressure amongst all of us to produce better and more than the person beside us.
A fellow worker of ours remarked that working under the union feels far more competitive than for a non-union company. The worker stated that at least at their non-union workplace, there was a collective attitude of everyone hating their superintendent, and working together to push back at the boss any time a worker got disciplined. They further stated that working in a supposed union-company, this class solidarity is nowhere to be found in these types of interactions. There is just pressure to do well in hopes you are not seen as dead weight and get permanently laid off.
When another one of our fellow workers inquired with the union as to why this is. The answer they got boiled down to the union bureaucrat saying they are well aware that this is the case, and they do not even really see an issue with it. The union bureaucrat chocked up the issue to their union contracts not defining “seniority” and thus there was no need for lay offs to follow seniority. The union also stated they were not intending to create such a definition. Thus, this allows workers to continue to be under the threat of layoffs while superintendents may continue to encourage competition while being in the union! What makes this even more outrageous is the unions policy towards superintendents violates even bare minimum BC labour law. In the definitions section of the British Columbia Labour Relations Code, it states that only “employees” may be members of a union. This definition excludes “managers” who are defined as those who can “discipline, hire, and fire”, all things a superintendent can functionally do.4 It is clear Local 280 is perfectly happy to keep superintendents in the contract and thus it is us workers who pay the price, while the bosses benefit in undermining worker solidarity, and have open sets of ears into all the activities of the unions. This should not be surprising though, given in a recent union meeting where workers were expressing concerns over layoffs with the threat of US tariffs on Canada,5 the local president, Jud Martell, stated that we should have some gratitude for company owners as they “pay your rent”. Now, despite the union openly welcoming the foot soldiers of our enemy as workers into the union, the union allows even worse collaboration with our fundamental enemy.
SMACNA, outright collaboration
Along with having superintendents within the collective agreement as workers, the union openly collaborates with the bosses through the organisation, SMACNA, or the Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors’ National Association, an international trade association of sheet metal companies that offers labour relations assistance, legislative assistance, and business management help to the companies involved. Sheet metal companies become a part of SMACNA when they are unionised through SMART. SMACNA is also the group who the union bargains with for a collective agreement.
The pure existence of SMACNA is a danger for workers as it allows greater organisation between bosses which opens the door to easier collaboration between companies to crush worker actions. On top of this, the union bureaucrats maintain very friendly relations with SMACNA. In Surrey, BC, SMACNA and SMART Local 280 co-run the training center for sheet metal apprentices. There is also a yearly golf tournament between the two organisations to encourage collaboration. But why encourage collaboration with our fundamental enemy as workers? Through collaborative training, and union cooperation, it is an integration of this supposed union with our enemy, capital, and thus is a further obstacle the union is happy to put in the way of worker being able to defend their interests.
Union Bureaucrats Disdain for Workers
Another aspect worth mentioning is the lack of effort and faith that is given from the union bureaucracy of Local 280. Our union contract expired as of May 1 and during negotiations for a contract, the union pushed hard for us to vote ‘yes’, stating that mediation at the labour board would be the next step if we shot down this offer. The major two points of the contract were a slight bump to retirement pensions, and a three-year agreement with a wage increase of between $1.80-$1.95 per year for journeyman rate. Inflation in the next years will likely be unpredictable, making many workers uneasy as to whether this will be enough to keep up. With this, given the union unwillingness to ever engage in a strike, Local 280 is essentially telling its workers to take the scraps they are given or suffer even worse consequences. No attempt will be made by the union to mobilize workers to fight for higher wages, even if that was a demand from the workers themselves.
Another point is around the issue of politics. At multiple union meetings, Local 280 has gone out of their way to stop talk about political parties and politics stating it is against meeting etiquette. This is particularly laughable as the Local has used funds to campaign on behalf of the NDP. Other union locals have made endorsements of figures like Doug Ford.6 At the center of politics is the question of power and who holds it. Local 280 makes it clear that the word of us workers is not that important when it comes to answering these questions.
Given this, many workers in the union have long ago come to the conclusion that SMART Local 280 does not do many of the things that make a union a true working class defense organisation. A common sentiment from union sheet metal workers is that they essentially do not care about the union and are only involved because it pays higher and has better benefits than the non-union sector.
Conclusion
What anyone can see from the above is that the current state of SMART is far from a fighting organisation of the working class, but instead, a body that is willing to give workers a couple dollars here and there and give some slightly better conditions without addressing the heart of the issues of workers. It is clear that these union bureaucrats have a vested interest in keeping the relationship between the workers and bosses peaceful, at the workers expense, and that their interests lay with keeping the employers as pleased (often times more) than the workers. It is imperative that us sheet metal workers win back our union away from these conditions and have it become a true organisation of the working class, and ultimately, fight for an industrial union in construction to protect all of us in the industry.
1http://cirb-ccri.gc.ca/en/resources/no-06-unlawful-strikes-lockouts
2https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2025/03/list-of-products-from-the-united-states-subject-to-25-per-cent-tariffs-effective-march-13-2025.html
3https://atom.library.yorku.ca/index.php/workers-unity-league-chapter-11-1933-gaining-momentum-the-stratford-strikes-of-1933-nancy-stunden
4https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96244_01#section1
5https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/trump-canada-steel-alumimum-tariffs-1.7480309
6https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/ford-cleans-up-with-union-endorsements-strong-polling